Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15 minute cities and the conspirators

629 replies

ivykaty44 · 13/02/2023 18:08

15 minute cities being organised to mean that you don't have to rely on a car to get to everything and can easily walk to many places therefore only have to use the car for longer journeys

the conspiracy theories im seeing on social media are suggesting its a world wide control formula and we will be fined for moving from one district to another.

www.forbes.com/sites/carltonreid/2023/02/08/15-minute-city-conspiracy-theories-insane-says-15-minute-city-creator/?sh=121378916156

I'm wondering if the car manufactures are behind the conspiracy, as they would have a lot to lose if people live in places where they don't need a car and can just ave one family car or hire a car. Billions of sales could be lost if this takes off.

Some cities have gone car free - theculturetrip.com/europe/spain/articles/the-car-free-spanish-city/ and found after much objection, that it works well - especially for the elderly

OP posts:
User18936572 · 20/02/2023 08:53

Won't it be a bit boring if you only mix with people from your neighbourhood, especially if you are young, everything will be very small.

Valeriekat · 20/02/2023 08:53

QuertyGirl · 14/02/2023 12:19

Oxford is a compact, medieval city.

It cannot fit all the cars that want to get in, in.

Oxford needs more public transport. People really shouldn't be driving into medieval cities unless there is no alternative

The last time I went into Cambridge (20 years ago), the Park and Ride had no parking! I very much doubt that it has improved.
Local government should be providing more and better public transport/ parking not punishing people who are trying to do their best.

lazycats · 20/02/2023 08:53

Whatever the merits/limitations of the scheme, it's clearly become a magnet for dickheads - Lawrence Fox was at a recent protest. It doesn't bode well for our future that something so mundane (and yes, it is mundance whatever hyperbole people use) can become so fractious.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 20/02/2023 08:50

the ghettoisation happens because there's a big variety of price/quality combinations for each type of business.

in an affluent area (where house prices are enormous) the local offering includes cocktail bars, bijou little independent stores, delicatessens, artisan bakers and organic grocers, interesting cuisine restaurants and various businesses aimed at capturing the wallet of the wealthy locals, but the people who work in these businesses will generally not be able to afford to live locally and probably can't afford to do all their shopping there either, and there are also a lot of people who culturally and for preference want to be able to spend their leisure and shopping time in such areas but can't afford to live there.

The more affordable areas don't have such shopping areas because the local population in general can't sustain them - they've got a "local value" convenience store, a fish&chip shop, a barber and a vape store, with an aldi/morrison low cost supermarket and a pharmacy a short drive away on the ring road. but a significant minority of the people living there would have loved to be able to live in one of the posh areas, and may even have a job there, but they are living where they can afford to live.

making the lovely area into a pedestrianised low traffic zone excludes all the people who can't afford to live within 15 minutes walk, or who like to stop by there on their way from affordable suburb to different suburb where they work.

gentrifying all these hinterland suburbs isn't a solution - the low budget options are needed by a large proportion of the local population, but don't meet the needs of a significant proportion of those living there, who want a different quality/price point for their goods and services. but while the population of a single zone will be variable, the economics of pricing and market for each business mean you simply can't put a low-budget version and a posh version of the same kind of business on the same street and let both attract their own customers from among the local population, it doesn't work like that. The low budget version goes in the poorer area and the posh version goes in the posh area, but people can move freely and go to where the businesses they want to use are located.

all the pilot schemes are about making it more difficult to use the lovely areas if you aren't lucky enough to live nearby, but the problem about how to give access to the same kinds of spending and working opportunities to those who would otherwise be driving to those areas regularly (but are now being prevented) isn't being addressed, because there isn't really a workable solution so it's easiest to just ignore it and focus on how much lovelier the lovely area is now that you can hear the birdsong rather than the streets being lined with the parked cars of those who you have now excluded.

15 minute cities and the conspirators
15 minute cities and the conspirators
User18936572 · 20/02/2023 08:50

Maybe the flyer about it should have put the rest of the country or everyone else instead of the rest of Oxfordshire to make it clearer.

QuietlyConfident · 20/02/2023 08:48

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/02/2023 23:34

Great, so I've got what I 'need' on my doorstep. What about having actual, ya know, fun? Or are people intent on sucking every last bit of joy out of life?

We should also remember that it wasn't too long ago that we were all being encouraged to stay apart. So, surely they can't be surprise that people would now prefer to use their own modes of transport? Public transport is nowhere NEAR where it needs to be yet for people to ditch their cars.

Playing fields, parks, gyms, pubs (including one which hosts music at the weekend), cultural stuff in the library in the evening and a church hall or similar for exercise classes/choir practice/whatever would meet most people's weekly requirements for fun.

Theatre/museums/clubs probably would be outside the scope of that routine fun and require a special trip downtown: I think that's more of a monthly thing than a weekly thing for most people.

Not sure where cinemas would fit in that scale: I guess smaller local cinemas with a faster rotating repertoire rather than big multiplex's should be part of the landscape. Not quite sure about gyms either, but given the fact that they're part of many people's regular routine and the fact that I've got at least 6 within a 15 minute walk then they should probably be in spec.

If you're a full-fledged clubber who wants to spend all weekend every weekend at the big clubs then this model of life wouldn't work for you though.

Valeriekat · 20/02/2023 08:46

QuertyGirl · 14/02/2023 10:03

Councils: here's an idea that will make life easier!

Conspiracy nuts: Noooooo!

That's what's happening.

Honestly, we need to get non-disabled people out of their cars. It'll literally killing us.

People are reacting emotionally to this because they've spent so much money on their cars, that they need to get to the jobs to pay for their cars.

(Yes, I exempt people with mobility issues from this, so please non of that argument)

In theory a great idea but are you really happy to lose a fundamental right of freedom of movement? You are literally asking that people carry "papers" around?

Abhannmor · 20/02/2023 08:25

QuertyGirl · 18/02/2023 09:25

@MrsDanversGlidesAgain

Oh well, let's just give up and drown in our own flab while sitting in metal boxes

Ah but that's just what Bill Gates secretly wants you to do , it was a double bluff all along !

( maniacal laughter)

ivykaty44 · 20/02/2023 08:11

Like I said, other cities have successfully reduced traffic without the need for permits and restrictions.

I asked previously you to name the cities and you've yet to do so? which cities are they and how have they reduced the congestion and by what percentage?

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 20/02/2023 08:09

The enforcement of these restrictions is almost certainly beyond the legal competence of a town council and will end up in court, where it will get short shrift.

if that was the case, how would a housing estate ever be built with cul de sac? as what the council is effectively doing is placing in cul de sacs but with the option of driving through. Just curious on what grounds will the legal challenge be?

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 20/02/2023 08:06

So does that mean that if you don't live in Oxfordshire you are not allowed into Oxford at all, people may have relatives there

Thats what the protestors want you to believe, that you will be denied entry to the city or leaving after so many times, and have to buy a permit to be allowed to see your relatives - its a load of bullshit.

There was a protestor on Saturday interviewed and he was confused as his mate John had told him that leaving the city would be banned but when he read the Oxford council literature on the scheme it was different and wasn't the case at all - thus his confusion

OP posts:
Genevieva · 20/02/2023 08:03

PS the same applies to county councils and even possibly to central government without repealing numerous Acts of Parliament.

Genevieva · 20/02/2023 08:01

You don't have to be a nut job to see that 15 minute cities are a stupid idea that will cause all manner of problems. The enforcement of these restrictions is almost certainly beyond the legal competence of a town council and will end up in court, where it will get short shrift.

ivykaty44 · 20/02/2023 07:59

Great, so I've got what I 'need' on my doorstep. What about having actual, ya know, fun? Or are people intent on sucking every last bit of joy out of life?

Not sure why you can't have fun anywhere you want to go? or why having or the necessities for everyday life on your doorstep would prevent you from having fun elsewhere

OP posts:
Jumpingthruhoops · 19/02/2023 23:34

ivykaty44 · 17/02/2023 16:34

They were for people to buy what they need for daily life.

and that is what the 15 minute cities are trying to achieve, places that people need within 15 minutes walk. Schools, doctors, chemist, small grocery stores, pub, library, playing fields, parks post office, hairdressers, dentist, opticians

Great, so I've got what I 'need' on my doorstep. What about having actual, ya know, fun? Or are people intent on sucking every last bit of joy out of life?

We should also remember that it wasn't too long ago that we were all being encouraged to stay apart. So, surely they can't be surprise that people would now prefer to use their own modes of transport? Public transport is nowhere NEAR where it needs to be yet for people to ditch their cars.

EmmaEmerald · 19/02/2023 22:19

User18936572 · 19/02/2023 21:51

So does that mean that if you don't live in Oxfordshire you are not allowed into Oxford at all, people may have relatives there

I'm sure visitors will be let in but have the same route options.

saw this and thought of this thread - possible Government challenge to ULEZ?

may just be weasel words or a chess game related to mayoral power though.

uk.sports.yahoo.com/news/downing-street-could-block-sadiq-091457863.html

User18936572 · 19/02/2023 21:51

So does that mean that if you don't live in Oxfordshire you are not allowed into Oxford at all, people may have relatives there

DappledThings · 19/02/2023 20:15

QuertyGirl · 19/02/2023 19:26

These objections really are starting to feel a bit freedom of the land (available on Google)

Definitely. The people who think 15 minute cities are the WEF trying to control them will have a big crossover with the people who think quoting Magna Carta in court gets them out of paying Council Tax.

MiaMoor · 19/02/2023 20:14

So this screenshot, from Oxford City Council website, is wrong then?

Like I said, other cities have successfully reduced traffic without the need for permits and restrictions. I’m not against limiting traffic anywhere, I’m against the introduction of a system that could insidiously be abused in the future.

15 minute cities and the conspirators
DietrichandDiMaggio · 19/02/2023 19:38

It’s local government driving this.

Yes, County Council rather than city council. Unfortunately, in Oxfordshire, this means decisions (not just LTNs, but many things) are made regarding the city by people who don't live there and who politically don't reflect the views of those who do.

QuertyGirl · 19/02/2023 19:26

These objections really are starting to feel a bit freedom of the land (available on Google)

ivykaty44 · 19/02/2023 19:17

If I’m told I need a permit, or I’m limited to a number of days, to leave a specific area, then I’m going to feel trapped and claustrophobic.

where are you getting this from? No council has said people will need a permit to visit their city or town. What they’ve said is if you come and visit section 1 then you’ll have to drive back out to the ring road to then drive back into section 2

ghent dies this same thing and tourists still flick there, they have found it’s improved traffic flow

are you against reducing congestion?

OP posts:
MiaMoor · 19/02/2023 14:51

Permits and restrictions are how dystopian situations arise. I can see how so many would blindly stumble into it.

If covid lockdowns showed us nothing but the contempt politicians hold for the population they are supposedly serving, then we really should not be mutely complying with schemes that even have a tiny potential to be abused.

Pyewhacket · 19/02/2023 14:49

boobot1 · 14/02/2023 08:51

Its just another pie in the sky idea, of course they will spend billions on it before they admit it. This government is bloody useless.

It’s local government driving this. 🙄

MiaMoor · 19/02/2023 14:44

QuertyGirl · 19/02/2023 14:22

@MiaMoor

Hate to break it to you, but where you can and can't drive is already massively restricted by a whole gamut of law.

I'm not watching a random ranting person the internet who uses the word "woke".

Where is restricted? I mean I know about London, but a car would be a hindrance there.

You seem to be quite aggressively arguing for humans to be limited, which I find quite odd.

I have a list of places I want to go, none of them accessible by rail or bus. Amazing places in the UK that I and many others wish to visit. If I’m told I need a permit, or I’m limited to a number of days, to leave a specific area, then I’m going to feel trapped and claustrophobic. You might not. You can argue and consent for your own limitations, but you cannot speak for others and tell them they must feel the same as you.

Pity you won’t watch the video, it really is amazing, instead of the usual drudgery society throws at us right now that wants to keep us down. I personally want more for my life and my children.