Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think people should stop recommending adoption as solution to infertility?

137 replies

Coffeefig · 13/02/2023 17:19

DP and I spent last year TTC before finding out he has male factor fertility issues that will make it impossible for us to conceive without donor sperm. Every single time I try to talk about this with a friend or family or post online to try to get support I'm met with people telling me to adopt as if it's the simplest and most straightforward solution in the world. I have huge respect for people who feel that adoption is the right choice for them, but there seems to be so little understanding of why it might not be the right choice for everyone – and certainly not a solution for infertility. It's posted numerous times on every infertility post on MN – and while I'm sure it's well meaning it seems to 99% of the time come from people who aren't going through infertility struggles themselves and haven't gone through the adoption process (they know a friend who it worked out for etc). I know that for many people it does work out – and that is great, there are obviously many children in need of a loving home. But to just recommend it to anyone going through infertility seems really insensitive and an inappropriate suggestion for both the adults involved and potentially the children. I'm sorry if this is coming across as a bit unhinged but I'm just so, so frustrated by it and need to know if it is actually a really inappropriate thing to say or if I'm being unreasonable as I know my MH is suffering dealing with infertility right now.

OP posts:
PlumPudd · 13/02/2023 19:36

You’re not being unreasonable at all.

To try to explain it a little though, I imagine the reason people say things like, ‘have you considered adoption’, is because most people’s immediate impulse when hearing about someone else’s awful situation is to try to offer solutions or advice, or try to ‘solve’ the problem, rather than offering a listening ear and empathy.

I’m sure everyone will have experienced this kind of response many times and been really frustrated when you try to tell a friend / parent / colleague about a difficult situation and they immediately start saying why don’t you try this, have you considered that? When all you want is for them to say, that sounds really tough, let me make you some tea. Giving advice / solutions instead of empathy is a very common way of reacting to hearing difficult things though, especially among the English!

Chenford · 13/02/2023 19:36

Jackofallsorts · 13/02/2023 19:17

@Chenford
Defined as "not fail".

I think there are many shades of grey between ‘total success’ and fail*

I know 5 adoptive families very well. Many many more less so and I’m less qualified to comment, so I won’t.

Of those 5…

1 is going well with whole family thriving
2 marriages have failed as a direct result of adoption
1 has disrupted (*not ‘failed’. The adoptive parents did absolutely everything they could and I would strongly rail against the word ‘fail’ being used to describe their lived experience even if it is in the abstract)
1 is going ok, but the parents would describe the relationships they have with their children as ‘transactional’ at best (their words).

I’m a big advocate of adoption - but it really is different to parenting birth children (not ‘natural parenting’ which is a hideous term that implies adoptive parenting is unnatural).

To pretend otherwise isn’t helpful to anyone, least of all the children who are by far the most important factor. As I’m sure you know given your personal and professional experience.

Particularprick · 13/02/2023 19:35

So sorry to read about your struggles op and yanbu. Agree with everything you have said.

People also talk about donor eggs and sperm and surrogacy as if they're not littered with moral and ethical questions and considerations. I very rarely see anyone give adoption or donor stuff any critical thought and it is never child focused. You want a kid? Do what you have to get one. No consideration for the decisions people make on these people they are creating (start reading about how donor kids feel... There isn't much out there but there is some).

Guaranteed any thread on here started by a woman who wants kids but isn't sure her partner is into it will get dozens of 'just get a sperm donor' replies. Like, have you considered a crossbody bag rather than a backpack? I find it horrifying and fertility clinics themselves are partly to blame - just get an egg donor, of course it'll be fine, you'll love it won't you?

Going through IVF has given me so much pause for thought. If I am ever lucky enough to have a kid I hope the thought I've had to give it will make me a better parent.

Adoption is different. It's not a 'solution' to infertility.

Good luck op

MatronicO6 · 13/02/2023 19:34

YANBU, I cringe when people suggest it. As if you don't know adoption exists. I know a two couples who adopted and adore their kids but it wasn't easy. The adoption process was long and emotional and the children had come from difficult family situations and needed a lot of support. It takes a special kind of person to adopt, it's much harder than just having your own and it's not for everyone. It also didn't magically erase their sadness they couldn't have children of their own.

At the same time, I think people just don't know what to say, what words of comfort or hope they can give, because there aren't any.

Prinnny · 13/02/2023 19:27

I think people say it because they just don’t know what to say. It’s a shame infertility is such a taboo subject. I think it comes from the right place but it’s the wrong thing to say when all you want is your own biological child.

I couldn’t adopt, the process sounds soul destroying, many children are damaged by past experiences, plus what after loving them for 18yrs they decide to go find their biological family, it’s just another heartbreak.

Praying you get what you want OP x

SquashPenguin · 13/02/2023 19:27

Say this louder for the people in the back!!!

I was ripped apart for trying to explain this on a different thread a while back. Probably because MN is full of people who like to pick which month they conceive in so not to clash with their brother’s/ cousin’s/ hamster’s birthday 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️, and don’t have a fucking clue how hard infertility is. No one would dream of suggesting adoption to a couple who conceived naturally.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/02/2023 19:26

Apologies @Coffeefig i hadn’t noticed you were quoting someone else - the thread moved a bit quickly for me and I missed it.

Coffeefig · 13/02/2023 19:23

@Jellycatspyjamas I know.. that's why I put it in quotation marks... it's what the PP I was replying to said, and I thought it was a ridiculous thing to say.. sorry if that wasn't clear!

OP posts:
Coffeefig · 13/02/2023 19:23

@Jackofallsorts I'm also not saying that adoption isn't rewarding or positive for the right situation / people – but it certainly isn't for everyone. Suggesting flippantly to anyone suffering from infertility that adoption is a solution is minimising the realities of adoption and I don't think is a responsible approach – this is my issue. As mentioned previously, I have huge respect for anyone who does go through the adoption process.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 13/02/2023 19:22

Of course, "natural parenting" is also challenging

Adoption isn’t “unnatural”.

NumberTheory · 13/02/2023 19:22

When I was struggling it was mooted a fair amount. I always saw it as people who were genuinely interested in what we were doing (we got lots of technical questions about infertility treatment too though, thankfully, not many about our sex life) and wanted the best for us. They never pushed it after we’d said we didn’t intend going that route. A couple of the people who asked were adopted themselves and one had a couple of adopted brothers. It felt a bit embarrassing saying no to them, but they were just as uninterested in changing our mind on the matter as anyone else. Some of the others had had their own struggles with fertility and were asking in part because it was an opportunity to discuss their own journey and compare and draw support and validation.

I only talked with people who were actually friends, though. So I’ve always been able to start off by assuming good intent. It might be different if you talk a lot with acquaintances or, say, family you don’t really like that much.

LividNC · 13/02/2023 19:21

I’ve said this before on MN but a nurse in the “bad news” room of EPU once asked if I’d considered adoption.

I have several very close friends who have adopted and they always knew it would be their route, like I always knew it would not be right for me.

The nurse was well meaning enough, but fucking hell.

Coffeefig · 13/02/2023 19:20

@Phineyj thank you so much for looking for me. I think I will give it another go – and posting on the infertility board for recommendations is a good suggestion x

OP posts:
Coffeefig · 13/02/2023 19:19

Jackofallsorts · 13/02/2023 19:05

@Coffeefig
I'm not sure why my response needs to be verified by personal experience. Adoption can be very challenging - just like natural parenting is challenging at times. But adoption is not for everyone and is not an "answer" to fertility issues and should not be presented as one. It's an alternative for some people.
And yes I can draw on personal experience of both fertility issues and adoption in a personal and professional capacity.

You previously said "Adoption is a realistic alternative for many couples and is seen as being overwhelmingly positive for both parents and child."

This is very different from what you have just said above... I was asking where you got the understanding of it being "overwhelmingly positive" as that is quite a sweeping statement and you made no mentions of the specific challenges it poses.

Of course, "natural parenting" is also challenging – but there are specific challenges with adoption that need to be addressed and the process needs to be entered into with a realistic understanding of those challenges (which many PP with much more experience than myself have detailed)

OP posts:
Jackofallsorts · 13/02/2023 19:17

@Chenford
Defined as "not fail".

Chenford · 13/02/2023 19:14

Jackofallsorts · 13/02/2023 19:09

@Chenford
Adoption is a rigorous and very involved process (thanks fully). I can't imagine any adult goes through it with out being very cognisant of the downside and upsides. It's a key part of the preparation.
It doesn't work out for everyone but thankfully for the majority this is not the case.

I know it’s a rigorous and involved process.…. I’ve done it.

How are you defining ‘work out’?

Phineyj · 13/02/2023 19:13

Another thought -- OP, you may find you get understanding in places you don't expect. Just because people are your relations/closest friends doesn't mean they're the ones.

I confided in a friend from my choir. She has suffered many difficulties in her life and tactless people suggesting simplistic solutions.

She was so kind and helpful.

If you reflect on the people you know, there will be others "on the outside" of the mainstream through no fault of their own. They will get it.

Orangesare · 13/02/2023 19:11

I realise it very unhelpful and hurtful when people say just adopt. But people do the same for most problems others have, although the solution is different. It seems to be human nature to want to solve problems. You know people suggesting changing your diet to cure a very disabling illness because great aunt Maude stopped eating anything from the potato family and could swing from the chandeliers once again. It would be comical if one’s self esteem wasn’t so battered.
I don’t think it’s meant ever in a hurtful way but it does hurt because there’s no easy answer and one’s life is out of step with the majority of peoples and they can comprehend it.

Jackofallsorts · 13/02/2023 19:09

@Chenford
Adoption is a rigorous and very involved process (thanks fully). I can't imagine any adult goes through it with out being very cognisant of the downside and upsides. It's a key part of the preparation.
It doesn't work out for everyone but thankfully for the majority this is not the case.

Phineyj · 13/02/2023 19:08

Sorry OP, looks like at some point I deleted emails that were 10+ years old.

But do keep looking. It needs to be the right fit.

PineappleMel · 13/02/2023 19:07

People can suggest whatever solutions they wish. You are free to reject any suggestions as you wish. But you don't get to police people's responses. You do not have that right or power.

Jackofallsorts · 13/02/2023 19:05

@Coffeefig
I'm not sure why my response needs to be verified by personal experience. Adoption can be very challenging - just like natural parenting is challenging at times. But adoption is not for everyone and is not an "answer" to fertility issues and should not be presented as one. It's an alternative for some people.
And yes I can draw on personal experience of both fertility issues and adoption in a personal and professional capacity.

Chenford · 13/02/2023 19:04

Jackofallsorts · 13/02/2023 18:45

There harsh reality for many couples is that they will be unable to conceive. There is now a whole industry (usually private) offering many services to couples which can lead to "false hope" not to mention the considerable expense. Prof Robert Winston has spoken on this at length.
Adoption is a realistic alternative for many couples and is seen as being overwhelmingly positive for both parents and child.
People who suggest this are not being callous or unthoughtful, it's a reasonable suggestion.

It might be seen as ‘overwhelmingly positive’

It absolutely doesn’t turn out that way for many and prospective adopters need to go into it with their eyes wide open.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/02/2023 19:04

Genuinely interested, as a lot of the experiences I have read and know of are quite challenging. I'm sure that if you are equipped to take on those challenges it can be a rewarding experience,

I wholeheartedly agree that adoption isn’t a bandaid for infertility - kids needing adoption deserve much better than that.

It is challenging, you’re loving and caring for a child you don’t know and you don’t have pregnancy hormones to help with that adjustment to parenthood. And yes, some children needing adoption have significant challenges and as is the case for all children with additional needs, support is pretty scarce and hard fought for.

I don’t consider adoption a “rewarding experience” any more than any other parent does. It’s life changing, my kids bring a joy and depth of love that is indescribable, I love them with every fibre of my being. Any challenges they have are just part of the little people they are, and we deal with them as any family would.

It’s hard thinking in abstract about taking unknown children into your heart, loving them and caring for them. It’s easy to look at their background and see the difficulties but there are huge potentials there too. I’m not doing them a service being their parent, I am their parent in every sense of the word, they’re my own kids and any challenges that come along are just part and parcel of family life.

Adoption isn’t an answer to infertility- it’s a wonderful, unique way to create a family.

Phineyj · 13/02/2023 19:02

I think I was just lucky tbh. I googled and found one I liked the look of. I sympathise though -- DH and I were sent to one (by the NHS) who was so awful she shouldn't have been practising.

Now a lot of them will counsel online, maybe it's worth posting on the infertility board here and asking for recommendations?

I will also see if I can find the company I used, but it was 10+ years ago.

Swipe left for the next trending thread