Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Take Back Control of our borders"

345 replies

verdantverdure · 13/02/2023 14:22

AIBU to think the Brexiteer rallying cry of "Take Back Control of our borders" did not lead me to expect net migration at record levels, asylum seekers in small boats at record levels, and suspect diseased meat in Britain due to a lack of border checks seven years after the vote.

You?

YANBU This was not what I understood by the phrase "take back control of our borders"

YABU I know what I voted for, and it was exactly this. Diseased meat YUM!

"Take Back Control of our borders"
"Take Back Control of our borders"
"Take Back Control of our borders"
OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
motherofqilins · 15/02/2023 07:34

you still fail to make an argument against the legitimate criticism towards the EU. It pushed down wages and has for a long time mainly benefited the middle classes at the cost of the working class that saw their own wage being pushed down by employers now actually finding people who will their job for literal peanuts. but yes the middle classes get their cheap labour.

verdantverdure · 15/02/2023 06:48

There's a noticeable overlap between how people who voted Remain seven years ago and people who voted Leave seven years ago describe Brexit

"Take Back Control of our borders"
"Take Back Control of our borders"
OP posts:
ListenToTheFacts · 15/02/2023 06:36

There's a real apathy towards the EU amongst Brits who actually live in the UK if you go out on the streets and talk to them. No one has the apetite to rejoin.

Take what a pro EU supporter claims are benefits of the EU and reverse them. E.g.

  1. "We get to live and work in 27+ nations visa free" vs "we can't control who comes to work and live here from 27 nations visa free".
  2. "We can trade freely with 27 nations" vs "we can't control the terms with those outside the EU that we can trade freely with".
  3. "We get economic benefits from being in the EU" vs "we have to pay billions to be in the EU and we believe those economic benefits can be replicated by a normal FTA".
  4. "We have the benefit of the EU having checks and balances over our national government vs "we have an unelected government and courts that can rule over our elected ones". And so on. Being in the EU has pros and cons. Just like being outside. The Pro EU side don't like to acknowledge any cons but that is in reality the only difference between Remainers and Brexit voters i.e. how we judge the pros and cons of exactly the same variables!

Would we be better off accepting FOM from the EU and flooding our coastal areas again with cheap workers while still dealing with the dinghy arrivals? If you have lived in one of the affected areas you will know what I mean.

Driving down wages again, accepting lorries thundering through the UK to Ireland which does not benefit us, accepting EU drivers to do backloads at a cost to our UK drivers? These are genuine questions - what do others think?

verdantverdure · 15/02/2023 06:04

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/02/2023 01:50

The UK needs to get Brexit done and become a more stable country before it can negotiate re-entering the EU.

Tricky when the thing that has destabilised our economy and given us 5 different Tory Prime Ministers since 2016...Is Brexit.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 15/02/2023 05:55

Good morning from Moscow Comrade @Blessedwithsunshine

The Kremlin concluded all UK policy objectives with Brexit. Just this one move weakens you by £2billion a week forever! More as time goes on.

We have old saying in Russia: “Country that can’t afford ambulances and operations can’t afford soldiers and tanks either!”

Brexit weakened EU a little bit too, and ruined special relationship between UK and US because Brexit causes a border that wrecks NI Good Friday Agreement.

The Single Market and Customs Union were keeping the peace in Ireland. Who knew?! (Everybody. But that didn’t stop you did it?)

It only cost us £4million in “donations” to Tory MPs in the Friends of Russia group!

It amuses us very much to have a Russian in your House of Lords. But when is a Russian not a Russian? When he has bought a golden visa from the Tories! Then he is a “UK citizen” and can make donations to The Tory Party from Putin.

We want you to leave the ECHR next, like Russia and Belarus.

Then the UN Convention on Refugees. Then the UN, then NATO.

But only for our own amusement.

You are of little strategic interest nowadays.

Our main aim is to stop Ukraine from joining EU and becoming successful and prosperous.

Like UK used to be.

Before Brexit.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 15/02/2023 01:50

The UK needs to get Brexit done and become a more stable country before it can negotiate re-entering the EU.

Blessedwithsunshine · 14/02/2023 21:23

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 20:41

It's costing the country £100 billion a year I read in The Telegraph.
Which is why we can no longer take it for granted that an ambulance will arrive when we need one. We can't afford civilised stuff like that any more.

Oh, it’s ‘we’ and ‘our’ now - well done for correcting your prior mistakes, no longer the ‘British people’
I was just wondering if it’s cold in Moscow or the weather generally

MarshaBradyo · 14/02/2023 20:54

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 20:09

Brexit voters are a dying breed though aren't they?

Most people don't want Brexit if it screws up our economy.

And that's exactly what it does.

The number of people committed to a Brexit that hurts their own country can't be very large can it?

It’s more what both parties are willing to do to win. Labour have already said no to SM and CU - presumably because they think it matters to enough voters.

I can’t see Tories reversing much

I do think outside FOM things will change but it’s that which causes a sticking point

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 20:41

Restingtoday · 14/02/2023 20:23

Brexit is a very large part of the reason we are all getting poorer and poorer. such an awful thing to happen to this country, so tory politicians and their mates could line their own pockets.

It's costing the country £100 billion a year I read in The Telegraph.
Which is why we can no longer take it for granted that an ambulance will arrive when we need one. We can't afford civilised stuff like that any more.

OP posts:
Restingtoday · 14/02/2023 20:23

Brexit is a very large part of the reason we are all getting poorer and poorer. such an awful thing to happen to this country, so tory politicians and their mates could line their own pockets.

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 20:16

Dymaxion · 13/02/2023 18:51

Is having African swine flu going to have an inpact on Liz's amazing pork markets in China deal ?

Everything Liz Truss does seems to screw someone over. Usually us if you've read one of her "trade deals".

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 20:09

MarshaBradyo · 14/02/2023 19:55

I don’t think that matters. Brexit voters won’t want FOM back.

It was one of the top reasons for voting according to analysis and I can’t see any party strong enough to sell it in.

Tories less likely but Labour already made unequivocal statement a few years prior to GE not to.

Brexit voters are a dying breed though aren't they?

Most people don't want Brexit if it screws up our economy.

And that's exactly what it does.

The number of people committed to a Brexit that hurts their own country can't be very large can it?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 14/02/2023 19:55

I don’t think that matters. Brexit voters won’t want FOM back.

It was one of the top reasons for voting according to analysis and I can’t see any party strong enough to sell it in.

Tories less likely but Labour already made unequivocal statement a few years prior to GE not to.

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:47

Net migration is higher than it was before Brexit and still climbing to ever higher record levels.

Freedom of movement is expected to reduce it.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:45

Oh sorry.

I meant it won't need to be in the Labour Manifesto.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 14/02/2023 19:39

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:34

They won't need it.

We'll already be 3/4 back in by the time Labour take over.

Stopping the downward death spiral of the U.K. economy is the only chance the Tories have got not to be wiped out at the next election.

So we're going back in, one step at a time. If Sunak can put the ERG back in their box and do it quickly they might even get to be the opposition next time.

We'll already be 3/4 back in by the time Labour take over.

Maybe you’re right idk. Do you mean SM and CU?

The problem that’s faced is FOM and I just can’t see Tories going back on that pre GE. Everything points to meeting lower movement not more. Five points etc including boats

So the Labour statement re no CU or SM goes into manifesto if they win

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:34

MarshaBradyo · 14/02/2023 19:28

The problem is a Labour manifesto won’t include it.

That’s out. I don’t think like the op that’s smart (I’m actually amazed someone who is this cross about Brexit sees Labour in a better light because they are chasing the Brexit voter over their preference, but anyway).. It’s just political cowardice to really make sure they don’t lose again. Miliband lead to loss was a kicker they don’t want to repeat.

It’s a big shame imo, if all these charts and polls are correct.

In another 6 to 7 years it may have worked out and we’ll never rejoin even SM, or not, but that’s a long time if not.

They won't need it.

We'll already be 3/4 back in by the time Labour take over.

Stopping the downward death spiral of the U.K. economy is the only chance the Tories have got not to be wiped out at the next election.

So we're going back in, one step at a time. If Sunak can put the ERG back in their box and do it quickly they might even get to be the opposition next time.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:31

Irish border! Sorry. Multi-tasking and typing with one thumb and no eyes.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:30

Lonelycrab · 14/02/2023 19:27

How long would it take to join SM or CU?

I don’t know. How long do you think it would take?

It would solve the Irish boot fee issue instantly so I think we're about to find out.

In between Rishi Sunak saying that Brexit is going well and he's proud to be a Brexiteer.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 14/02/2023 19:28

The problem is a Labour manifesto won’t include it.

That’s out. I don’t think like the op that’s smart (I’m actually amazed someone who is this cross about Brexit sees Labour in a better light because they are chasing the Brexit voter over their preference, but anyway).. It’s just political cowardice to really make sure they don’t lose again. Miliband lead to loss was a kicker they don’t want to repeat.

It’s a big shame imo, if all these charts and polls are correct.

In another 6 to 7 years it may have worked out and we’ll never rejoin even SM, or not, but that’s a long time if not.

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:28

@MarshaBradyo is right.

So long as they keep telling the Brexit fanatics that it's still Brexit and we're not rejoining the EU, most won't care about the details.

OP posts:
Lonelycrab · 14/02/2023 19:27

How long would it take to join SM or CU?

I don’t know. How long do you think it would take?

verdantverdure · 14/02/2023 19:21

All they have to do is renegotiate the Brexit deal @Lonelycrab. If Gibraltar can be part of Schengen we can be in the EFTA.

During the referendum campaign Brexiteers said we'd still be in Erasmus, Horizon, Reach, Europol, the Kite Mark, the Single Market and the Customs Union and probably more that I have forgotten so the first steps will be to renegotiate the deal so we realign. We can do that easily because the Leave campaign lied so much. We could have a Norway type deal any time we like.

Then we need greater cooperation and a pan Europe plan over things like semi conductors, future pandemics, energy, Defence, Russia, China...

Then the debate will be rule takers versus rule makers, and if we want a say we have to rejoin.

Then all we need is a referendum.

Back in for the 10th anniversary of the referendum? If not before.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 14/02/2023 19:20

Why not?

How long would it take to join SM or CU?

It doesn’t have to be full on rejoin in EU

All the commentary I’ve heard on this suggests it’s a political decision not practical barrier

Since MPs on both sides are not willing to go there as they don’t want to lose the Brexit voter I haven’t heard much on why. I googled, a few things came up including this

‘This does not mean opening a debate about rejoining the EU. That ship sailed some time ago. But there is a new possibility. The EU has held out an olive branch: to join a grouping of European countries that don’t want to be part of the EU but do want to benefit from its single market and many collaborative bodies.’

It’s The Guardian and yes remain bias but it seems outside politics people are asking the same question.

Lonelycrab · 14/02/2023 19:10

People keep posting charts re dissatisfaction with Brexit

Yes, but that doesn’t translate into simply undoing it, because thats not the reality of it, that’s what I mean. It’s a years and possibly decades thing. You can’t just stick that as an election pledge unless your names David Cameron of course