Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Take Back Control of our borders"

345 replies

verdantverdure · 13/02/2023 14:22

AIBU to think the Brexiteer rallying cry of "Take Back Control of our borders" did not lead me to expect net migration at record levels, asylum seekers in small boats at record levels, and suspect diseased meat in Britain due to a lack of border checks seven years after the vote.

You?

YANBU This was not what I understood by the phrase "take back control of our borders"

YABU I know what I voted for, and it was exactly this. Diseased meat YUM!

"Take Back Control of our borders"
"Take Back Control of our borders"
"Take Back Control of our borders"
OP posts:
Thread gallery
37
thehorsehasnowbolted · 17/02/2023 00:21

Most lower skilled young Indians use UK as a stop gap arrangement and want to move to Canada. Canada is considered a more tolerant and family friendly country.

😂

Have you been keeping up with the news? Canada would certainly not be my first choice at the moment if I came from a traditional background and was looking for a tolerant and family friendly country (where my values were respected)

thehorsehasnowbolted · 17/02/2023 00:17

Can you imagine a better advert for the EU than only 3 years after the Brexit bongs the UK is back in?

I expect the EU would be happy for everyone to know this.

It's quite puzzling that you are so invested in how well or badly the EU is perceived. Why don't you focus on what's important..like the UK?

You seem a bit desperate

Timesawastin · 16/02/2023 22:16

DadOnIce · 13/02/2023 15:42

Yyyyyyyyyeah, right. A better analogy would be that we are in the 'middle-aged bloke who divorced his wife of 25 years because he thought the grass would be greener on the other side (even though all his mates advised against it) now finds fit 20-somethings are not exactly falling over themselves to sleep with him, and he is stuck in a basement wanking and eating cold baked beans out of a tin' phase.

Beautifully put.

verdantverdure · 16/02/2023 21:42

Not as OK as I'll be when Brexit has been reversed and is no longer dragging our country down, obvs.

I thought it might take a decade, but Brexit is such a crock of shit it's only been two years since the Brexit bongs.

Pretty chuffed actually @ListenToTheFacts Grin

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 16/02/2023 21:41

WiIson · 16/02/2023 20:13

It's happening. Watch.

I doubt that very much. It seems like it's all getting to you a bit.

You should bear in mind that I didn't vote for the obvious lies of Brexit so I have a track record of being right, whereas people who did have a track record of being wrong. Grin

OP posts:
WiIson · 16/02/2023 20:13

It's happening. Watch.

I doubt that very much. It seems like it's all getting to you a bit.

ListenToTheFacts · 16/02/2023 19:40

verdantverdure · 16/02/2023 14:26

People used to say that Gibraltar would never join Schengen. But look at it. It effectively is in Schengen right now. Spain control Gibraltar's borders and Gibraltar has an open border with Spain. The UK government just haven't admitted that's Schengen.

People used to say we wouldn't be able to rejoin the EU for 40 years.

Then they said we wouldn't be able to rejoin for 20 years.

But it's on the table now. Already. After only 6.5 years because everyone can see that Brexit is bad for Britain and most people don't want that.

We’re going to rejoin the Single Market. We’re going to rejoin the Customs Union. We’re going to rejoin the EMA. We’re going to rejoin the Horizon 2020/FP9 science programmers. We’re going to rejoin the Copernicus & Galileo space programmes, We’re going to rejoin Erasmus+, We’re going to rejoin Euratom, rejoin the REACH framework, rejoin Open Skies, rejoin Europol, rejoin EASA, rejoin EGNOS, rejoin Natura 2000. Probably financial passporting and the EHIC healthcare system too.

Then we'll want a say in all the rules we're taking and rejoining will be complete.

It's happening. Watch.

Lol...are you ok, hun?

ilikepinknblue · 16/02/2023 15:59

Jimboscott0115 · 14/02/2023 07:48

Feels like it could be quite a mutually beneficial deal to be fair, we plug in the gaps in our skills shortage and increase trade and India gets more trade, plus a regular flow of returnees with even more skills and entrepreneurial ability.

Currenr Indian government is right wing, and there is a sudden rise in anti English/ British sentiment because of colonial past.

After covid travel travel restrictions were lifted, India allowed eVisa to all EU countries but not to the UK citizens purely because of political reasons. UK had far better relationship with India when it was part of EU.

T individual level, Indians find countries like US, Dubai, Singapore highly lucrative financially and for growth opportunities.

Regarding lower skill workers, they prefer countries like Canada.

Would you like to move to a country which is 5 time zones away and you need to travel about 15 hours + to visit your family to pick vegetables in farm? Most lower skilled young Indians use UK as a stop gap arrangement and want to move to Canada. Canada is considered a more tolerant and family friendly country.

UK can only be attractive to immigrants from far away countries if its economy and public services are in good condition, which is not the case currently.

verdantverdure · 16/02/2023 15:07

lljkk · 15/02/2023 22:51

There was a podcast called Remainiacs now called OGWN.
So they are fervent Remainers & even they say that rejoining is a tricky decision. UK's old deal (rebate, not in single currency, all sorts of special membership tweaks) is gone, couldn't be reclaimed.

Single market is best Uk could hope for.

Can you imagine a better advert for the EU than only 3 years after the Brexit bongs the UK is back in?

Everyone will know that our economy took a nose dive in 2016 as soon as there was even the possibility that we might do something so monumentally stupid as leave the most successful trading bloc of all time on our doorstep and try to go it alone. In a world where most countries are all in trading blocs with the countries on their doorstep.

Everyone will know our economy has been on a downward trajectory ever since.

Everyone will know how badly Brexit has failed.

I expect the EU would be happy for everyone to know this.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 16/02/2023 14:26

People used to say that Gibraltar would never join Schengen. But look at it. It effectively is in Schengen right now. Spain control Gibraltar's borders and Gibraltar has an open border with Spain. The UK government just haven't admitted that's Schengen.

People used to say we wouldn't be able to rejoin the EU for 40 years.

Then they said we wouldn't be able to rejoin for 20 years.

But it's on the table now. Already. After only 6.5 years because everyone can see that Brexit is bad for Britain and most people don't want that.

We’re going to rejoin the Single Market. We’re going to rejoin the Customs Union. We’re going to rejoin the EMA. We’re going to rejoin the Horizon 2020/FP9 science programmers. We’re going to rejoin the Copernicus & Galileo space programmes, We’re going to rejoin Erasmus+, We’re going to rejoin Euratom, rejoin the REACH framework, rejoin Open Skies, rejoin Europol, rejoin EASA, rejoin EGNOS, rejoin Natura 2000. Probably financial passporting and the EHIC healthcare system too.

Then we'll want a say in all the rules we're taking and rejoining will be complete.

It's happening. Watch.

OP posts:
Blessedwithsunshine · 16/02/2023 07:52

Clearly op has not realised the legal, financial and political hurdles that any kind of ‘rejoining’ would look like.

It’s a total non starter and even the most devoted remain activist have accepted it will never happen. They are pushing for single market entry. Rejoining would mean accepting the euro, FOM and paying tens of billions again, joining future EU army and all the other present and future plans the EU has. Without a say. Sorry to break to you op but there is zero chance of this.

MarshaBradyo · 16/02/2023 07:24

Democracy is people voting for MPs at a GE

They usually represent a party. Neither party is giving you the option to join SM or CU. One has already stated it won’t happen.

So of course you can be loud as you like but in this instance politicians are more worried about winning the Brexit voter.

No one has said they’ve written to their MP, whatever is happening being loud on places like mn isn’t doing much.

I think on other issues it does actually do something but for remainers not really.

verdantverdure · 16/02/2023 05:59

Democracy isn’t trying to silence people pointing out that Brexit is hurting our country.

Democracy isn’t being held hostage by the bad decision of people who want to continue with a course of action that hurts our country.

Democracy is free speech and being free to change course to one that doesn’t hurt our country.

"Take Back Control of our borders"
"Take Back Control of our borders"
"Take Back Control of our borders"
OP posts:
lljkk · 15/02/2023 22:51

There was a podcast called Remainiacs now called OGWN.
So they are fervent Remainers & even they say that rejoining is a tricky decision. UK's old deal (rebate, not in single currency, all sorts of special membership tweaks) is gone, couldn't be reclaimed.

Single market is best Uk could hope for.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 18:34

verdantverdure · 15/02/2023 14:18

@OopsAnotherOne

Why do we "have to"

Don't we live in a democracy any more?

Yes, democracy has worked and people have voted to Leave.

Can we drop it now?

verdantverdure · 15/02/2023 14:18

@OopsAnotherOne

Why do we "have to"

Don't we live in a democracy any more?

OP posts:
OopsAnotherOne · 15/02/2023 11:38

OP - A lot of us knew this would happen as we understood we already had control of our borders and the whole "take back control" was a guise to get the headline readers foamed up. It worked! But this is what we knew would happen. It was dismissed as "fear mongering" by the people who now call threads daring to mention Brexit "goady".

There's no point engaging with it - what's done is done and we can't change the past. People voted the way they chose to, for reasons that they may or may not still believe. Some people may or may not now regret the way they voted, on both sides. Everyone had the right to vote however they wanted to and as a country, the majority of people who voted decided to vote to leave. All we can concentrate on now is trying to reduce the amount of people making dangerous crossings and drowning in the channel, as well as trying to revive our struggling economy. We just now have to do that outside of the world's largest trading bloc.

verdantverdure · 15/02/2023 11:30

unherd.com/2023/01/introducing-unherd-britain-2023/

"Take Back Control of our borders"
OP posts:
thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 11:18

WhatdoImean · 15/02/2023 10:49

Hmmm - or it could be more like rushing overboard, throwing yourself on a raft with a single sail (and no navigation) while the cruise liner keeps on heading off in the Med (severely lacking in Icebergs) over the horizon with you shouting "Hahahah - See I told you! Any moment now, any moment, a LOT more people will jump overboard, just you wait. Any moment now. Any. Moment. Now....."

Severly lacking in Icebergs? Really?😂

SleeplessInEngland · 15/02/2023 10:51

YANBU, but if I'm honest we haven't really had a proper Brexit so far.

Fuck off with this, we absolutely did.

You sound like the communists who say 'real communism has never been tried.'

WhatdoImean · 15/02/2023 10:49

Hmmm - or it could be more like rushing overboard, throwing yourself on a raft with a single sail (and no navigation) while the cruise liner keeps on heading off in the Med (severely lacking in Icebergs) over the horizon with you shouting "Hahahah - See I told you! Any moment now, any moment, a LOT more people will jump overboard, just you wait. Any moment now. Any. Moment. Now....."

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 09:44

WhatdoImean · 15/02/2023 09:37

The sad sad truth is... there is very little chance of us rejoining the EU.

We may rejoin specific elements (SM etc.), but not the EU.

Why? Because the UK has shown itself to be an unreliable negotiator; threatening to break the agreements that WE proposed, not implementing elements that we said we would etc. Even now we still are not even doing the basics for the WTO trade (we need a crazy number of vets to be able to even think of doing the sanitary checks etc on incoming food), etc.

As a result, considering that we would need a unanimous vote that we can rejoin, who in their right mind would say "yes" to the UK rejoining?

As a remainer (and proud of it), the BEST that I can hope for is joining the CU/SM and accepting that the price of some right wing loons wanting to avoid paying tax have destroyed our world political standing along with our economy.

Good, we need to look out for ourselves

The EU lunacy will unravel soon enough. See what's happening in the Netherlands with farmers, etc. We need room to maneouvre

Insisting with rejoining the EU would be like managing a narrow escape on a boat from the Titanic and then frantically paddling trying to re-embark

WhatdoImean · 15/02/2023 09:37

The sad sad truth is... there is very little chance of us rejoining the EU.

We may rejoin specific elements (SM etc.), but not the EU.

Why? Because the UK has shown itself to be an unreliable negotiator; threatening to break the agreements that WE proposed, not implementing elements that we said we would etc. Even now we still are not even doing the basics for the WTO trade (we need a crazy number of vets to be able to even think of doing the sanitary checks etc on incoming food), etc.

As a result, considering that we would need a unanimous vote that we can rejoin, who in their right mind would say "yes" to the UK rejoining?

As a remainer (and proud of it), the BEST that I can hope for is joining the CU/SM and accepting that the price of some right wing loons wanting to avoid paying tax have destroyed our world political standing along with our economy.

CryingAtTheDiscotheque · 15/02/2023 09:35

I thought the reason politicians "don't go there" re advantages of eg joining SM/CU is to do with the key electoral seats. Labour need to win back the red wall, where there is still some/relatively more support for Brexit. So Keir Starmer for example can't risk losing votes there by talking openly about the huge damage Brexit has caused/is still causing.

Having said that a recent survey suggested that only Boston in Lincolnshire was still a Brexit supporting area so perhaps that explanation does not stack up any more.

MarshaBradyo · 15/02/2023 07:39

ListenToTheFacts · 15/02/2023 06:36

There's a real apathy towards the EU amongst Brits who actually live in the UK if you go out on the streets and talk to them. No one has the apetite to rejoin.

Take what a pro EU supporter claims are benefits of the EU and reverse them. E.g.

  1. "We get to live and work in 27+ nations visa free" vs "we can't control who comes to work and live here from 27 nations visa free".
  2. "We can trade freely with 27 nations" vs "we can't control the terms with those outside the EU that we can trade freely with".
  3. "We get economic benefits from being in the EU" vs "we have to pay billions to be in the EU and we believe those economic benefits can be replicated by a normal FTA".
  4. "We have the benefit of the EU having checks and balances over our national government vs "we have an unelected government and courts that can rule over our elected ones". And so on. Being in the EU has pros and cons. Just like being outside. The Pro EU side don't like to acknowledge any cons but that is in reality the only difference between Remainers and Brexit voters i.e. how we judge the pros and cons of exactly the same variables!

Would we be better off accepting FOM from the EU and flooding our coastal areas again with cheap workers while still dealing with the dinghy arrivals? If you have lived in one of the affected areas you will know what I mean.

Driving down wages again, accepting lorries thundering through the UK to Ireland which does not benefit us, accepting EU drivers to do backloads at a cost to our UK drivers? These are genuine questions - what do others think?

The latest study showed lower appetite to rejoin overall. Not sure re SM and CU, but politicians have taken view not to use those key words as not liked enough.

Generally people are ok with closer connections though and ease of trade presumably. Basically don’t reverse much but ok to do other stuff. On immigration people are more ok with skill based visas than boat issue.