Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people outsource life

370 replies

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 12:36

Some outsourcing of life is fairly normal. Using some childcare, having a weekly cleaner for those who can afford it, dog walkers, etc. But there comes a point where people seem to outsource a lot of life that is not work.

So people who have several nannies so the child is only brought to them for the fun bits of life. Having firms in to decorate your house for Christmas and put up a tree. Having staff to plan, organise and run your child's birthday party with you just showing up to welcome parents and smile as you watch. Having staff to choose and buy your kids Christmas presents.

I used to nanny for families like this and I think you just end up outsourcing life outside of work. Trying to live a personal life like this must be really unfulfilling.

OP posts:
bussteward · 13/02/2023 14:46

I should outsource arguing on Mumsnet, I’d free up so much time.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 14:45

@minipie Lots of men have pretty superficial relationships with their kids.
But no not all men do this.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 13/02/2023 14:42

I love outsourcing. I get to spend my time doing what I want to do, which is way more fulfilling than doing the stuff I don’t.

I’ve never been of the mindset that doing things I don’t want to do, if I don’t have to, is either valuable or necessary when it comes to my moral development. Seems a bit Protestant and joyless tbh.

minipie · 13/02/2023 14:41

Many men outsource all of this —shit— domestic joy to their wives.

They seem pretty fulfilled.

Do you judge them too OP? Or just the women?

GerbilsForever24 · 13/02/2023 14:41

Funny how the examples of outsourcing are all things that women tend to do. No one is suggesting that outsourcing the growing and processing of food is "not living life" nor that choosing to employ someone to build a house or do repairs is "not living life".

This is just a marginally more subtle way of judging women for daring NOT to do all the shitty bits of life.

UpCloseAndVeryPersonal · 13/02/2023 14:39

@womanwithbooks "The idea that you miss 'the small moments' with your children if you're not burdened down doing endless chores is a fantasy dreamed up to keep women earning less! It's precisely because I outsource so much that in the evenings and at the weekends, my time is my own and I can do all sorts of things with my kids, big and small, without constantly telling them I'm too busy/just have to clean something/mow the lawn/clean the car/whatever."

Couldn't agree more. There's nothing heroic about wasting your precious time on chores. It makes you LESS available to your kids, not more.

I hired a party planning agency to do my DD's bday this year, and it went like a dream. I had time to take photos and videos, join in with the games, laugh and have fun and chat with the kids, it was brilliant. In previous years I've been stuck in the kitchen, making endless rounds of sandwiches and stressing.

Lucky me to have the money to do it, I know, but it was worth every penny.

Gerwurtztraminer · 13/02/2023 14:39

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 14:14

@FineThings There is a sci fi film about just that and he ends up being very unfulfilled and knowing he missed out with shallow family relationships.
I think important life happens in the cracks. I know if I have a deep conversation with my kids say about things bothering them, it is never when we are doing the big fun activities. Instead it is when I am cleaning the kitchen, or driving them somewhere, or just something mundane.

I know if I have a deep conversation with my kids say about things bothering them, it is never when we are doing the big fun activities.

It's going to be a tiny minority of people who outsource every single opportunity for your so-called 'mundane' interactions with their children.

Even for the mega rich, there will be many who still have times together chatting over something comparable to cleaning the kitchen or driving kids to activities (for them that might be sorting out the Gucci handbags in the walk or travelling on the private jet but it's still unstructured time together). It might not be what you aspire to but doesn't make them 'wrong'. You are saying their relationships with their children are less meaningful than yours and their lives less fulfilled. You can't know that - what's the measure of 'meaningfulness' that you are winning on and they are losing? It's based on your opinion so it is judgemental.

WickedStepmomNOT · 13/02/2023 14:38

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 14:28

@womanwithbooks You have a poor woman who is expected to be nanny, cleaner and housekeeper? So basically run around cleaning and doing housekeeping and making sure the kid is kept alive.

And chosing to do it and being paid for it - unlike the wife / mother! What's the problem?

rexythedinosaur · 13/02/2023 14:38

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 12:41

My point is outsourcing the bits you do not want to do just leads to an unfulfilling personal life. You can't just play with your child for half an hour a day and then read them a story once staff have them tucked up in bed and settled down to listen, and have a meaningful deep relationship. It is curating life experiences in a very false way.

Maybe unfulfilling for you, but not for those who decide to do it.

People are different.

WestwardHo1 · 13/02/2023 14:37

Forgot grocery shopping and gardening. Decorating. House maintenance.

Pyewhacket · 13/02/2023 14:36

womanwithbooks , I agree with you that time is the most valuable of everything, once it's gone you can never have it back. And time spent on "stuff" that I can "outsource" is time claimed for what genuinely matters to me. That is why I have a cleaner, a gardener, and a handyman to do the DIY and the odd jobs.

WestwardHo1 · 13/02/2023 14:36

Ah man, if I could afford it I would outsource large amounts of my life. Cooking, cleaning, laundry and admin to start with...

What's that I hear? That they are so fulfilling?

BodyShapeWoes · 13/02/2023 14:32

I’d love to be able to afford to pay someone to come and put up & take down my Christmas decorations 😂

I’d personally outsource most of it, cleaning, cooking someone to do the house admin (car tax/insurances)

Id love to be able to just spend evenings with the kids doing fun stuff and not having to rush to get the washing on, cook dinner etc

GenuinelyDone · 13/02/2023 14:28

If I had the money I'd outsource everything apart from looking after my children. I've always joked to a colleague that if I won the lottery she would be my personal assistant who could then organise outsourcing everything for me. She loves that sort of thing and would be delighted if I gave her a blank cheque for shopping.

There's nothing life affirming in shopping, organising, decorating, cleaning, hosting parties or gardening for me. They are all chores and I hate every minute spent on them. Each to their own.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 14:28

@womanwithbooks You have a poor woman who is expected to be nanny, cleaner and housekeeper? So basically run around cleaning and doing housekeeping and making sure the kid is kept alive.

OP posts:
Andsoforth · 13/02/2023 14:28

I’m not sure I believe in fulfilment.

bussteward · 13/02/2023 14:28

If I had the cash, I’d outsource:

Childcare
Weekend clubs and activities and transport
Driving
Cleaning AND tidying
Life admin/household management
Food shopping and meal planning
Some cooking except when I feel like it
The grunt work gardening
Decorating
Social diary

Loads of things! Life would be heaven: come down on a Saturday to the kids already up and dressed and being supervised, breakfast on the table, then someone else cleans it up while the driver takes us to a farm or something. All the fun bits of time as a family with none of the dishwasher loading or arguments about car seats. More time to read books and write and paint and sew, to go for walks, to flit about my country estate dictating a list for the staff of what canapé I’d like at the party, and please have afternoon tea ready promptly on my return. Heaven.

GloomyDarkness · 13/02/2023 14:27

If I could have outsource household drudge task to spend even more time with the kids and me- I would have.

I suspect the Op is talking about parents who are outsource the spending time with kids bit as well to fit more work or more socialising centered around work - networking more than fun.

I only really know one couple who did this in RL though they used GP rather than professional nanny - it was extreme more GP raising child than parents then parents being surprised the teen and they weren't close.

I suspect most people find a reasonable balance in life and OP as a nanny has just seen the extreme version of this behavior.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 13/02/2023 14:27

Sounds great to me.

womanwithbooks · 13/02/2023 14:25

YAB very U, in my opinion. Nothing is more important or valuable than time - literally not one thing. No money in the world can buy it back and when it's gone, it's gone. I'm slightly obsessive about it, to be honest, and am continually baffled by people who make decisions that suggest they don't understand this.

I prioritise time above all else and am now a high earner in a busy job so I outsource a lot. We have a part-time nanny/cleaner/housekeeper (same person) who does a lot of chores, also have a gardener, do online shopping. There are other chores both my husband and I enjoy doing and so don't outsource, like cooking.

I've only recently earned enough to be able to do this so I've done it the other way too - outsourcing much less stuff, doing more chores myself. And it's unquestionably worse. The idea that you miss 'the small moments' with your children if you're not burdened down doing endless chores is a fantasy dreamed up to keep women earning less! It's precisely because I outsource so much that in the evenings and at the weekends, my time is my own and I can do all sorts of things with my kids, big and small, without constantly telling them I'm too busy/just have to clean something/mow the lawn/clean the car/whatever. I am home from work every night in time to have dinner with them, I read to the little one and put him to bed every night etc.

The other thing that should go without saying but doesn't always in threads like these is if one of my kids has a problem or needs me I drop everything for them, regardless of what is going on at work. They are not having difficult and emotional conversations with my nanny because I'm not around...

Some of my worst and toughest times for both me and my kids were when my career was at the point when it was busy enough that I had to work hard, but not earning enough to outsource anything. I felt like I was constantly telling them 'in a minute, I just need to reply to this message/put away this washing etc etc'. It was 100% not an experience any of us cherished or 'making memories' that anyone will be clinging on to...

WickedStepmomNOT · 13/02/2023 14:24

I'd certainly employ staff if I could - especially a cook. No more dieting, just 3 calorie controlled but tasty meals served by a professional daily and no being tempted going into the kitchen.

I love my cat dearly, but won't miss litter box cleaning. Ditto DSD's room after her EOW stays when she seems to deliberately trash her room, and DH buries his head in his book to remain Mr nice dad.

Slowsteps · 13/02/2023 14:24

I would totally outsource most of these things if I could!

But agree that you probably lead a very selfish existence if you don’t have to do anything that you don’t want to do.

I don’t think it’s very good for the kids either not to have to help with chores and not to understand that adults have to do these things.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 14:24

rubberduckiee · 13/02/2023 14:17

I used to outsource most things, even as a uni student – that's how I was brought up – but living with DH was a revelation as we both fought and bonded over doing chores etc, growing closer over the process :) Sorting out groceries and other mundane tasks together was frustrating but bonding.

That said now that not being able to outsource is a permanent financial reality for us, I would love to have the option! I still wouldn't outsource everything or even most things though.

Otherwise everything you focus on at the level above daily tasks - eg large corporate projects - is abstract, amorphous and often asocial in a sense. A tiny amount of graft and necessity adds both simplicity and connection (to loved ones around you sharing that life) to your life imo.

Thank you for explaining this better than I did.

OP posts:
rubberduckiee · 13/02/2023 14:23

Should have said "everything you focus on at the level above daily tasks - eg large corporate projects, emotional navel-gazing and/or superficial enjoyment".. The latter 2 especially are poisonous in large doses 😅

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/02/2023 14:23

With parties ,some people enjoy the planning and hosting. I bloody hate it. You spend all your time getting stressed and filling people's glasses. You do'nt get to enjoy them yourself. I would enjoy them a lot more if someone else was running the party and I could just mingle with my guests.

General childcare of little ones I was more than happy to do with mine as I enjoyed it. You build bonds while you're having little sing songs with them during a nappy change etc. or teaching them how to tie their shoelaces. If I could have disappeared at meal times and have someone else cook and feed them I would have done that though cos mine were a nightmare to feed. I do agree that some parents don't seem to know their children that well, and it's probably through not spending enough time with them generally.

Cleaning - I bloody hate it, all of it. Gardening, I hate the boring stuff so I'd pay someone to do that if I could. I'd like the nice stuff like buying plants and planning borders etc.

Cooking, I'm not a huge fan really although I can. DH enjoys it more so he does most of it. But if I could get a chef in 3 nights a week to do lovely meals then I absolutely would.