Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some people outsource life

370 replies

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 12:36

Some outsourcing of life is fairly normal. Using some childcare, having a weekly cleaner for those who can afford it, dog walkers, etc. But there comes a point where people seem to outsource a lot of life that is not work.

So people who have several nannies so the child is only brought to them for the fun bits of life. Having firms in to decorate your house for Christmas and put up a tree. Having staff to plan, organise and run your child's birthday party with you just showing up to welcome parents and smile as you watch. Having staff to choose and buy your kids Christmas presents.

I used to nanny for families like this and I think you just end up outsourcing life outside of work. Trying to live a personal life like this must be really unfulfilling.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 13/02/2023 17:30

LobeliaBaggins · 13/02/2023 17:24

Why is baking so venerated on MN? I have never baked with my DC. Probably because I don't bake at all. My mum never baked either, and I didn't care.

I bake with mine because we all enjoy it. If they didn't, I'd do something else with them.

Actually, we've done a lot less since I started making a hard effort to lose the lockdown weight. But I still do things with them.

RedToothBrush · 13/02/2023 17:26

Daizie · 13/02/2023 12:37

If these people have plenty of money and don't want to do these tasks themselves what's the problem?

DH runs a scout group and has seen kids who are effectively parented by au pairs and nannies. And it shows. They aren't a substitute for a parent because there's one thing they can't provide - and thats love.

We refer to it to a form of emotional neglect.

I think child care is fine - to a point - but there is a point where there's too much too. There's times you have to be there for your kids because they need you, not just when it fits in with your other life plans. Its all about how they fit into life in terms of being a priority.

Bitofhelpoverhere · 13/02/2023 17:24

Honestly, a lot of that sounds brilliant. I have fantasies about the army of servants I would have to outsource my life too, if I could afford it. I’d even have a valet to tell me what to wear Grin

LobeliaBaggins · 13/02/2023 17:24

Why is baking so venerated on MN? I have never baked with my DC. Probably because I don't bake at all. My mum never baked either, and I didn't care.

LoraPiano · 13/02/2023 17:22

As a child of parents who outsourced everything, I think it affects children. A lot of interaction with children happen when you pick them up from schoo, stop for a pain au chocolat on the way, take them to their evening lessons, cook or do gardening when they are around etc. All these in my house was done by others. I had quality time with my parents, but found our family time to be a bit forced and artificial and they were disengaged from the minutia of life that I used to find exciting as a child. I can remember literally one occasion when I baked with my mother.

Funkyblues101 · 13/02/2023 17:21

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 12:36

Some outsourcing of life is fairly normal. Using some childcare, having a weekly cleaner for those who can afford it, dog walkers, etc. But there comes a point where people seem to outsource a lot of life that is not work.

So people who have several nannies so the child is only brought to them for the fun bits of life. Having firms in to decorate your house for Christmas and put up a tree. Having staff to plan, organise and run your child's birthday party with you just showing up to welcome parents and smile as you watch. Having staff to choose and buy your kids Christmas presents.

I used to nanny for families like this and I think you just end up outsourcing life outside of work. Trying to live a personal life like this must be really unfulfilling.

It's their choice and it creates jobs which, in turn, pay taxes. Mind your own beeswax.

PegasusReturns · 13/02/2023 17:19

I used to feel I/the event was only worthy if I’d done it all myself.

5 years ago for our annual Christmas party I got a planner and it was transformative. I’d been busy at work so hadn’t overthought the menu or the decorations as I would normally, instead saying “do what you think best”.

the morning of the party people descended on the house; they set up the rooms, saw to the floral arrangements, got everything ship shape. I went for lunch, then for a blow dry. I came back at 6pm got changed and lit the candles. That. Was. It!

no more living life in the mundane for me. Why would you?!

LobeliaBaggins · 13/02/2023 17:18

Oh, the desperation for parenting validation. That's what this reads like to me.

Really, you have no idea whether these parents have shallow relationships with their children or feel unfulfilled. It's just that you think they do.

Actually, most rich people strike me as perfectly happy and fulfilled. Probably because they are not being bored sick picking up paper plates for kiddie birthdays. And the kids could not care less who buys the plates.

ReneBumsWombats · 13/02/2023 17:18

Time is most people's most precious commodity. That's why so many people work 70 hour weeks and earn megabucks but complain they don't have any time to themselves.

To be honest, even if you do want to spend your spare time watching Love Island and scratching your bum, so what? Again, assuming you're not neglecting your relationships - which is not unique to the fabulously wealthy - why shouldn't you? You can afford to outsource and you're not exploiting anyone, so why is it somehow virtuous to make your life more unpleasant and boring than it needs to be?

IncompleteSenten · 13/02/2023 17:15

I don't think they would pay lots of money in order to feel unfulfilled tbh.

GerbilsForever24 · 13/02/2023 17:12

A lot of your arguments don't make sense or appear to contradict themselves. You complain about lack of fulfilment by removing the boring stuff, but then claim that the boring stuff is what makes for strong relationships with your children even in the face of loads of people pointing out how removing this stuff improves their relationships.

You claim not to judge but then you swap from unfulfilling lives to, I think, worrying that children are not getting good lives as a result?

If you're saying that you aren't experiencing "real life" if you don't sometimes have to do the real drudge work, I could sort of understand. I'd disagree though as my real life isn't the same as anyone else's. That's the glorious thing about humans - we are so diverse in our experience, desires and outcomes.

womanwithbooks · 13/02/2023 17:11

Yes exactly @MsMarch to all of the above, but also it's interesting/telling how little time the OP has spent thinking what jobs these selfish women might do that means they have to outsource everything.

Working on a cure for cancer, or in an ICU, or for the UN, or in a hospice. All less important and fulfilling than personally booking a clown for a three-year-old's birthday party.

ReneBumsWombats · 13/02/2023 17:10

I used to arrange all the birthday party stuff with my eldest...village hall, entertainer, do the food and party bags myself and cleaned up afterwards. Once he got old enough to have activity parties, I discovered the joys of throwing money at a business and having them do absolutely everything while I had a coffee and he had the time of his life. It was a no brainer by the time my second came along.

They get their party, cake and candles and all the rest, and they love it. What more do I need to do? Where's the additional virtue?

MsMarch · 13/02/2023 17:07

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:56

@MsMarch The examples I used were things I thought people would understand more.
I don't think it matters of someone is paid to wash the car - a traditional dad job
or paid to clean the house - a traditional mum job
It is the extreme of people who try and outsource everything except fun times. For either mum or dad it leads to shallow relationships with children and pets and an unfulfilling life.

Okay, fine. So your premise is that lots of outsourcing, of any type, is bad.

I disagree. I think outsourcing lots of things so that you can focus on the more meaningful is fine. Outsourcing because you don't care about the outcome and/or have no intention of being part of whatever is going on is a problem, but that's not about outsourcing per se.

I have limited time. The more I can outsource, the more time I have to do the things that really matter. And FYI, that's NOT just about spending time with my children. My life is more fulfilled (also, your original question) because if I outsource more, I have time to spend with my family AND to do other things I care about like see friends, read books etc. For DH, becuase we outsource certain things, he has more time for music and sports - both things he enjoys and finds fulfilling. For my BFF, outsourcing some things means she has time to work on her art. All of these things fulfilling all of us far more than cleaning the car or organising a kids party. Last time I had the car cleaned, I used the timeto check out the lovely new coffee shop where I had the best turkish coffee I've had in years. That was fulfilling.

beamout · 13/02/2023 17:07

I outsource Most of my life. It works well for me but also sometimes leaves me feeling a bit disconnected from it. It's the right thing for me and my family though. The irony is that I outsource so I can do a job for someone who has completely outsourced. I think what you are doing is assuming that the task equals the fulfilment. People who outsource get the same fulfilment from different areas to you.

Gabby8 · 13/02/2023 17:06

There is another side to this, I use a nursery, cleaner and have somebody help with the horses. I did a party package for my daughters birthday at a popular children’s venue (it meant I focussed my time on her) my husband works long hours and I have no family support. I might outsource less if I had somebody to help- but doing it this way means I can focus my time outside of work on my family and animals and home life. For a lot of people outsourcing is a way of facilitating a more fulfilling life they spend with their family.

womanwithbooks · 13/02/2023 17:03

Also, why the sudden mention of pets? I am lol-ing at the idea that I have a superficial relationship with my cat, due to having selfishly prioritised my career. I mean, I probably do have quite a superficial relationship with him, but I'd say the blame is more than 50% on his side due to his... being a cat.

ReneBumsWombats · 13/02/2023 17:01

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:03

No I am saying that outsourcing everything has a negative impact. And I have said everyone outsources some things. It is up to you what you outsource. Most outsourced jobs are women's because the only jobs men traditionally do around the house is occasional DIY, mowing lawns and washing the car. Loads of people now outsource those jobs too.

What is this negative impact?

Distant, absent, disengaged parents are a problem, yes. But there are far more of those than there are mega rich people who outsource everything, and that's just the issue of not spending enough time with your own kids. What's outsourcing the gardening, cleaning, cooking, driving or whatever got to do with it? If anything, that frees up time you could spend with your family.

So leaving aside absent parents, because that's a specific issue that's really not limited to the hugely wealthy and well-served...what is this negative impact? What exactly is someone missing out on if they fairly pay a willing contractor to keep the garden, clean the house, cook the food and do the DIY? What's the problem? Why is it virtuous to do mundane shit you don't want to do when you don't have to?

Haffiana · 13/02/2023 16:59

"I have done a bit of parenting and in order to feel good about myself I am going to look down on a hypothetical everyone else who I imagine has not done exactly the same bit of parenting".

Comparison is the thief of joy, OP.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:56

@MsMarch The examples I used were things I thought people would understand more.
I don't think it matters of someone is paid to wash the car - a traditional dad job
or paid to clean the house - a traditional mum job
It is the extreme of people who try and outsource everything except fun times. For either mum or dad it leads to shallow relationships with children and pets and an unfulfilling life.

OP posts:
MsMarch · 13/02/2023 16:52

I have tried not to be really condemning of either mums or dads. If that is what you are looking for you will not get it.

Except that you are consistently complaining about outsourcing of tasks that are traditionally done by women. It's not a HUGE stretch to assume you're more focused on women.

I have been explaining why outsourcing reaches a tipping point. Some outsourcing is normal, but once you pass the tipping point it affects the relationship mums and dads have with their children and pets and their own fulfilment in life.
Well no, you've got this weird theory that some kinds of outsourcing reduce people's fulfilment because you seem to think that not doing the cleaning or the party organising means that parents can't have a relationship with their children. Which is weird. As I said earlier - if you're complaining about parents who don't even turn up to the party, or attend the school play, or go to the brownies camp out, that's a different argument.

As I said lots of men who are Disney dads do have superficial relationships with their children. I said not all dads because not all dads behave as Disney dads and some indeed do the actual caring and grunt work. My DH does.
But, as I said before, even the "good dads" tend not to do the kind of work that you're complaining about being outsourced. My DH is the DC"s primary carer, yet your examples - organising parties, buying presents - is almost exclusively done by me. And that's true of most of the families I know. A man who is pulling his weight is nonetheless still less likely to be doing these specific things.

Also, superficial relationships is completely different to "unfulfilling lives" The less involved you are with your children, absolutely the more likely you are to have a superficial relationship. But I can assure you that removing the drudge work from my life does nothing except enhance relationships with my children and that's true for the vast majority of parents I know.

womanwithbooks · 13/02/2023 16:51

@ExistenceOptional ... and I'll ask again, because yet again you've said 'it affects the relationship mums and dads have with their children and their own fulfilment in life '... what evidence can you point to that backs up this claim?

You asked people here - everyone on the thread who outsources significant amounts of stuff says they feel more not less fulfilled. Do you think we're all lying? And have you surveyed our children and found them unhappier than your own? Or is this all just pure guesswork and wishful thinking on your part?

Boohisspiss · 13/02/2023 16:50

Guess, it’s what you deem to be boring. Would hate to not plan parties, but would love someone to cook every night. Foodies, however would be miserable having their hobby taken away. Horses for courses.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:50

@BlingLoving I am not mad. It makes me a bit sad. The children's parties is what others have focused on and the more major issues of constant nannies is ignored. Parties are not a big deal. Its more about extreme outsourcing when the aim is simply to swoop in for the good bits so both parents effectively become Disney dads in their own life and their home becomes like a managed hotel suite.

OP posts:
ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:47

Nancydrawn · 13/02/2023 16:46

Congrats on being a better parent, and person, than others, OP.

Thanks! Nice to be recognised.

OP posts: