Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BIL wants us to pay for their lifestyle

331 replies

MsPorridge · 13/02/2023 07:18

Sorry for my English: not a native speaker. BIL has asked my partner to give them money every month because they "can't cope" with all the expenses.

My partner went to visit his brother and his family last week. I wasn't there. Brother started asking partner how we are coping with cost of living and partner was just honest and said that energy bills are more expensive, etc. but because our expenses have always been so low, we are ok. Brother kept asking questions and partner did not think of any hidden intentions and answered and gave details about our financial situation (they were not very specific but it was just made clear that we were able to save around 2000 per month, except when there is some unexpected cost that month).

For some background: we have no children, no car, no pets, love cooking our own meals, no expensive hobby and maybe we are just very busy to spend money (we spend our time volunteering for different causes, doing exercise, love going on walks which is free...). This is just how we enjoy our life and the saving part just naturally happens. We also own our flat outright because we bought a small one (we could have afforded a much bigger place but not complaining, it was just what we felt we needed) and payed our mortgage quickly. Now we make around 3000 per month combined, so not really a high-income by any means, but it's fine for our situation. Most months we only spend like 1000 and the rest goes to savings/investments. It does help that I've never been interested in make-up or having lots of nice clothes, none of us drink alcohol, etc.

Going back to the problem: his brother started almost crying to him asking if we could give them around 500 per month during an indefinite amount of time to help with the expenses. My partner is a really soft person who always wants to help everyone. I've had a few arguments with him because of this. So he didn't say a straight no and from what he has told me he made it sound like he would talk with me about it and almost like a yes. Apparently the brother said things like "it wouldn't make any difference to you two, right? It seems you are really very comfortable with your life but we are really struggling at the moment". He also mentioned how my partner had to go back to stay with their mum and stayed rent-free for a year (this was 10 years ago and he still seems bitter and about it) as if somehow this justifies what he's asking.

They have 3 children, live in a much nicer and bigger house than us, have 2 expensive cars, 1 dog, 1 cat and 2 rabbits, I see pictures of them dinning out often or going away for the weekend with the whole family, always seem to have new fancy clothes, always redecorating the house, and children have a few expensive hobbies/after-school activities etc. Which I'm happy for them and don't feel any jealousy about but also don't see this is a desperate situation in which they are asking for money to put a meal on the table or pay the mortgage. They just need to adjust. My partner feels very sad for them and thinks it's not fair for the children not to be able to enjoy their life as usual. I feel very very angry that his brother feels entitled to my partner's money just because he has chosen to live a frugal life.

I am really disappointed with my partner for allowing this to happen. Please help. He has agreed with me that is totally unacceptable to ask but does not want to upset him.

OP posts:
NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 13/02/2023 12:52

Your BIL is being rather grabby, but a one-off payment of 1k would be a nice gesture, as long as he is made aware that it is a one-off payment. Do not get into subsidising him regularly.

Thesharkradar · 13/02/2023 12:47

If my partner started giving our joint money to other people I would cut him loose and no longer be in a financial partnership with him
Seriously if he can't stop himself from giving money away I'd be separating my finances from his pretty damn quickly!

JudgeJ · 13/02/2023 12:38

Needmoresleep · 13/02/2023 11:01

Don't!

You are damned if you do and damned if you don't.

If you do they will resent you. They should be grateful but they won't be, as they way they will rationalise it as them being entitled to the money. At the same time you will resent seeing them using the money on luxuries.

If need be make an excuse You already have commitments to your family? You are thinking of buying a larger property/making larger pension contributions etc.

If you do lend money (and it should involve a lump sum and a formal loan agreement) it should be for a specific purpose, and with a repayment date. (Though mentally you should write off the money, it should at least discourage them from coming back for more, and will give a chance to discuss their finances and scope for repayment.)

We had this. Supposedly very successful brother, large detached house, non working wife, and two privately educated daughters, suddenly phones me. Could we lend a large amount of money immediately as he had a tax payment deadline the next day which he could not meet, and the bank was refusing to lend him money. Failing to pay would put his career as a solicitor at risk. We paid, albeit with a loan agreement and eventually half was repaid. The resentment was huge and destroyed any relationship. His wife had always looked down on us as the poor relatives, and as clear social inferiors. I am not sure that she knows about the loan as her attitude has not changed. My brother certainly knows we know he is not the success he claims to be, and this is very difficult for him. (He is now head of compliance at quite a large firm. I hope he has learnt something from the experience, though I suspect one day we will get another call.)

In an odd way it has usefully taught the kids that being able to live frugally gives you freedom. Getting tied into a lifestyle you can't afford is a trap.

I am not sure that she knows about the loan as her attitude has not changed.

I would make damned sure she knew that her lifestyle is built on other people's money.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 13/02/2023 12:37

MsPorridge · 13/02/2023 11:08

Thanks for the replies. I don´t have time to reply to everything right now but want to clarify a few points.
I am not British but everyone else is. And we live in England. So this has nothing to do with my culture as some people thought. And yes, in my culture people ask for help from families and are expected to help (and guess what, there are lots of broken relationships in my family due to this reason. Either because somebody asked and didn´t help, or somebody helped but never got any help back/their money back, etc.)
We know for a fact that they earn more than us. I will not say what profession but the salaries for their jobs is public - we dont even need to ask, anyone can know. You can guess what I´m talking about.

Like somebody said we would not be able to afford their lifestyle with our salaries.

Also, regarding whether the money is to be returned. This was not expressed in any way, what was expressed was the idea that it "wouldnt be a big deal for us" and for how long, well, just until "things get better".

I always find the cultural expectations of being expected to support family members a bit strange and often skewed.

I’ve got a friend who’s Nigerian but went to school in England and has lived and worked here for years, not in high paying jobs and also unmarried but has had her siblings (one is a millionaire back in Nigeria and other is very wealthy also in Nigeria) ask her to send money home to her parents (her DF was a diplomat). She always felt she couldn’t say no and was obligated to do this.

Have heard of other people (not close friends) trapped into sending money home.

Their relatives assume that if you live in the West you have a great lavish lifestyle and lots of spare money and don’t consider in most western countries the cost of general living is/can be high.

If you’re able to send money home and have the means to do so then that’s a different story, but to place pressure on people to pay for extra costs just because it’s expected of them to do so, I find really unfair if they can’t afford to do so or situations make it hard for them to do so.

JudgeJ · 13/02/2023 12:36

CohenTree · 13/02/2023 10:08

Ok, I thought families were supposed to help each other out, but apparently not!

All families need to live along the lines of Never a borrower nor a lender be, as well as Always live within your means, everyone would be far happier.

MsPorridge · 13/02/2023 12:35

Biker47 · 13/02/2023 12:28

The fact that he's frothing over the fact your husband moved into back his mothers for a year, still now; after 10 years passing, leads me to believe if the shoe was on the other foot and you actually needed financial help (not just have expensive tastes and not enough to fund it), they'd either tell you to manage your own finances better or they might lend you money while charging you interest.

Look after your own family first, those £500 a month add up, and means simple things like you can retire earlier than planned and/or purchase better quality things and experiences. They're not entitled to a share of your hard work just because you have it and because you're related, if they want to spend more money they need to work more, or change jobs, or just cut their cloth according to their means.

Your husband discussing your finances with them is not on as well.

I fear you are right in the fact that BIL would not help my partner if we were the ones who had problems (or just my partner alone). I agree with you and I think my partner is hopefully starting to see this.

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 13/02/2023 12:34

@MsPorridge am I correcting in thinking you come from a culture where supporting family members is the norm?

Supporting and being a mug are two different things in whatever 'culture', oddly it's those with a 'culture' of bumming off families who find it OK. What happens when there are two different 'cultures' involved, whose prevails?

Xol · 13/02/2023 12:34

If your BIl is still stewing over your brother getting rent free accommodation from his mother 10 years ago, maybe the answer is to go to his mother himself and ask her to help out to an equivalent extent? If your husband paid anything towards his accommodation I suspect the help involved will amount to little more than a couple of grand, but it that's what takes to get rid of his grievance then so be it.

JudgeJ · 13/02/2023 12:32

CohenTree · 13/02/2023 10:00

You DP needs to stand firm on this or you will be paying for them forever. @GreenFingersWouldBeHandy how do you know this? Perhaps the brother is just going through a rough patch. Presumably he and his wife are hard working people or they would not have been able to accumulate a nice house and cars.

Then they can sell their nice house and cars instead of being bums.

Topsyturvy78 · 13/02/2023 12:28

That's a bit cheeky think they need to be cutting back on some non essentials not going begging family for money.

Biker47 · 13/02/2023 12:28

The fact that he's frothing over the fact your husband moved into back his mothers for a year, still now; after 10 years passing, leads me to believe if the shoe was on the other foot and you actually needed financial help (not just have expensive tastes and not enough to fund it), they'd either tell you to manage your own finances better or they might lend you money while charging you interest.

Look after your own family first, those £500 a month add up, and means simple things like you can retire earlier than planned and/or purchase better quality things and experiences. They're not entitled to a share of your hard work just because you have it and because you're related, if they want to spend more money they need to work more, or change jobs, or just cut their cloth according to their means.

Your husband discussing your finances with them is not on as well.

billy1966 · 13/02/2023 12:26

Warrensrabbit · 13/02/2023 12:21

I think the BIL was quite manipulative, getting your DH to admit to having disposable cash and targeting that. He got clarification that their was money available, which makes it harder to say no.

The OP's partner is weak and a bit dim and his brother knows that.

That's why he got all the information from him, set him up, and then went in for the kill.

He doesn't care about his brother or his life, he just sees him as a mug that can be used.

Like all cheeky fxxkers we read about on here.

Warrensrabbit · 13/02/2023 12:21

I think the BIL was quite manipulative, getting your DH to admit to having disposable cash and targeting that. He got clarification that their was money available, which makes it harder to say no.

MsPorridge · 13/02/2023 12:17

@WinterDeWinter Sorry, my message was for you!

OP posts:
Pollyputthekettleonha · 13/02/2023 12:17

I wouldn't agree to anything without going through the BIL's budget first and looking at how he can cut back. And if he's in debt, he needs to be upfront about it. Maybe he has taken on too much credit card debt or something and is in financial trouble. I wouldn't make any decisions without getting the full picture first. If he genuinely needs some help in the short term I would consider it but it needs to be made clear that the help is time limited and is dependent on him taking steps to make his lifestyle less expensive.

MsPorridge · 13/02/2023 12:15

This is such a good way to put it. I couldn´t have expressed it better! I will show this to my partner! Thank you so much.

Thank you so much for all the very useful replies, there have been many.

Others not so useful - the person who said we had a miserable life. Far from the truth!

OP posts:
2bazookas · 13/02/2023 12:11

Your DP needs to send a BIL a message

"Ms Porridge and I have discussed your request for financial aid in some depth. Comparing your income to your extravagant lifestyle we concur that the problem is that you spend far more than you can afford. That is your responsibility, not ours. So don't ask us for money again. "

WinterDeWinter · 13/02/2023 12:11

BIL, the reason things are ok for us is because we have not much in the way of property, have not had children, and now spend very little.

You've made different choices - good choices - and you will benefit from them in the future in terms of your eventual income, your property assets and having a family around you as you get older. Things might be tight for a while, and maybe it will feel like a step backwards, but overall the future is bright.

As for us, we have to our outgoings so that we are secure as we age (not much in the way of property to fall back on).

If you had already cut everything back to the bone and you were on a precipice we would of course try our utmost to help you avoid disaster - but can you see that we can't sacrifice our own security when it seems like you have so much more than we do already, and definitely will do in the future? I know it feels like a disaster at the moment but there will be ways to rearrange things/cut back and I can help look at it all with you.

puffyisgood · 13/02/2023 12:08

It's a really blindingly obvious no.

How your in-laws balance their incomings and outgoings is none of your business, but I'm afraid the second they start ask for hand-outs they forcibly make it your business. Very very easy to turn them down.

lobeliasb · 13/02/2023 12:04

The audacity of them to ask! Dinner out several time a month for a family of 4 or 5 is easily a few hundreds pounds. They can eat at home instead of begging you for a handout.

TakeMe2Insanity · 13/02/2023 11:59

Rent free with your mum to sort yourself out is different to handing over a monthly allowance.

I would suggest your husband sits down with his brother and his bank accounts and help him to help himself. Work out where to make cuts/what needs to change etc.

WaltzingWaters · 13/02/2023 11:58

How utterly cheeky of BIL. Not a chance.

Get your DH to request they write their monthly spending down and he can offer to help see where they can make changes and save more, saying this is how you are able to save the money you have. (I’m sure they’ll decline and leave it at that).

Or tell them to downsize their house. Or get a cheaper car.

If your DH does insist on helping, ensure you two start splitting your savings, so he can do with his what he likes, and you save yours and treat yourself to something nice. But he should of course just tell them sorry, besides helping them downsize/save he cannot help. He’d be an absolute mug to give them money so they can live their fancy lifestyle whilst you live frugally.

And tell him to absolutely NOT discuss finances with anyone but you again!

Xol · 13/02/2023 11:56

You probably need to talk to BIL together, to back each other up. All you need to say is that (1) it is quite absurd to suggest that someone on a lower income should subsidise someone on a higher income; (2) you have to budget yourselves for increased fuel bills and inflation so are unlikely to have money to spare in the foreseeable future; and (3) the only reason you have had anything to save in the past is because you live much more frugally than BIL, and there is absolutely no reason why he and his family should not follow your example.

I'm afraid the relationship is going to end up damaged, but really the damage was done when BIL raised this ridiculous suggestion in the first place.

007DoubleOSeven · 13/02/2023 11:55

Unlike other posters I don't think there's anything wrong in asking his family for help and he seems to have checked you could without struggling through his awkward questioning.

But , if you're going to ask for ongoing help then you do need to prepared to justify why you need it - how you've cut back, what payments you're struggling with specifically etc. And agree a way of paying it back when possible.

I wouldn't get worked up about this but treat it as a conversation to open up to discussion how you can help them out. It really only becomes cfery if they refuse any other way to help them, refuse to cut back on luxuries etc.

Honestly, I think you've overreacted a bit and it's a subject that should be further explored before jumping to assumptions of entitlement etc.

FictionalCharacter · 13/02/2023 11:46

Twillow · 13/02/2023 11:13

To keep your partner happy, I might, in this case, make an offer of something like this
'We will pay for one club each for the kids for 6 months. But if we see that you are spending money on luxuries like regular meals out and weekends away during this time, this will stop. We economise to have savings money and so should you.'

No! That validates BIL’s view that he deserves money from his much lower earning brother. And opens the door to him wanting more. BIL and his wife can afford clubs for the kids. If they need to cut down on spending they can do so easily. Downsize their cars, stop buying more clothes, have less lavish holidays and fewer weekends away. They don’t need handouts from people who earn less and don’t live lavishly.