Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to refuse this "gift"

357 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 12/02/2023 22:44

Short version.

Parents decided to give my sister and I £25k each. In theory it was to pay off our mortgages as they wanted us to have financial security. Except that while this plan was in its infancy my sister and her husband moved. So they now have a much bigger mortgage than this money can pay off. But they do have a "doer upper" and due to covid blah blah the money thing didnt happen and my sister took a back step in her career for work/life balance. So they give my sister a cheque, hers to do with as she wishes.

Mine is partly going on the mortgage pay off (not a lot as bought at the arse end of the last recession and only have 18 months to go) and the rest was to be given to me. I need a new car, we all know this.

Except now............I am being expected to go car shopping and the rest of the money to go on that. It has been implied that the money going into my savings until I am ready to decide how much I want to spend on a car, what I want the rest for (savings, I have none) will not be happening.

I have always known that my mother thinks I am the feckless one and my sister the savvy one. My sister has always earned well and so has her husband. I have earned well but as a single parent with a very abusive (aka tried to murder me) exH I struggled. Sometimes I have struggled for money. I am stable now and have been for a long time but she has never ever trusted me, ironic as I am the person she calls whenever she needs something.

The mortgage thing is a done deal, cant change that, but WIBU to turn down the rest of this "gift"? To me a gift that comes with strings is not a gift but an obligation, and it has brought up so many old feelings of how my mother views me.

I cannot afford to turn it down, it would be life changing. I was looking into the best way to make the most of it, which (safe) investments would be the best, how to have some easily accessed in case of emergency but the rest there for longer term. But no.......I need to be watched. I should have a grown up with me when I choose a car and the grown up will pay for it instead of me having the money in my hand.

Frankly right now I feel like telling them to shove it. I am definitely on the side of saying "Thanks but no thanks" and telling them that they should give it to the child they trust to spend it "wisely". I have no issue with my sister, she is my best friend. I only agreed to this bloody fucking stupid plan in the first place because I knew it would make such a difference to her. I never wanted their damn money.

FWIW.....I am almost 50, work, had a year and a half to pay on the mortgage and am the mother 6 amazing kids, 4 adults, 1 about to turn 18 and an 11 year old. All the older ones have amazing careers or are studying at top uni's/high achievers. I am not some scumbag drug addled alky who will spunk it on heaven knows what!

My crime I think was having a baby at 17......that marked my card for life. Everything I have achieved since means nothing.

OP posts:
Dillydollydingdong · 15/02/2023 10:01

What humiliation? She wants to come with you to share the experience of buying a car. It's fun buying a car. Just make sure you buy one she approves of, and then sell the old one and put that money in the bank.

gettingolderbutcooler · 15/02/2023 10:01

Buy a really expensive (£30k) car and then sell it. You lose £5k as soon as it's off the forecourt.
😜

WickedStepmomNOT · 15/02/2023 09:44

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/02/2023 01:08

She likened the situation to parents who insist on contributing to a childs wedding and then demanding a certain menu, a whole list of their friends as guests and deciding who the bridesmaids should be "Well we are paying!!". A very good analogy and more accurate than either of us like. She said that they are buying an opinion that they have no right to. She pointed out that knowing them, unless I basically agree to whatever they want, I cannot get it right.

She thinks that our parents are doing this from a good place, and I agree, but also thinks that the way they have gone about it is completely wrong. I bought up a couple of issues about the financial rules over this gift that she hadnt considered so hopefully this will also help clear up a few things all round.

It's so great you and your sister are good friends so your parents cant play one off against the other. I agree the manipulation and implied lack of trust is maddening but is there any way to play them at their own game and get what you need? After all, they made the offer wanting to help - with your sisters help, can you manipulate them or your own feelings to turn this unfair situation around?

Good luck OP - rooting for you.

Not financial but I had a former date I was interested in but no physical at that stage offer me a weekend away - but only if I had sex with him. He was quite attractive and I had been considering him as a proper bf but that 'invitation' ie ultimatum put me right off and that was the end of that. My feelings looking back say at least he was honest and open but Im glad I refused the coercion.

Whatever you decide, I hope you feel good about being able to make your own choices 💐

multikids · 15/02/2023 08:13

My mum is exactly like this.
Similar, but less costly situation. She wanted to pay off my education loan - about 3k left - out of the blue - I was paying it off, hadn’t asked her to, but she insisted that she had paid for my sisters Masters and wanted to pay for mine.
With my sister she just transferred the money.
With me - she refused to transfer it - she made me go into a branch of the bank , made the lady get the paperwork and settlement figure and paid it off in front of me - just for a little power play and to reinforce that she doesn’t trust me with money.
Mine stems from when I was young and married against their wishes. I’m remarried now with their blessing, but she still needs to make me feel small when she can. I sucked it up as I always do to make her happy.
She also knows that I cannot complain to anyone as I would appear so ungrateful !!
I completely sympathise OP, but don’t refuse it - it still benefits you overall.

LaDamaDeElche · 15/02/2023 07:26

Roundabout78 · 12/02/2023 22:49

YABU and ungrateful. Who cares if she insists you pay your mortgage off and buy a car? It’s so generous of them.

What? Insisting that you spend the money on a specific thing they decide is not generous, it's controlling,

pookie999 · 15/02/2023 06:41

If you buy a car online there's a 2 week no fault return and refund

BarbaraofSeville · 15/02/2023 04:41

Good that your sister is on your side and can see how badly they're treating you. If she can make them see this even a little bit, it might improve things?

Random thought on the 'helping them' aspect, how do you think it would go down if she just turned up and did it instead?

They ask you, you tell her and if she is available, she just arrives, says that she had more spare time than you thought she would take them to the appointment instead?

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/02/2023 01:26

Sugarfree23 · 15/02/2023 01:13

Do you know what car you want, have you priced it?
Would you be happy for them to give you a car?

Thats the thing..... I have an idea but I want some time to have a good long look and take the advice of a couple of very car savvy friends. They are both very knowledgable (not your average tyre kicker who watches Top Gear and thinks they know it all!). I would give myself as long as it took to get the best I can. The way my father was talking, they have looked at cars, found some that they think would be good and so we should go shopping.

Given that they have bought brand new from the same dealership for the last 18 odd years.......well yes they can just walk in and choose one. Second hand? Not so much! They dont seem to realise just how much a difference there can between X Make and Model for (say) £12k and the same but at a different dealership.

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 15/02/2023 01:13

Do you know what car you want, have you priced it?
Would you be happy for them to give you a car?

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/02/2023 01:08

She likened the situation to parents who insist on contributing to a childs wedding and then demanding a certain menu, a whole list of their friends as guests and deciding who the bridesmaids should be "Well we are paying!!". A very good analogy and more accurate than either of us like. She said that they are buying an opinion that they have no right to. She pointed out that knowing them, unless I basically agree to whatever they want, I cannot get it right.

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 15/02/2023 00:52

Hopefully your sis can talk some sense into them.
But don't cut off your nose to spite your face. £25k could really make a huge difference to you and your situation.

blubberyboo · 15/02/2023 00:43

Hopefully your sister will talk some sense into them but it is grating that they would listen to her but not you.

Try and get some arguments prepared for how home improvements is a better investment than a car. How it will add value to your house and reduce energy costs whereas a car depreciates

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/02/2023 00:34

Long conversation with my sister tonight. Turns out that something else has happened that I didnt know about and she didnt know that I wasnt asked about. It is something to do with this whole situation (a conversation with an IFA) that was offered to sister and not to me. She turned it down, I would have taken them up on it but I wasnt asked.

It has further cemented my feelings on this.

My sister is disgusted, again she assumed that we both had the same ie, a cheque and a choice. She is going to speak to them tomorrow, so we will see.

ANd it isnt that she wouldnt do stuff for my parents, she really would but they never ask her, and she told me tonight that actually it upsets her that they always ask me and not her. Goes to show that we are both trapped in our boxes. Luckily we are genuinely close, there is no animosity between us at all.

She thinks that our parents are doing this from a good place, and I agree, but also thinks that the way they have gone about it is completely wrong. I bought up a couple of issues about the financial rules over this gift that she hadnt considered so hopefully this will also help clear up a few things all round.

THanks for you help in helping me work through this.

I am still coming down on the side of refusing the money but I am prepared to discuss it now, and will make a more considered decision based on their reaction.

The daft thing is that if they really want every penny spent (and I have information that suggests it may need to be due to the law around how they have accessed the money) then I could squeeze so much more out of it that we need than one single car! Home improvements that have been desperately needed for years would be a far better way to spend it, if I cant save it, and a cheaper car. But we shall see......

OP posts:
Gbtch · 15/02/2023 00:11

I may be missing something here but could it be that your parents know you would buy a cheaper car to spread the rest of the money around your family? Could it be that they want to make sure you have a treat yourself- a good car that will last?
why not let them give you ( you) a gift that is better than you would usually alow for yourself and will last longer?

Sugarfree23 · 14/02/2023 23:44

Op how would it work if you increased your mortgage - let them pay it of and with the money you increased the mortgage by get a car?

Ailsamary · 14/02/2023 22:48

I had this from my parents when I was younger told them to stuff it. In the end they actually sold all of our trusts as they needed the money themselves.

Money with expectations is not a gift, just a way to manipulate

OhwhyOY · 14/02/2023 22:39

@PyongyangKipperbang I'm so sorry you are in this situation. I know lots of friends and family members whose parents have similarly screwed up approaches to being 'fair' when in reality they are treating one child (appreciate you are an adult but you are their offspring!!) preferentially. I'd write an email or letter, and say what you want to do with the money and how that is far more financially responsible than just buying a more expensive car. I would say how them just giving your sister a cheque and treating you differently is making you feel. I would ask them to reconsider, and say that if they won't and don't trust you to make your own financial decisions as an adult then you respectfully decline the gift as it isn't then a gift but more about control. Based on your description of your mother I'd expect her to shush you and say you're being ridiculous, and not at all acknowledge the difference in treatment. Perhaps worth your sister raising it too in case they listen more to her. Finally I'd re-evaluate your wider relationship with them and the help you offer - not out oc spite but to make them realise how much they rely on you and what that means about how responsible you are.

Justgorgeous · 14/02/2023 22:28

You sound pretty incredible - well done for everything you have achieved. I would take the money.

SparklyShoesandTutus · 14/02/2023 22:25

Not change her view*

SparklyShoesandTutus · 14/02/2023 22:25

The question is can you detach your emotions from this and see it as a business transaction?
You could be mortgage free and have a new (presumably more reliable) car. This would allow you to put your current mortgage payments into a savings account for 18 months to give you a bit of a buffer.
Sounds like the relationship with your mum has been toxic for a long time. Only you will lose out if you say no to the money. Saying no will not improve your relationship and she will not shave her view, in fact it will probably reinforce her view about your questionable/reckless decision making.
If you can view it purely as a business transaction that might be helpful.

Sugarfree23 · 14/02/2023 21:44

Chocolatehamper · 14/02/2023 19:03

I agree that it’s wrong for them to dictate how a gift is spent, but the other side is - if you clear your mortgage, the money that would cost you monthly goes into savings so you will build a pot up quite quickly. That would sort the issue of a clutch as per your example.

However, buying a car at the moment is pointless - especially a new one! You’d lose thousands as soon as you drive off the forecourt. Second hand cars are at a premium, you’re paying more because they are in short supply.

Have you told them you want to put money into short term ISAs or the like? I’d still say accept it though!

Buying new cars at the moment you'll not lose thousands on it. New cars are in short supply, people are waiting up to a year for them.
This in turn means nearly new are more expensive than new.
I know someone who was trying to buy a BMW the ex demo was 20% more expensive than new.

On the back of this thread I looked to see what my a similar car to what I'm currently driving would cost - the same as I paid 3 years ago.

Madamum18 · 14/02/2023 21:37

Swiftswatch · 14/02/2023 18:44

Seems like such a non issue. It’s hardly strings, they aren’t dictating what car they are buying you they just want to be able to actually gift you a car. It’s not going to feel like that if you take money and buy a car 18 months later. They just want to feel like they’ve been helpful in a tangible way.

I think this is missing the point!!

AutumnTreacle · 14/02/2023 21:37

*car

AutumnTreacle · 14/02/2023 21:36

Saying no to the ‘gift’ will cause tensions anyway, so I would just bite the bullet and have it out with them (her) about the issue around you choosing how to spend your money as your sister has.
FWIW I would also say no with these stupid conditions especially as you have such a small mortgage and just want to have a buffer for the future, she is being a right muppet in trying to force you to get a new care.
Stop being a pushover like your dad and letting things slide for a quiet life, and actually tackle the real issue, your mum.

Meandkids · 14/02/2023 21:31

Just say you have found a car, get the money transferred and then say it fell through?!