Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what boarding school is like

206 replies

Thesweetlife · 12/02/2023 22:24

I went to a ‘normal’ state school and so did all my friends, both when I was a child and now. My life in my childhood/early teen years consisted of going to school, going home, eating tea with my family, watching TV, saw my friends on the weekends etc. It was quite a mundane life but I was very happy in my school days. I guess I wonder what it’s like to go to boarding school. How was your (or your DC’s) life different to that of the normal child/teen? Where you happy at your time at boarding school? Have you been shaped by it in the long run? How did it influence you in the long run? What sort of things went on that someone who went to a day school would be surprised by?

OP posts:
PumpkinPie2016 · 13/02/2023 20:11

I haven't boarded but know two people who have, in the last 25 years, so fairly recently.

One boarded for Y11/12/13 but he attended Chetham's music school and by the time he was in Y11, he was playing for the national youth orchestra and had many rehearsals and performances, for that and other things. Although his home wasn't miles away, his hectic schedule meant it made sense to board. Plus, he had a added benefit of being close to city centre venues. It was entirely his choice and he was, and still is, very close to his parents. He read music at Oxford and is very successful in his field.

The other was at uni with me. He boarded from 11-18. He was fine and well adjusted but didn't exactly gush about the experience. He wasn't particularly negatively affected by it but equally, it didn't give him any advantage either.

Each to their own but I wouldn't send my son.

Poopoolittlerabbit · 13/02/2023 20:09

Boarding schools are so great they have a whole syndrome named after them… and as a psychologist and therapist you can specialise in helping ex-boarders.

‘Boarding School Syndrome is recognized as a specific psychological condition characterized by depression, problems with relationships and long-term emotional or behavioral difficulties.’

Poopoolittlerabbit · 13/02/2023 20:06

These threads always go the same - a few defensive posters who have sent their kids away, and get REALLY upset about any negative comments about boarding schools and everyone else who are all ‘ er, why have kids if you are going to ship them off to an institution

Addymontgomeryfan · 13/02/2023 20:05

CTRALTDEL · 13/02/2023 19:58

‘It is completely normal for lots of families and has been for many generations.’

I didn’t go to boarding school,
my parents liked me…

and no, it’s not normaL to send young children away and not see them for weeks, months, terms ,
when you have the means and time to look after them yourself. No

So the first hand experience of boarding school that you said you have isn't you actually attending. The OP was asking for people who went to boarding school to tell them what it was like.

Since your arguments against boarding schools seem to be centered on ridiculous opinions about parents not liking their children I can't be bothered to reply to any more of your nonsense.

CTRALTDEL · 13/02/2023 19:58

‘It is completely normal for lots of families and has been for many generations.’

I didn’t go to boarding school,
my parents liked me…

and no, it’s not normaL to send young children away and not see them for weeks, months, terms ,
when you have the means and time to look after them yourself. No

Addymontgomeryfan · 13/02/2023 19:53

CTRALTDEL · 13/02/2023 19:13

@EstoPerpetua you talk as if it’s normal not to see your own young children 3 weeks at a time.
god knows it would be easier to farm them out to someone else to look after…

It is completely normal for lots of families and has been for many generations. You obviously had a bad time at boarding school, and I do feel bad that you had such a tough time and didn't enjoy it, but it doesn't give you the right to attack the choices of others, we are all different and whilst you didn't enjoy it many others do.

1Wanda1 · 13/02/2023 19:35

I went to boarding school at 8. The book Boarding School Syndrome by Joy Schaverien accurately describes the characteristics common to me and every other person I have ever met who attended boarding school. You can also find her talking on YouTube if you're interested.

I am still very good friends with the girls (women) I made friends with at my second school (aged 12-18). We're sort of bonded for life by the weirdness of being told you're so lucky and privileged, whilst feeling like you no longer belong in your own family/home.

If I were to see anyone from the prep school I attended, I'm sure I would have a full-on panic attack. The horrors of what children can do to each other at a young age.

EveryoneButSam · 13/02/2023 19:21

EstoPerpetua · 13/02/2023 19:10

A further thought. Even children who are full boarders come home between school holidays. When we looked at DC1's school, they were very concerned to tell us that we would have to be able to manage without seeing our DC for 2.5-3 weeks at a time - so it's hardly the case that they are packed off and then collected 6 weeks later. They also have very, very long holidays (often late June - mid Sept).

They don't if they live thousands of miles away. I absolutely never went home between the long holidays. Half term was at my grandparents' house (better, but not home) or a friend's. There will be plenty of children in boarding schools still like this. We were packed off and collected 10-13 weeks later (actually not collected, we flew by ourselves). Holidays were usually 4 weeks Christmas, 4 weeks Easter, 8-9 weeks summer.

CTRALTDEL · 13/02/2023 19:13

@EstoPerpetua you talk as if it’s normal not to see your own young children 3 weeks at a time.
god knows it would be easier to farm them out to someone else to look after…

EstoPerpetua · 13/02/2023 19:10

A further thought. Even children who are full boarders come home between school holidays. When we looked at DC1's school, they were very concerned to tell us that we would have to be able to manage without seeing our DC for 2.5-3 weeks at a time - so it's hardly the case that they are packed off and then collected 6 weeks later. They also have very, very long holidays (often late June - mid Sept).

CTRALTDEL · 13/02/2023 17:13

'I have no doubt that some kids do have negative effects from boarding '

Oh mate. It's not some. 'Some' children might escape too many negative effects.

Handyweatherstation · 13/02/2023 17:07

Did you not tell them til then because it took you that long to work it all out?

@OldieButBaddie it's complicated. A lot of stuff it took me a long time to work out, but I couldn't bring myself to voice some of the shame and humiliation I experienced, so I never told them.

The things I have worked out have come about with the support of an ex-boarders fellowship, where we share our stories and do our best to comfort each other. A great deal said in that group is so familiar and finally helped me understand some of the discomfort I'd felt inside for decades. The sense of abandonment and not knowing where 'home' is, getting along with anyone but belonging nowhere, the hypervigilance and reluctance to join groups. No one else in my family went to boarding school, so they didn't know what those places can be like, so it's been very hard to talk to family about what happened. My dear brother told me he thought I was 'having a lovely time with the other little girls' and was horrified when I told him the truth. And, y'know, I look back at old photos from school and we're all smiling, but the smiles are mainly Happy Masks, they hide the hurt.

TheFTrain · 13/02/2023 17:04

This is so interesting. I read an article on 'Boarding School Syndrome' a while ago. From what many of you are saying, it stacks up.

Petronus · 13/02/2023 16:59

CrkdLttrCrkdLttr · 13/02/2023 11:03

I despair of MN sometimes …

Honestly, get a grip. People are sharing their experiences and an interesting discussion is being had. Stop getting ruffled because you have children/other family at boarding school and it doesn't suit you personally to hear anything negative.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:59

@Namenic It depends why they are in care. Obviously some children have no contact with their parents. But it is thought best where safe to try and keep a relationship going between children and parents.

Namenic · 13/02/2023 16:55

@ExistenceOptional - ah, thanks for that, I didn’t realise. I have a close relationship with my parents and siblings.

happygolucky42 · 13/02/2023 16:55

@PeachesPudding you hit the nail on the head. I just crave now my own company because I never had it. Such an intense experience.

happygolucky42 · 13/02/2023 16:54

If I hear the theme of Antique's roadshow or last of the summer whine, I am triggered back to being 13 again and being driven back to school. It took me years and years to recover, now and then such feelings of sadness descend upon me that I cannot explain it. My home life wasn't particularly happy and was probably saved from a lot of crap. But we pretty much brought ourselves up within strict parameters of regimented lifestyle. We did nothing at mine but study in the evening. No after school clubs. I think things are different now due to competition.

ExistenceOptional · 13/02/2023 16:53

Some kids in care see their parents every week.

Namenic · 13/02/2023 16:52

I have no doubt that some kids do have negative effects from boarding - and I do think that there is a definite risk of not knowing what is going on (and this is the reason I wouldn’t send my kids even if I had the money - there is a lot of stuff on the internet now and it is hard to monitor).

BUT - it can work out well - some people do genuinely enjoy it. It’s really different from being in care (at least in my experience) - because you see your parents every 3 weeks due to exeat, long holidays, additional weekends out if you have special celebrations etc.

hourbyhour101 · 13/02/2023 16:46

I think it's very common for parents to be delighted that their children are boarding and harp on about it to them being such a great opportunity/sacrifice, how lucky they are, so the children cannot voice their real thoughts without seeming ungrateful.

I think a lot of these children that felt like this are probably on the stately homes thread.

It takes a certain kind of person to ignore their child who looks unhappy at the prospect (even if they don't vocalise it) and then tell them they should be grateful.

Most children if they don't verbalise something will show it with actions. I personally couldn't ever ignore any child that was showing signs of being desperately unhappy. Sadly that cannot be said for all people.

Luminousnose · 13/02/2023 16:39

I boarded a long long time ago (70s). I think it’s very different now - most are weekly boarders and it’s much easier to stay in touch with modern tech. I started aged 9 (which I can hardly believe now!), but had been there for a year as a day pupil so it wasn’t such a shock. I actually enjoyed it and 15 of us now have a WhatsApp group, but as a PP has said we really did bring each other up and it has affected me in later life. I was talking to my sister about it recently and we decided that it gave us both a hard edge and we never had the relationship with our mother that we both have with our own (now grown up) daughters. Mum doesn’t know the difference, but we see it quite clearly.

As I say though, I think it is very completely different experience nowadays, but I wouldn’t have encouraged my own DD to board.

CTRALTDEL · 13/02/2023 16:38

'I think it's very common f'or parents to be delighted that their children are boarding and harp on about it to them being such a great opportunity/sacrifice, how lucky they are, so the children cannot voice their real thoughts without seeming ungrateful.'

Yeah, common for kids to put on a brave face, once they realise they aren't coming home that is - once they realise this is it, after being told to stick out a term, the next term, the year.

OldieButBaddie · 13/02/2023 16:32

Handyweatherstation · 13/02/2023 12:48

you don't tell you parents everything!

I didn't tell mine anything until I was in my 40s and still haven't told all. There's no way I would now as they are old and frail. They were really shocked at some of the things I said and now regret sending me. It was hard to tell them as they thought it the best thing for me at the time and I didn't want them to feel bad when they heard the truth.

Re weekly boarding, I did some of that and my main memories are that I seemed to live out of a suitcase, always packing and being jerked back and forth, never settling.

Did you not tell them til then because it took you that long to work it all out? I would be very interested to hear how many people have ever been honest to their parents about the effects they have suffered. I don't think many if any of my friends have. Those that have were labelled ungrateful and like you have suffered rifts with their parents. People don't want to accept that they damaged their children especially when they felt they were doing the best for them.

I think it's very common for parents to be delighted that their children are boarding and harp on about it to them being such a great opportunity/sacrifice, how lucky they are, so the children cannot voice their real thoughts without seeming ungrateful.

CTRALTDEL · 13/02/2023 16:20

Lives at the school that parents pay a fortune to send their child to, often from overseas, and she still does't think boarding is good for kids.