Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Getting vilified as a high earner

295 replies

MagicMondays · 12/02/2023 20:58

DH and I are both high earners. We do highly skilled and quite niche professional jobs which involved most of our 20s spent grafting, living apart, anti social hours etc when our friends were all having more fun! Both jobs still demand long hours and have a lot of responsibility. We have two DC and it's a struggle to sort childcare that works and make sure one of us is around for them. Our mortgage is huge (cos London) on a run of the mill Victorian terrace.
We obviously get no allowances - no personal allowances on income tax, no 30 hours childcare, no child benefit etc. Our tax bill is huge.
No issue with any of that. High earners should pay a disproportionate amount into the system to support others/redistribute wealth etc.

What I can't get my head around is how much people in the UK seem to dislike people like me. I see it on these boards all the time. People demanding I pay more tax, people complaining high earners are not as deserving as nurses, teachers etc, my own family making unfavourable comparisons with others.
We don't live a flash lifestyle at all - ordinary clothes, old car, not really interested in grand holidays, posh restaurants etc. You wouldn't know other than from knowing the jobs we do that we must have a good income.

I'm just a bit tired of this idea that people like me are arseholes in some way. I'm really not!

OP posts:
DontMakeMeShushYou · 13/02/2023 00:42

This is absolute nonsense and the fact that a poster would even spout this sort of thing is a reflection of the poor level of education in British society generally and how ignorant people are indulged rather than corrected.

No, though it may be a bitter pill to swallow and an inconvenient truth if you are a higher earner, it is simply the truth. You clearly don't understand what needs to be measured in order to calculate true value. But don't let my expertise in this area stand in the way of your ignorance.

Orders76 · 13/02/2023 00:35

I'm doing ok, but not from money and no safety net.
My favourite anecdote on this is prachetts Sam vines boot theory. Basically the richer you are the better and longer lasting boots you can afford whereas if poor, you get to buy the cheapest boots for a little less but more frequently.
The there's the opportunity cost, the richer tend to have more money to buy that really good coat for their child, on sale. The poorer, not so much.
Surely you can see how feeling lesser all the time upsets a person.

OneHundredOtters · 13/02/2023 00:27

I think this is a simpleish way to explain the tax thing

Because the personal allowance tapers after your net income hits 100k (once pensions contributions have been deducted) the marginal tax rate between 100k and 125k is 70%. That means of that extra 25k you have earned you actually end up with £6250 extra in your bank account.

Because you also lose your free childcare hours and tax free childcare if your net income is over 100k if you had two kids in childcare you could feasibly be worse off than before the pay rise.

The sensible thing to do is to try and increase pension contributions to keep net salary lower, although there presumably comes a point where this isn't possible which I guess is what has happened to the OP.

Still should be able to manage comfortably but I get the frustration with not seeing the benefit of what on paper is a massive pay rise.

Cobaltnorthstar · 13/02/2023 00:19

"Because most people are not paid the true value of what they produce. They are paid a fraction of that value so that every manager, every person in that organisation that earns more than the lowest paid worker, every shareholder, is creaming some of that value off."

This is absolute nonsense and the fact that a poster would even spout this sort of thing is a reflection of the poor level of education in British society generally and how ignorant people are indulged rather than corrected.

Low paid workers don't necessarily add more economic value than the amount they cost their employers. Often higher paid workers are adding more economic value and some of that economic value is subsidising the lower paid workers. That's particularly the case given national minimum wage. Shareholder capital funds the establishment of the business, cost of set up, infrastructure, etc. That capital requires a return.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 13/02/2023 00:13

Walkaround · 12/02/2023 23:58

The big issue is not that most people take more from the state than they put in, as that implies the moral failure rests with those people and not with an exploitative organisations and people that manufactured this situation. If, despite the fact more people take more from the state than they pay into it than vice versa, we are still one of the richest countries in the world, that begs the question how can that possibly be? Could it be that there is huge profit to be made from not paying people enough to live on and that this country is somehow benefiting from that, but in a grossly uneven and offensive way?

This.

The idea that most people take more than put in is based on flawed thinking. It looks at people's wages and the tax they pay but that isn't actually what they are 'putting in' to the country's coffers. Because most people are not paid the true value of what they produce. They are paid a fraction of that value so that every manager, every person in that organisation that earns more than the lowest paid worker, every shareholder, is creaming some of that value off.

bobbytorq · 13/02/2023 00:12

MagicMondays · 12/02/2023 21:10

If you listen to what people say on these boards the answer to all the country's problems is tax the high earners more. I'm not sure how that would work because eventually you'd be paying more in tax than you take home.
I had a pay rise this year that was a pay cut because it flipped me into a new threshold. I don't expect anyone to care because there are bigger problems in the world, I get that. But with 10% inflation on top it's strained our finances.

It all depends on your definition of high earner. If you;ve just tipped into the top tax band, whilst earning significantly over the average, you are not a high earner. That's reserved for the 7 figure and above bracket.

Cobaltnorthstar · 13/02/2023 00:07

"we are still one of the richest countries in the world"

I see this mantra trotted out all the time by British people. The stats show the UK has been falling behind relative to its peers for the past 15-20 years. In GDP per capita terms the UK is poorer than New Zealand, Canada, Australia, Germany, Belgium and many other countries. Furthermore there is a massive difference in GDP per capita between London / SE England and the rest of the UK. If you remove London / SE England the rest of the UK has a lower gdp per capita than Poland. It's the first and second generation immigrants in London (only 37% white English in last census) that sustain its economic growth and the UK's tax base.

CombatBarbie · 13/02/2023 00:05

I don't think your an arse hole, I'd admire you. Unless you told me you were doing tax loopholes.

We all cut our own cloth, where I am, a combined salary of 80k makes us millionaires...... But my kids are teens so less output, but they have been in childcare growing up. To some I've damaged them......

Walkaround · 12/02/2023 23:58

Vinniepolis · 12/02/2023 23:29

I don’t think you can compare someone on 150k to the prime minister’s wife who is a millionnaire many times over. Most high earners are salaried employees who pay PAYE tax and have very little opportunity to squirrel their money away in offshore accounts. So that’s really not The Big Issue. The Big Issue is that most people take out more from the statem than they pay in, and that is not sustainable in the long term. You can’t just keep taxing “high earners”, who are not Rishi-Sunaks-wife rich by any means.

The big issue is not that most people take more from the state than they put in, as that implies the moral failure rests with those people and not with an exploitative organisations and people that manufactured this situation. If, despite the fact more people take more from the state than they pay into it than vice versa, we are still one of the richest countries in the world, that begs the question how can that possibly be? Could it be that there is huge profit to be made from not paying people enough to live on and that this country is somehow benefiting from that, but in a grossly uneven and offensive way?

Hillary17 · 12/02/2023 23:57

Feel exactly the same and have to bite my tongue often. We don’t have kids (trying) and feel like I’m always having to defend myself for having a good job and decent disposable income. We didn’t get a penny of the cost of living payments, no government help etc. but all our outgoings have increased. Pay a stinking amount of tax every year plus extra student loans. Purposefully waited a while to start trying for kids so we would be comfortable and not struggling to make ends meet. We live in a normal house, share a normal ish car, aren’t super flashy, shop in Asda etc. I guess our one extravagance is holidays which seems to cause lots of whispering. Constantly looked at by friends with several kids like I should feel guilty for having more, like I’m foolish for spending our money on travel or like I’m ridiculous for being annoyed that our outgoings are increasing.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 12/02/2023 23:55

Well, I earn less than the average UK income and I get nowt off the state either. If we had children I'd qualify for some universal credit, but as a childfree household we get zero help. I'm the sole earner and I have to cover my mortgage and all bills on that. I've worked full time non-stop ever since graduating 30 years ago. I'll swap you, OP.

LexMitior · 12/02/2023 23:54

@ACynicalDad you have it. Bank balances change. Personalities do not

ACynicalDad · 12/02/2023 23:52

My view on people with wealth is usually not generalised nor is it based on their wealth but their personality. If I think someone is a rich t I'd think they were a t regardless, but I wouldn't call them a poor t* if they had that personality but not a lot of cash,

PinkPantherPaws · 12/02/2023 23:49

But with 10% inflation on top it's strained our finances

This right here op - comments like this one of yours, when you have a household income of over £250k gross - this is why some people will think you're an arsehole.

I mean seriously, from someone who claims to have come from a poor background, how can you be quite so dense? And don't give that 'six figure incomes aren't all that much is Lonnndonnn' bollocks. You're earning an absolute fortune by anyone's standards - and that's great for you. But don't try and pretend that CoL or inflation has 'strained' your finances. You don't know what strained means compared the vast majority of the rest of the UK, as well you know. You have an abundance of options at your fingertips many could only dream of. Read the room.

So in summary - if you don't want people to think you're an arsehole, don't act (or post) like one.

Merryoldgoat · 12/02/2023 23:48

@2thumbs

but the allowance tapers from £100k so OP hasn’t gone from a £12k allowance to zero unless she’s had a salary increase from, say, 100k to 126k in which case it’s still a £10k net salary increase.

weirdoboelady · 12/02/2023 23:46

I have sympathy for the OP. I think she is suffering from a class war which is constantly stoked by the Tories, and which most of the posters on this thread have bought right into. Yes, some people earn loadsa money, but it doesn't/shouldn't make them arseholes. I think there should be some 'Rules for Rich People' and would like to suggest some, to help challenge this growing war. Please add your own suggestions, and these aren't in a thought out order of priority - this is a stream of consciousness sort of thing.

  1. Cultivate a wide range of friends, keep in touch with your childhood friends etc.
  2. Be thoughtful about, and sensitive to, the financial problems of others. Don't expect less high earning friends to jump enthusiastically into expensive social events (or tactfully subsidise these for them, probably without telling them - eg 'Ooo do you want to come to the opera, we have a couple of [in reality £100] £25 tickets and a bunch of us are going if you're interested'
  3. Think about Scrooge post ghost, and give liberally to causes you support.
  4. If you are a CEO, FFS be aware of the wages of your lowest paid workers and make sure the CEO to worker payment ratio is a decent one.
  5. Maybe follow a couple of the pages on Facebook (apologies, there may be similar on here) - things like 'Food-Surviving on 50p a day' to see how some people work their hearts out and still struggle.

There are a lot of decent rich people out there, honestly! Don't let the bastards running the country convince you that everyone is like them......

SgtBilko · 12/02/2023 23:42

Forgooodnesssakenow · 12/02/2023 23:03

Ridiculous comment, if you think the problem is 30k earners not appreciating how high your bills are, you know you could live a 30k lifestyle on 160k right? You have that option. It's not that your bills are higher, you have more chosen luxuries.

This.

2thumbs · 12/02/2023 23:41

BigChesterDraws · 12/02/2023 23:26

no personal allowances on income tax

What? Do you understand how income tax works? Everyone, even the high earners, gets a personal allowance. You only pay tax on income over that amount. And if your raise room you into the next bracket (I’m assuming you are saying you went into the £125,140+ and it caused a loss because of the increased tax, then it wasn’t a raise worth having in the first place. You only pay an additional 5% on any amount over £125,140. Not your entire income. So an extra 50 quid in tax for every thousand of your raise over that amount.

Well, somebody doesn’t understand…. Your personal allowance is zero once your taxable income is greater than £125,140. This is presumably what the OP is referring to.

spirit20 · 12/02/2023 23:40

I'm a teacher, probably earn a lot less than you and I pretty gave up my twenties to the job, working evenings, weekends and holidays. Please don't think that whatever high-paying job you do is the only job where people work long hours.

MeganTheeScallion · 12/02/2023 23:38

🎻

MsBump31 · 12/02/2023 23:37

My partner earns over £100k and I earn £70k.. so we’re both fairly high earners (and youngish, only 31) but I’ve never encountered the “hate” you speak of…

What do you do? Could it be more to do with your profession? My partner is an intellectual property solicitor and I work in a senior role in media - neither of us get much criticism from others, most people we meet are quite interested in our jobs.

SamanthaCaine · 12/02/2023 23:35

Maverickess · 12/02/2023 23:19

Exactly this.

It's not the money, it's the attitude that goes with it much of the time, the whole 'work(ed) hard and sacrifice (d)' clap trap.
Have a low income and struggling? Move house! Stop the luxuries! (that you probably don't have anyway) Take a 2nd/3rd job! What do you expect in a job like that? Why do you think you deserve enough to live on? Get a better job! Retrain! Work harder! Have aspirations! Make better choices! (While simultaneously moaning about shit services and customer service in companies because no one wants to do those jobs for the money on offer and the way they're degraded....)

Have an above average income and struggling? Well it's just all not fair and you should be able to afford whatever you want because you work hard and you shouldn't have to do without anything. Couldn't possibly cut back on anything and of course it's never down to choices, I often seen "Well...... London" in answer to the reasons people have chosen to have a massive mortgage - where do they think all the care assistants, waitresses and shop assistants that work in London and serve them live? Under a bridge? They likely don't even earn what some people's mortgage payment is, or what they pay in tax, yet still manage.

The rules appear to be different when you're struggling depending on what you earn and that's why there's bad feeling.

In a nutshell for sure.

I genuinely don't think people have an issue with people who've done well for themselves. I've never noticed any animosity.

But people do rightly have an issue with BS attitudes and 'woe is me'.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 12/02/2023 23:34

People demanding I pay more tax, people complaining high earners are not as deserving as nurses, teachers etc, my own family making unfavourable comparisons with others.

Perhaps you have a skewed idea of what the word “vilified” means. Expecting those with the most money to cut back to ensure nobody starves or freezes to death isn’t vilifying anyone. Insisting that saving lives or educating the next generation are more worthwhile jobs than most high-paid careers isn’t vilifying anyone either.

Working and middle class people in this country have been told for over a decade that they need to endure “austerity” for the good of the country. They’ve accepted declining standards of living, to the point where many are now unable to feed their families or heat their (rented) homes. Now no more can be squeezed from them, you feel vilified because you’re expected to make some cutbacks in order to contribute a bit more?!

Botw1 · 12/02/2023 23:33

@Vinniepolis

Yes.

The big issue is that most people don't earn enough because the top 10% earn too much.

Which we try to fix by taxation which is obviously not working

Massively increasing lower wages and linking wages would be much more effective

quietnightmare · 12/02/2023 23:33

News flash time...

honestly no one cares how much you earn it's strange you think they do.

Higher your pay doesn't mean the harder you work. A quick example I'm sure single parents, working 2-3 jobs, putting a roof over their kids heads, sacrificing social life and luxuries for themselves for their kids and still gets up every morning being the best resign of themselves despite having the bare minimum doesn't work any less hard than you or anyone doing there best for that matter

Good for you earning well and you should be proud but as I said no one cares

Swipe left for the next trending thread