Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say religious state schools shouldn’t exist?

219 replies

Mushroo · 12/02/2023 18:54

This is probably controversial but interested in opinions on both sides!

I attended a catholic primary and secondary school and had a lovely education (my parents are actually quite religious). However, given how increasingly secular the UK is it seems quite antiquated and divisive to segregate schools based on religion?

Where I live, our closest primary school as the crow flies is religious (c of e) and as a now atheist we wouldn’t get a place as we sit at the very bottom of the admissions criteria (other religions are given priority over atheist). This means we’d have to walk past it to get to the non-religious school further away.

This leads to many people ‘finding god’ in the nursery years to get a place which I refuse to do.

I don’t see the benefit of religious schools, surely if you are a religious family, you can learn about religion at your place of worship / Sunday school or equivalent.

I think state school should be secular and teach all religions equally (including atheism as an option) and places shouldn’t be offered based on religion. State school places should be based on particular needs (e.g. adopted children, siblings and then distance only).

Genuinely interested in thoughts, AIBU?

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 00:59

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:45

what’s absurd? We don’t all have the choice we might like but there is a secular (or non denominational) school available for everyone. Not so with many religious schools.

Abolishing schools for a big chunk of the population is hardly a reasonable request because you might have to travel slightly further than otherwise.

This is not true in many areas. Often, there are no options for non-Christian schools, so atheists and people of other faiths have no other choice but to use these schools.

In any case, there are no truly secular schools in the UK at the moment. If we are going to keep religious schools with their discriminatory admissions requirements, can we at least covert all of the non-denominational schools into atheist/humanist schools and give priority in admissions to children whose parents are not religious in any way?

It seems absurd at the moment that Christian families in my town have the choice of twice as many schools as non-Christians!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 00:54

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:46

I pay my taxes. Why should I not have a suitable school to send my children? Why should schools only suit you?

I'm not asking for them to suit me - I'm not asking them to indoctrinate my child in any particular belief system. A secular school is not an atheist school, it caters to all.

It simply is not possible to provide state funded schools in every community for every single faith, so if you allow religious schools at all, then there will always be some taxpayers whose needs are not met. The fairest approach is therefore to provide a secular school that doesn't cater for any one group.

Ceilingplaits · 13/02/2023 00:53

mumyes · 12/02/2023 21:11

@Mushroo I have never heard of admission gong based on religion for a state primary, apart from non CofE - eg catholic.
As enough for non CofE to do it, but fir mass market CofE big standard primary: shocking.

Which part of the uk is this OOI?

It's normal in London.

Ceilingplaits · 13/02/2023 00:49

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:45

what’s absurd? We don’t all have the choice we might like but there is a secular (or non denominational) school available for everyone. Not so with many religious schools.

Abolishing schools for a big chunk of the population is hardly a reasonable request because you might have to travel slightly further than otherwise.

There aren't enough places at secular schools in my area. Christians make up a small proportion of the UK population, but a lot of UK schools are C of E or Catholic. There isn't room for all the non-Christians in non-Christian schools.

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:46

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 00:34

It's absolutely fine for religious parents to send their children to religious schools if they so wish. Personally, I think they're very misguided but that's just my opinion.

The question is not whether or not religious schools should exist, but rather who should pay for them. If parents and/or religious organisations wish to fund religious institutions in which to indoctrinate their children, then that's entirely fair enough. What isn't fair is that the taxpayer should pay for it. Why on earth should religious families have access to a wider choice of schools than non-religious families?

Religion is a private matter. It has no place in the state education system, other than as a subject to be taught in the RE curriculum.

I pay my taxes. Why should I not have a suitable school to send my children? Why should schools only suit you?

Ceilingplaits · 13/02/2023 00:45

I agree with the OP, feel strongly about it due to horrifying experiences when my C of E primary school was taken over by evangelists who preached about the devil and made the children sing hymns until they learned to praise the teachers' deity with smiles on their faces.

Just musing, though, it would be interesting if there were more schools based on belief systems. I come from an anarchist family and wanted an anarchist school, but I think only a few exist (Summerhill in Suffolk perhaps and the home-ed place in Sussex?) and they're private so inaccessible to those of us without lots of money.

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:45

Ceilingplaits · 13/02/2023 00:37

This is absurd. You do realise there is often little choice and that children are allocated by councils, also that it isn't always easy to travel further afield to a non-faith school?

what’s absurd? We don’t all have the choice we might like but there is a secular (or non denominational) school available for everyone. Not so with many religious schools.

Abolishing schools for a big chunk of the population is hardly a reasonable request because you might have to travel slightly further than otherwise.

Jailapeche · 13/02/2023 00:44

I totally agree with you OP. I find it bizarre that we have religious state schools. Sure, teach RE to put religion in its historical and social context but don't indoctrinate kids. If the parents want to do that, that's their choice but it shouldn't be part of state education.

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:40

JassyRadlett · 13/02/2023 00:17

How?

First - there are no 'secular schools'.

Second, 'secular' is not the same as 'atheist'.

Third, schools without faith admissions don't exclude anyone. They have no admissions criteria that exclude based on religion or lack thereof. A Catholic child, a Muslim child, an atheist child, a Sikh child are all treated equally in the admissions criteria.

Religious people would be effectively excluded from those schools (especially in my case where you have a minority religion). Our school offers suitable food for our dietary requirements, holidays at the time of our religious holidays and teaches our children about our religion from an insider’s perspective (they would not get this in a non denominational school). They are also free from discrimination that they might suffer on the ground of their religion elsewhere. If we didn’t have state religious schools most of us would go private and many would home school.

There is no point treating (for example) Sikh children equally with other children for admission to a Sikh school. The school is a school which teaches particularly about sikhism. It’s most suitable for Sikhs and it’s not unreasonable that that is a factor for entry.

as I said- people with no religion imo need to be more tolerant of those with religion. There is no harm in having a variety of schools. Everyone has access to a non denominational school so you try to abolish religious schools because you would prefer to send your children there (usually because the particular school gets good marks) but are not of that religion is intolerant. Send your children to the non denominational school and work to make it better rather than trying to abolish minority schools.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/02/2023 00:40

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 00:34

It's absolutely fine for religious parents to send their children to religious schools if they so wish. Personally, I think they're very misguided but that's just my opinion.

The question is not whether or not religious schools should exist, but rather who should pay for them. If parents and/or religious organisations wish to fund religious institutions in which to indoctrinate their children, then that's entirely fair enough. What isn't fair is that the taxpayer should pay for it. Why on earth should religious families have access to a wider choice of schools than non-religious families?

Religion is a private matter. It has no place in the state education system, other than as a subject to be taught in the RE curriculum.

How are you going to find the millions it's going to cost to buy the land and buildings (and fully maintain them without the church and trustee contributions) for the state?

Ceilingplaits · 13/02/2023 00:37

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:26

Parents who are religious don’t want to send their children to a secular school or a school of another religion nor should they be forced to do so. Religious schools are open to all - the very maximum you have to do is practice that religion (many are not so selective). Parents who want their children to learn about their religion (especially if it is a minority religion as mine is) cannot and would not send their kids to a secular school.

a variety of schools to suit a variety of people is best. I think it’s intolerant that some can’t bear for schools to suit people who are not like them. Secular schools do not suit everyone.

This is absurd. You do realise there is often little choice and that children are allocated by councils, also that it isn't always easy to travel further afield to a non-faith school?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 00:34

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:26

Parents who are religious don’t want to send their children to a secular school or a school of another religion nor should they be forced to do so. Religious schools are open to all - the very maximum you have to do is practice that religion (many are not so selective). Parents who want their children to learn about their religion (especially if it is a minority religion as mine is) cannot and would not send their kids to a secular school.

a variety of schools to suit a variety of people is best. I think it’s intolerant that some can’t bear for schools to suit people who are not like them. Secular schools do not suit everyone.

It's absolutely fine for religious parents to send their children to religious schools if they so wish. Personally, I think they're very misguided but that's just my opinion.

The question is not whether or not religious schools should exist, but rather who should pay for them. If parents and/or religious organisations wish to fund religious institutions in which to indoctrinate their children, then that's entirely fair enough. What isn't fair is that the taxpayer should pay for it. Why on earth should religious families have access to a wider choice of schools than non-religious families?

Religion is a private matter. It has no place in the state education system, other than as a subject to be taught in the RE curriculum.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/02/2023 00:33

Florenz · 13/02/2023 00:31

The best way to get rid of private/grammar/religious schools is to make the other schools so good that parents would rather send their children to them instead of the private/grammar/religious schools.

As soon as there is any selection criterion which parents can manipulate then you will get stratification as already described.

Florenz · 13/02/2023 00:31

The best way to get rid of private/grammar/religious schools is to make the other schools so good that parents would rather send their children to them instead of the private/grammar/religious schools.

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:26

ErrolTheDragon · 13/02/2023 00:15

Secular schools exclude the religious same as religious schools exclude the secular.

No. 'Secular' means no religious privilege or discrimination. There are no schools which deprioritise the children of religious parents in our country.

Parents who are religious don’t want to send their children to a secular school or a school of another religion nor should they be forced to do so. Religious schools are open to all - the very maximum you have to do is practice that religion (many are not so selective). Parents who want their children to learn about their religion (especially if it is a minority religion as mine is) cannot and would not send their kids to a secular school.

a variety of schools to suit a variety of people is best. I think it’s intolerant that some can’t bear for schools to suit people who are not like them. Secular schools do not suit everyone.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 00:20

I completely agree with you, OP. I honestly can't wrap my head around why the state is continuing to fund religious schools and to allow those schools to discriminate against children in their admissions requirements on the basis of what their parents believe or claim to believe. It's mind boggling!

And yes, I would scrap state grammar schools too!

JassyRadlett · 13/02/2023 00:17

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:09

Secular schools exclude the religious same as religious schools exclude the secular.

How?

First - there are no 'secular schools'.

Second, 'secular' is not the same as 'atheist'.

Third, schools without faith admissions don't exclude anyone. They have no admissions criteria that exclude based on religion or lack thereof. A Catholic child, a Muslim child, an atheist child, a Sikh child are all treated equally in the admissions criteria.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/02/2023 00:15

Secular schools exclude the religious same as religious schools exclude the secular.

No. 'Secular' means no religious privilege or discrimination. There are no schools which deprioritise the children of religious parents in our country.

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:09

BadHabitsGoodFun · 12/02/2023 23:24

@Mammyloveswine but that’s the point isn’t it, all schools should be teaching about a caring and inclusive ethos. Although religious schools can’t really do that with a straight face because they exclude from the word go whereas secular schools don’t start from that premise of hypocrisy 🤷‍♀️.

Secular schools exclude the religious same as religious schools exclude the secular.

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:07

I’m from a non Christian religion and moved across the country to ensure I had access to a state school that was of my religion. Now my dds learn about our religion at school and get our holidays off (as well as some Christian holidays).

ime people who want to abolish state religious schools aren’t religious and are intolerant of those who are. Live and let live - you may not have a religion important to you but plenty do. Why should schools only suit you and not everyone else as well.

Oldsu · 12/02/2023 23:59

BadHabitsGoodFun · 12/02/2023 23:17

Totally and utterly agree with you OP, and to the pp that said parents would fund it themselves - crack on!

Taxpayers money should not be used to fund schools that our children are excluded from. It’s utter indefensible bollocks.

And what what about the 1000s of tax paying parents whose children are excluded from certain schools as they could never afford to buy a property in the catchment area of the better ones, why is that so different?

Saschka · 12/02/2023 23:49

Another76543 · 12/02/2023 22:43

There is a CofE school near us which specifies in its admissions criteria that the bulk of places is given to worshipping CofE applicant.

There’s one near me which literally insists you attend their church specifically - another CoE church won’t do.

Very oversubscribed school, single form entry, so after sibling spaces are taken into account, they could say they were only offering to people with red hair and a surname beginning with T and they would probably still fill their spaces twice over.

Potaytocrisps · 12/02/2023 23:43

BrokeAsABone · 12/02/2023 20:13

Sigh. I send my children to Catholic schools because we, as a family, value our faith . Not only that, though. In Catholic schools they learn, in NI where horribly sectarian unionists abused their fellow citizens, IRISH history. They learn about absentee landlords, the Land League, Home Rule, the truth about the 'Irish famine' that was actually the British Genocide..I could go on and on. Irish history is not taught in state schools in the North of Ireland so Catholic schools it is. My children, my choice.

Ideally there would be no religious element to schools and all history could be taught. How much time at a Catholic primary school is taken up with teaching Irish history? I can't imagine it's that much (I agree it is important to know about history but I mean as part of the curriculum it can't be a huge proportion).

The division of children into Catholic and state aka Protestant schools by default in NI is one of the (many) factors contributing to some people living in the past instead of looking to the future.

It's so different to England where Church of England parents would send their children to a Catholic school, it just doesn't happen in NI. There is a huge lack of genuine integrated education options for schools in NI which is a real shame and a dilemma for people who don't subscribe to any faith. Some of my relatives there are struggling to find a school, and it's ridiculous that my nieces and nephews in NI who live so near ecah other can't go to the same school because some are Catholic and some are not.

I think religious schools should be private if they really need to exist but as a concept I am very much opposed to them.

JassyRadlett · 12/02/2023 23:43

The London point chimes with me. The majority of our local primary schools are faith schools, all have faith admissions criteria. The impact of this on the community schools is that their catchments are absolutely tiny, whereas the faith schools have a fair few out of borough children.

We were 'lucky' to get our elder into the local CofE school thanks to a poor Ofsted, when suddenly all those parents who needed their children to have a CofE education suddenly discovered it wasn't that important after all.

Apparently there was much wailing when the follow up Ofsted gave it a clean bill of health and was quite glowing. Lots of folk had got a bit lax on their churchgoing when there wasn't a school place on the line.

JassyRadlett · 12/02/2023 23:38

From the Campaign for Fair Admissions to take the anecdata out of whether CofE schools have faith admissions or not:

•19% of secondary schools are faith-based. 16% religiously select to some degree, with 72% of all places at faith secondaries – equivalent to 13% of places at all secondaries – being subject to religious admissions criteria.
•We estimate that 17% of places at primaries are similarly religiously selected, or 1.2 million primary and secondary places across England.
•This means that 16% of children at state schools are subject to religious selection criteria. This compares with 5% of secondary-age children in grammar schools, 5% in single-sex schools and 7% in independent schools.
•99.8% of places at Catholic secondaries are subject to religious selection in admissions criteria. For Church of England schools the figure is 49.7% but for those CofE schools fully in control of their own admissions policies with no legal or regulatory limitations it is 68%.
•Anglican dioceses vary widely in how religiously selective their secondaries are. The most selective is Liverpool (84%) and the least is Leicester (3%). The Diocese of London, despite its recent commitments to inclusivity, has 68% of places subject to religious selection – well above average and therefore still with some way to go.