Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say religious state schools shouldn’t exist?

219 replies

Mushroo · 12/02/2023 18:54

This is probably controversial but interested in opinions on both sides!

I attended a catholic primary and secondary school and had a lovely education (my parents are actually quite religious). However, given how increasingly secular the UK is it seems quite antiquated and divisive to segregate schools based on religion?

Where I live, our closest primary school as the crow flies is religious (c of e) and as a now atheist we wouldn’t get a place as we sit at the very bottom of the admissions criteria (other religions are given priority over atheist). This means we’d have to walk past it to get to the non-religious school further away.

This leads to many people ‘finding god’ in the nursery years to get a place which I refuse to do.

I don’t see the benefit of religious schools, surely if you are a religious family, you can learn about religion at your place of worship / Sunday school or equivalent.

I think state school should be secular and teach all religions equally (including atheism as an option) and places shouldn’t be offered based on religion. State school places should be based on particular needs (e.g. adopted children, siblings and then distance only).

Genuinely interested in thoughts, AIBU?

OP posts:
unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:17

A primary school in our county wants to have a non-religious moral/ethical assembly instead - governors, staff and parents all support it - but not allowed by law.

And what are they proposing to replace it with? Woke morals? Can't you see that morals and 'ethics' are as debatable as religion and many taxpayers perhaps don't agree with what would they are proposing to 'teach'?

Cockerdileteeth · 13/02/2023 09:14

Every school - not just the faith schools - legally has to have a daily act of worship. Of a Christian nature unless the school has obtained permission to substitute in a different religion. But either way, it has to be religious worship. A primary school in our county wants to have a non-religious moral/ethical assembly instead - governors, staff and parents all support it - but not allowed by law.
We could start by changing that.
I agree, though, religious worship should be for personal/private life, not state funded schools. Educate about all religions in schools, but don't endorse one "school" religion as the way and the truth. Let all children be educated with all their neighbours' children, not silo'd by faith or denomination. Historically entrenched vested interests make it hard to change that, though.
I find it interesting how many people of faith seem to think that having "secular" schools would somehow stop them practising their faith and raising their children in their faith.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 09:14

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:12

It wouldn't work.

The school would be quickly full of kids (and parents) who hate said religion, and would do anything within their power to disrespect those beliefs and teachings. No

OK. So getting rid of state funding altogether is the only option then.

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:12

Itsjustlikethat · 13/02/2023 07:25

As a first step, why not to change the admission criteria from faith-based to distance-based for all faith schools? At least it will stop excluding people in the community. No need to abolish any school that or restructure the asset ownership or similar.

It wouldn't work.

The school would be quickly full of kids (and parents) who hate said religion, and would do anything within their power to disrespect those beliefs and teachings. No

Another76543 · 13/02/2023 09:11

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:46

I pay my taxes. Why should I not have a suitable school to send my children? Why should schools only suit you?

There are lots of taxpaying families who don’t have a “suitable” school to send their children to. As an example, the highest performing schools are often religious, and effectively exclude families who don’t go to church. When you have an academic child, but one who isn’t religious, there is often no “choice” but to send them to a school with a poor academic track record. Religious schools often have better music departments. A non religious musical child has to be sent to a comprehensive with little music provision. The only other “choice” for those parents is to pay privately. Why should religious families be given more choice over the children’s education, when every tax payer is funding those schools?

I’m not suggesting banning religious schools. A tolerant society is something which should be welcomed. They should not be funded by the state though. If schools are discriminating based on faith, they should be wholly funded by the church or by parents. Otherwise, everyone should be give an equal chance of being given a place.

The only “fair” way to allocate state funded school places is by lottery. That would also stop those who can afford more expensive houses moving into catchment of better performing schools and would open those schools up to everyone. I do accept that they’re is an argument for academically selective schools (although if that system is kept, we need to build more of them because that system is entirely unequal and unfair at the moment).

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:10

Out of interest @unsureatthispoint do you agree with state funded religious schools that aren’t Christian?

Yes, I do agree. I have no problem with other religions

AlwaysLatte · 13/02/2023 08:49

I totally agree. Our choices were narrowed down when school hunting due to some of them being religious - we are atheists.

vdbfamily · 13/02/2023 08:47

gogohmm · 13/02/2023 07:37

There's more than one kind of nominally religious school, called controlled and maintained. The Catholic, other faiths and a few c of e (in cities typically) are controlled and actually have religious institutions giving oversight, 20% spaces must be allocated to local pupils without the faith criteria (80% allocated on faith, some newer schools it's less though). Aided are different, there's very little oversight or input and are for historical reasons, the church built the school pre 1900 so owns the land generally - a quick visit from the local vicar a few times a year and that's it.

This.
In the UK, 1625 of our CofE schools are voluntary controlled and admissions criteria are set by the LA. They will be set based on local need but no different too other schools in the County.
1491 are voluntary aided where the governors set the admissions criteria. In those schools, which tend to be more ' Christian' as more of the staff and governors will be practising Christians, they may be admitting church families from beyond catchment but would normally be looking to provide education to their surrounding community.
I would be interested to know how big an issue it is that local families cannot get kids into local school because they do not attend church. I would have thought a bigger factor is population increase whilst village school remains tiny.

eurochick · 13/02/2023 07:56

I agree with you OP. Religion should not be any sort of criterion to access state education. Why should my taxes prop up a school that my child can't access because her parents don't believe in a particular brand of sky pixie? Religion should be an extra-curricular activity.

Comtesse · 13/02/2023 07:51

It is a ridiculous anachronism and ought to go. Admission based in church attendance for a state funded school is appalling - why should our taxes prop up these religions?

SoupDragon · 13/02/2023 07:48

State funded religious discrimination is never acceptable.

In this case it is discrimination against those who do not practice the right religion. It would not be acceptable in any other area of life - Catholic/CofE hospitals anyone...?

gogohmm · 13/02/2023 07:44

My kids first school was nominally ce but no religion criteria at all, village school. I work for the church now and the primary takes 80% max on religious grounds but we aren't quite full (demographic changes in area) so take anyone

gogohmm · 13/02/2023 07:37

There's more than one kind of nominally religious school, called controlled and maintained. The Catholic, other faiths and a few c of e (in cities typically) are controlled and actually have religious institutions giving oversight, 20% spaces must be allocated to local pupils without the faith criteria (80% allocated on faith, some newer schools it's less though). Aided are different, there's very little oversight or input and are for historical reasons, the church built the school pre 1900 so owns the land generally - a quick visit from the local vicar a few times a year and that's it.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 07:37

Itsjustlikethat · 13/02/2023 07:25

As a first step, why not to change the admission criteria from faith-based to distance-based for all faith schools? At least it will stop excluding people in the community. No need to abolish any school that or restructure the asset ownership or similar.

I agree that this would be a good start.

Itsjustlikethat · 13/02/2023 07:25

As a first step, why not to change the admission criteria from faith-based to distance-based for all faith schools? At least it will stop excluding people in the community. No need to abolish any school that or restructure the asset ownership or similar.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 07:19

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/02/2023 00:40

How are you going to find the millions it's going to cost to buy the land and buildings (and fully maintain them without the church and trustee contributions) for the state?

If the government has to borrow to fund this, then so be it. It's a valuable investment for the future of our society.

The alternative is to continue using taxpayer funds to support a divisive and discriminatory system.

rexythedinosaur · 13/02/2023 07:15

On your point that ‘we’re a Christian country’ historically yes, but the latest census says that we aren’t (see below)

@Mushroo Actually if you look at the Census, Christianity is still the largest proportion of the pie chart, even though it is no longer more than half of the population.

It's very tricky. I'm not religious myself and wouldn't send my children to a religious school. But we do have a majority-religious country, if not majority-Christian, so that makes it difficult, and I think anyone trying to abolish religious state schools would have a huge challenge on their hands. (Not a reason not to do it, but I think a lot of people would be upset).

rexythedinosaur · 13/02/2023 07:11

From the most recent (2021) Census:

37.2% of the UK have 'no religion'

46.2% describe themselves as Christian.

(Other religions are small percentages in comparison)

So it is really quite close but there are on the whole more people in the UK who are religious than not.

It makes it a very difficult question and religious state schools are an institution which have been with us forever.

But I agree with OP that if we want a truly integrated and multicultural society, state religious schools don't help with that vision and they are exclusive.

ChaToilLeam · 13/02/2023 07:10

All publicly funded schools should, in this day and age, be non-denominational. Comparative religion only. Feel free to practice your religion at home and to attend worship outside school hours, but keep it out of the classroom.

It is ridiculous that publicly funded faith schools even exist.

JassyRadlett · 13/02/2023 06:59

vdbfamily · 13/02/2023 01:03

Our village had a C of E primary and I was a church governor. The criteria was mainly catchment. No advantage for church kids. I think it depends how they are funded and most church schools are d of e funded and follow normal rules

All state faith schools have all their running costs and most or all of their capital costs paid for by the government.

I posted above the proportion of faith schools in England that have at least a proportion of their admissions with a faith priority. It's a large number of schools.

JassyRadlett · 13/02/2023 06:55

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 00:40

Religious people would be effectively excluded from those schools (especially in my case where you have a minority religion). Our school offers suitable food for our dietary requirements, holidays at the time of our religious holidays and teaches our children about our religion from an insider’s perspective (they would not get this in a non denominational school). They are also free from discrimination that they might suffer on the ground of their religion elsewhere. If we didn’t have state religious schools most of us would go private and many would home school.

There is no point treating (for example) Sikh children equally with other children for admission to a Sikh school. The school is a school which teaches particularly about sikhism. It’s most suitable for Sikhs and it’s not unreasonable that that is a factor for entry.

as I said- people with no religion imo need to be more tolerant of those with religion. There is no harm in having a variety of schools. Everyone has access to a non denominational school so you try to abolish religious schools because you would prefer to send your children there (usually because the particular school gets good marks) but are not of that religion is intolerant. Send your children to the non denominational school and work to make it better rather than trying to abolish minority schools.

But the vast majority of children, including Sikh children, Jewish children, Muslim children don't have a nearby school that caters to their religion, and they attend non-faith schools. Just as they do in countries where state-funded faith schools aren't a thing.

Everyone has access to a non denominational school

Utter rubbish. In some areas, the faith schools are all there is. In areas like ours, the faith school intakes have so distorted the catchments that the community schools have tiny catchments and so some 'lucky' kids (like mine) will get non-faith-priority places at a church school, others get allocated an unpopular school a long distance away.

Simonjt · 13/02/2023 05:56

I don’t agree with religious state schooling, if you want religious schooling for your child you should have to pay to attend a religious public school. I find a lot of people who are heavilg pro religious schools are the ones who shield their children from every non-religious as they actually have very little confidence that their child will be religious, so they have to almost prevent them from accessing the non-religious world.

littleburn · 13/02/2023 01:14

My DC are at the local CofE primary. We're in a small city and about a third of the primaries are CofE. There's no religion-based entry criteria at the DC's school nor for the other CofE primaries. The one Catholic school does require the parents to be practicing. Based on my DCs' friendship groups, their CofE school intake includes children from Muslim and Hindu families.

I'd say the school wears it religion quite lightly, but maybe that's more typical of CofE schools. There's a daily act of worship (I think that's a requirement for all schools still?), which is usually a prayer and signing a hymn and the local vicar takes an assembly occasionally. The curriculum includes religious studies, but this covers learning about a range of faiths, as it would for non-religious schools. Mostly the religious elements seem very similar to my experience of attending a non-religious junior school in the late '80s!

The CofE schools - for whatever reason - have better results in our area, we're in the catchment and the school isn't pushing a heavily religious agenda, so that's where we sent the DC without really thinking about it too much. I'd assumed most CofE primaries don't have entry requirements, but clearly based on this thread some do. If there were religion-based entry requirements and I'd had to send my kids to the non-CofE primary that's currently in special measures I would be pissed off too OP!

vdbfamily · 13/02/2023 01:03

Our village had a C of E primary and I was a church governor. The criteria was mainly catchment. No advantage for church kids. I think it depends how they are funded and most church schools are d of e funded and follow normal rules

Ceilingplaits · 13/02/2023 01:00

Grumpybutfunny · 12/02/2023 21:14

Did you consider this when buying your house? I don't necessarily think kids should have to go to the local school, for us it would have been a lot easier for him to go to a school near work. Religion in our area actually comes lower than being in a feeder primary of the same academy trust

Not everyone is rich enough to buy a house, nor in a position to choose where to live, nor necessarily to travel far to schools. In fact, those things seem pretty rare and highly privileged in my experience.