Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say religious state schools shouldn’t exist?

219 replies

Mushroo · 12/02/2023 18:54

This is probably controversial but interested in opinions on both sides!

I attended a catholic primary and secondary school and had a lovely education (my parents are actually quite religious). However, given how increasingly secular the UK is it seems quite antiquated and divisive to segregate schools based on religion?

Where I live, our closest primary school as the crow flies is religious (c of e) and as a now atheist we wouldn’t get a place as we sit at the very bottom of the admissions criteria (other religions are given priority over atheist). This means we’d have to walk past it to get to the non-religious school further away.

This leads to many people ‘finding god’ in the nursery years to get a place which I refuse to do.

I don’t see the benefit of religious schools, surely if you are a religious family, you can learn about religion at your place of worship / Sunday school or equivalent.

I think state school should be secular and teach all religions equally (including atheism as an option) and places shouldn’t be offered based on religion. State school places should be based on particular needs (e.g. adopted children, siblings and then distance only).

Genuinely interested in thoughts, AIBU?

OP posts:
Middletoleft · 13/02/2023 11:38

Im on the west coast of Scotland and hate the religious bigotry of the divided school system and how it feeds into society. I went to a RC school in England at one point and know from that experience that it doesn't need to be that way.

JassyRadlett · 13/02/2023 11:36

So unfortunately no 'As is the notion that parents sending their children to religious schools are somehow 'more engaged' than others. ' , that isn't nonsense. The pre-school and year 5 epiphanies are a real phenomenon.

Ultimately this is true of any school that practises selection on particular characteristics. You give an advantage to parents who can jump through hoops, essentially. So yes, faith schools that select have lower FSM and higher prior attainment,

In faith schools that don't practise selective admissions, their results are much more what you'd expect for their local areas. Faith education itself isn't the magic ingredient. It's selective admissions.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/02/2023 11:33

* No, but there are no 'teachings' in supermarkets or swimming pools*

My kid had lessons in swimming and water safety at a swimming pool.
She was taught about other subjects at school, it's what they are there for. English, maths, science, etc - and also facts about various religions.Confused

The job of a school shouldn't be to indoctrinate a kid in one specific religion, should it?
Is some peoples faith so weak that they cant contemplate having their kid exposed to learning about other religions, science, history etc etc?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/02/2023 11:26

If we didn’t have state religious schools most of us would go private and many would home school

Nothing could be fairer, and if you wish your child to receive a more narrow education based mainly on faith that's absolutely your choice to make.
And the point of paying tax is to make services available for all, so if for whatever reason you opt not to use them that's again your choice

When emphasising tolerance you might at least have taken the trouble to get it right when you mentioned that everyone has access to secular schools though ... if only

ErrolTheDragon · 13/02/2023 11:22

There is no such thing as a 'secular' school. Religion is part of the national curriculum and a broad variety of faiths are taught.

Teaching about a variety of religions is fine with most secularists. In fact, many see it as a very good thing, especially for kids who would otherwise only learn about their parents' faith.
Someone can even have a faith and be a secularist, you know - like the founding fathers of the US. There seems to be a lot of misconception as to what the word means in practice.

The old myth that religious schools are somehow 'better' than other state schools is being trotted out. It's nonsense, frankly.

When our dd was school age, DH was somewhat involved with the fair schools admissions campaigns. He did some statistical analysis for schools in our county (he enjoys that sort of thing) - whether a school was 'faith' or not didn't correlate well with league table position but percentage on free school meals did... it appeared that the oversubscribed 'good' faith schools which could apply selection criteria were (perhaps inadvertently) discriminating against poorer kids.

So unfortunately no 'As is the notion that parents sending their children to religious schools are somehow 'more engaged' than others. ' , that isn't nonsense. The pre-school and year 5 epiphanies are a real phenomenon.

Cockerdileteeth · 13/02/2023 11:07

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves "It's not about non-religious people establishing their own school. I don't think that the state should fund atheist or humanist schools that discriminate against children with religious parents any more than I think the state should fund faith schools that discriminate towards children with non-religious parents.

The point about secular schools is that they would be inclusive of all children. If people want to indoctrinate their children in a particular world view, religious or otherwise, then they should pay to do it privately."

That hits the nail on the head for me.

I'd prefer our state-funded schools didn't endorse and advance a particular religion/worldview. (Teach about all the major faiths and worldviews as part of the curriculum so our kids are literate in navigating a multicultural world, sure, but no worship and no school religion.)

I don't see why people of faith should feel threatened by that. The extent to which some on this thread seem to, and the way they assume that "secular" schools would promote atheism / discriminate against people of faith, is tbh makes me more uncomfortable than I already am with the present system.

TeaKlaxon · 13/02/2023 10:33

Absolutely absurd that public funding would pay for schools whose theological stance is that gay people, for example, are 'intrinsically disordered'.

Imagine being a gay student at that school.

Imagine being a student raised by gay parents at that school.

Those schools don't just discriminate based on religion - they also discriminate based on sexual orientation by being hostile environments for gay people or their families.

CornishIrish · 13/02/2023 10:33

Our small rural school just wouldn’t exist without the church. It’s very open on admission ms though as it serves the local community.

it’s quite light touch as CofE and aside from the grumpy vicar who hands out a bible to leavers and Haribo for the Christingle it’s a bit take it or leave it on the religious front (although I love a bit of a harvest festival).

Religious state schools have also helped bridge class divides in certain areas allowing a decent education for non-fee paying families.

I’d rather have good all round state education and ban fee paying class system enforcing schools but it’s unlikely under this cue shower.

twoshedsjackson · 13/02/2023 10:28

I'm afraid the status quo will remain as long as the system is so strapped for cash.
If the government closed down schools with a religious foundation, they would then have more pupils needing provision elsewhere.
Some state schools are better than others; selection by faith will be replaced by selection by mortgage,
Not far from where I live, there is an excellent state primary which serves a small estate. I am told that the catchment area has a radius of 500 metres.

BadHabitsGoodFun · 13/02/2023 10:17

Oh absolutely no issue with religious schools - as long as they’re not funded by taxpayers! Simple. And I did help to set up a new secular school for precisely that reason so I think I can tick that off my to do list 😄.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/02/2023 10:13

So no- those schools do serve communities- the descendants of those original communities who setup those schools. That the numbers are dwindling doesn’t mean the school shouldn’t exist. If there is a sufficiently large number of children who want to attend a secular or non-religious school, set up a local academy. Run that instead. Why say to the religious they can’t have the schools they setup when the issue is others can’t be bothered to establish their own?

Nobody is saying that they can't have the schools that they set up. They are merely saying that the taxpayer shouldn't pay for these schools.

It's not about non-religious people establishing their own school. I don't think that the state should fund atheist or humanist schools that discriminate against children with religious parents any more than I think the state should fund faith schools that discriminate towards children with non-religious parents.

The point about secular schools is that they would be inclusive of all children. If people want to indoctrinate their children in a particular world view, religious or otherwise, then they should pay to do it privately.

BadHabitsGoodFun · 13/02/2023 10:12

Many posters have hit the nail on the head too by reminding us that’s its selection based on PARENT beliefs not the child’s. Another good reason to get rid as 4 year olds will be facing years of indoctrination at home - they should be able to think more freely at school.

ThreeImaginaryBoys · 13/02/2023 09:58

A lot of misconceptions on this thread.

There is no such thing as a 'secular' school. Religion is part of the national curriculum and a broad variety of faiths are taught.

In no way do mainstream schools discriminate against children from a particular faith. In fact, they are catered for (provision of Halal food options are common, for instance).

The old myth that religious schools are somehow 'better' than other state schools is being trotted out. It's nonsense, frankly. As is the notion that parents sending their children to religious schools are somehow 'more engaged' than others.

It is, frankly, appalling that state-funded education can employ religion-based selection criteria. It is no more legitimate than selecting children based on their hairstyle, or income, or eye colour.

I'm with you OP. Faith-based schools should not be state-funded. Practise your religion as you wish, but don't cross the line between church and state.

Cockerdileteeth · 13/02/2023 09:57

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:20

Again, what would a 'secular' 'ethical' assembly cover? It would be funding discrimination also. Very quickly, as religious families would be excluded

How on earth is an assembly that doesn't include formal worship, "funding discrimination" or "excluding religious families"?
Please think about the current position, whereby children of no religion have to participate in or at least quietly and politely observe Christian worship every schooldays.
Now that does technically fund discrimination - there's a carve out from equalities legislation in order to allow it. And atheist/humanist children have to suck it up, or exclude and isolate themselves during assembly.
Whereas if you remove the religious worship element, and address shared values and humanity, everyone is included aren't they? Why would people of faith have to remove themselves? Nobody's going to be preaching atheism or telling believers not to believe, or think about issues raised through the prism of their religion.
And are you really saying it's not possible to address moral, ethical and social issues without a context of formal religious worship and one religion's teachings?
That sounds very like the senior CofE education dept gentleman who told me that people of faith understand values better than those of us without faith, because they come from God. I imagine you, like he, are being deliberately provocative hence your reference to "woke morals".

Kabalagala · 13/02/2023 09:48

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:25

No, but there are no 'teachings' in supermarkets or swimming pools

Well then I assume you don't watch TV, or read books, sing nursery rhymes, listen to the radio....
What exactly do you think happens in secular schools that is exclusionary to the religious?

Itsjustlikethat · 13/02/2023 09:35

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:12

It wouldn't work.

The school would be quickly full of kids (and parents) who hate said religion, and would do anything within their power to disrespect those beliefs and teachings. No

Disrespecting any religious belief is not acceptable in any setting, school or otherwise. In my view, it is fine for schools to have a religious leaning, set certain expectations for students’ behaviours inside the school, and be clear about them (even including some mandatory participation in religious sessions). It’s part of giving choices to the families.

My problem is when they exclude children based on their parents’ beliefs using bogus criteria like church attendance. As said before, some non-religious people will go to church to get a place for their child at the right school, while some religious people might not manage to do so depending on other factors like work or other commitments.

ChungusBoi · 13/02/2023 09:33

ACynicalDad · 13/02/2023 09:23

The local cofe primary in London is struggling to recruit kids, frankly the middle classes are generally not keen to send their kids to somewhere religious if they can avoid it. It still has immigrant (largely African) communities but there aren’t enough of them to fill it. It doesn’t seem such a problem once people move out to the countryside, but that’s not a big sample size and I don’t know if it’s practicality (we have about 5 primaries in walking distance) or people who are a bit less woke about it? Still I don’t see anyone doing anything about it for the foreseeable future but I’d be fine if faith was removed from schools.

Yes it’s the same where I live. The secular primary schools are more popular than church ones because the middle class white majority are not religious.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 13/02/2023 09:30

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:12

It wouldn't work.

The school would be quickly full of kids (and parents) who hate said religion, and would do anything within their power to disrespect those beliefs and teachings. No

Except that is exactly the policy elsewhere in the UK and you don’t get people choosing a school specifically to “disrespect it’s beliefs and teachings”

jennytheonionslayer · 13/02/2023 09:30

1000% agree OP

Hiddenmnetter · 13/02/2023 09:29

I think this attitude thinks of schools as something that were created by the state and it is just not true. Schools, especially religious schools, were the product of local communities banding together to create institutions that they wanted for their children.

Over the last century the state has gotten more and more involved in education and part of that has been the way in which state funding is used to control schools (for instance catholic schools receive a % less funding for every hour/week they spend on teaching catholic classes).

Its not that “as the UK becomes more secular these schools are an anachronism” but rather as the demographic of the country changes the education offer should change with it. Unfortunately modern Britain is SO state reliant that people don’t want to set up schools anymore, except when they do everyone says “this is terrible and should be shut down because it’s not a state comp”.

The situation is basically that religious groups (who had a vested interest in educating children) set up these schools- if there are secular groups who want to setup secular schools they could do so. The issue is they don’t want to/can’t be bothered/think the government should do it. But governments are terrible at doing things like this because they work with big data, they don’t work with local communities. Which makes them utterly shit decision makers.

So no- those schools do serve communities- the descendants of those original communities who setup those schools. That the numbers are dwindling doesn’t mean the school shouldn’t exist. If there is a sufficiently large number of children who want to attend a secular or non-religious school, set up a local academy. Run that instead. Why say to the religious they can’t have the schools they setup when the issue is others can’t be bothered to establish their own?

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:25

Kabalagala · 13/02/2023 09:21

By that logic religious people are "excluded" from doing anything that isn't overtly religious. Do you go to a religious supermarket? Faith based swimming pool?

No, but there are no 'teachings' in supermarkets or swimming pools

ACynicalDad · 13/02/2023 09:23

The local cofe primary in London is struggling to recruit kids, frankly the middle classes are generally not keen to send their kids to somewhere religious if they can avoid it. It still has immigrant (largely African) communities but there aren’t enough of them to fill it. It doesn’t seem such a problem once people move out to the countryside, but that’s not a big sample size and I don’t know if it’s practicality (we have about 5 primaries in walking distance) or people who are a bit less woke about it? Still I don’t see anyone doing anything about it for the foreseeable future but I’d be fine if faith was removed from schools.

Kabalagala · 13/02/2023 09:21

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:20

Again, what would a 'secular' 'ethical' assembly cover? It would be funding discrimination also. Very quickly, as religious families would be excluded

By that logic religious people are "excluded" from doing anything that isn't overtly religious. Do you go to a religious supermarket? Faith based swimming pool?

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:20

Kabalagala · 13/02/2023 09:18

That's the point though. Taxes shouldn't be funding discrimination. If people want a religious education they should pay for it themselves.

Again, what would a 'secular' 'ethical' assembly cover? It would be funding discrimination also. Very quickly, as religious families would be excluded

Kabalagala · 13/02/2023 09:18

unsureatthispoint · 13/02/2023 09:12

It wouldn't work.

The school would be quickly full of kids (and parents) who hate said religion, and would do anything within their power to disrespect those beliefs and teachings. No

That's the point though. Taxes shouldn't be funding discrimination. If people want a religious education they should pay for it themselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread