Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of giving this woman a lift home?

412 replies

MinceandMash · 12/02/2023 18:52

I’ve got into a habit of giving a woman in my hobby group a lift home. To begin with it was done as a favour but now I feel like it’s become expected and she’s started to wait around for me at the end of a session. One time when I wasn’t able to attend she messaged me on FB asking where I was! I feel like I’m being taken advantage of. For context she lives about five minutes away from me but in the opposite direction meaning I have to drive to her house and then back on myself to get home. She doesn’t drive or own a car so car sharing isn’t an option. How the hell do I get out of this without coming across as a bitch?

OP posts:
PurpleButterflyWings · 13/02/2023 12:40

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1

To @MakeItADouble2 You sound like a CFer and chancer who doesn't think of anyone else but yourself. The OP has MORE than done her share, she didn't intend it to be every single day! She has a right to drive where she wants in her own car! You're clearly not a driver and are so self-absorbed that you can't see that 'only 5 minutes out of her way' adds up. Petrol, time, etc. It's people like you who will reap what you sow because you are so incredibly selfish you can't see it from the OP's point of view.

To @doodleygirl Because she doesn't want to! What is it that you don't 'get' about that? OP wants her freedom, her peace, her privacy. She is not a taxi service! You people who don't 'get' that are clearly CFers and chancers who don't think of anyone else but your selfish selves and see anyone with a car as your personal taxi. No woman has to 'be kind' to selfish CFing chancers! How about you CFing chancers try 'being kind' yourself, and stop expecting people to be your free personal chauffeur because you're too lazy to get off your arse and learn to drive like every other normal well-adjusted adult!

Well said! @PurpleButterflyWings The amount of ignorant CFers on here who say 'it's only a couple of minutes out of the way' boils my blood! No, it bloody well ISN'T 'only' that. You can the see lazy CFs on here who don't drive and expect us drivers to be their personal taxi service and chauffeur! We adulted and got off our arses and got our licence and car, maybe they should try that! Instead of being so lazy and having no initiative and expecting every one to cater to them. They honestly just simply don't 'get' it because they have no personal responsibility and are used to being catered for. Oh and the #bekind aholes can get stuffed! Why is it always on us doormats to #bekind ? Why is it that these CF chancers are never #kind to us? Why is it all one way! Time for the CF chancers to #bekind . For a change.

To @wurlycurly
Why is it always on the good people, the mugs and the doormats to #bekind ? Why don't the CFers and chancers ever bekind? I think the OP has already #beenkind for too long. Stop telling people to #bekind. Try being kind yourself by allowing others to be assertive and have self esteem and self respect.

I love these posts. Grin You do know how to roar @IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 - and I love it! I could have written all that. !!! The entitlement of some - not all but SOME non-drivers/people who have no car is breath-taking. Utter UTTER CF-ers! Of the highest order. I am also guessing that you are someone who has been used and mugged off by CF-ers like this, as I have too... and so has DH. DH used to get people expecting him to drop them off when he worked in a factory some 20 years ago.

His workplace was about 2 miles from where we lived - and a couple of times he gave several people a lift home a mile or two further on from our house, as it was raining hard, or they missed the bus and would have to wait 20 minutes for another. Almost immediately, they started waiting for him to finish work, (every day) and were constantly hanging around outside for him and their 'lift,' and started bitching at him when he was a few minutes late coming out.

Got on his tits so much that he got a pushbike and started cycling to and from work. Putting HIMSELF out, getting rained on, and having to cycle along a busy A-road in the dark to get home. I have had a number of similar experiences, and so have many drivers I know. Entitled CF-ers assuming you're their free taxi service, and being aghast, and annoyed, and actually quite nasty when you withdraw the 'service.'

As for the 'why can you not have an adult conversation' posters. LOL as if. Everyone knows not as simple and straightforward as that, and it's a lot easier to come on here and say 'I woulda said this and I woulda said that!' But you wouldn't. Wink

I am also mightily sick and tired of the #bekind brigade. AKA do what other people want you to do, no matter how much it inconveniences you, even though these same people wouldn't lend you as much as a cardboard cup with a teaspoon of sugar in it.

Also, yes I KNOW some people cannot drive, and/or cannot afford to learn, but that doesn't mean people who CAN drive should be their free taxi service. For an occasional emergency yeah sure, but on a regular basis. Not likely. Had far too many people taking the piss ta very much! Wink

TheBadLuckOfTeelaBrown · 13/02/2023 12:00

I would just tell her ('ask' her) to walk from yours in future so that you don't need to drive out of your way. And also say in advance that you have to do things on the way home so that you can't. Occasionally. randomly. Just to stop her expectation. She is a CFer

Mothership4two · 13/02/2023 11:57

Not sure what one has to do with the other @MrsMikeDrop? My comment was about non-drivers being called lazy. But no I wouldn't expect people who couldn't drive to refuse all lifts or drivers to boycott non-drivers - that would be quite odd (if that's what you meant?)

The OP seems mainly fed up by this woman's entitled attitude, as well as being tied into the arrangement, not by her being unable to drive (if that's even the case) IMO.

HuntingoftheSnark · 13/02/2023 11:56

I don't drive and would never accept a "regular" lift, only as a one off and would always offer money in those rare cases. I attend a meeting every Sunday and, if train strikes mean I can't get there, I make alternative plans. An exception was Christmas Day last year when I did accept a lift and gave a gift in return. I agree that it's incredibly CF ish to expect.

MrsMikeDrop · 13/02/2023 11:25

Mothership4two · 13/02/2023 10:28

Silly to say people who can't drive are lazy. How judgemental. Some people can't afford it or don't want to prioritise the costs (even middle class people!). It's not just the cost of lessons, it's what comes after: the cost of the car and upkeep, parking and possibly permits, fuel and the big one insurance. Some people struggle to pass the driving test. Some don't drive for ecological reasons. I know people who live in big cities where congestion is horrendous, parking expensive and difficult, and there's reasonable public transport who just never bothered as they don't see the point.

This is fair enough, but then surely you don't expect others to drive you either?

flabbygoldfish · 13/02/2023 10:29

I get the OPs point. It is not the cost\time but the entitlement and assumption that this is a continuing arrangement which grates. Done it once so now committed for evermore with probably no thanks or acknowledgment.

Mothership4two · 13/02/2023 10:28

Silly to say people who can't drive are lazy. How judgemental. Some people can't afford it or don't want to prioritise the costs (even middle class people!). It's not just the cost of lessons, it's what comes after: the cost of the car and upkeep, parking and possibly permits, fuel and the big one insurance. Some people struggle to pass the driving test. Some don't drive for ecological reasons. I know people who live in big cities where congestion is horrendous, parking expensive and difficult, and there's reasonable public transport who just never bothered as they don't see the point.

UdoU · 13/02/2023 09:42

ramanw · 13/02/2023 08:51

I would say you are picking a cousin up from work for the next few weeks as their car is broken. Hopefully then she will just stop asking.

I have a lady in work who does this to me (but not as bad). She gets picked up every single day by a family member because she comes in in heels and thinks she's above walking home. When he can't get her, she will ask me. I live in the complete opposite direction. She also asks for lifts everywhere on lunch when she could walk there in 10 minutes. Piss take.

I hope you say no?

ZombieMumEB · 13/02/2023 09:36

You can either be direct - let her know this arrangement no longer works for you, and do not give her a reason or excuse.

If pressed, just say you'd rather not go into it as it's personal.

Or you could take the cowards way out, and make the lifts uncomfortable for her, so that she chooses another option.

Depending on the night, and if shops are open - just go shopping on the way home, and drag it out, so she gets home later.

Start playing Christian music in the car, and sing along.

Join Amway and try to recruit her.

BreatheAndFocus · 13/02/2023 09:28

Just invent a regular chore/visit that will occur after the hobby group and is in the opposite direction to her house. I’d give her one final lift home then take that opportunity to tell her that due to the above chore/visit, you’ll no longer be able to give her a lift home and she should make other arrangements.

clairelouwho · 13/02/2023 09:27

The thing with driving lessons you don’t need to have them with a driving instructor. If you have a family member over a certain age who has been driving x amount of years they can teach you how to drive.

Then you need to pay for provisional license, theory test and eventually practical driving test with examiner. Plus any, no doubt, lowered cost of tuition from family member or friend. So it’s not necessarily the case that being unable to afford professional tuition means you’ll be unable to drive.

Evasmissingletter · 13/02/2023 09:21

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 I understand my post was clearly about socioeconomic disadvantaged people. I understand you replied. “If the UK had a different attitude, and took personal responsibility and stopped being lazy and learned to drive they'd have less people out of work.”. So how I was supposed to deduce from that you were talking about middle classes?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 13/02/2023 09:19

Thatcatisdrivingmenuts · 13/02/2023 09:15

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 Utter rubbish, frankly. Driving lessons are £40 hour, and LOTS of people can't afford it. And anyway, driving lessons need to be more than monthly, so the cost adds up.

Excuses. It is very expensive where I am, but there is NO CHOICE but to do it. To not do it, is not an option. If you have no option, you do it.

Quveas · 13/02/2023 09:16

BlondeBombshelf · 12/02/2023 19:00

You clearly don’t like her so it should be easy enough to say ‘I don’t want to, make your own way there as I drive past in comfort’.

Why should she "like" her? She's just some random starnger who happens to attend a group the OP goes to, not her bestie. Perhaps you are ok with doing whatever randon strangers want you to, but not everyone is. It is unreasonable for someone to expect a lift every week just because they want one. If the women had anything about ther then she would have at least offered a contribution to the extra petrol being used.

OP, I agree with others that a simple, sorry, but I can't offer you a lift - no explanation is necessary because you don't owe her a lift.

Thatcatisdrivingmenuts · 13/02/2023 09:15

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 Utter rubbish, frankly. Driving lessons are £40 hour, and LOTS of people can't afford it. And anyway, driving lessons need to be more than monthly, so the cost adds up.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 13/02/2023 09:14

CalpolOnToast · 13/02/2023 09:00

You're aware it's not taught in schools here and costs £20-30 an hour aren't you?

Unfortunately it's not taught in schools where I live either, and the cost here is more like 50-70 an hour, but through societal expectations you spend that money, even when you're on the dole, because it's expected of you. If it's a expectation you don't think about the cost much more than you think about paying taxes. It's just something you have to do.

clairelouwho · 13/02/2023 09:06

Honestly I think it’s clear on this thread who the CFs are and who the people who have been taken advantage of by CFs are.

First, can we stop telling people to be kind and just do something even if it inconveniences them? OP has been kind in giving lifts thus far and now she feels roped into an arrangement she didn’t agree to.

Yes the financial cost may be negligible but it all adds up. In fact, OP is potentially saving this woman quite a bit in public transport fees and as such an offer to contribute should be made. Even if the offer would be refused it’s still nice to offer and shows an acknowledgment of the favour being done.

If OP booked a taxi to go home one night and this woman decided to cadge a lift home and share the taxi, wouldn’t she be expected to pay half the cost of the whole taxi fare and not just the cost of the difference between their two houses? So why shouldn’t she be expected to contribute to the whole journey?

It seems that the be kind crew on this thread are also the same people balking at the idea of this or any other CFer contributing financially when OP is actively saving them money whilst being put out of pocket.

A lot of non drivers are like this. They don’t want the hassle, effort and expense of learning to drive and running a car, but are more than happy to benefit from those of us who do. Maybe just a thought for all the CFs on the thread who think OP should continue to be taken a lend of for the sake of being kind whilst receiving no kindness in return.

CalpolOnToast · 13/02/2023 09:00

You're aware it's not taught in schools here and costs £20-30 an hour aren't you?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 13/02/2023 08:52

Evasmissingletter · 13/02/2023 08:47

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 “If the UK had a different attitude, and took personal responsibility and stopped being lazy and learned to drive they'd have less people out of work.” Horrible stereotype there that socioeconomic disadvantaged people in the UK are lazy. Many are struggling economically so driving lessons, driving tests, buying a car, insurance and car tax are just not viable which limits job choices and so perpetuating the poverty cycle.

You misunderstand me I was talking about the UK non-driving culture in general regarding driving, because there are so many posters on here that say they 'don't drive' and they're middle class, not just low socioeconomic.

And as I said, even the poorest of the poor in other countries still have driving lessons, tests, and buy a car etc. Even the poorest socioeconomic people manage to do it. And those on welfare. So it's not really a justification because poor people in other countries do it, so there is no reason they can't in the UK.

PuzzledObserver · 13/02/2023 08:52

If the OP never attended this group the woman would have to pay for public transport back so she should give that money she has saved to the OP

Not quite. There are rules around accepting money for giving lifts - for both insurance and tax reasons, it can’t be any more than the actual cost of taking the car on the journey. HMRC accept 45p per mile as a reasonable estimate for that, with no evidence of actual costs required. If the bus fare was that, or less than that, then the woman could indeed give it to the OP. That might make her think twice about needing the lift so much.

I regularly give lifts to people who are not friends, colleagues or even known to me. I do it through a charity, which organises everything. And I receive 45p per mile for every mile I drive. The intention is that, although I give my time freely, I should not be out of pocket for the use of my car. I also give lifts to other members of my walking group. The organiser of that has a rule of thumb of 25p per mile, to be shared between all passengers, with the driver not counted.

Both of those recognise that there is a significant cost to running a car - it is not just the petrol, it’s the servicing, tyres and so on (which are mileage related), insurance, tax, and - the biggest cost of all - buying the thing in the first place.

It is good for lots of reasons for car journeys to be shared. But it is not reasonable IMO to expect the driver to bear the full cost - even if it does not involve them going out of their way.

Note that the OP does not describe the passenger as a friend. She’s just somebody she met through the hobby group. She should feel under no obligation to offer a lift at all if she doesn’t want to. If she chooses to, it is perfectly reasonable to ask for a contribution.

ramanw · 13/02/2023 08:51

I would say you are picking a cousin up from work for the next few weeks as their car is broken. Hopefully then she will just stop asking.

I have a lady in work who does this to me (but not as bad). She gets picked up every single day by a family member because she comes in in heels and thinks she's above walking home. When he can't get her, she will ask me. I live in the complete opposite direction. She also asks for lifts everywhere on lunch when she could walk there in 10 minutes. Piss take.

LookItsMeAgain · 13/02/2023 08:50

Do you have her phone number? You need to text her before you get to the hobby group telling her "Hi Jane, just to let you know that I'm not in a position to give you a lift home going forwards. I wanted to let you know so that you have time to arrange an alternative way home. See you at Hobby Group later on".

Don't expand on why you can't give her a lift home. Just repeat that you can't give her a lift home if she tries to pull a fast one. If, when you're leaving, you see her putting on her coat as if to get in the car with you, stand firm and repeat that you're not able to give her a lift home and that she needs to find an alternative way to get home.

Best of luck!

EsmeSusanOgg · 13/02/2023 08:49

ThreeblackCats · 12/02/2023 18:58

“I’m not heading your way tonight, sorry”

repeat until she gets the message.

I had to do this a few years ago. Worked out fine. I don't mind the occasional lift... But not all the time.

ramanw · 13/02/2023 08:49

I w

Evasmissingletter · 13/02/2023 08:47

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 “If the UK had a different attitude, and took personal responsibility and stopped being lazy and learned to drive they'd have less people out of work.” Horrible stereotype there that socioeconomic disadvantaged people in the UK are lazy. Many are struggling economically so driving lessons, driving tests, buying a car, insurance and car tax are just not viable which limits job choices and so perpetuating the poverty cycle.