Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of giving this woman a lift home?

412 replies

MinceandMash · 12/02/2023 18:52

I’ve got into a habit of giving a woman in my hobby group a lift home. To begin with it was done as a favour but now I feel like it’s become expected and she’s started to wait around for me at the end of a session. One time when I wasn’t able to attend she messaged me on FB asking where I was! I feel like I’m being taken advantage of. For context she lives about five minutes away from me but in the opposite direction meaning I have to drive to her house and then back on myself to get home. She doesn’t drive or own a car so car sharing isn’t an option. How the hell do I get out of this without coming across as a bitch?

OP posts:
MasterBeth · 15/02/2023 12:36

"Driving is an essential life skill and it is not damaging to the environment"?, oh please. You are either seriously misinformed or being disingenuous.
What on earth do you think people did before 1886?

This is exactly the same argument as saying reading is not an essential life skill because before 3500BC, writing hadn't been invented...

FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly · 15/02/2023 11:25

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 15/02/2023 10:03

That is a very long screed to say that you don't care that I was excluding health conditions, and a lot of words to excuse your inability to read. As well as your inability to use common sense and critical thinking and you were caught out. Driving is imo a vital life skill and may save your life one day. It is not an 'environmental disaster' any more than an ambulance on 4 wheels is an environmental disaster. It is a mode of transport and an essential life skill. But do go on with your hyperbole to hide your embarrassment at not being able to read, use common sense or possess critical thinking. All you've done is embarrass yourself.

I can read perfectly well. Where on earth do you get the impression that I don’t care that your original quote didn’t include exclusions for anyone who is medically unable to drive? Was it when I called it inane, short-sighted and cruel? Yes, probably, I think I adequately expressed my contempt for your original post and it seems going back a page that others agree.
But wait, now you seem to be confusing illiteracy with the simple fact that I have better things to do than crawl through a sixteen page thread searching for all the times that you have recanted the error of your original post.
Driving is an essential life skill and it is not damaging to the environment, oh please. You are either seriously misinformed or being disingenuous.
What on earth do you think people did before 1886? People have been riding horses and bicycles for longer. The stats or vehicle emissions, recycling, the percentage of microplastics from cars that return to the environment, noise pollution etc. etc are all freely available if you care to look.
You appear not to like long posts and respond in an unreasonable way to a reasonable argument. Clearly I can read, and I took exception to your original post, because I read it. It seems you made a mistake of some proportion and are now trying to post your way out of it.
Im not insulted by anything you have written…or embarrassed by anything I posted. Post again when you have learned how to construct a reasoned argument for your case.
Bye.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 15/02/2023 10:03

FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly · 15/02/2023 09:47

Repeatedly adding the addendum about ‘excluding health issues that would mean driving wasn’t possible’ probably after it had been pointed out that your comment as quoted above, which did not contain any consideration towards those of us with seizure disorders etc. but was as it stood inane, short-sighted and downright cruel.

Having a driving license is not the definition of a responsible adult and to ‘get of your arse’ and attain a license does not a a responsible adult with common sense and critical thinking skills make. Obviously it isn’t and an excellent example is that if the license and these attributes were mutually inclusive you would have thought a little harder about your post, as quoted, and included exclusions.

Judging by the pronoun ‘we’ in the quoted first sentence, you are a driver, so is my husband. He drives professionally, he consistently complains about the standard of driving on the road, especially at weekends when more ‘non-professional’ drivers are out on the roads. Weekend drivers. He also frequently jokes about how often someone has tried to ‘kill him’.
This is the complex motor skill that you hold up as the gold standard for Secondary School Graduation?!
MIT and Cornell have a swim test as a requirement of graduation. At MIT every student swims 100 yards continuously of the Zesiger centre pool or signs up for the introductory swimming lessons. At least then you graduate with a life skill that can not only save yourself but possibly another person, keep yourself fit and healthy. Driving? environmental disaster on four wheels. At least I can happily say when I do use a car, I car share.
I hope you have to keep posting your ‘explanation’ to get out of a very dumb post, it might teach YOU some critical thinking skills and how to apply them.
Roar a little more quietly in future please.

That is a very long screed to say that you don't care that I was excluding health conditions, and a lot of words to excuse your inability to read. As well as your inability to use common sense and critical thinking and you were caught out. Driving is imo a vital life skill and may save your life one day. It is not an 'environmental disaster' any more than an ambulance on 4 wheels is an environmental disaster. It is a mode of transport and an essential life skill. But do go on with your hyperbole to hide your embarrassment at not being able to read, use common sense or possess critical thinking. All you've done is embarrass yourself.

FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly · 15/02/2023 09:47

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 15/02/2023 03:56

@FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly Sigh. I have said repeatedly excluding health issues that would mean driving wasn't possible. I shouldn't have to qualify every single statement for every single whataboutery I can foresee someone making. Surely you can use some common sense and critical thinking. For goodness sake.

Repeatedly adding the addendum about ‘excluding health issues that would mean driving wasn’t possible’ probably after it had been pointed out that your comment as quoted above, which did not contain any consideration towards those of us with seizure disorders etc. but was as it stood inane, short-sighted and downright cruel.

Having a driving license is not the definition of a responsible adult and to ‘get of your arse’ and attain a license does not a a responsible adult with common sense and critical thinking skills make. Obviously it isn’t and an excellent example is that if the license and these attributes were mutually inclusive you would have thought a little harder about your post, as quoted, and included exclusions.

Judging by the pronoun ‘we’ in the quoted first sentence, you are a driver, so is my husband. He drives professionally, he consistently complains about the standard of driving on the road, especially at weekends when more ‘non-professional’ drivers are out on the roads. Weekend drivers. He also frequently jokes about how often someone has tried to ‘kill him’.
This is the complex motor skill that you hold up as the gold standard for Secondary School Graduation?!
MIT and Cornell have a swim test as a requirement of graduation. At MIT every student swims 100 yards continuously of the Zesiger centre pool or signs up for the introductory swimming lessons. At least then you graduate with a life skill that can not only save yourself but possibly another person, keep yourself fit and healthy. Driving? environmental disaster on four wheels. At least I can happily say when I do use a car, I car share.
I hope you have to keep posting your ‘explanation’ to get out of a very dumb post, it might teach YOU some critical thinking skills and how to apply them.
Roar a little more quietly in future please.

Billybea · 15/02/2023 08:55

I think the first error was giving her your phone no! Tell her this is the last week you can drop her off as from next week you now have to collect your (daughter, son husband etc) from somewhere at a certain time which means you have to leave the hobby class exactly on time and go in the other direction.

ComfortablyDazed · 15/02/2023 08:28

P.S. 🙄

ComfortablyDazed · 15/02/2023 08:28

Ladybug14 · 15/02/2023 05:56

Of course she follows you to your car

YOU HAVEN'T TOLD HER YOU'RE NOT GIVING HER A LIFT

🙄

She hasn’t told her she IS giving her a lift, either?!?

TigeToo · 15/02/2023 06:52

I knew an annoying piss taker like this. She asked me once if I’d give her a lift home as it was raining. I agreed (Sam’s scenario, she lived in opposite direction to my house). After that it became expected every day (school run). I put up with it for too long before I eventually said I couldn’t do it one night as I was going shopping straight from school. The next day she stood next to my car waiting for me so I told her I couldn’t do it as I was visiting my mum. This went on for a week before she finally got the hint 🙄

SunshineAndFizz · 15/02/2023 06:30

PomsInOz · 15/02/2023 04:03

I'm struggling to see how this can't be dealt with by a friendly "sorry, I can't give you a lift home tonight" from OP to the person expecting lifts. Repeat every week until she gets the hint. No need to say anything else or give excuses that can be argued against.

Yes please do this.

thegreencomet · 15/02/2023 06:04

She's got into a comfortable familiarity with getting the lift home, and that has bred an expectation that she will get a lift home - to the point where if you're not there she's messaging incredulously, where are you??, because she thinks you ought to be there to give her that expected lift.

You really will have to actually say something.

You don't want to do it anymore, you can't do it anymore, it really doesn't matter how you phrase it, once you are set in your intention to stop doing this favour.

Ladybug14 · 15/02/2023 05:56

Of course she follows you to your car

YOU HAVEN'T TOLD HER YOU'RE NOT GIVING HER A LIFT

🙄

MrsMarkRonson · 15/02/2023 05:25

DISCLAIMER: I know not all non drivers are like this:
This reminds me of a family that live near me who did a very smug interview about not owning a car (where we live is a city, everythings spread out so were walking to town for work etc is impossible). Gloated about how they were saving the environment, and had saved heaps of money blah blah. Then stated that when they did need a lift people were generally nice but some people 'wouldn't go out of their way at all.' All us parents were lumbered ferrying their DC around, (who were nice kids) but when I read the interview (where people were commenting how wonderful they were) I was a little bit annoyed - how nice you, as a couple, have saved sooo much money not having a car, while me, a struggling single mum drives your daughter in a car I pay petrol, rego, warrant etc on!

Cariadm · 15/02/2023 04:29

PomsInOz · 15/02/2023 04:03

I'm struggling to see how this can't be dealt with by a friendly "sorry, I can't give you a lift home tonight" from OP to the person expecting lifts. Repeat every week until she gets the hint. No need to say anything else or give excuses that can be argued against.

OMG!! A sane, rational, adult voice and attitude amongst the defensive and at times almost hysterical nonsense posted here!! Mountain out of the proverbial again by an OP!! 🙄😫

PomsInOz · 15/02/2023 04:03

I'm struggling to see how this can't be dealt with by a friendly "sorry, I can't give you a lift home tonight" from OP to the person expecting lifts. Repeat every week until she gets the hint. No need to say anything else or give excuses that can be argued against.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 15/02/2023 03:56

FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly · 14/02/2023 19:23

Feck, I would literally still be in a nightmarish time warp of seizures and failed graduation if THAT actually was a reality.
On top of that, if I ever managed to get the cursed thing, one seizure would mean I would have to give up my license, until I had a year clear of seizures.
What flavour of idiot thinks that everyone who doesn’t have a driving license shouldn’t graduate from High School?
@Frazzledmummy123 smug isn’t the word I would use, but yes you are right they are generalising

@FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly Sigh. I have said repeatedly excluding health issues that would mean driving wasn't possible. I shouldn't have to qualify every single statement for every single whataboutery I can foresee someone making. Surely you can use some common sense and critical thinking. For goodness sake.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 15/02/2023 03:48

Cariadm · 14/02/2023 14:27

Sorry but IAmaWomanHearMeRoar (?!) it's you who needs to take a look and listen at and to yourself...You're looking at this from entirely the wrong perspective and assuming things that you could not have any idea about... Come down off your high horse and see this for what it is and how it could be dealt with compassionately and calmly...the OP is making a mountain out of a molehill and if she has a rational legitimate reason for not kindly giving this person a lift once a week other than she's annoyed by the so called 'entitled' attitude then just deal with it like a grown up?! For instance she could say something like I'm happy to give you a lift most weeks but there will be others when it's not possible, just let her know on a week by week basis what the situation is, FFS, just maybe she could try talking to the actual person instead of looking for sympathy on here?!

@Cariadm That post of mine was solely to another poster, NOT addressed to the OP or her issue. If you had read my post, it would have been obvious who it was about.

RaiseTheBar · 14/02/2023 23:09

ComfortablyDazed · 14/02/2023 23:05

Name change fail?

I presumed that @ellyeth was thanking people for their suggestions in reply to her post (from the opposite scenario to the OP), which was somewhere in the middle of the thread.

JustABloodyMinute · 14/02/2023 23:07

@FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly @Frazzledmummy123 absolutely agree!!!

ComfortablyDazed · 14/02/2023 23:05

Name change fail?

ellyeth · 14/02/2023 22:34

Thanks to those who have made suggestions.

Beaverbridge · 14/02/2023 19:44

Some crazy attitudes here. Why should OP have to tow someone home. How did she get back before. She shouldn't have to make excuses up, just tell person I'm not doing it.

CSUK · 14/02/2023 19:29

There is an imbalance here of good will from those who spend lots of money and time, learning to drive and meeting all the expenses of running a car. If you’re one of the people regularly relying on someone for lifts that doesn’t go out of their way to make an occasional gesture of thanks and gratitude, you are one of the people stretching the good will of others. Those people should not be in the position of having to explain ‘Flip it, I just don’t feel like being that nice today.’ … but when they do, I think they should just say. “I can’t do it today, because I’m in a bad mood. I wouldn’t be great company and my driving might be affected. I wouldn’t take the risk of having you in my car when I’m feeling like this.” It’ll at least prompt them to think… Lol.

FortunateCatsGlugDaquirisAllEveningBlindly · 14/02/2023 19:23

Frazzledmummy123 · 14/02/2023 14:26

@IAmWomanHearMeRoar1
Get off your arse and get your licence like a responsible adult, like we have. Tbh I think it should be a compulsory module that you cannot graduate secondary school unless you get your licence.

Generalising a lot there, not every non-driver is a CF who expects lifts off drivers. You sound very smug.

Feck, I would literally still be in a nightmarish time warp of seizures and failed graduation if THAT actually was a reality.
On top of that, if I ever managed to get the cursed thing, one seizure would mean I would have to give up my license, until I had a year clear of seizures.
What flavour of idiot thinks that everyone who doesn’t have a driving license shouldn’t graduate from High School?
@Frazzledmummy123 smug isn’t the word I would use, but yes you are right they are generalising

LookItsMeAgain · 14/02/2023 17:35

Just thinking about this again @MinceandMash, when you're next doing your hobby and the woman gets up to leave with you when you're heading home, just say to her "Actually Jane, I'm not going in your direction tonight. I think that it's probably best for you to call an Uber or taxi or something. I'll see you next time though" and then leave. If she follows you, then drive to your house and go in. Don't invite her in to your home, when she gets out of the car say to her "See you at the hobby again" and go in and leave her there.

It's unlikely that she would (a) take the lift if it's not going in her direction and (b) if she did, she won't do it again as the walk from yours to hers will be too long for her.

VivX · 14/02/2023 16:48

MadMadaMim · 14/02/2023 14:15

I've responded YABU because it's a non issie

Inform her that you're not going to be able to give her a lift in future. If she asks why (rude if she does!) say you won't be going straight home

Then on those occasions that you do feel like offer a lift, you can say you'll be going straight home this evening, would youike a lift (and drop her at a bust stop if you don't want the 10 min diversion)

The woman lives in the opposite direction to the OP from the venue. To give the lift, the OP has to* *divert, because logically there is no bus stop on the OP's way home that would be nearer to the woman's house than the venue they originally left from.

If the OP went straight home, she (the OP) would actually be taking the woman further away from where she (the woman) lives. How on earth would that be helpful?