Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of giving this woman a lift home?

412 replies

MinceandMash · 12/02/2023 18:52

I’ve got into a habit of giving a woman in my hobby group a lift home. To begin with it was done as a favour but now I feel like it’s become expected and she’s started to wait around for me at the end of a session. One time when I wasn’t able to attend she messaged me on FB asking where I was! I feel like I’m being taken advantage of. For context she lives about five minutes away from me but in the opposite direction meaning I have to drive to her house and then back on myself to get home. She doesn’t drive or own a car so car sharing isn’t an option. How the hell do I get out of this without coming across as a bitch?

OP posts:
MeanderingGently · 13/02/2023 01:49

I never understand these posts where people don't appear to be able to have a normal, adult conversation with another adult. In this case it's about lifts.
Instead of making up all sorts of excuses, why not just say, "I'm sorry but I'm not going to be able to continue with giving you a lift every day, it's very tying for me and I need to stop the current arrangement. I know you'll be disappointed but you'll need to sort out other transport from (tomorrow/next week/the weekend)" And then stop.

Occasionally I offer someone from work a lift into the nearest market town, but only if I'm going that way. I have already said to her that no, I'm not prepared to pick her up in the mornings because it would "tie" me to a specific time, and I don't want to give regular lifts home as it will become a habit and I want to be free to come and go to my workplace as it suits me. But occasionally, if she is absolutely stuck, I will help.

Surely it's not that difficult?

HollaHolla · 13/02/2023 01:49

MinceandMash · 12/02/2023 21:30

To answer some questions no she’s never offered me petrol money, but to be honest that’s not the problem really it’s the expectation that I’ll always do it. Last week she even followed me out to the car park and to my car. Sometimes I’d like to be able to pop to the shops or get petrol on the way home.

That’s what you do. Go for fuel, or to the shops, on the way home. Tell her you’re doing that. If it doesn’t suit, she’ll likely whine, but you might find that she self-selects out. Oh, and I’d also say you need to just drop her at yours. (As long as it’s not a dangerous walk to hers from there.)

CombatBarbie · 13/02/2023 01:48

MakeItADouble2 · 12/02/2023 19:13

I personally believe you reap what you sow. 5 mins is hardly too much out of your way, is it? One day your kindness will be returned in some other way, and not necessarily by this lady. However it needs to be done with kindness.
Why are you getting so upset by this relatively small blip to your journey home?.

Because its expected..... It would grate on me too.

annonymousse · 13/02/2023 01:12

Regarding the cost the woman is getting a lift all the way for free. Without the lift she would presumably have a bus fare to pay? So despite the fact it's only 5-10 minutes extra for op lift taker should offer a contribution for her transport

melj1213 · 13/02/2023 01:05

alanabennett · 13/02/2023 00:05

I couldn't agree more. Some people here wouldn't give you the steam off their pee.

The problem is those "just two minutes" add up time wise and cost wise. If you break it down on a trip by trip basis then it seems trivial as "it's only 40p a trip" (for example) but when you look at the cost as a whole over a longer period of time then those trivial amounts add up. Then you sound petty asking for a contribution on a weekly basis when it's such a small amount but if you wait a couple of months and then ask for £10 to cover the last couple of months costs then people get narked because you never said anything in the beginning.

Especially at the moment with the cost of living going up, as someone making barely over minimum wage who has had bills go up massively in the last few months, recently o have found I barely have £10 left a few days before payday more often than not so all those "just two minute" trips people are expected to absorb the cost of could literally be the difference between finishing the month in the red or in the black. I'm not about to share my financial situation with everyone I work/volunteer/interact with but as nice as a gift at Christmas is, it doesn't put fuel in the tank or help with the decision of whether to spend my last £10 on fuel to ferry other people around or groceries for DD and I, and I'm not about to say "Sorry Ethel, I can't take you to choir practice as I can't afford the fuel even though it's only an extra couple of miles to pick you up" because it's embarrassing to have to admit that.

Not only that but it's always easy to say "it's only a couple of minutes" but once resentment starts because what was once an occasional favour, or what was supposed to be short term support, turns into an expectation or a long term commitment then it is very hard to get out of that mindset. Even if someone is grateful for the lift it's the extra admin - if you can't go to a class (or just CBA one week) then you have to tell the other person so they can find other transport; you have to work round the expectation of picking up/dropping off someone else.

Sometimes giving lifts to someone very close is worse than someone where you have to detour. At least with a detour you can drop the person off and then decide whether you want to continue home or go back and do your grocery shopping, for example, but if they only live a minute or two away then you either have to drag them on your errands (and even if someone says "Oh it's fine, I don't mind!", I mind and I feel pressured to do things quickly) or instead of going venue > shopping> home you essentially have to go venue>home>shopping>home, so that "two minute" lift has cost you significantly more in time, cost an inconvenience (even if you don't do your shopping and just go straight home then it means you have to go another time which may not be convenient)

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 13/02/2023 00:42

Just make something up next time "oh by the way, I've taken up spinning / basketweaving / an affair after this from next week, so won't be able to give you a lift in future"

Gives her a week's warning, and ensures she'll never ask you again

Trez1510 · 13/02/2023 00:32

You couldn't make it up. 😁😂

You did just make that up, though.

Fortunately, people (even on just this thread) are much more diverse than your brain seems to recognise.

Busybutbored · 13/02/2023 00:31

Trez1510 · 13/02/2023 00:00

I had to read the post twice to make sure I understood the poster intends to ask the passenger for the cost of running the car for four minutes per week.

This is despite the passenger being grateful, asking if it is convenient and giving a gift at Christmas.

I can just imagine the OP and her husband bitching about this poor woman and calculating just how much they should charge her for that four minutes. Will there be a increase in charge if only one of this scintillating couple is present on any journey?

I am beyond gobsmacked, really.

I wouldn't care about the petrol, I might about the time if it's 10 minutes a week, then that's 40 extra minutes a month etc etc. It probably wouldn't bother me, but it would be nice if the friend gave her some flowers or something just to say thank you. I agree asking for petrol money would probably make OP look silly, but then I guess that would add up too. If I was OP I don't think I'd care if the friend was thankful, if she expects it, then yes it would annoy me. Both of my parents are doormats so it probably touches a nerve for me!

PurpleButterflyWings · 13/02/2023 00:24

There are 2 types of people on this thread...

The people who have spent half their life being used, and mugged off, by entitled people who think 'well you're going that way anyway, how DARE you not give me a lift!' etc.

And then there are the ones who are the entitled ones, who DO the mugging off, and use people, and who can't fathom why people paying a fortune to run, maintain, and tax and insure a car should not be their free taxi service! 😂

You couldn't make it up. 😁😂

alanabennett · 13/02/2023 00:05

Trez1510 · 13/02/2023 00:00

I had to read the post twice to make sure I understood the poster intends to ask the passenger for the cost of running the car for four minutes per week.

This is despite the passenger being grateful, asking if it is convenient and giving a gift at Christmas.

I can just imagine the OP and her husband bitching about this poor woman and calculating just how much they should charge her for that four minutes. Will there be a increase in charge if only one of this scintillating couple is present on any journey?

I am beyond gobsmacked, really.

I couldn't agree more. Some people here wouldn't give you the steam off their pee.

SandyY2K · 13/02/2023 00:03

The entitlement and expectation would annoy me tbh.

Trez1510 · 13/02/2023 00:00

alanabennett · 12/02/2023 23:27

Jesus wept. Only on MN do people ask for a contribution "to the cost of running the car" for a regular lift of a couple of minutes.

This place is positively overflowing with the milk of human kindness 🙄☹️

I had to read the post twice to make sure I understood the poster intends to ask the passenger for the cost of running the car for four minutes per week.

This is despite the passenger being grateful, asking if it is convenient and giving a gift at Christmas.

I can just imagine the OP and her husband bitching about this poor woman and calculating just how much they should charge her for that four minutes. Will there be a increase in charge if only one of this scintillating couple is present on any journey?

I am beyond gobsmacked, really.

Mothership4two · 12/02/2023 23:53

MinceandMash · 12/02/2023 21:30

To answer some questions no she’s never offered me petrol money, but to be honest that’s not the problem really it’s the expectation that I’ll always do it. Last week she even followed me out to the car park and to my car. Sometimes I’d like to be able to pop to the shops or get petrol on the way home.

Then tell her you won't be able to give her a lift next time or whenever OP. You don't have to give any reason but a bit of fair warning would be considerate of you.

I think it would be mean to stop giving lifts altogether

FiddleLeaf · 12/02/2023 23:34

I think it’s kind to ask permission and offer petrol money 🤷🏻‍♀️

alanabennett · 12/02/2023 23:27

PuzzledObserver · 12/02/2023 19:51

DH and I were asked in mid-October if we could give a lift to someone from our choir as she had been told not to drive for medical reasons and was waiting for an appointment which should clear her drive again. Was only supposed to be a couple of weeks, so of course we said yes.

And the appointment was cancelled…..

I will say that she has always been grateful, asks if we are going next week etc, and gave us a gift at Christmas. If we’re not there, she has to leave practice early in order to get a train/bus home.

It is 15-20 minutes from choir to our house. And a further couple of minutes beyond to her house.

We have continued with this on the assumption it is temporary. But if it turns out to be permanent - if she doesn’t get her licence back - then I will have a word about her making a contribution towards the cost of running the car. I know we would be going anyway - but we are driving further to take her home, and she is saving the cost of running her own car!

Jesus wept. Only on MN do people ask for a contribution "to the cost of running the car" for a regular lift of a couple of minutes.

This place is positively overflowing with the milk of human kindness 🙄☹️

FrenchBoule · 12/02/2023 23:24

@Evasmissingletter socioeconomic disadvantage is not an excuse for lack of manners.
If you’re a lift taker don’t be late and always say “thank you”. Offering fuel money should also be considered as somebody saves the lift taker time and bother.

OP just tell her your arrangement isn’t working for you anymore and you’re stopping the lifts. You don’t have to explain yourself to anybody or apologise.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 12/02/2023 23:10

Just start making excuses-oh I’m going to my friends/shopping/the gym etc etc.

Thatboymum · 12/02/2023 23:05

a work colleague done this to me it was meant to be a one off as she missed the bus and we work 25 mins away from our town, then it ended up being every single shit where she then had our manager change her shifts to match mine, bearing in mind she lived about 10 min drive across a by pass away from me so not close or convenient, I tried the whole i need to go to shops after work she came and done a full weeks food shop, tried to actually be late for work she didn’t care, stopped off at childcare and grandparents she didn’t care , in the end I told my manager who I got on well with and he changed her shifts so I never had to do it again. So from experience just say that it’s not working for you because I should have done that myself

wurlycurly · 12/02/2023 23:03

I haven't read all the answers but I would say, be generous. You say it's not about the money. And it's not really about the time. Unless the woman you give a lift to is ungrateful, I'd give her a lift. Think of yourself as being a great and generously spirited person, rather than someone who is being 'taken advantage of'. You are being kind.

Beaglesonlyplease · 12/02/2023 23:00

Did she start by asking or did you offer?
If someone offered once and then again and again I’d probably think they weee going to do it from then on but I wouldn’t expect it.
If she asked it’s different and then you can just say it without explanation.
But if I got a message from someone who had offered me a lift, on several occasions and then sent a message saying they couldn’t give me a lift, I’d assume I’d done something wrong and be extremely embarrassed.

NewNovember · 12/02/2023 22:50

PuzzledObserver · 12/02/2023 19:51

DH and I were asked in mid-October if we could give a lift to someone from our choir as she had been told not to drive for medical reasons and was waiting for an appointment which should clear her drive again. Was only supposed to be a couple of weeks, so of course we said yes.

And the appointment was cancelled…..

I will say that she has always been grateful, asks if we are going next week etc, and gave us a gift at Christmas. If we’re not there, she has to leave practice early in order to get a train/bus home.

It is 15-20 minutes from choir to our house. And a further couple of minutes beyond to her house.

We have continued with this on the assumption it is temporary. But if it turns out to be permanent - if she doesn’t get her licence back - then I will have a word about her making a contribution towards the cost of running the car. I know we would be going anyway - but we are driving further to take her home, and she is saving the cost of running her own car!

You would ask for a contribution for a four minute round trip?

Keroppi · 12/02/2023 22:49

Just say "Hi soandso, just a quick msg that dropping you home from hobby won't be convenient for me going forward from March/whenever. Looking forward to seeing you next week as usual!"

Then she has a set date to prepare for and you can always say some white lie about elderly relative/care/going to the gym or another group not long after that one ends.

TheDogthatDug · 12/02/2023 22:49

You've got that elderly relative who needs help after your hobby group haven't you?

Evasmissingletter · 12/02/2023 22:46

Not learning to drive or not owning a car is often a sign of socioeconomic disadvantage. With the reduction of cheap and regular public transport it’s difficult and costly for many to get to work often resulting in limited job choices and so the circle of disadvantage continues. This same limiting factor also affects the ability for people to socialise, play sports or enjoy hobbies.
I’m not saying this is your case OP or in fact other posters who have talked about CF people.
By all means call them out. But thought it was worth considering…. Not everyone has access to a safe, comfy, warm car for travel options.

Mum97540 · 12/02/2023 22:45

But op has not said she didn't say thank you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread