Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Accent slip - real or fake? (Not too serious)

107 replies

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 18:12

M dp has a friend who visits sometimes after moving away some months ago to live in the region where they spent the first few years of their childhood.

I noticed that when they arrived to visit, we had a full conversation together and they spoke the same as they ever did, before the move.

Then a couple of hours later we were out in a restaurant and when speaking to the staff, the friend's accent changed entirely, taking on a different lilt and pronouncing words completely differently. The new accent didn't match that of the people running the restaurant either, who were from a different region to all of us.

After the meal, and for the rest of the visit, speaking to others etc the new accent didn't reappear again once.

We didn't say anything in the restaurant to the friend, but I mentioned it to dp afterwards. I thought the accent change seemed odd, especially as it didn't last long and never reappeared that weekend. Dp agreed they'd not heard that accent before from them, but suggested it could be something that happens naturally to people sometimes. I'm curious about it, and wondered what caused it and if it would be terribly rude to point it out if it happens again. I felt weird that neither of us mentioned it at the time, it was such a change.

I'm aware of code switching which makes sense to me and I find myself doing it sometimes myself, but it's not really a conscious thing and not a change to an entirely different regional accent.

This was more like switching from their regular Leeds accent to a Somerset one and then back to Leeds for the rest of the time.

What do you think caused it?

YABU, it's perfectly normal in these circumstances
YANBU, it's odd

OP posts:
Blessedbethefruitz · 12/02/2023 21:36

I thought I was going nuts, I had no idea there was a term for this. At work events or on the phone for work I have a tv American accent. I'm not a weirdo!!

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 21:29

ElliF · 12/02/2023 21:16

It’s a natural empathic response. People alter their speech patterns, rhythms, tone and attenuation, vocabulary, and accents depending on who they are speaking to and the situation they are in.

People who travelled well when they were young, or who were exposed to a wider variety of accents and cultures develop a greater flexibility in their voice than those who remain exposed to a single sociopath-economic class and a single geographical area.

So if child A grows up with parents for example who are in the military, they travel the world and are exposed to many children of different cultures and or nationalities, they will likely have a greater ability to be flexible in their vocalisations when they are adults.

Whilst Child B who grows up on a housing estate in the Birmingham and who is predominantly socialised with children from the estate who also have parents in similar work, similar backgrounds and the same local accent, and who for whatever reason do not mix cross culturally, or holiday away from the same caravan parks. They tend to be more restricted in what they have learned and have a more limited vocal library from which to draw upon.

So it’s an empathic response, similar to a mother softening her voice when talking to a child and conveying calm and joy. Or indeed hardening the consonants and shortening the vowels, raising the voice and lowering the pitch to exert control and authority.

...

Luckily for many of us, we live in a far more culturally diverse world than we did even 20 years ago. So when someone who hasn’t been aware of this comes across it, and to them it sounds contrived or fake, that’s an age and exposure thing. Our children we’ll see it as normal.

I'm not sure it's that in this case. They've lived in two places in the UK their whole life, almost all of it in the place where their usual accent is the norm, whereas I've lived in different countries on various continents and in big cities and I don't do what you describing. And they've never spoken to us in that accent before in all the years we've known them. So I don't see who they'd be changing their voice to empathetically respond to in this case? The vocabulary wasn't different, just the accent was very pronounced.

OP posts:
BettyBoopy · 12/02/2023 21:27

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/02/2023 18:19

Speaking as someone who develops a dreadful South African accent when I'm speaking to Australian/NZ people, and an appalling Scottish accent when I speak to people from Manchester, I'm going to say it is perfectly normal. Blush.

😂

TakeNoTweetsGiveNoQuacks · 12/02/2023 21:23

I've definitely had to change the odd word to make myself understood. My accent is originally soft Belfast, but I haven't said the word 'owl' in my real accent in quite some time! It just is not understood in SE England, even by well travelled people who generally can adjust their ear to understand my accent. "What? Oil? Aisle?" - it simply doesn't compute 😂. Anyone from NI who has lived abroad or over the water may have experienced the same. Everyone gets how, now, brown, cow, but owl absolutely flumoxes them

Abba123 · 12/02/2023 21:19

I’ve lived in a few different areas and my accent changes according in an attempt to be understood. Sometimes subconscious but sometimes deliberate.

It’s just communication.

Fake vs not fake? Grow up.

ElliF · 12/02/2023 21:16

It’s a natural empathic response. People alter their speech patterns, rhythms, tone and attenuation, vocabulary, and accents depending on who they are speaking to and the situation they are in.

People who travelled well when they were young, or who were exposed to a wider variety of accents and cultures develop a greater flexibility in their voice than those who remain exposed to a single sociopath-economic class and a single geographical area.

So if child A grows up with parents for example who are in the military, they travel the world and are exposed to many children of different cultures and or nationalities, they will likely have a greater ability to be flexible in their vocalisations when they are adults.

Whilst Child B who grows up on a housing estate in the Birmingham and who is predominantly socialised with children from the estate who also have parents in similar work, similar backgrounds and the same local accent, and who for whatever reason do not mix cross culturally, or holiday away from the same caravan parks. They tend to be more restricted in what they have learned and have a more limited vocal library from which to draw upon.

So it’s an empathic response, similar to a mother softening her voice when talking to a child and conveying calm and joy. Or indeed hardening the consonants and shortening the vowels, raising the voice and lowering the pitch to exert control and authority.

...

Luckily for many of us, we live in a far more culturally diverse world than we did even 20 years ago. So when someone who hasn’t been aware of this comes across it, and to them it sounds contrived or fake, that’s an age and exposure thing. Our children we’ll see it as normal.

JudgeJ · 12/02/2023 21:14

IsItBedtimeYetNope · 12/02/2023 18:26

I inadvertently slip into a deep Brummie accent whenever I speak to anyone from the North. I have no idea how or why. It's really embarrassing. I'm just glad no one has ever mentioned it because I don't know how to not do it.

Where's 'The North', are you talking about Birmingham and up?? When I'm in the North East, Newcastle area, I tend to pick up a slight accent from there subconsciously, I think it's a lovely accent.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 12/02/2023 21:13

My partner has always lived within5 miles of where we live now but he speaks differently to everyone he talks to 🤣
Honestly if we got into an Albanian shop he becomes Albanian 🤣if we get a taxi he becomes Indian 🤣.
I fancy a trip to Scotland but I couldn't bear to listen to him with the locals so that's off the cards 🤣😂🤣

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/02/2023 21:13

This is pretty normal. I grew up in a medium sized town where there’s a bit of an ooh-ar tone to the accent.

I’ve lived in London for decades and normally speak a standard RP/Estuary hybrid but when I go back to my hometown the bumpkin comes out.

dudsville · 12/02/2023 21:09

I also sometimes go posh when I'm tired.

LewisCapaldisCamelToe · 12/02/2023 21:09

This thread could almost be about me out in Leeds last night with my friend and her friends. I'm autistic, I often chameleon my accent and manner of speech without realising it - depends on where I am, who I'm with. I often parrot back at people the way they sound to me. It can be quite embarrassing.

Sometimes it happens because of things or memories I'm thinking of in my head, so it can be entirely random from the outside.

When I'm happy and excited or drunk, I often end up with a particular British regional accent; when I lived where that accent came from I spoke the language also.

So since being away from that area, and picking up the posh accent for where I currently live, I switch between the posh southern accent, the accent I had for a decade and a half when I was daily speaking a whole other language, and whatever accent and dialect the people around me have.

I'd be mortified if anyone thought I was a fake. I'm a harmless sod with a lot of autism-related quirks and this is just how I am.

dudsville · 12/02/2023 21:08

I had a colleague years ago with an accent that i seemed unable to stop myself mirroring. He called me on it. I pretended it hadn't happened. Argh, the cringe.

hopeishere · 12/02/2023 21:06

My friend from Ireland has lived in America for 20+ years when she comes home her accent is mostly "home" but occasionally will become pure American!

IheartBTS · 12/02/2023 21:05

IsItBedtimeYetNope · 12/02/2023 18:26

I inadvertently slip into a deep Brummie accent whenever I speak to anyone from the North. I have no idea how or why. It's really embarrassing. I'm just glad no one has ever mentioned it because I don't know how to not do it.

I’m exactly the same 😳! It’s so embarrassing, so I have to say at little as possible in that situation, and work really hard on sticking to my normal accent.

Wagt · 12/02/2023 21:00

Yeah I do that sometimes. My parents have two very different accents and brought be up somewhere with a third accent. If I talked to grandparents growing up I did so in their accent. If I meet someone with a different accent sometimes my tongue feels muddled and I eg find myself being Irish at an Australian.

It’s a bit like a really crap version of being trilingual

Onnabugeisha · 12/02/2023 20:57

Silverboot · 12/02/2023 18:46

Not really on topic but I was once in love with a Dubliner who moved to Canada then New York State as a teenager. My god his accent 😍

You’ve reminded me of a Welsh boy I met at a castle concert with my parents. 🥰😍

WiddlinDiddlin · 12/02/2023 20:56

I switch accents a lot though it is usually related to the accents of the people I am talking with, sometimes it goes very off, if I am aware and worried they'll think I am mocking them.

Weirdly, I can't 'do' accents on purpose like a party trick though my sister can, she's really REALLY good and can switch between Brummie, Northern Irish, Welsh, various flavours of scottish, Scouse, Manchester pretty much on demand.

Stick me in a room with someone with a strong accent though and in minutes I sound close to native, and people have asked if I am taking the piss in the past so I am wary of it with new people.

U1sce · 12/02/2023 20:54

Having lived in a few different countries, I find different phrases somehow suit different accents and automatically come out in that accent when I speak.

Euchariahere · 12/02/2023 20:48

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 20:03

Interesting stuff. It says it's generally about fitting in with the people you're speaking to, which is also how I've always understood code switching to work.

What threw me off in this case was that there was no fitting in, it was actually the opposite - the friend's accent changed from being the same as mine and dp, to being different to everyone in the room, including the wait staff. That's what made it stand out. Perhaps it's another linguistic phenomenon I've not heard of.

Lol, or perhaps not 😆

Frlrlrubert · 12/02/2023 20:46

Did the wait staff have an accent? Other people's accents bring out mine. I'm Northern and live in the midlands. If I'm taking to people who have a neutral accent mine is fairly neutral too, but if I'm speaking to a Brummie my Yorkshire comes out.

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 20:03

PAFMO · 12/02/2023 19:49

It's a known linguistic phenomenon and you might want to educate yourself.

www.unitedlanguagegroup.com/blog/linguistic-code-switching

Joining in with the non- GF and sensible conversation, I'm currently having to battle not to speak like Siobhan Finneran every time I open my mouth.

Interesting stuff. It says it's generally about fitting in with the people you're speaking to, which is also how I've always understood code switching to work.

What threw me off in this case was that there was no fitting in, it was actually the opposite - the friend's accent changed from being the same as mine and dp, to being different to everyone in the room, including the wait staff. That's what made it stand out. Perhaps it's another linguistic phenomenon I've not heard of.

OP posts:
PAFMO · 12/02/2023 19:49

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/02/2023 19:38

I therefore would have been awkward or perhaps even rude to mention it...

Yes, you handled it right OP. It's practically a disability so you drawing attention to it would be like saying "So Bob, I notice you are shouting"Fucking Fucker" a lot this evening" to someone who has Tourettes.

It's a known linguistic phenomenon and you might want to educate yourself.

www.unitedlanguagegroup.com/blog/linguistic-code-switching

Joining in with the non- GF and sensible conversation, I'm currently having to battle not to speak like Siobhan Finneran every time I open my mouth.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 12/02/2023 19:48

I work for a very international company with head quarters in the UK so daily speak to people with all sorts of accents. A good number of people do slip into other accents. It seems most common when they have lived elsewhere then speak to someone from 'home' and its impossible to not slip back to their old accent. However it does occur with other accents that have never been their own too. I have a neutral accent at work to make sure I'm understood but if I'm speaking to a geordie I'm straight back matching them as that's my home accent. I occasionally do a Yorkshire or Scottish accent to although I have no reason to.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/02/2023 19:43

You surely do not mean that, do you?!

Well, perhaps just a mild social disability, like a lack of humour for example. Not within the control of the individual.

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 19:42

Autumnnewname · 12/02/2023 19:30

OP why would you say something to the friend?

What would you have said?

This is what I posted to find out!

I think I could've said something like 'oh your accent changed just now' but I don't know if that would be insensitive or not. Or just very, very awkward! We just wanted to catch up.

But it was very sudden and noticeable so maybe they would be aware of it and not offended or anything. Idk.

OP posts: