Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Accent slip - real or fake? (Not too serious)

107 replies

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 18:12

M dp has a friend who visits sometimes after moving away some months ago to live in the region where they spent the first few years of their childhood.

I noticed that when they arrived to visit, we had a full conversation together and they spoke the same as they ever did, before the move.

Then a couple of hours later we were out in a restaurant and when speaking to the staff, the friend's accent changed entirely, taking on a different lilt and pronouncing words completely differently. The new accent didn't match that of the people running the restaurant either, who were from a different region to all of us.

After the meal, and for the rest of the visit, speaking to others etc the new accent didn't reappear again once.

We didn't say anything in the restaurant to the friend, but I mentioned it to dp afterwards. I thought the accent change seemed odd, especially as it didn't last long and never reappeared that weekend. Dp agreed they'd not heard that accent before from them, but suggested it could be something that happens naturally to people sometimes. I'm curious about it, and wondered what caused it and if it would be terribly rude to point it out if it happens again. I felt weird that neither of us mentioned it at the time, it was such a change.

I'm aware of code switching which makes sense to me and I find myself doing it sometimes myself, but it's not really a conscious thing and not a change to an entirely different regional accent.

This was more like switching from their regular Leeds accent to a Somerset one and then back to Leeds for the rest of the time.

What do you think caused it?

YABU, it's perfectly normal in these circumstances
YANBU, it's odd

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sashh · 13/02/2023 03:59

My accent can cross three counties in one sentence.

Then sometimes I open my mouth and I think, "I don't talk like that" as my mouth does talk like that.

I'd been at my dad's a while ago and I was packing the car, one of my dad's neighbours came out to chat and a thick Lancashire accent came out, matching the neighbours.

I wouldn't describe what the OP refers to as code switching, that's where two or more people swap languages or language varieties when talking to each other.

So for example a couple of cousins who are born and bread in England and usually speak to each other in English, but Granny is from a country with another language and they both speak to gran in her own language might say something like, "I love when Granny cooks ...." and what the food is is said in Granny's language.

"I love when granny makes papas bravas"

"I love when granny makes golabki"

"I love when granny makes murgh makhani"

The same speaker would use English words to say the same thing to someone who did not share the same language.

LadyJ2023 · 13/02/2023 03:06

I've lived in many parts of the uk and I do it to apparently wen South my accent changes when I'm back home north the same. I never realised till hubby pointed it out lol

RicherThanYews · 13/02/2023 01:39

I've never heard of code switching so I'll have to Google that! I think it's probably normal for many people. I have 2 accents despite living in one place my whole 34 years and my accent on any given day will depend on factors such as mood and energy level. I'm Welsh 20% of the time but the rest is a weird non specific English/Canadian blend 😬 I didn't know that I did it until people told me. It doesn't seem to change depending on who I'm speaking to though, so weird.

HollaHolla · 13/02/2023 01:35

Meh. I get very posh when I’m drinking. Maybe it’s because I find it tricky to pronounce things when my mouth is feeling sloppy?! 🤣
I lived overseas for a few years, and I went to Uni at the other end of the country for 2 years. I flattened out my definitely Scottish accent, but I am not broad spoken originally.

I once confused a linguist anthropology specialist, who thought I might have lived in Canada or New Zealand, and brought up with an Irish accent in the house. (She used to guess people’s origin through accent, as a party trick! 🤣) None of those were correct.

I suspect you’d also find my switching around a bit confusing/annoying. 🤷🏻‍♀️

pigpinkstockings · 13/02/2023 01:27

I confuse myself with my accents. My husband has a strong accent which he has retained since living in uk for 25 years, however I pick up his accent. My voice definitely changes depending on who I'm talking to, how tired I am and if I've had a drink. I think it started as my mother made us speak really 'properly' but that didn't go down well at my rough school so I would switch accents depending on where I was. Potty mouth at school, never allowed to swear at home.

Belladonna208 · 13/02/2023 01:24

@Idkrealorfake I was making a sweeping generalisation rather than referring to your specific situation. :) We have a family friend who grew up in the north (east) but moved to London when he was quite young and now moves between Geordie, Cockney and RP, typically - I'll have to listen out to see if it's situation-dependent.

AnitaPNesse · 13/02/2023 00:44

I'm from the North and have lived in Singapore, Australia, LA and Hong Kong where, overtime, I lost my old UK accent and returned home with an accent that was quite annoying I think. Relatives who I hadn't spoken to in years, like cousins, thought I sounded American, but looking back it was just the result of hanging around an international group of people and somehow letting my accent change. Similarly when I left Australia and moved to Singapore, the expat Aussies there thought I was one of them. I've also noticed that I'm the type of person whose accent changes depending with whom I'm speaking and I can have a bit of a phone voice. All annoying, I know, just fessin' up.

I could well imagine myself being this person you describe in that restaurant: not aware that my accent had changed slightly when ordering food. I can't quite put my finger on it, but speaking to certain people triggers my international transatlantic accent. I've been home for years now so it happens much less.

You should mention it to your 'friend' - why not? Say you watched Split with James McAvoy and all of the different voices intrigued you, haha!

CombatBarbie · 13/02/2023 00:43

My daughters are typical military kids with no accent and we now live in Scotland (where I'm from). My youngest interchanges her accent constantly.... At school she's completely Scottish, at home she's non accent but when her friends come round she speaks to me normally and then her friends in a Scottish accent..... Even when we're in the same room.

My eldest used to do it, now she's just embraced it.

Idkrealorfake · 13/02/2023 00:29

Belladonna208 · 12/02/2023 23:58

Ah just seen you wouldn't describe it as code switching.... I guess it's a kind of verbal mirroring maybe then? And an attempt to communicate with the people you're with, whether it's conscious or not.

Mirroring who? None of us have that accent. Dp and I usually have the same accent as this friend.

OP posts:
Belladonna208 · 12/02/2023 23:58

Ah just seen you wouldn't describe it as code switching.... I guess it's a kind of verbal mirroring maybe then? And an attempt to communicate with the people you're with, whether it's conscious or not.

JenniferBarkley · 12/02/2023 23:55

This would totally happen to me - I always mirrored accents, sounded American the second I got off the plane etc. I moved for my first graduate job and so my "formal" voice sounds much more like that area than the rest of my speech. Ordering in a restaurant is definitely the kind of place that would come out - speaking to strangers, trying to speak loudly and clearly so they could hear me. And then it would be back to normal when speaking to my friends.

Belladonna208 · 12/02/2023 23:54

There's a term for it, which is code switching. I'm originally from a part of the country with quite a distinctive regional accent though never had a particularly strong accent myself. I've moved round a lot though, mainly for work, and have found myself often adapting the cadence and some aspects of accent of where I've moved to. The theory is that it makes listeners more receptive to what you're saying...

Thinking of it, the fact I am beyond determined to not pick up the accent of the area I'm currently trapped in may be a factor in why it's taking me so long to settle. I've gone very RP instead as I absolutely don't want to end up sounding like I'm from round here....!!

Oh, and my original accent does get a bit stronger when I've been visiting family, though never particularly strong. It's all in the flattening of the vowels...

QuizzlyBears · 12/02/2023 23:45

I am married to an American and can confirm we both cringe on the occasions a person we are talking to slips into an American accent. Intentional or not, it’s embarrassing and vaguely irritating tbh.

stargirl1701 · 12/02/2023 23:39

I 'copy' accents. It's not a conscious thing. I think it comes from living in a few different countries growing up. It helped me fit in if I could 'sound normal'.

ChopSuey2 · 12/02/2023 23:31

I can totally believe it wasn't intentional. I've got a mixed up mess of an accent. Part Yorkshire, bits of everywhere in London, occasionally slightly posh London. It switches depending on who I talk to (including being more London when talking to my Northern father) but there is no logic. Sometimes it switches based on mood and whether I've had a drink!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/02/2023 23:19

Couple of wines in and DP begins to sound like he never came off the moor.

Leave me down there for a fortnight and I take weeks to sound more like myself again - and I'll drop back into it whenever I'm talking about the place or somebody else is.

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 23:10

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/02/2023 22:02

I think it's weird and while there's seemingly loads of people that do it (according to this thread) I've literally never met a person in real life who does this.

Have had friends in the past who put on an accent for whatever reason. Normally just for fun when chatting people up.

Note: I'm not talking about code switching, or those who flatten their accents in time from moving away from the area they grew up in.

Yeah I've not encountered this particular kind of switch before either. Lots of posters are saying they do the same thing as the friend though, and then describing something quite different that they do.

OP posts:
Nothingbuttheglory · 12/02/2023 22:11

I do this. Sometimes I realise it and sometimes I don't. It's generally involuntary.

I was born in one place with a very distinctive accent and moved to another place-with-a-distinctive accent when I was about 4. My parents have fairly neutral accents.

I sound fucking weird at the best of times, tbh. Well, that's what I've been told. No one has ever successfully placed me. (I'm 40)

I once read an article that mentioned Leonardo DiCaprio's accent in Gangs of New York. Apparently this was derided as being 'all over', but it was done deliberately as his character had grown up in two different places and it's normal for people's accents to wander a bit as a result.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/02/2023 22:02

I think it's weird and while there's seemingly loads of people that do it (according to this thread) I've literally never met a person in real life who does this.

Have had friends in the past who put on an accent for whatever reason. Normally just for fun when chatting people up.

Note: I'm not talking about code switching, or those who flatten their accents in time from moving away from the area they grew up in.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 12/02/2023 21:48

It's a known linguistic phenomenon and you might want to educate yourself.

www.unitedlanguagegroup.com/blog/linguistic-code-switching

Joining in with the non- GF and sensible conversation, I'm currently having to battle not to speak like Siobhan Finneran every time I open my mouth.

I'm unclear what I am being chastised for, but thank you for the link.

LiftyLift · 12/02/2023 21:47

I grew up in Scotland but moved to the South East as a teenager. I dropped my broad accent and adopted a much softer one, but when I visit Scotland I pick the accent up again, yet the Scots think I sound English.

I absolutely chameleon with who I speak to and imitate their accents. I don’t realise I do it most of the time. I go between broad Scots, posh Scots, a bit English RP, South African and American.

I speak to my Mum frequently and notice that despite living in Scotland she has picked up my new accent from speaking to me.

JaninaDuszejko · 12/02/2023 21:46

I code switch when I speak to my family. My kids think it's hilarious because I don't realise I'm doing it. I also do it when I talk to anyone Scottish but it's amore gradual change, one of my colleagues was very confused when she heard me have a conversation with another Scot at work.

I also have issues with my vowels, when I first moved to England I lived down south but now I live in northern England. My natural Scottish 'a' is between the long southern 'a' and short northern 'a' in length. So how I say e.g. 'castle' to an English person never feels natural to me.

JassyRadlett · 12/02/2023 21:44

I'm an Australian who's lived in the UK for nearly 20 years, with periods elsewhere as well. I've been an accent sponge since childhood - including unconscious code switching within different Australian accents - and I've had to learn to consciously not mirror the accents of the people I spend significant amounts of time with. When I'm relaxed, it just happens. Most people who meet me have no idea I'm Australian.

The people who do this - are you musical? Good at learning languages? I'm quite musical and have a good ear for accents when learning other languages and I've always wondered if this plays into my accent mirroring.

thatheavyperson · 12/02/2023 21:41

Due to the area I live having a very mixed-up regional accent and the different accents of my mother and father, I have four accents that I slip in an out of, usually depending on which family members I've recently spoken to 😬 I hate it as I suspect people think I'm putting accents on to seem a certain way

Idkrealorfake · 12/02/2023 21:38

Abba123 · 12/02/2023 21:19

I’ve lived in a few different areas and my accent changes according in an attempt to be understood. Sometimes subconscious but sometimes deliberate.

It’s just communication.

Fake vs not fake? Grow up.

Sorry if this touched a nerve for you. I did say in the title that is not a very serious matter, I'm just curious.

The odd part for me that doesn't fit with your explanation was that they used the accent with me and my DP and we usually all have the same one, and so if anything, the accent change could make it harder to understand them, not easier.

OP posts: