Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Life is too expensive and not enjoyable.

391 replies

buildingourdreams · 12/02/2023 15:49

I am only 26 years old and I am tired

H and I both earn okay money both work ft and I sometimes do part time work too

We've 2 boys under 7 and After rent bills and food and petrol we have not a penny .
This is with our parents helping with childcare we don't even have to pay childcare for the boys thankfully 🙏

We Can't go on holiday. Can't even have a takeaway or my nails done

We rent and Can't save for a house to buy don't get any benefits other than the basic Cb about £200 month. (And I don't expect or want handouts anyway)

Is this our life now ? Don't tell me to get a better job as I might do as I get older but this is not the point I'm making . If someone works full time they should be able to afford a few treats in life and specially with 2 incomes!

I worry constantly that we are failing our kids and should I even have had them? And also Like, what will even become of people like us when we're old ?

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 11:26

For a Government who apparently believe in market forces they appear to have an astonishingly low level of comprehension of how markets function.

They do, don't they? I'm no fan of the free market lunatic fringe, but you do at least know where you are with them.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:26

The fact that Hunt had to "launch an enquiry" to try to find out why people aren't working more, when he is the one in charge of the disfunctional tax system creating the problem, is absolutely mind boggling.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:20

This is also why it's utterly laughable when these politicians stand up in Parliament droppjng words like "growth" into their speeches when they appear to have zero comprehension of where growth comes from, evidenced by the fact they are doing nothing to create an environment where it can happen. And all of them, on both sides of the house, are too gutless to mention the elephant that is now so huge that it's taking up half of the Chamber of Commons: that they must rejoin the single market and customs union immediately if they want any improvement in living standards for British people.

Instead, they bicker about how they can snip yet more off budgets for services, and whom they can not-so-stealthily pickpocket next to plug the gaps. Eventually the bucket has so many holes it cannot hold any water at all. No comprehension of the difference between costs for services and investing to actually increase tax revenue in the longer term. Because they do not care about the longer term, it's all about today's optics and the election in 2024. Absurd suggestions on convincing retirees that there they should return to work, rather than making it worthwhile for the working age population to work more. For examples of how this is impacting people at every level of earnings being less productive than they could, see this article:

www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/13/full-time-part-time-work-no-longer-pays-uk-economy

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:09

ElliF · 14/02/2023 10:03

Thanks for expanding on that.

But as I see it the money still has to be put in place first.
Productivity is a result of investment, and that investment can only come from three sources - The people in the country. Outside Investors. Or printing Government Bonds and selling into the market.

In a collapsing world economy, with all major corporations culling their overheads, I don’t see outside investors stepping in regardless of any tax breaks the country is willing to offer.

So you're left with taxing the people and the employers that are already in the UK, or money printings, and I can’t see how either of those two can work given the debasement of the currency we have seen over the past 15 years.

The mistake was not letting the banks fail in 2008. We covered up the mess and swept it under the carpet, and proceeded to kicked the can down the road for 15 years. We broke the cardinal law that interest gets paid for money borrowed by setting interest rates to zero. At a governmental level we set the value of money at next to nothing and held it there for a decade. I don’t see how you can get out of that. That was the death of money right there.

Where do you see the money coming from for all the investment?

Until very recently there was a prolonged period where the Government could borrow at 0% or even negative interest rates. It is absolute economic insanity for them to have not done so and implemented an enormous investment program, in a country that had zero productivity growth, skills gaps and failing infrastructure. Instead, they implemented an austerity program which made these problems worse.

Investments have a return. So yes they involve outlay, but well-planned investment with a proper industrial strategy leads to higher returns: increased growth and productivity, and more tax for the treasury. A proper industrial strategy of this nature then encourages business investment. And yes, there is significant business capital around the world that can be obtained, if you create an investable environment in this way. If, on the other hand, you let your infrastructure fall apart, create huge skills gaps, have no industrial policy to grow key sectors, and then erect huge and expensive barriers to trade, clearly you are not creating an investable proposition. This is why an increasing proportion of the UK economy consists of low skilled, low paid, low margin work.

It isn't rocket science. And it is the reason that other countries even despite interest rates now being higher and Government debts already high due to Covid, are creating large scale investment funds anyway. It is a necessity to remain competitive. Provided you have competent people who understand business and economics in charge of the program (i.e. none of our current MPs) it is still possible to implement such a program successfully - you simply have to ensure that there is a proper cohesive and integrated strategy, not the piecemeal throwing around of funds at random projects like with the "levelling up funds", to ensure that the ROIs exceed the interest rates, in real terms. This requires competent people making the decisions with a long-term view. And to rejoin the single market and customs union, of course.

If we do not raise business investment and productivity then not only will productivity (and therefore salaries and living standards) continue to fall, the value of GBP will also fall further which is very bad news for anybody struggling with living costs because that also makes imports more expensive and we import large proportions of essentails such as energy and food.

This is all basic economics.

To make this work as I said you also need people to have an incentive to work, therefore the bottlenecks caused by universal credit thresholds, CB thresholds, tax free childcare threshold, higher rate tax threshold, and the threshold for removal of the personal allowance all need addressing also because currently these are hugely impeding productivity and growth.

For a Government who apparently believe in market forces they appear to have an astonishingly low level of comprehension of how markets function.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 10:03

Thanks for expanding on that.

But as I see it the money still has to be put in place first.
Productivity is a result of investment, and that investment can only come from three sources - The people in the country. Outside Investors. Or printing Government Bonds and selling into the market.

In a collapsing world economy, with all major corporations culling their overheads, I don’t see outside investors stepping in regardless of any tax breaks the country is willing to offer.

So you're left with taxing the people and the employers that are already in the UK, or money printings, and I can’t see how either of those two can work given the debasement of the currency we have seen over the past 15 years.

The mistake was not letting the banks fail in 2008. We covered up the mess and swept it under the carpet, and proceeded to kicked the can down the road for 15 years. We broke the cardinal law that interest gets paid for money borrowed by setting interest rates to zero. At a governmental level we set the value of money at next to nothing and held it there for a decade. I don’t see how you can get out of that. That was the death of money right there.

Where do you see the money coming from for all the investment?

Debred78 · 14/02/2023 10:00

buildingourdreams · 12/02/2023 19:07

Because our rent is £1000 a month (and my house is a crap hole)

Because my winter fuel bills have been £500 a month since late November / December because my house is poorly insulated and damp.

Because I spend £100 a week on petrol to get to work and get the boys to school / collect them from their childcare

And that's before food, council tax, internet, car maintenance, car tax, our car insurance,
Kids clothes shoes school stuff etc

Two full time wages should cover all of those things with spare tbh.
Is it worth looking at moving somewhere more expensive and saving on energy bills? Or do you have the heating on a lot and unlikely to save any? I know that isn’t always straightforward.
If property is damp then reporting and getting that sorted could help.
Are there any savings you can make in your expenditure? Can you renegotiate anything? Internet etc?
Are you reducing your food shopping as much as you can?
Without exact figures it is hard to see but allowing £1000 (which seems plenty) for the extras you mentioned, you are spending £2600 a month and your income must be considerably more than that.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 09:42

So, where does the money come from to increase salaries across the board?

I had literally just explained that in the post you replied to: productivity growth. The UK has had zero productivity growth for 15 years. The only way to sustainably raise everyone's salaries and standard of living is from productivity growth. This is why people in the UK have got slowly poorer compared to our international counterparts.

The two main reasons for the lack of productivity growth as I said are:

  1. A huge lack of business investment. This was poor anyway due to bad economic management, for example there being no long-term industrial strategy, no energy security strategy, poor national investment in skills and infrastructure, etc. Then, it absolutely fell off a cliff after 2016, unsurprisingly. If you cut yourself off from your main trading market and erect expensive and completely unnecessary barriers to trade, of course business investment will vanish. Entirely predictable and indeed was predicted. Why would a company invest in the UK with access to only 60 million consumers when it can set up in France or Germany and have access to 300 million? On top of this the US and EU - recognising the need to compete with China et al, are currently implementing huge state funded investment plans to support businesses with grants etc to aid growth and drive productivity, making them even more attractive than us because unsurprisingly our Government is not doing anything like this, as usual.
  2. The tax system is an absolute mess per my previous posts creating huge disincentives at an individual level for productivity to be increased. Remove the rudiculous bottlenecks at various thesholds if earnings and you would very quickly see productivity rise.

Until both of these things happen very little will change. In fact given fiscal drag's impact on point 2, and the sensible actions of other countries to boost investment set out in point 1, things in the UK will not only not improve, but get substantially worse if no action is take .

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/02/2023 08:55

I was utterly skint in my 20’s, the cat ate better than we did. I was building my career and holidays etc were a rarity. We ran a small, old car gifted to us and lived in a very cheap one bedroomed flat in a dodgy area. Kids weren’t remotely on the horizon.

It takes time to build a life, and yes things are different now in terms of much higher house prices and the job market but even when things were easier many 20 somethings were pretty poorly off. I agree two people earning a full time wage should be able to afford the basics but early in your career it’s going to be hard going. Throw kids into the mix and it becomes a huge juggling act.

HeatherMac007 · 14/02/2023 08:38

Wow super interesting thread.

Tory bashing might feel good but it's not exactly helpful when the only alternative at the minute (starmer labour) would only seek to maintain the corrupt systems of power. Labour under Corbyn might have been different but we seen how the media dealt with that threat to their worldview. We get a choice between two sets of globalist, neoliberal social-democrats, one just happens to be more "woke" and spendthrift than the other. And ultimately will turn out the same in most other EU countries despite what propaganda will say.

Declining living standards are always going to feel sh!t. We really had things looking good for a little while! And whilst your feeling are valid, leaning too much into them won't help.

My best advice- in the short term, let go of expectations and come off social media!! You'll feel more content of what riches you do have (a roof over your head, food on the table, a country at peace, a moderate climate, healthy kids).

In the long term- get educated, read beyond propaganda and meet others to fight for real change. I personally favour a model of decentralisation but that (like any change) wouldn't be painless either, and the fight from the big players who want the status quo to continue could get pretty nasty.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 08:30

So £45K is very doable outside of London. That’s one salary for most working professionals. One train driver salary. Yes, maybe it would be a pinch at 28K, but then we’d qualify for social housing and UC too.

Where do you live that 28k would qualify you for social housing? In most places it's not about income anyway, and in the areas where demand outstrips supply (most of the UK) being on a low income doesn't in itself qualify you to be socially housed.

Themumdoc · 14/02/2023 07:57

I empathise with how you are feeling however agree with others who have pointed out you are only 26.

I would have loved to have children when younger but for the life we wanted to live it wasn’t financially feasible. I spent my 20’s working towards some level of financial stability. We bought a house before considering having children. I had my first child aged 32 and am now due my second age 34. I’m not saying this is the right way to do things, it’s a choice. I had 2 miscarriages then pre eclampsia with my first which may have been related in part to age but you just don’t know. There’s no perfect solution.

Things are tight with cost living crisis but that’s affecting most people currently.

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 07:50

ElliF · 14/02/2023 05:55

Part of the problem with housing is that we (the British people) have this allergic reaction to living together in high rise buildings. Almost every country I have been to builds blocks of flats (cheap housing) for people, and people live in them amiably and get on with one another. In this country if you build social housing and they are not houses, they become ghettos very quickly. When you give someone something for free, something they haven’t had to work for, they tend not to care about it or look after it.

Council tenants pay rent. The problem with council estates is that they need to be mixed - some homeowners and also renters. The caveat should be that the homeowners cannot just sell to anyone (so that the housing stock is kept for those on the median income for the area and below). A lot of ex council flats in London are now owned by landlords. I was looking at an ex council flat and it was actually the FTB flat of a lawyer who worked for a law firm that paid an average of £250k per annum. I actually know someone who lives in an ex council flat in central london and she owns a second home in Scotland.

In my home country, even the president lived in government housing (two big apartments that were knocked together for her, her 5 kids, mum and DH). She wanted to continue living in it even when she became president but it was too hard for her personal security forces to keep track of everyone.

3kidswouldfinishanyoneoff · 14/02/2023 07:43

@ElliF well I left him in 2014 so any savings I had are long gone. We haven't seen him since. No chance of maintenance.

BarbaraofSeville · 14/02/2023 06:51

buildingourdreams · 12/02/2023 19:07

Because our rent is £1000 a month (and my house is a crap hole)

Because my winter fuel bills have been £500 a month since late November / December because my house is poorly insulated and damp.

Because I spend £100 a week on petrol to get to work and get the boys to school / collect them from their childcare

And that's before food, council tax, internet, car maintenance, car tax, our car insurance,
Kids clothes shoes school stuff etc

Hi OP, sorry your thread has been derailed. I think sometimes, some people can't help the chance to rant at the government and those who voted for them, which is obviously a big part of the problem, but not helpful to you.

I think something that makes the current cost of living crisis worse for people your age is that it's the first time you've experienced significant inflation and the last recession was 15 years ago so you were very young so unless one of your parents lost their job and there was significant fall out from this, you probably can't remember times like this before.

If you actually do want budgeting advice, you probably want to repost in Money Matters or have a look at Moneysaving Expert which is a great resource to help to work out where your money is going and see if you can cut any costs. If you can do this, you can sometimes free up a bit of money to make things more comfortable.

Definitely also do a benefit check because, even if you're only entitled to a small amount of universal credit, and every little helps, you'll also get extra help with energy costs, be entitled to a social broadband tariff and also the Help to Save account, if you can manage to put a little money by for Christmas, car MOT and repairs etc, you get a bonus equal to half the maximum balance after 2 years, so free money from the government and a big incentive to try and save a bit if you can.

From the post I'm replying to, what stands out to me is that you're spending a lot of money on petrol, and also you appear to be paying for your energy by a method other than equal monthly direct debit.

On petrol, do you live a long way from work and can you find a job closer to home? Where does your DH work compared to where you live? Could you move? I know moving costs money, but if you could manage it, it might be worth the investment and upheaval if you found somewhere where petrol costs would be lower and is cheaper to heat even if it means borrowing the deposit from a parent or looking for help with a deposit scheme.

Can you pay your utilities by standard direct debit so you can spread the cost all year?

On a slightly brighter note, if you pay your council tax over 10 months, you don't pay in February and March (this sometimes applies to water too) so that's a bit of money spare that you could save, or use some of to treat yourselves.

On treats, with DC your age, a family National Trust membership could be a good investment if you have suitable properties nearby as it allows you free days out for about £10 a month (take a picnic because cafes are £££s and really busy at weekends).

Takeaway pizza isn't really a treat to me because it's usually very expensive for something that isn't significantly better than a nice one from a supermarket, but you could have a look at the Too Good to Go app to see if there's anything on there that you can get cheaply for a treat.

Good luck Smile

ElliF · 14/02/2023 06:01

echt · 14/02/2023 03:19

Because no political party would do better now

The Tories dfepend on this viewpoint to keep getting in.

Lol.
Name any labour government that hasn’t left office having bankrupted the country.

Those who run the country depend on your belief that voting changes things.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 05:55

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 01:57

OP I have to disagree, it's wages.

Most countries experience high energy costs... But I had a chat with my DH's German cousin's boyfriend. He has a very ordinary job - mortgage free, not worried about heating in the slightest and driving a BMW. He isn't that old either- late 30s, I would probably say. The reason why inflation hits the UK so badly is because of the many people on low wages. For many of them, food could be practically free and they would still struggle. We have just been accustomed to low wages for so long that we don't realize we are getting poorer everyday.

Your landlord may not make a shit ton of profit on rent. I know if I rented out my flat, I would be making a loss and indeed my neighbour who rented out her flat is barely breaking even. We have to pay 40% tax (but would never have been able to buy the property in the first place if one of us wasn't on 40% tax). The landlords who make a profit are those with huge portfolios so they can spread the risk - another example of how the system is designed for those with genuine wealth not the middle class.. but at the same time, rent is very expensive due to lack of supply .

Part of the problem with housing is that we (the British people) have this allergic reaction to living together in high rise buildings. Almost every country I have been to builds blocks of flats (cheap housing) for people, and people live in them amiably and get on with one another. In this country if you build social housing and they are not houses, they become ghettos very quickly. When you give someone something for free, something they haven’t had to work for, they tend not to care about it or look after it.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 05:42

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 00:46

My parents are pretty traditional, like I said before, my dad bought a house with his parents and we lived together until they both passed on. But my dad has always raised me to believe that I should earn my own money and not be dependent on family money. There is a Chinese saying- even if there is a mountain of money, if you just sit on it and eat, it will vanish into thin air. My parents are self made, and they don't want their money to vanish! It is not a bad thing for a family to pool resources but I think that there should be an affordable option for those without families with resources.

The thing is if you allow families to pass on this kind of wealth tax free, it will mean we collectively get poorer. My parents might be rich but they are not billionaires. And wealth is relative. It is entirely possible that in a generation, £1 million would be the entry level price for an apartment in Manchester and so if you were someone in the North relying on your 500k inheritance to get on the housing ladder, you would be stuffed. If you get £100 and someone else gets £1000, you have just gotten poorer. It's different with salaried employment as that is work that contributes to the country's GDP and has a knock on effect. It will also benefit local businesses and services Wealth on the other hand is largely not spent except on assets. Great wealth and low salaries lead to great inequality.

Well put, especially the last bit.
I am all for taxing inheritances. The problem seems to be that we allow the formation of private trust funds and shelter wealth within them why can be passed from person to person tax free.
We have huge swathes of our population already living their lives on benefits and in subsidised housing. I don’t see that creating dependency on the state for food and shelter helps people. I can see that it is desirable as a control mechanism. But at the end of the day if your employer owns your home and pays you your wages, are you not just a slave to the owner by some other name?

ElliF · 14/02/2023 05:28

TheLostGiraffe · 13/02/2023 23:57

That's the nail on the head. Salariesneed to increase, massively. The only way that can happen is increased productivity. That means getting rid of all of the perverse incentives and bottlenecks in the tax system, and massively increasing business investment (which unsurprisingly has fallen even further off a cliff since 2016 - rejoining the single market and customs union would be a good start if people want any prospect of significant payrises).

Serious question then...

So, where does the money come from to increase salaries across the board?
Train drivers just got 18% in London. It helps and it was as good as they realistically could have hoped for. But it barely scratches the surface of the pain working families are feeling in London.

So let’s say we want to give everyone in the UK below £80K a 50% pay increase, and a similar increase in benefits. That’s what... £1.6Trillion? The US prints much more than that a year. So within the realms to possibility.

Where does the £1.6Trillion a year come from? Do we increase taxes on corporations? Do we print government bonds? How do we get the benefit of the £1.6Trillion a year without inflating the money supply?

echt · 14/02/2023 03:19

Because no political party would do better now

The Tories dfepend on this viewpoint to keep getting in.

treasurefoil · 14/02/2023 02:30

That reply from @Greenfairydust was shocking. Your like us, but asking for more help and information but get destroyed. It's disgusting. Not long and people will be priced out of living. Only the rich will find a way to get richer. We are on the brink of death and being told how we vote is the problem is just crap. Because no political party would do better now

mackthepony · 14/02/2023 02:10

Op, I think people have been really harsh with you on here, especially criticising you about not knowing a ton about the Tories and politics.

What really stands out to me is how RIGHT you are about the current situation. It is shit. You shouldn't have to pay so much for food, rent and heat. You DO deserve more and it's not some fucking race to the bottom, put another sweater on and stop whinging about utilities attitude that we should just suffer through.

If I were you I'd be either moving away and trying to buy a house or moving abroad.

You would probably be wealthier not working actually.

Which says it all

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 01:57

buildingourdreams · 12/02/2023 21:22

My wages are okay ! If I was on minimum wage or part time I'd get it !

It's not wages that are the issue imo it's the cost of everything and I don't buy into all this bullshit like oh it's cos of the Ukrainian war etc. it's because companies know they can price gouge so they continue doing it ! Like do you think all the supermarkets aren't making a fuck load of money ?? Has anyone seen the profits some of the Energy companies have recently declared for example ? Do you think my landlord doesn't make a shit ton of profit on my rent ?? If I had a mortgage for the same house it would be less than my rent according to the calculators online. but no one will give us one as we have no deposit

I've had enough honestly 🤦‍♀️

OP I have to disagree, it's wages.

Most countries experience high energy costs... But I had a chat with my DH's German cousin's boyfriend. He has a very ordinary job - mortgage free, not worried about heating in the slightest and driving a BMW. He isn't that old either- late 30s, I would probably say. The reason why inflation hits the UK so badly is because of the many people on low wages. For many of them, food could be practically free and they would still struggle. We have just been accustomed to low wages for so long that we don't realize we are getting poorer everyday.

Your landlord may not make a shit ton of profit on rent. I know if I rented out my flat, I would be making a loss and indeed my neighbour who rented out her flat is barely breaking even. We have to pay 40% tax (but would never have been able to buy the property in the first place if one of us wasn't on 40% tax). The landlords who make a profit are those with huge portfolios so they can spread the risk - another example of how the system is designed for those with genuine wealth not the middle class.. but at the same time, rent is very expensive due to lack of supply .

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 01:24

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 01:22

My left wing views were actually shaped after meeting my DH and living with his family (they had a house in London where I stayed in the first few years). My DH is from the same university as me and we studied the same course. But he is on the other end of the income spectrum; he was on free school meals..he received no secular education until secondary school (no English or maths ) as he attended an ultra orthodox Jewish school. When I first met him, he had no money for lunch as he was waiting for his student loan payment to come through..we had very little money when we first got married at 22 and 24. So yes while my DH still thinks he earns very little, I suppose he has worked his way out of poverty as he is now a higher rate taxpayer, owns a London flat, only has 12 k of student loan left to pay and goes on multiple overseas holidays. Due to his pay, we would not qualify for child benefit which is funny cos family allowance was a big chunk of his family's income when he was little. Hewould never vote Tory. He is allergic to the word 'aspirarion' as he thinks it's a con to trick poor people into voting Tory.

*aspiration!

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 01:22

ElliF · 14/02/2023 00:22

Thank you for that considered and very lucid response.

There are cultures where, if one’s parents bought one’s children a house, it would be seems and an addition to the family’s wealth, and families then protect those assets and distribute them as required among subsequent generations as needed to protect and improve the family’s prospect for prosperity.

Of course we see that type of family centric lifestyle as barbaric and we expect each child to flee the nest and keep in touch. But I don’t see your Dad’s offer of assistance as being anything not fitting of modern Britain. I can’t remember if you said you had kids, and I can’t scroll back and see, but it is a very natural instinct to want to pass the fruits of one’s labour onto one’s children. The idea that generations have now been raised to believe that inheritance is in some way evil and unjust is a very malignant sign or the way our country may develop.

We are a 45K income household. So DH is earning what you are earning. I’m a stay at home mum. We don’t live in London. We’d never be able to afford it. But we save £500 a month out of out £2800 income, and with CB we still have about £200 breathing room when all the bills and food are taken care of. I fully expect that £200 to be eaten up by energy bills hikes, council tax hikes, Internet, mobile phone, etc. hikes all happening at the beginning of the next tax year. And we rent privately, we received no benefits apart from CB. We don’t own a house. We’re saving for a deposit.

So £45K is very doable outside of London. That’s one salary for most working professionals. One train driver salary. Yes, maybe it would be a pinch at 28K, but then we’d qualify for social housing and UC too.

You say yourself that you are I. The top 10% of earning families in our country. That places you close to the top 2% richest families in the world. And you’ve come from money. You must surely appreciate that your view of the poor and their finances is very different to those who have lived it and learned to work their way out of it.

My left wing views were actually shaped after meeting my DH and living with his family (they had a house in London where I stayed in the first few years). My DH is from the same university as me and we studied the same course. But he is on the other end of the income spectrum; he was on free school meals..he received no secular education until secondary school (no English or maths ) as he attended an ultra orthodox Jewish school. When I first met him, he had no money for lunch as he was waiting for his student loan payment to come through..we had very little money when we first got married at 22 and 24. So yes while my DH still thinks he earns very little, I suppose he has worked his way out of poverty as he is now a higher rate taxpayer, owns a London flat, only has 12 k of student loan left to pay and goes on multiple overseas holidays. Due to his pay, we would not qualify for child benefit which is funny cos family allowance was a big chunk of his family's income when he was little. Hewould never vote Tory. He is allergic to the word 'aspirarion' as he thinks it's a con to trick poor people into voting Tory.

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 00:46

ElliF · 14/02/2023 00:25

That should have read, ‘it would be deemed an addition to the family’s wealth.’

My parents are pretty traditional, like I said before, my dad bought a house with his parents and we lived together until they both passed on. But my dad has always raised me to believe that I should earn my own money and not be dependent on family money. There is a Chinese saying- even if there is a mountain of money, if you just sit on it and eat, it will vanish into thin air. My parents are self made, and they don't want their money to vanish! It is not a bad thing for a family to pool resources but I think that there should be an affordable option for those without families with resources.

The thing is if you allow families to pass on this kind of wealth tax free, it will mean we collectively get poorer. My parents might be rich but they are not billionaires. And wealth is relative. It is entirely possible that in a generation, £1 million would be the entry level price for an apartment in Manchester and so if you were someone in the North relying on your 500k inheritance to get on the housing ladder, you would be stuffed. If you get £100 and someone else gets £1000, you have just gotten poorer. It's different with salaried employment as that is work that contributes to the country's GDP and has a knock on effect. It will also benefit local businesses and services Wealth on the other hand is largely not spent except on assets. Great wealth and low salaries lead to great inequality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread