Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Life is too expensive and not enjoyable.

391 replies

buildingourdreams · 12/02/2023 15:49

I am only 26 years old and I am tired

H and I both earn okay money both work ft and I sometimes do part time work too

We've 2 boys under 7 and After rent bills and food and petrol we have not a penny .
This is with our parents helping with childcare we don't even have to pay childcare for the boys thankfully 🙏

We Can't go on holiday. Can't even have a takeaway or my nails done

We rent and Can't save for a house to buy don't get any benefits other than the basic Cb about £200 month. (And I don't expect or want handouts anyway)

Is this our life now ? Don't tell me to get a better job as I might do as I get older but this is not the point I'm making . If someone works full time they should be able to afford a few treats in life and specially with 2 incomes!

I worry constantly that we are failing our kids and should I even have had them? And also Like, what will even become of people like us when we're old ?

OP posts:
ElliF · 14/02/2023 14:32

MavisFlump · 14/02/2023 14:21

Christ almighty!
Try living on a joint income of £40k , yours is nearly three times what ours was before we retired. Now we live on half of that. How? By living frugally, making wise decisions and never expecting to be able to buy immediately anything we fancy - always saving for what we needed.
We live in a throwaway society where a whole generation has been brought up to expect to get what they want when they want it, even if that exploits much poorer countries. And to always expect someone else to help them out and to always blame everyone and anyone other than themselves.
I’ve seen this with my nephews and nieces, overindulged and now unable to live within their means.
Carry on and blame the Tories, Labour are utterly impotent and look where voting them in in Wales has ended up.

I try not to follow the news about Wales.
Its gonna become Britain’s California.
The intelligent and skilled will leave and those that remain will turn the place into a socialist shithole.
Scotland is going the same way.

But I don’t think it’s a Tory/Labour thing.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 14:28

Truestorypeeps · 14/02/2023 14:00

Budgeting is key. Get a spreadsheet setup in MS Excel, I have a weekly budget but monthly might work better for you, in this put the money coming in and a list of the things you HAVE to pay in your outgoings. This leaves you with a figure for how much you have left to spend/save on other things. It can be a scary thought to put this together and the amount left over each month might be disheartening, but you really need to know where you are at so you don't overspend and you'll feel better for being in more control of your finances. You may also be able to identify things you can cut. For example I got rid of Sky TV as it was poor VFM versus how long I spent watching it. Without some idea of how much money you have to play with, it's easy to spend what you can't actually afford.

Yep.
How to budget should be taught at school.
At the very least it should be taught at universities because they are supposed to be or brightest individuals.
But when you see programs with people talking about money, none of them have ever written down what they spend until a film crew and a presenter is there showing them how to do it.
We all have excuses for not making changes.
None of us should have excuses for not knowing where our money is going unless a partner is concealing some gambling habit or a mistress, or there is fraud happening on your account and you don’t ever look at your statements.
Do it once a day. It takes 10 minutes. We succeed at what we focus on, so focus on managing your money.

MavisFlump · 14/02/2023 14:21

socialmedia23 · 13/02/2023 22:59

My DH said today that we are low earners.i am on 45k and he is on 65k, we do live in London (where we have a mortgaged 2 bed flat). No DC yet. I do know we earn more than the median London income and according to ONS, we earn more than 90% of the country as a household of our size. But yet I can see where he is coming from, a combined income of £110k is really not high for a graduate couple in the capital city of a developed country. If wages had grown in real terms, we should be earning that each rather than combined..and of course paying the high taxes to match (which we would do so gladly). Most of us with earnings below £150k are not earning well particularly if we have been working for a few years. It's because we are a low earning/low productivity country with wages that have not grown in real terms that we think that £60k is a good salary!

And actually a lot of our problems as a country are linked to this. Our house prices only seem high because earnings from salaried employment are so low (on the other hand, bank of mum and dad is with £14 billion). I know people who were gifted £280k for a house..so there is plenty of money out there, it's just not being paid to the majority of people for their labour.. low pay means less tax revenue which leads to poor public services.

Christ almighty!
Try living on a joint income of £40k , yours is nearly three times what ours was before we retired. Now we live on half of that. How? By living frugally, making wise decisions and never expecting to be able to buy immediately anything we fancy - always saving for what we needed.
We live in a throwaway society where a whole generation has been brought up to expect to get what they want when they want it, even if that exploits much poorer countries. And to always expect someone else to help them out and to always blame everyone and anyone other than themselves.
I’ve seen this with my nephews and nieces, overindulged and now unable to live within their means.
Carry on and blame the Tories, Labour are utterly impotent and look where voting them in in Wales has ended up.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 14:17

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 14:05

And no, this is wrong. In an unstable world economy, somewhere like Britain used to be a beneficiary of people looking for somewhere safe to invest their money. Stable Government, rule of law, separation of Government and judiciary. When international markets were turbulent it was a boon for the UK, just like money rushes into what are perceived to be "safe" assets like gold and property.

However, very unfortunately, we've spent 7 years undermining our international credibility, reducing our international influence, destroying our infrastructure, and on top of that have had politicians undermining the independence of the judiciary and also breaking the law, even constitutional law, with no consequences. Destroying all of the things that foreign investors valued about the UK. Thus, much of the business community elsewhere in the world now views the UK as a bit of a basket case, with no plan or prospects and not such a safe place to put their investment, aside from the limited prospects from self-imposed trade barriers. In 2014/15 our currency was considered so stable it was on the cusp of being considered reserve currency status again. Now, that is a pipe dream.

So of course business investment is not forthcoming! Which is very worrying given that our balance of payment deficit has quadrupled since Brexit from 2% to 8% so we literally cannot keep the country afloat without foreign investment. We are absolutely dependent on it now. So much for sovereignty, eh? Idiotic to say the least.

If we want things to change then we need people managing the economy who will implement proper long-term economic plans for the good of the country and its citizens, not for political optics. Some people won't like them, because they also hold such views as yours where they do not understand that the point of investment is that you get your money back afterwards and a profit on top. As opposed to just spending more and more on unsustainable costs you cannot afford, a country has to find a way to produce more to fund decent living standards. We need to make the UK a place where businesses want to invest, and cut the crappy tax disincentives that stop people being able to participate and actually get a personal benefit from that which is worth their while.

Wait, didn’t Gordon Brown sell half of the UK’s gold reserved at the lowest possible price he could find? Didn’t he like tell everyone before hand that he was going to do it to make sure the market tanked so he could get the lowest possible return on the nations reserves?

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 14:14

A friend who works in off shore wind, says that it's really hard to get investment because the government keeps moving the goal posts. They don't even require government money, just clear guidelines and legislation that will allow investors to feel secure.

Yep. A stable platform. Nobody would take the risk now with what, 5 Prime Ministers in 7 years? Many of whom attempting to implement their conflicting policies without any mandate from the electorate. 5 Business Ministers in the last 2 years! What trust would anybody have to put their money into investing in that environment?

We have a very windy country, surrounded by thousands of miles of coastline. Yet have proportionately very low amounts of wind power, and we import hydro-generated power from Norway. 🤣 I mean, how stupid do you have to be?

ElliF · 14/02/2023 14:13

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:50

I've already answered this question.

Government need to borrow to do this. It should have done it when it could borrow at a negative interest rate (i.e. a profit!!!) but even now, international markets have no problem lending money to Governments on favourable long-term rates if that money is for a proper industrial investment strategy that will generate revenue and growth long term. If you do this and create a decent environment for private investment then there is no issue in obtaining this. The reason this is not happening in the UK is because our Government is not creating that environment: it has let our infrastructure crumble, huge skills gaps emerge due to lack of investment in education, has no industrial strategy to invest in key strategic growth sectors, and has cut us off from our main trading markets. Therefore, private investors are not interested, due to said economic mismanagement and there being no coherent strategy to improve this.

If the Government do not borrow to do this - that will actually make a return on their investment and make both the treasury and the population better off - they will continually run up more debt to plug the eve more unaffordable gap between the cost of services the population require and the decreasing revenue it can raise from the ageing population with no productivity growth, and we will all get poorer and poorer. International markets are far less keen on continuing to fund that, and will not do so in perpetuity.

You call it ‘borrowing’ but you are mischaracterising what is happening though. Governments don’t ‘borrow’ anything. They print Treasury Bonds and sell the to the Bank of England, and the BoE prints money (figuratively) and gives it to them in exchange for the Treasury Bonds.

The money supply is inflated. We have already devalued our currency by 75% through Covid. How much further poorer do you want to make people? The rich don’t suffer cos they understand how the system works.

And if you devalue the pound further, and you can’t convince all the other countries in the world to devalue their currencies in tandem, how do you hide the falling pound from the public?

The fact that most people think that the pound is stable and don’t understand that it is falling is because they don’t understand what inflation is and where it comes from.

I just don’t understand how you can justify further inflating as a solution to solving an inflation problem.

The government has still not paid back the money they ‘borrowed’ for World War I. Those Treasury Bonds just keep getting rolled over when they expire and have stayed on the national debt for over a century. The government, every government, ‘borrows’ more and more money every year and never pays any of it back. We both know that is not sustainable. You can’t keep buying food and fuel on your credit card year in year out paying minimum payments, and asking your credit card company to just keep increasing your spending limit because you have no intention ever of paying them back.

Its a noble idea, and I understand that it works, but your proposal does not work for on the other side of the equation.

What I think will happen is Labour will be voted in, they’ll spend lots and lots of money, and, like every single time they have been in power in this country, they will bankrupt the nation and walk away leaving a subsequent tory government to step in and decimate the welfare state and working classes of this country.

I don’t vote because I know neither party has a cat in hells chance of balancing the country’s budget and setting in course for a sustainable future. I just don’t get how more debt makes us stronger, and I feel for the people who are confused by the maths and don’t have the ability or inclination to save.

And like you said (I think), don’t save in anything that won’t keep up with inflation.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 14:05

ElliF · 14/02/2023 10:03

Thanks for expanding on that.

But as I see it the money still has to be put in place first.
Productivity is a result of investment, and that investment can only come from three sources - The people in the country. Outside Investors. Or printing Government Bonds and selling into the market.

In a collapsing world economy, with all major corporations culling their overheads, I don’t see outside investors stepping in regardless of any tax breaks the country is willing to offer.

So you're left with taxing the people and the employers that are already in the UK, or money printings, and I can’t see how either of those two can work given the debasement of the currency we have seen over the past 15 years.

The mistake was not letting the banks fail in 2008. We covered up the mess and swept it under the carpet, and proceeded to kicked the can down the road for 15 years. We broke the cardinal law that interest gets paid for money borrowed by setting interest rates to zero. At a governmental level we set the value of money at next to nothing and held it there for a decade. I don’t see how you can get out of that. That was the death of money right there.

Where do you see the money coming from for all the investment?

And no, this is wrong. In an unstable world economy, somewhere like Britain used to be a beneficiary of people looking for somewhere safe to invest their money. Stable Government, rule of law, separation of Government and judiciary. When international markets were turbulent it was a boon for the UK, just like money rushes into what are perceived to be "safe" assets like gold and property.

However, very unfortunately, we've spent 7 years undermining our international credibility, reducing our international influence, destroying our infrastructure, and on top of that have had politicians undermining the independence of the judiciary and also breaking the law, even constitutional law, with no consequences. Destroying all of the things that foreign investors valued about the UK. Thus, much of the business community elsewhere in the world now views the UK as a bit of a basket case, with no plan or prospects and not such a safe place to put their investment, aside from the limited prospects from self-imposed trade barriers. In 2014/15 our currency was considered so stable it was on the cusp of being considered reserve currency status again. Now, that is a pipe dream.

So of course business investment is not forthcoming! Which is very worrying given that our balance of payment deficit has quadrupled since Brexit from 2% to 8% so we literally cannot keep the country afloat without foreign investment. We are absolutely dependent on it now. So much for sovereignty, eh? Idiotic to say the least.

If we want things to change then we need people managing the economy who will implement proper long-term economic plans for the good of the country and its citizens, not for political optics. Some people won't like them, because they also hold such views as yours where they do not understand that the point of investment is that you get your money back afterwards and a profit on top. As opposed to just spending more and more on unsustainable costs you cannot afford, a country has to find a way to produce more to fund decent living standards. We need to make the UK a place where businesses want to invest, and cut the crappy tax disincentives that stop people being able to participate and actually get a personal benefit from that which is worth their while.

Truestorypeeps · 14/02/2023 14:00

Budgeting is key. Get a spreadsheet setup in MS Excel, I have a weekly budget but monthly might work better for you, in this put the money coming in and a list of the things you HAVE to pay in your outgoings. This leaves you with a figure for how much you have left to spend/save on other things. It can be a scary thought to put this together and the amount left over each month might be disheartening, but you really need to know where you are at so you don't overspend and you'll feel better for being in more control of your finances. You may also be able to identify things you can cut. For example I got rid of Sky TV as it was poor VFM versus how long I spent watching it. Without some idea of how much money you have to play with, it's easy to spend what you can't actually afford.

Herecomestreble1 · 14/02/2023 13:49

Jesus, the race to the bottom comments in this thread are hilarious. It's absolutely fair that the OP should lament not being able to afford a takeaway, just because you didn't have a colour TV or think reusing tea bags 16 times is essential doesn't mean OP can't have a moan!

Reversiblesequinsforadults · 14/02/2023 13:21

I totally agree OP. My household income is £45K, which has been plenty in the past, even when we had to pay for childcare. I find myself watching every penny. My son asked for some clothes yesterday and I said 'no' because I felt that he has a couple of months growing room in them. A couple of years ago, I would have said, 'yes'. I'll have to get him some in a couple of months anyway because the child is shooting up! I'm turning down meeting up with friends because I can't afford to eat out. Luckily, everyone is in the same boat and are happy to have tea (or wine) around someone's house. God knows how those on minimum wage are coping.

On the political side, if the government hadn't provided ridiculous subsidies for their billionaire friends in the fossil fuel industries and invested in renewables as they should have done, then we wouldn't be reliant on gas from Russia and fuel prices wouldn't be such a problem. A friend who works in off shore wind, says that it's really hard to get investment because the government keeps moving the goal posts. They don't even require government money, just clear guidelines and legislation that will allow investors to feel secure. The same is true of things like electric cars. These simple fixes would reduce fuel and food prices. (food prices have gone up because of fuel and fertiliser (based on fuel prices).

The other things that the Tories have done over the last 12 years is made public services hard work. Every single thing that you need, you have to fight for with time and energy, which makes life miserable. Whether it's getting a grit bin, a GP appointment, disability benefits, SEND provision, social care, youth services etc. etc. One woman I know was in tears at her PIP assessment because it was so humiliating. Do they think that she's magically going to regain her sight? Perhaps it's her own fault that Jesus hasn't turned up. She's not the same woman as she was 10 years ago, her mental health has deteriorated so much.

Public sector workers hate this. They'd like to be able to provide what's needed without having to prioritise the most desperate and failing everyone else while working ridiculous hours. And they're in the same position financially, having not had a pay rise for 10 years. I've worked in the public sector under Labour and I've worked in the public sector under the Tories. It's vastly different!!

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 13:17

Well, indeed. It wasn't always so (that there were state support and services), and in many countries around the world such things do not exist. I find it baffling that people do not grasp that countries are not always on an upwards trajectory - you have to manage them properly to make that happen - and the services people took for granted and are now missing simply won't continue to exist at all unless we find a way to increase productivity, especially with the demographic time bomb of the ageing population that will need supporting. This has been known about for 40 years. At the moment we borrow every year to plug the gap between services and revenue. If people still want services - with a lower and lower proportion of working age people to fund them - then how do they propose to pay for them? A smaller and smaller proportion of even the working age population has been funding everything, now only the top 10% of earners are net contributors and those of them on PAYE have already been milked dry and then some. Is it not obvious to people that we have to find a way to make productivity and salaries rise across the board so that a much higher proportion of people are net contributors? Stop the brain drain of our most intelligent and highly qualified young people leaving the UK to escape the punitive tax rates and lower living standards for the same qualifications? Invest in schools properly? Get rid of the stupid new trade barriers so businesses can invest in the UK again and create the high margin businesses we need in sectors with real growth prospects like tech and energy, that can them pay decent salaries?

Where is the economic plan? Likewise with the NHS. The state public and state pension ponzi schemes. Energy security, food security. Pandemic planning. 🤣🤣🤣 Where are the plans? What are all of these successive Governments doing?!

I think they deliberately defunded state education to keep a large proportion of people so oblivious to basic economics that could be taught in just a few hours of school time out of the entire 12 years of compulsory schooling, so that people are so ignorant of things that they'll put up with all of this nonsense, or even vote for their own demise a la Brexit. That you actually had many, many people saying "I don't care if we're poorer..." was just so unbelievably stupid. Do they not want healthcare or education or heating in their homes? Not just shooting yourself in the foot but in the face. I wonder where they all are now, that their chickens have come home and are making a racket.

It's all very depressing and makes me sad that even when I've taken the time to try to explain in completely politically neutral terms (I don't support any political party and never have, I think all current prospects are imbeciles. I would support competent Government of any coloured) the economic facts, basic mechanisms causing the issues and simple proposals for how these could be addressed, you still get people saying they don't get it or it must just be some individual's fault for not budgeting properly. 🙄 There isn't a face palm in the world that's big enough.

Veryxonfused · 14/02/2023 13:08

I think the biggest thing couples do to ‘trap’ themselves financially is have children before getting on the property ladder. It will naturally be incredibly difficult to buy a house now

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 12:53

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 12:24

Really @ElliF all you are doing is playing into the hands of the incompetent idiots who created this situation. What they want is for everyone to fight amongst each other about how what is left after their mismanagement is divided up. To convince people it must be other people's fault that they are in difficult situations. This is all a distraction from the fact that everyone's situation, including yours, would be better if they were doing their jobs properly. It's depressing that you have fallen for it and are apparently unable to see the bigger picture despite these explanations, and as @socialmedia23 just pointed out there is only so far that your approach to it can take you because if the issue isn't fixed then you will see your own situation become poorer and poorer no matter how "virtuously" you budget.

And the things we take for granted - free healthcare,.state pension, free education are only possible for a rich country to pay for. If we continue down this route, we would not be a rich country..I would like to point out your meticulous budget assumes that you are not paying for healthcare and education. It all flies out the window if you have to pay for healthcare cos the NHS doesn't work on top of having no state pension.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 12:24

Really @ElliF all you are doing is playing into the hands of the incompetent idiots who created this situation. What they want is for everyone to fight amongst each other about how what is left after their mismanagement is divided up. To convince people it must be other people's fault that they are in difficult situations. This is all a distraction from the fact that everyone's situation, including yours, would be better if they were doing their jobs properly. It's depressing that you have fallen for it and are apparently unable to see the bigger picture despite these explanations, and as @socialmedia23 just pointed out there is only so far that your approach to it can take you because if the issue isn't fixed then you will see your own situation become poorer and poorer no matter how "virtuously" you budget.

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 12:19

ElliF · 14/02/2023 11:53

... or you spent too much on things you wanted and never considered saving.
How many people get a new phone every year or two?
How many people keep their car longer than 5 years?
How many people subscribe to more than one subscription TV service?

All very doable, and kudos for keeping consumerism alive, is you’re earning a decent wage, but if you’re not earning well, don’t have a financial safety net, and are living paycheck to paycheck, what the frack are you doing blowing your money on stuff you want.

Is a new phone or a nice car or a morning latte to be expected? are they entitlements?

You can economize all you want but at some point the savings will run out and inflation will kick in..for my friend in Wolverhampton, rent has doubled in two years. It can happen to you. You can budget all-day long but at a certain point, if rent becomes 60-70% of what you earn, utilities have increased, you will be at the food bank. This is less of an issue for richer people as food is a small percentage of outgoings and so are utilities. Only issue may be the mortgage but many people have fixed term mortgages. Also richer people have more potential to increase their salary. Like warren buffet said, the only thing that will beat inflation is skills as there would always be a demand for highly skilled people who would be paid accordingly.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 12:18

Look @ElliF , you've made it very clear from all of your posts that you pride yourself on being frugal. And you consider that other people who don't wish to live such a constrained life to be profligerate wasters who only have themselves to blame.

As I pointed out previously, people's circumstances differ from your own for a great many reasons. Some will be single parents with huge childcare bills. Others have to live in far more expensive areas due to caring responsibilities or work, etc.

Yes they could probably tinker around the edges and try to convince themselves that they're virtuous for sitting in a freezing cold house and eating lentils every day, and if you enjoy that and your spreadsheets to keep track of every penny you've spent over the last few decades then fine. But what I've tried to explain to you is that there are structural reasons why people at all levels of earning in the UK are becoming increasingly worse off than their counterparts in comparable countries. And that this trend will continue unless the very obvious actions I've set out above are taken at a Government level.

Most people do not find it fun to be forced to be frugal in every aspect of their lives. And why should they have to when their counterparts with similar jobs/ careers/ education in the countries which have historically always been our comparators are not suffering the same, extended drop in living standards? Yes all countries have suffered due to geopolitical events, but most of our historical comparator countries were in a better situation to deal with it at all levels of society because they had not just had 15 years of zero productivity or real-terms salary growth. And they have Governments who actually have a plan, who are trying to find solutions with national strategies to improve things for their citizens again moving forward. No country is perfect but the management of the UK economy in the last 15 years would have been better if it had been based on a random coin flip for every decision. Why should people accept this and be worse off than is necessary when there are things that could be done to create a sustainable rise in living standards for everyone?

I do not understand your obsession with criticising individuals for wanting a better life, which is absolutely achievable if the Government took the appropriate and absolutely obvious steps set out above, and telling them effectively that they should just suck it up and enjoy getting increasingly poorer when this is completely unnecessary.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 11:53

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 11:26

And even for local produce, the prices are set by the international market so if the value of GBP falls, even the price of local British cheese and butter will go up. Other countries becoming richer and consuming more = more expensive for us.

London is actually a very affordable city compared to many other capital cities and it is because the UK is relatively less well off. I hate the term 'cost of living crisis ' because it is gaslighting in the truest sense of the word. If you cannot withstand an extra £100 in your energy bills or you have to immediately change your eating habits because groceries went up 20%, you never earned enough to begin with..it is a scandal that so many people who deem themselves average struggle with the cost of things like bread..

... or you spent too much on things you wanted and never considered saving.
How many people get a new phone every year or two?
How many people keep their car longer than 5 years?
How many people subscribe to more than one subscription TV service?

All very doable, and kudos for keeping consumerism alive, is you’re earning a decent wage, but if you’re not earning well, don’t have a financial safety net, and are living paycheck to paycheck, what the frack are you doing blowing your money on stuff you want.

Is a new phone or a nice car or a morning latte to be expected? are they entitlements?

ExistenceOptional · 14/02/2023 11:51

You need to do free fun things. I grew up in a very poor family, I think it was hard for my mum and she worked full time. But I remember fun times.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:50

ElliF · 14/02/2023 11:41

Okay.
I see the mechanism of what should happen.
Who pays for it?

It can only come from three sources.

  1. The people and companies already in the UK.
  2. The Government selling bonds (gilts) to the BoE or foreign investment banks.
  3. Foreign companies investing their own capital in the UK.

Lets say Toyota we’re going to build a car plant to make EVs in Huddersfield or wherever. Their motivation is profit and long term stability for their company. Why invest say £10B in a new plant in the UK to manufacture right hand drive cars here, when we have no competent staff or experienced EV automotive engineers, high corporation tax and VAT on the sale of cars, and at the moment they can manufacture them in the Pacific and their only offsetting cost is the difference in import duty between shipping us raw materials and shipping us assembled cars. Their labour costs are substantially cheaper in the East. We’re the only country that’s dumb enough economically speaking to continue driving on the left, so everyone pays more than everywhere else in the world.

Yes, we are completely deficient in skills and infrastructure to compete with the economic powerhouses of the world. But we are too far down the road to change that with money.

The change that is coming is unavoidable and it will be near biblical. They will hide it in global war, use the ‘because foreign aggressor’ excuse, take away everyone’s right to control their own money, and train us with carrots and sticks to own nothing and be happy. It’s been written about is professional journals and white papers for close on 30 years. Everything that has been predicted by the global ruling classes has come true.

Like I said before, we printer 3 out of every 4 pounds in the fast three years, but we haven’t yet suffered the consequential loss in value of that 75% reduction in the value of the pound. That inflation is only just beginning to show up in our economy. Things will get a lot lot worse.

And with all this going on, we’re trying our best to g et the party started in Ukraine? We’re absolutely mental.

I've already answered this question.

Government need to borrow to do this. It should have done it when it could borrow at a negative interest rate (i.e. a profit!!!) but even now, international markets have no problem lending money to Governments on favourable long-term rates if that money is for a proper industrial investment strategy that will generate revenue and growth long term. If you do this and create a decent environment for private investment then there is no issue in obtaining this. The reason this is not happening in the UK is because our Government is not creating that environment: it has let our infrastructure crumble, huge skills gaps emerge due to lack of investment in education, has no industrial strategy to invest in key strategic growth sectors, and has cut us off from our main trading markets. Therefore, private investors are not interested, due to said economic mismanagement and there being no coherent strategy to improve this.

If the Government do not borrow to do this - that will actually make a return on their investment and make both the treasury and the population better off - they will continually run up more debt to plug the eve more unaffordable gap between the cost of services the population require and the decreasing revenue it can raise from the ageing population with no productivity growth, and we will all get poorer and poorer. International markets are far less keen on continuing to fund that, and will not do so in perpetuity.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 11:41

Okay.
I see the mechanism of what should happen.
Who pays for it?

It can only come from three sources.

  1. The people and companies already in the UK.
  2. The Government selling bonds (gilts) to the BoE or foreign investment banks.
  3. Foreign companies investing their own capital in the UK.

Lets say Toyota we’re going to build a car plant to make EVs in Huddersfield or wherever. Their motivation is profit and long term stability for their company. Why invest say £10B in a new plant in the UK to manufacture right hand drive cars here, when we have no competent staff or experienced EV automotive engineers, high corporation tax and VAT on the sale of cars, and at the moment they can manufacture them in the Pacific and their only offsetting cost is the difference in import duty between shipping us raw materials and shipping us assembled cars. Their labour costs are substantially cheaper in the East. We’re the only country that’s dumb enough economically speaking to continue driving on the left, so everyone pays more than everywhere else in the world.

Yes, we are completely deficient in skills and infrastructure to compete with the economic powerhouses of the world. But we are too far down the road to change that with money.

The change that is coming is unavoidable and it will be near biblical. They will hide it in global war, use the ‘because foreign aggressor’ excuse, take away everyone’s right to control their own money, and train us with carrots and sticks to own nothing and be happy. It’s been written about is professional journals and white papers for close on 30 years. Everything that has been predicted by the global ruling classes has come true.

Like I said before, we printer 3 out of every 4 pounds in the fast three years, but we haven’t yet suffered the consequential loss in value of that 75% reduction in the value of the pound. That inflation is only just beginning to show up in our economy. Things will get a lot lot worse.

And with all this going on, we’re trying our best to g et the party started in Ukraine? We’re absolutely mental.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:40

He could've saved himself some time and started a thread on here. That and meeting a group of reasonably affluent early retirees would've probably provided about 95% of the explanation needed.

Ha! Well yes. One can only hope this thread makes its way across his desk. 🤣

While he's at it, as I've said on other threads, they need to prioritise removing the discrimination in the tax system against single people, who make up an ever increasing proportion of our population. They are taxed far more on the same household income than a couple. This is not the case in many of our competitor countries, for good reason, as it again creates a huge disincentive to work at full capacity, and means many taxpayers not reaching their full earning potential and therefore over a lifetime paying in far less and requiring far more state support.

This particularly impacts single parent households, so is also discriminatory given that over 90% of them are headed by women. The treasury is losing an enormous amount of revenue and skills from the workforce as a result. Not to mention its impact on child poverty levels, which is again storing up far more cost and less revenue for the future (aside from the moral issue). Again, a no brainer and very simple to implement. But will they do it? I highly doubt it.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:35

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 11:26

For a Government who apparently believe in market forces they appear to have an astonishingly low level of comprehension of how markets function.

They do, don't they? I'm no fan of the free market lunatic fringe, but you do at least know where you are with them.

Same. Markets need regulating for sure, but these people don't even seem to understand how market forces operate in the first place! An A-level economics student would do better.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:33

And, as the article also alludes to, the lack of productivity growth and therefore salary growth actually exacerbates the housing issue also, making it relatively more productive to invest in assets than the actually work, which in turn inflates asset prices relative to average incomes. The only solution to improve things is to create the conditions for a sustained period of productivity and salary growth and remove the tax and childcare funding bottlenecks.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 11:31

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:26

The fact that Hunt had to "launch an enquiry" to try to find out why people aren't working more, when he is the one in charge of the disfunctional tax system creating the problem, is absolutely mind boggling.

He could've saved himself some time and started a thread on here. That and meeting a group of reasonably affluent early retirees would've probably provided about 95% of the explanation needed.

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 11:26

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 11:09

Until very recently there was a prolonged period where the Government could borrow at 0% or even negative interest rates. It is absolute economic insanity for them to have not done so and implemented an enormous investment program, in a country that had zero productivity growth, skills gaps and failing infrastructure. Instead, they implemented an austerity program which made these problems worse.

Investments have a return. So yes they involve outlay, but well-planned investment with a proper industrial strategy leads to higher returns: increased growth and productivity, and more tax for the treasury. A proper industrial strategy of this nature then encourages business investment. And yes, there is significant business capital around the world that can be obtained, if you create an investable environment in this way. If, on the other hand, you let your infrastructure fall apart, create huge skills gaps, have no industrial policy to grow key sectors, and then erect huge and expensive barriers to trade, clearly you are not creating an investable proposition. This is why an increasing proportion of the UK economy consists of low skilled, low paid, low margin work.

It isn't rocket science. And it is the reason that other countries even despite interest rates now being higher and Government debts already high due to Covid, are creating large scale investment funds anyway. It is a necessity to remain competitive. Provided you have competent people who understand business and economics in charge of the program (i.e. none of our current MPs) it is still possible to implement such a program successfully - you simply have to ensure that there is a proper cohesive and integrated strategy, not the piecemeal throwing around of funds at random projects like with the "levelling up funds", to ensure that the ROIs exceed the interest rates, in real terms. This requires competent people making the decisions with a long-term view. And to rejoin the single market and customs union, of course.

If we do not raise business investment and productivity then not only will productivity (and therefore salaries and living standards) continue to fall, the value of GBP will also fall further which is very bad news for anybody struggling with living costs because that also makes imports more expensive and we import large proportions of essentails such as energy and food.

This is all basic economics.

To make this work as I said you also need people to have an incentive to work, therefore the bottlenecks caused by universal credit thresholds, CB thresholds, tax free childcare threshold, higher rate tax threshold, and the threshold for removal of the personal allowance all need addressing also because currently these are hugely impeding productivity and growth.

For a Government who apparently believe in market forces they appear to have an astonishingly low level of comprehension of how markets function.

And even for local produce, the prices are set by the international market so if the value of GBP falls, even the price of local British cheese and butter will go up. Other countries becoming richer and consuming more = more expensive for us.

London is actually a very affordable city compared to many other capital cities and it is because the UK is relatively less well off. I hate the term 'cost of living crisis ' because it is gaslighting in the truest sense of the word. If you cannot withstand an extra £100 in your energy bills or you have to immediately change your eating habits because groceries went up 20%, you never earned enough to begin with..it is a scandal that so many people who deem themselves average struggle with the cost of things like bread..