Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Life is too expensive and not enjoyable.

391 replies

buildingourdreams · 12/02/2023 15:49

I am only 26 years old and I am tired

H and I both earn okay money both work ft and I sometimes do part time work too

We've 2 boys under 7 and After rent bills and food and petrol we have not a penny .
This is with our parents helping with childcare we don't even have to pay childcare for the boys thankfully 🙏

We Can't go on holiday. Can't even have a takeaway or my nails done

We rent and Can't save for a house to buy don't get any benefits other than the basic Cb about £200 month. (And I don't expect or want handouts anyway)

Is this our life now ? Don't tell me to get a better job as I might do as I get older but this is not the point I'm making . If someone works full time they should be able to afford a few treats in life and specially with 2 incomes!

I worry constantly that we are failing our kids and should I even have had them? And also Like, what will even become of people like us when we're old ?

OP posts:
buildingourdreams · 14/02/2023 16:13

**As it happens I had ds at 21 and had bought a house at 19, however I am not immune to inflation as a consequence and am facing my mortgage practically doubling. I do earn more now but not a high earner by any stretch, infact most mners would assume I had a shite job based on my salary. But somebody has to do those jobs. Those people shouldn't just... Not have kids.

Two minimum wages should afford a half decent standard of living. It's not a fucking race to the bottom. Oh well I survived on stale bread and never left my village. Yes, and was that a good life? No. No it wasn't. Don't make that "normal" it's not 1800s anymore**

Also really agree with this @Birdsbirdsbirds

(Hope the boldening thing has worked!)

OP posts:
buildingourdreams · 14/02/2023 16:08

Herecomestreble1 · 14/02/2023 13:49

Jesus, the race to the bottom comments in this thread are hilarious. It's absolutely fair that the OP should lament not being able to afford a takeaway, just because you didn't have a colour TV or think reusing tea bags 16 times is essential doesn't mean OP can't have a moan!

👏🏻👏🏻

OP posts:
buildingourdreams · 14/02/2023 16:06

But not everyone will get high paying jobs by 37 or whatever. Because somebody has to do the minimum wage jobs, don't they

@Birdsbirdsbirds

This exactly !!! While I hope I will improve my earnings as I get older - not everyone can / will .

So what will become of those who don't "move up" from minimum wage ? Does society just think well fuck them it's tough shit?

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 16:04

It's ultimately a question of whether we're prepared to provide sufficient state subsidy to increase the workforce participation of working parents or not. The rest is tinkering round the sides.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 14/02/2023 15:52

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:42

But not everyone will get high paying jobs by 37 or whatever. Because somebody has to do the minimum wage jobs, don't they?

Exactly. And should have a decent standard of living. And it's clear this can't be achieved by taxing higher earning PAYE earners any more because they've already been milked to death to fund everyone else for a decade. So what do we do? Instead of fighting over the crumbs we need to actually build a productive economy that can afford to pay people properly and provide proper services. Particularly as there will be an ever-growing proportion of elederly people and a lowe proportion of worker people: each working person will have to produce more in profit and tax revenue otherwise salaries will not cover living costs and tax will not cover services. Everybody has known this for 40 years.

We know that the things preventing this are the screwed up disincentives in the tax and childcare system, the lack of business investment, and (obviously compounding the latter point!!) us now being outside the single market and customs union.

So the question is what we do now. If anybody wants things to improve, are they going to ask their MPs to address these issues?

I have contacted my MP about the cost of living, when the nursery my child attended closed down when they announced the new minimum wage rate. She assured me labour were doing all they could but realistically, what does that equate to?

LemonTT · 14/02/2023 15:45

SomeAlienConcept · 12/02/2023 17:01

Yes because Tory policies benefit them. They are made for and by rich people who use private schools, private health cares, don't want their second and third homes penalised... they don't care or need to worry about ordinarily people's NHS, social housing or schooling. They begrudge the income tax they pay to support poorer people. Unless someone is exceptionally fair minded, this is human nature. If you were rich, you too might cross to the dark side.

London is one of wealthiest parts of the UK. It is predominantly Labour. Tory voters are a mix of rural wealthy and poor and people who live in towns.

The conservatives could not get a majority based on rich people alone. They only make up about 5-10% of the population.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:42

But not everyone will get high paying jobs by 37 or whatever. Because somebody has to do the minimum wage jobs, don't they?

Exactly. And should have a decent standard of living. And it's clear this can't be achieved by taxing higher earning PAYE earners any more because they've already been milked to death to fund everyone else for a decade. So what do we do? Instead of fighting over the crumbs we need to actually build a productive economy that can afford to pay people properly and provide proper services. Particularly as there will be an ever-growing proportion of elederly people and a lowe proportion of worker people: each working person will have to produce more in profit and tax revenue otherwise salaries will not cover living costs and tax will not cover services. Everybody has known this for 40 years.

We know that the things preventing this are the screwed up disincentives in the tax and childcare system, the lack of business investment, and (obviously compounding the latter point!!) us now being outside the single market and customs union.

So the question is what we do now. If anybody wants things to improve, are they going to ask their MPs to address these issues?

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:35

Needsomeadvice33 · 14/02/2023 15:20

@TheLostGiraffe you just asked if I would manage if my husband did a vanishing act - to afford my mortgage, childcare etc. My answer is yes I would as I earn enough because I focused on career and climbing property ladder in my 20s rather than having children. I'm reiterating the point that if you don't come from family money/inheritances then you choose a harder life by having children young.

Well good for you. I'm a lone parent. I have two children with SEN. Luckily for me I did the same as you: I got lots of qualifications and I worked 80-100 hours in my 20s and built a very good career before getting married and having children, and my husband decided to leave me and the two babies. So yes, I can support them myself and I do, even with our huge mortgage and their specialist childcare that is £££.

Do you think that makes us more virtuous and nobody else deserves a decent standard of living? Like @ElliF with her spreadsheets and miserliness?

Good financial planning perhaps. Of course this is sensible, but in many circumstances life gets in the way of that.

The point of the thread as far as I understood it is why is it so difficult for people on average salaries to have a decent life anymore, even when there are two of them working not juggling everything alone like me? Why do people feel that they have to wait until mid-30s to be able to have a family? Why can many couples working full time still not have any prospect of ever buying a house? Why do people in the UK have such a lower standard of living now for whatever level of qualifications/ skills they have, when compared to their counterparts in other countries that used to be our comparators? Why is the UK doing so much worse, and what can we do about that?

It's all very well telling people just to budget better, but why should they expect a lower standard of living than people doing the same job in Australia, Canada, France, Germany, the Netherlands? Or be faced with the tiresome Brexit-voter idiocy of "well leave then" 🙄🙄 if they point this out? Should we not instead expect our Government to have managed the economy so that our living standards kept pace with these countries, and be demanding that they implement the required policies now to fix the mess they have created?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 15:29

Individuals can't be expected to take this into account themselves, but it's a good job for our obstetric services that women as a whole don't wait until they're of an age to have built up a large financial cushion. On a population level, we get more complex and expensive to provide maternity care for, as we age.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 14/02/2023 15:28

ElliF · 14/02/2023 15:25

Yes, we all have a right to enough money to live. That’s why we have a welfare system. I can’t afford a new car. But I don’t believe I have aright to a new car and I don’t complain. I can’t afford to go on holiday, but I don’t believe I’m entitled to. I’ve got a 6yo tablet and a 6yo mobile phone and I can’t afford to buy new ones, but I don’t believe I am entitled to.

I have a right to live and pay my bills, which are all going up, but I don’t believe I am entitled to have Netflix or Sky. I’d love to have horse riding lessons for myself as DD, but I don’t believe we’re entitled to those things.

We are not entitled to all the things we want in life. It something children who are brought up well should understand about the world. The world owes us nothing. You work, you live on less than you earn, you save the rest. It is an ancient wisdom that has been known for thousands of years.

As we both know, the welfare system is a big bag of shit. It doesn't really work. If it did, this thread probably wouldn't exist.

Nobody has mentioned a right to a new car, so why you're harping on about that I don't know. I haven't mentioned any of the other shite either. I was referring to your comment about the life a cleaner deserves. Clearly you don't think they deserve much, rich coming from someone who doesn't work at all.

I do work, I live and I save. You don't work, and yet you're lecturing others on how to do it. Read the room.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 14/02/2023 15:25

Needsomeadvice33 · 14/02/2023 15:11

@TheLostGiraffe I would manage that yes as I earn enough now. Had it happened I'm my 20s then no as i didnt earn enough. This is specific why i choose not to have any children and especially wouldnt have them before building a career and equity in the property market. If people are desperate for children then fine but you have to also accept the negative financial implications.

But not everyone will get high paying jobs by 37 or whatever. Because somebody has to do the minimum wage jobs, don't they?

As it happens I had ds at 21 and had bought a house at 19, however I am not immune to inflation as a consequence and am facing my mortgage practically doubling. I do earn more now but not a high earner by any stretch, infact most mners would assume I had a shite job based on my salary. But somebody has to do those jobs. Those people shouldn't just... Not have kids.

Two minimum wages should afford a half decent standard of living. It's not a fucking race to the bottom. Oh well I survived on stale bread and never left my village. Yes, and was that a good life? No. No it wasn't. Don't make that "normal" it's not 1800s anymore.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 15:25

Birdsbirdsbirds · 14/02/2023 15:07

This is the biggest load of shite I've ever read..as for what people "deserve" take a look at yourself. What a revolting statement.

I get it op.

You should be able to live on your wages. People should be able to live on minimum wage ffs, otherwise what is the point of it?

Yes, we all have a right to enough money to live. That’s why we have a welfare system. I can’t afford a new car. But I don’t believe I have aright to a new car and I don’t complain. I can’t afford to go on holiday, but I don’t believe I’m entitled to. I’ve got a 6yo tablet and a 6yo mobile phone and I can’t afford to buy new ones, but I don’t believe I am entitled to.

I have a right to live and pay my bills, which are all going up, but I don’t believe I am entitled to have Netflix or Sky. I’d love to have horse riding lessons for myself as DD, but I don’t believe we’re entitled to those things.

We are not entitled to all the things we want in life. It something children who are brought up well should understand about the world. The world owes us nothing. You work, you live on less than you earn, you save the rest. It is an ancient wisdom that has been known for thousands of years.

Needsomeadvice33 · 14/02/2023 15:20

@TheLostGiraffe you just asked if I would manage if my husband did a vanishing act - to afford my mortgage, childcare etc. My answer is yes I would as I earn enough because I focused on career and climbing property ladder in my 20s rather than having children. I'm reiterating the point that if you don't come from family money/inheritances then you choose a harder life by having children young.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:18

Needsomeadvice33 · 14/02/2023 15:11

@TheLostGiraffe I would manage that yes as I earn enough now. Had it happened I'm my 20s then no as i didnt earn enough. This is specific why i choose not to have any children and especially wouldnt have them before building a career and equity in the property market. If people are desperate for children then fine but you have to also accept the negative financial implications.

Manage what? I am not sure which post you're responding to.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:17

You call it ‘borrowing’ but you are mischaracterising what is happening though. Governments don’t ‘borrow’ anything. They print Treasury Bonds and sell the to the Bank of England, and the BoE prints money (figuratively) and gives it to them in exchange for the Treasury Bonds.

This is also wrong. What you are talking about is QE. We also sell bonds to international markets for financing.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:15

The government has still not paid back the money they ‘borrowed’ for World War I. Those Treasury Bonds just keep getting rolled over when they expire and have stayed on the national debt for over a century

🤣🤣 This is exactly the point. Due to natural inflation etc the impact of this on current finances is so miniscule that it's totally irrelevant. Long-term Government borrowing for investment into things that create a higher return than the interest rate actually makes the treasury richer, aside from improving quality of life, and encouraging further investment into the country.

For almost a decade our Government could borrow on very long-term bonds for 0%, or even for much of it negative interest rates. They would actually have made a profit just from borrowing money, and doing nothing with it. If it is beyond the wit of our politicians in that situation to find any project to improve our infrastructure, skills or business environment with an ROI of anything above 0% then I despair. And this was money that you rightly point out that they could have borrowed at said rates for decades. So you invest in a project that will pay back plus profit in 5 or 10 years. Reap the benefit. Increased employment, increased productivity, increased salaries, increased tax revenue, reduced state support required. And can then invest the same money and do the same again! And again. And again.

Needsomeadvice33 · 14/02/2023 15:11

@TheLostGiraffe I would manage that yes as I earn enough now. Had it happened I'm my 20s then no as i didnt earn enough. This is specific why i choose not to have any children and especially wouldnt have them before building a career and equity in the property market. If people are desperate for children then fine but you have to also accept the negative financial implications.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 14/02/2023 15:07

ElliF · 13/02/2023 10:45

But there is a difference between an established career as a cleaner and an established career as a dentist. You can’t use ‘established career’ as an expectation for a comfortable life. An established cleaner in Essex deserves a completely different lifestyle as an established dentist in Penrith. The choices you make in life dictate your outcomes. We are not ‘entitled’ to anything. You only need to look at all the new hatchbacks and baby SUVs parked outside Starbucks, which is always packed where I live, to see the choices the younger generations are making and the fact that their helicopter parents didn’t explain how money works or the world works to them. If anyone is letting people down it’s their moms and dads.

This is the biggest load of shite I've ever read..as for what people "deserve" take a look at yourself. What a revolting statement.

I get it op.

You should be able to live on your wages. People should be able to live on minimum wage ffs, otherwise what is the point of it?

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:06

Needsomeadvice33 · 14/02/2023 14:58

I think having children young is choosing this life these days. People can be annoyed at that statement but ultimately its just a fact, unless you have family money/inherited. I'm 31, I work 24 hours per week and earn well for this. I have been consistent at uni through my 20s alongside working. I have 2 postgraduates and now earn more on my 24hours that when I worked fulltime as I've advanced my career. My husband earns less than me on his fulltime wage but our household income is very good. We have a large equity in our large house as we renovated 2 houses alongside working and extra uni postgraduate degrees (we had no inheritance/family money). We sacrificed a lot in our 20s and wouldn't be where we are now had we had children, that is just a fact. These are all choices. You choose to have children young, your life is the consequence of that.

I'm oleased for you but lots of people make such sacrifices and decisions and are as qualified as you are and still end up struggling due to the structural problems in the economy as described in the thread. Not everyone's life circumstances are predictable. You could do everything "right" as you say and then tomorrow if you husband did a vanishing act would you find it easy to juggle your career and looking after your children and the additional childcare expenses and paying for your house all on your own?

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:03

Why is everyone's instinct to economize when there isn't enough money. Surely it should be to make more money or get a raise. You can economize all you like but if I gave you a £100k medical bill, all that economizing would fly out of the window..

Exactly. The answer is to increase productivity so that salaries can rise to meet the cost of living. It is the only answer. I'm happy to listen to anybody else's proposals if they have a better alternative, but I've posted about it repeatedly, explained why it needs to happen, and how it can be achieved, and nobody has replied with another viable idea, probably because if you actually know anything about economics you know that it is the only viable idea.

So the question surely is how do we achieve that? For everyone's sakes, at every level of earning. Sniping at people for not budgeting well enough or because they earn more and you think they should pay even more tax or they earn less and you resent some extra support they get is entirely counterproductive and won't fix the issue. It's just scrapping around and fighting over the crumbs.

Instead I suggested some ways that the situation could be improved for everyone by better Government policy. Does anybody disagree with those suggestions? If so, why? What would be a better policy to fix it, in your opinion?

Why can't people have a rational and actually constructive debate about how to fix the problems, instead of villifying people who are struggling in a failed economic model and blaming them for it?

If people have better suggestions then suggest them. If they don't, then why aren't they contacting their MPs to tell them to do what I've suggested?

Needsomeadvice33 · 14/02/2023 14:58

I think having children young is choosing this life these days. People can be annoyed at that statement but ultimately its just a fact, unless you have family money/inherited. I'm 31, I work 24 hours per week and earn well for this. I have been consistent at uni through my 20s alongside working. I have 2 postgraduates and now earn more on my 24hours that when I worked fulltime as I've advanced my career. My husband earns less than me on his fulltime wage but our household income is very good. We have a large equity in our large house as we renovated 2 houses alongside working and extra uni postgraduate degrees (we had no inheritance/family money). We sacrificed a lot in our 20s and wouldn't be where we are now had we had children, that is just a fact. These are all choices. You choose to have children young, your life is the consequence of that.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 14:39

Wait, didn’t Gordon Brown sell half of the UK’s gold reserved at the lowest possible price he could find? Didn’t he like tell everyone before hand that he was going to do it to make sure the market tanked so he could get the lowest possible return on the nations reserves?

Sorry what? Where did I say this?

Yes that was yet another utterly stupid decision by a politician. As I said I don't support any political party and never have, so I'm struggling to understand the relevance of your comment given I was talking about how we encourage the investment we need i to the UK to raise living standards, rather than the idiotic sale of gold reserves at rock bottom prices? I don't see how the two are related?

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 14:39

MavisFlump · 14/02/2023 14:21

Christ almighty!
Try living on a joint income of £40k , yours is nearly three times what ours was before we retired. Now we live on half of that. How? By living frugally, making wise decisions and never expecting to be able to buy immediately anything we fancy - always saving for what we needed.
We live in a throwaway society where a whole generation has been brought up to expect to get what they want when they want it, even if that exploits much poorer countries. And to always expect someone else to help them out and to always blame everyone and anyone other than themselves.
I’ve seen this with my nephews and nieces, overindulged and now unable to live within their means.
Carry on and blame the Tories, Labour are utterly impotent and look where voting them in in Wales has ended up.

We have always cleared our credit card at the end of every month..We bought our flat at 27 and 29 (in 2019) which cost £400k, and didn't have a wedding until we were married for 7 years (as we were saving, admittedly covid did it's best to delay it as well). DH only has 12k left on student loan balance. I am not saying I am struggling, I am saying that our wages are very low compared to our counterparts in other countries. Believe it or not, people on other countries live on much more. My BIL was saying that his father's health insurance is 2000 per month. That is probably your entire living expenses right? But it's not like his father is subsisting on gruel and not heating. No his father has a nice condo, can travel overseas regularly, has a nice life etc. As his overall income is much more.. so he still has much more than many people on this thread despite high medical expenses. I am not saying that I support expensive medical care but when the whole country has low wages, sudden shocks to the system i.e. health care system needing money, high energy prices will decimate whatever disposable income most people have. This has knock on effects too.

Now just think how your life would be without state pension and free healthcare. And this kind of low wages/pension. I think I would have adjustment problems if I had to pay £1k for health insurance per month for my family. But that is where we are headed if things don't improve.

Why is everyone's instinct to economize when there isn't enough money. Surely it should be to make more money or get a raise. You can economize all you like but if I gave you a £100k medical bill, all that economizing would fly out of the window..

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 14:37

@ElliF you really do not understand how inflation works. Your comment earlier about how salary rises would generate inflation was like this. The causality is the other way around, even Friedman accepted this.

QE not "printing money". You seem to be stuck in some of the misguided narrative about how the money supply works that was circulating after the financial crisis 15 years ago. At that time everyone was worried about deflation.

Current inflation rates are not being driven by bond sales, they are being driven by international issues primarily supply chain issues post-Covid (including Americans now buying so much "stuff" they are driving prices up, as their economy actually recovered to pre-pandemic levels, like much of the rest of Europe...) and the fact that Russia was a huge supplier of gas and Ukraine a huge supplier of vegetable oil and grain - the "breadbasket if Europe" as it was always known. What is not helping those uncontrollable factors - from a UK perspective - is that: 1) most people at all income levels had little slack in their budgets following 15 years of zero growth in productivity or salaries in real terms; 2) our Government had no energy or food security strategy so a much larger proportion of these essentials are imported than in many of our comparator countries; 3) our Government had trashed the value of GBP through Brexit making said imports far more expensive; and 4) the Bank of England only has one lever it is allowed to pull to control inflation which is to control interest rates, when in this situation that will obviously have a minimal impact on reducing it because the inflation is not demand driven. In fact, it has increased inflation by raising housing costs.

The Government's solution of "oh well everyone should have a real terms paycut of 10% and just accept being poorer" is not the answer. BoE is in charge of monetary policy. This issue requires fiscal policies to mitigate/ solve. Our elected representatives, including the opposition, appear to have no credible plan about what to do about it.

Selling bonds to invest in infrastructure to create an environment businesses can invest in will have close to zero impact on inflation, and the inflation rate will actually reduce when productivity increases, by definition. Inflation is happening because GBP is being devalued, relative to our neighbours. While everyone has had the international issues to contend with, we have been hit harder because productivity in the UK is so low. If that isn't addressed then the cycle will continue, as I have explained. Particularly given our demographics.

Markets cannot solve this problem on their own. Investors don't owe the UK a free ride, they will not invest unless an attractive environment for investment is created and our Government has spent over a decade now doing the opposite. To the detriment of every citizen's take home oay and services and pension. Government has to create the conditions for growth and investment, with appropriate infrastructure, political stability, access to markets, skilled employees to do the work who actually can without the punitive thresholds in the tax system held down for a decade already with fiscal drag and lack of affordable childcare making it prohibitive for them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread