Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Life is too expensive and not enjoyable.

391 replies

buildingourdreams · 12/02/2023 15:49

I am only 26 years old and I am tired

H and I both earn okay money both work ft and I sometimes do part time work too

We've 2 boys under 7 and After rent bills and food and petrol we have not a penny .
This is with our parents helping with childcare we don't even have to pay childcare for the boys thankfully 🙏

We Can't go on holiday. Can't even have a takeaway or my nails done

We rent and Can't save for a house to buy don't get any benefits other than the basic Cb about £200 month. (And I don't expect or want handouts anyway)

Is this our life now ? Don't tell me to get a better job as I might do as I get older but this is not the point I'm making . If someone works full time they should be able to afford a few treats in life and specially with 2 incomes!

I worry constantly that we are failing our kids and should I even have had them? And also Like, what will even become of people like us when we're old ?

OP posts:
YouHaveAnArse · 14/02/2023 19:39

"but you really have to make choices these days like buy a house OR have kids in your 20s."

Some people would never have kids if they decided to wait until they bought a house. If the average age of a first time buyer is 36 - and I'm surprised it's that low tbh - that doesn't give you a lot of time there.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 19:21

kitcat15 · 14/02/2023 19:15

Fucks sake….this thread needs to end🙄

Okaaayyy. Nobody is forcing you to look at it.

kitcat15 · 14/02/2023 19:15

Fucks sake….this thread needs to end🙄

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 18:57

So when I look at my mum, or my SIL, and what they go through, and those around us, and then I see threads where people earning high wagers are complaining that they can’t do their nails or go on holiday, and I know that I’m in a worse position than they are and I have £700 spare in my budget, I just have to point out the real world of people struggling out there, and the blatant entitlement of wanting too much and not being willing to work for it

I am sorry your family are struggling. And what I've been saying is that that should not be the case: salaries need raising across the board and there is only one way to fix that.

But please do bear in mind that when you look at your income and outgoings, and struggle to understand why someone earning a much higher salary might struggle, that as I said earlier circumstances are different. For example I earn well, but to do so I have to live in expensive place. I am a lone parent so obviously have high childcare expenses that you don't, compounded by being in an expensive area. And my children can't go to standard childcare, so I have to hire nannies for every hour I work. So by the time I've been taxed and paid our living costs and childcare what looks like a good salary on paper means that not in a million years - even if I lived incredibly frugally - could I save £500 like you say you are doing. That's just the one example of me. But people's circumstances are different for very many reasons and you can't just look at income and say if it's the same or more than yours - without any idea of the outgoings or circumstances - and say that they should have loads of money left otherwise they must be irresponsible. In many cases that really isn't what is happening.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:51

I certainly can't imagine the Tories will engage in any acknowledgement at all that their decision to let people access pensions from aged 55 has led to some over 55s accessing their pensions.

😂😂

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 18:46

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:01

... and no, I most definitely are not telling anyone how to work. I’d suggest staying at home with your kids and saving the cost of childcare and a second car and all that jazz. It makes life A LOT cheaper clearly.

As a lone parent since mine we babies, this was never an option. Aside from the cost I feel sad every day about how much time in their early childhoods I have missed. Just do bear in mind that some things you think are decisions really aren't.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:44

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 18:20

It also damages long term earning potential. I got a pay rise of 19k this year. Women who give up their jobs to save on childcare nwoild miss out on three or four years of career progression which could translate to many tens of thousands over the years. How many cold nights does one have to endure to make that up..

Honestly as someone who bought, earnings make the biggest difference, not saving. The reason why we can even think of upgrading now is because we have increased our earnings since 2019 ( salaries in our sector financial services have grown 15% since 2019)... And we go on 6 foreign holidays per year. No car though and no new tech by and large. Inequality is such that it is very difficult to buy a property by saving alone. The only reason why we bought is because DH was earning in excess of 50k when we bought and that is above London median. Most home owners (in late 2019/2022) earn in excess of the median wherever they live. Even those that move miles out. The bank decides how much you borrow based mainly on what you earn and not how much you spend on restaurants and the like. Even with high interest rates, the biggest difference is earnings. In

I worked before I got married and had DD. Don’t have a degree, so earning potential in the corporate world is limited. DH earned about £20K when we met, the £30 when we had DD, and £44K for the past 3 years. So me working would cripple us financially, and TBH I love homeschooling DD.

But yes, I can see that those who already have an established career damage it if they stop. However, many of us are limited in career prospects to begin with, don’t have careers to damage, or are unfortunately forced to be cleaners or checkout staff through necessity rafters than choice.

So when I look at my mum, or my SIL, and what they go through, and those around us, and then I see threads where people earning high wagers are complaining that they can’t do their nails or go on holiday, and I know that I’m in a worse position than they are and I have £700 spare in my budget, I just have to point out the real world of people struggling out there, and the blatant entitlement of wanting too much and not being willing to work for it.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 18:43

@TheLostGiraffe
Okay. I hope you are right and I am wrong.

I don't know why, because I am saying what I think a Government should do. As far as I can see neither the current lot or the opposition will do what I'm suggesting so things will likely continue to get increasingly worse.

I think you’ll find a more sympathetic government at the next election.

I wish this way true but even if the other lot get in we'll likely trade on bunch of ideological and ineffective nonsense policies for another and they still will ignore at least half of the problem. They are all cowards and do not have the sense of conviction to do what is needed because they are so desperate to remain popular.

Can I say, sincerely, that having slowed down and taken the time to explain to me how you see things, I appreciate it and I feel like I have benefitted from your insight.

That is really nice to hear. You don't have to agree with me of course but I appreciate that you listened and considered what I said. That is all any of us can do.

I will save and not go on holiday or put our heating on, because If you’re wrong I think my family will be all the better for starting our hard times early. Maybe it’s a fear play, and I am wrong. I hope so for everyone worse off than myself. As I say, we have no home of our own, and we’d like one one day.

Sadly I think you are correct in how things will play out. My point was just that there are other options, and that the false narrative that this or that person has to pay is madness when there are measures that could be taken that improve things for everyone, across the board. And maybe make it easier for you to get the home you want, without that needing to be at the expense of others losing theirs.

Its selfish, but a collapse in house prices may be the only chance we have of owning a cheap house, and retirement with no home leeks bleak to me.

I do understand your frustration. I have supported myself since I was a teenager and it is horrible the situation many people are in, including you.

Maybe we’ll turn up on the same thread in a year or two and you can tell me, ‘I told you so.’ I’ll take it on the chin and raise a glass to you. I hope so. If things other way round, I’ll have switched off my internet access by then.

I hope things get better for you, and for everyone, me included! I wish I had more hope that anybody would do the simple things that need to be done to make that a reality. Certainly would be no "I told you so", I'd be shocked if any Government actually implemented the policies needed. But I hope you manage to find a way through it all.

💐

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 18:28

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:21

I suspect the current thinking in Whitehall is that if they leave things as they are and ‘manage the decline’, as people slide into poverty the job openings will be filled by those who currently choose not to participate.

I can’t quite believe that there are millions of job openings and at the same time, millions of people who left the workforce during Covid and decided, fuck it, I’ll stay at home and live on benefits. There’s something not right about that picture.

Yes, I'm not sure that's an entirely accurate picture.

The biggest drop in workforce participation has been over 55s. That's been due to either early retirement, in which case there's not likely to be a lot of benefits involved and higher rates of long term sickness. They may well be getting benefits in that instance but it wouldn't be a choice.

Which isn't to say that the policy response won't look like bleating about top up benefits whilst doing the square root of fuck all about the shrinking of the childcare sector and the expense: the new policy proposals don't necessarily do anything about childcare businesses not being financially viable. I certainly can't imagine the Tories will engage in any acknowledgement at all that their decision to let people access pensions from aged 55 has led to some over 55s accessing their pensions.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:21

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 16:04

It's ultimately a question of whether we're prepared to provide sufficient state subsidy to increase the workforce participation of working parents or not. The rest is tinkering round the sides.

I suspect the current thinking in Whitehall is that if they leave things as they are and ‘manage the decline’, as people slide into poverty the job openings will be filled by those who currently choose not to participate.

I can’t quite believe that there are millions of job openings and at the same time, millions of people who left the workforce during Covid and decided, fuck it, I’ll stay at home and live on benefits. There’s something not right about that picture.

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 18:20

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:01

... and no, I most definitely are not telling anyone how to work. I’d suggest staying at home with your kids and saving the cost of childcare and a second car and all that jazz. It makes life A LOT cheaper clearly.

It also damages long term earning potential. I got a pay rise of 19k this year. Women who give up their jobs to save on childcare nwoild miss out on three or four years of career progression which could translate to many tens of thousands over the years. How many cold nights does one have to endure to make that up..

Honestly as someone who bought, earnings make the biggest difference, not saving. The reason why we can even think of upgrading now is because we have increased our earnings since 2019 ( salaries in our sector financial services have grown 15% since 2019)... And we go on 6 foreign holidays per year. No car though and no new tech by and large. Inequality is such that it is very difficult to buy a property by saving alone. The only reason why we bought is because DH was earning in excess of 50k when we bought and that is above London median. Most home owners (in late 2019/2022) earn in excess of the median wherever they live. Even those that move miles out. The bank decides how much you borrow based mainly on what you earn and not how much you spend on restaurants and the like. Even with high interest rates, the biggest difference is earnings. In

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:08

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 17:47

A collapse in house prices is only good if you are a cash buyer or have a lot of equity/a big deposit. It's not great for most typical FTBs who only have a 10% deposit.

I might be wrong but I think your budget was 150k (I might have misremembered). At that level, if it fell 50k, and you have a 20k deposit, I expect that you would have been able to afford to buy previously and not rent so any savings made from waiting would be marginal. So a house price crash does not benefit you as much as a wealthy FTB with a £1 million budget for a mansion flat in Kensington. I expect those can fall 30% and such buyers would have big deposits anyway so could save a lot of money..

I’m hoping to have a £25-30K deposit on a £120-130K house. As I see it that’d be a £100K mortgage at more that 20% down, and I think we can service that debt (at a stretch) for 5 years even if the interest rate hit 15%.

The house price decline thing is merely a hope that current houses outside of what we can afford drop into our affordability bracket. I.e. we get a better house for our money than what we are currently looking at.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 18:01

... and no, I most definitely are not telling anyone how to work. I’d suggest staying at home with your kids and saving the cost of childcare and a second car and all that jazz. It makes life A LOT cheaper clearly.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 17:58

Birdsbirdsbirds · 14/02/2023 15:28

As we both know, the welfare system is a big bag of shit. It doesn't really work. If it did, this thread probably wouldn't exist.

Nobody has mentioned a right to a new car, so why you're harping on about that I don't know. I haven't mentioned any of the other shite either. I was referring to your comment about the life a cleaner deserves. Clearly you don't think they deserve much, rich coming from someone who doesn't work at all.

I do work, I live and I save. You don't work, and yet you're lecturing others on how to do it. Read the room.

The discussion was about couples earning more than the national median wage, above the welfare state threshold with is what? £40K and above? more? And the fact that, due to their family choices, they can cover all their essential bills, but can not afford to go on holiday or get their nails done etc.

OP hasn’t disclosed income or expenses, but it’s probably comparable to mine, and I posted a breakdown of our income and expenses to show that on £44K a year, also not entitled to benefits, and with only one tax allowance instead of two, we still have a spare £700 a month of which we save £500.

So the problem is not the income at all. The problem is the budget. OP’s gripe is that they don’t have enough spare money to spend on what they want, because they are already spending all the sale money they do have on other things they want.

I drew the comparison to a cleaner on minimum wage living on benefits, because this whole thread is about higher than median household justifying what they should be able to have this or that because they work for it.

Well the maths proves that they don’t, or that they want too much, or that they just don’t understand maths.

Things are going to get a lot worse before they get better, and as @TheLostGiraffe has gone to great pains to point out to me, we can fix this thing. But that’s a good few years away of steady or accelerated decline.

And all the affronted justification of why people are entitled to this or entitled to that, in a world where no one owes anyone a living, only serves to make already unhappy people more stressed and more happy because it perpetuates their entitlement mentalities.

socialmedia23 · 14/02/2023 17:47

ElliF · 14/02/2023 17:31

@TheLostGiraffe
Okay. I hope you are right and I am wrong.
I think you’ll find a more sympathetic government at the next election.
Can I say, sincerely, that having slowed down and taken the time to explain to me how you see things, I appreciate it and I feel like I have benefitted from your insight.

I will save and not go on holiday or put our heating on, because If you’re wrong I think my family will be all the better for starting our hard times early. Maybe it’s a fear play, and I am wrong. I hope so for everyone worse off than myself. As I say, we have no home of our own, and we’d like one one day.

Its selfish, but a collapse in house prices may be the only chance we have of owning a cheap house, and retirement with no home leeks bleak to me.

Maybe we’ll turn up on the same thread in a year or two and you can tell me, ‘I told you so.’ I’ll take it on the chin and raise a glass to you. I hope so. If things other way round, I’ll have switched off my internet access by then.

💐

A collapse in house prices is only good if you are a cash buyer or have a lot of equity/a big deposit. It's not great for most typical FTBs who only have a 10% deposit.

I might be wrong but I think your budget was 150k (I might have misremembered). At that level, if it fell 50k, and you have a 20k deposit, I expect that you would have been able to afford to buy previously and not rent so any savings made from waiting would be marginal. So a house price crash does not benefit you as much as a wealthy FTB with a £1 million budget for a mansion flat in Kensington. I expect those can fall 30% and such buyers would have big deposits anyway so could save a lot of money..

ElliF · 14/02/2023 17:31

@TheLostGiraffe
Okay. I hope you are right and I am wrong.
I think you’ll find a more sympathetic government at the next election.
Can I say, sincerely, that having slowed down and taken the time to explain to me how you see things, I appreciate it and I feel like I have benefitted from your insight.

I will save and not go on holiday or put our heating on, because If you’re wrong I think my family will be all the better for starting our hard times early. Maybe it’s a fear play, and I am wrong. I hope so for everyone worse off than myself. As I say, we have no home of our own, and we’d like one one day.

Its selfish, but a collapse in house prices may be the only chance we have of owning a cheap house, and retirement with no home leeks bleak to me.

Maybe we’ll turn up on the same thread in a year or two and you can tell me, ‘I told you so.’ I’ll take it on the chin and raise a glass to you. I hope so. If things other way round, I’ll have switched off my internet access by then.

💐

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 17:31

I mean I don't doubt that is the Government's plan - to try to inflate away the mess they have created to the detriment of everybody who lives in the UK - that of course will be their idea of the solution. But it's the worst possible answer for UK citizens so people should be telling them "no" and insisting they actually fix the mess they have created.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 17:16

And what you are advocating by "inflating the way out of the problem", let's be clear, is to make everyone progressively poorer year on year for the foreseeable future. More cuts to services, more expensive food and energy every year, higher taxes every year, shitter education and healthcare every year and probably state pensions disappearing entirely.

I think my solution of raising productivity is far better.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 17:11

And no, it wouldn't require anywhere near the amount of money that the Government pissed away on Covid. Interesting though that before that they spend a decade saying that there was no money for them to make these necessary investments..

You are blaming Keynes? I am not a fan personally but if you know anything about his work surely you know that he would not have implemented an austerity program during a recession where there was pretty much zero inflation and you could borrow at negative interest rates?! What a bizarre comment.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 17:03

Economies do not work like personal finances. Again, you show you have a complete lack of understanding of economics. A government refusing to invest in its economy simply increases private sector debt. A Government making strategic investments in appropriate and viable projects means that the Government also makes its money back plus a profit, while also encouraging business investment which creates higher value jobs and raises salaries and living standards. This is fact and has been demonstrated over and over again in countries around the world.

The alternative - because the UK cannot meet the costs if its already very poor services from its tax revenue - is to continue that spiral as our population ages and requires even more cost with fewer and fewer people to pay for it. Who do you think will continue to invest their money into that? That balance of payments deficit is already 8% GDP. If productivity is not raised, living standards will continue to decline. The only way productivity will be increased is by the Government (whatever one we have!) investing in the infrastructure to make large scale business investment viable again, removing the artificial trade barriers with our trading partners that they have erected, and removing the barriers to people participating in the labour market by removing the disincentives through these ridiculous thresholds in the tax system for imposing taxes/ removal of childcare support, at every level of earnings, plus also equalising tax so that all households are taxed the same on the same household income.

I am certain that if these policies were implemented productivity (and salaries and living standards) would quickly increase. I've explained why. If you have a better idea, please do say so.

ElliF · 14/02/2023 16:31

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 15:17

You call it ‘borrowing’ but you are mischaracterising what is happening though. Governments don’t ‘borrow’ anything. They print Treasury Bonds and sell the to the Bank of England, and the BoE prints money (figuratively) and gives it to them in exchange for the Treasury Bonds.

This is also wrong. What you are talking about is QE. We also sell bonds to international markets for financing.

It is still debt creation, and you’re advocating using it as the solution to solving a debt problem. It’s no different to just getting a different credit card with a different bank.

If that works, then the solution to everyone’s financial problems is simple. Just put it on the credit card and when you can’t do that anymore, get a new credit card or go and take out payday loans.

The only reason people don’t do that is because they are not dumb, and we have credit reference agencies to try to stop the stupid.

Using debt to get out of debt when you are £2.5Trillion in debt is asinine. We’ve nearly doubled the national debt since 2008, and most of it in the past three years. And your solution is what? Fuck it, just double it again!

The best the UK can hope for (as a nation) is to inflate our way out of the problem, and to do so in a controlled manner. That means higher interest rates and higher food prices. A lot of people are going to suffer, and a lot of people are going to lose their homes.

At this late stage in our little Keynesian fiat money experiment, the best any any of us can do is stop wasting money on wants, buy the best needs we can afford, and save whatever we have left somewhere that won’t be eaten up by inflation.

We invented this system remember. Keynes was British born and bred. We have a lot to answer for.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 16:26

buildingourdreams · 14/02/2023 16:06

But not everyone will get high paying jobs by 37 or whatever. Because somebody has to do the minimum wage jobs, don't they

@Birdsbirdsbirds

This exactly !!! While I hope I will improve my earnings as I get older - not everyone can / will .

So what will become of those who don't "move up" from minimum wage ? Does society just think well fuck them it's tough shit?

I agree, exactly the point I've been arguing. Instead of fighting over who is more deserving people should be asking why the UK is doing so much worse than its competitors on living standards and salaries for the same jobs and asking politicians to implement the policies that will change that.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 16:23

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 16:04

It's ultimately a question of whether we're prepared to provide sufficient state subsidy to increase the workforce participation of working parents or not. The rest is tinkering round the sides.

Again from even an objective uncaring and purely economic point of view, from a state perspective it is WAY cheaper to provide the childcare heavily subsidised/ free and not lose so many mothers from the workforce then have to support them not just during childbearing years but also in retirement, and have many never reach their earning potential as a result so lower tax revenue. That's why other countries do it: it's been proved to be good economic sense. But this requires a long-term view, which our Governments never take hence our situation.

CottonSock · 14/02/2023 16:22

I was poor in my 20s and with two young kids I would have been poorer. You may not change career, but as you become more senior your pay will rise. Seek out any extra training they can offer e.g colouring. Think about if you could offer to get involved with any running of the salon.
Good luck. I'm an older mum (kids same age) and has its benefits in terms of my pay, but disadvantages in terms of other things.

TheLostGiraffe · 14/02/2023 16:19

I have contacted my MP about the cost of living, when the nursery my child attended closed down when they announced the new minimum wage rate. She assured me labour were doing all they could but realistically, what does that equate to?

They are making a lot of noise saying that they plan to make childcare more affordable, while also without reducing adult: child ratios as Liz Truss proposed as it was very clear the public do not support that. I believe the shadow minister went to Estonia (which has a well-run Government in general and a very good childcare system) to get "ideas". But there they do have very much lower ratios, to make it viable. Although the staff are degree-level educated. But it is a very different culture. They need to be looking at what has been proven to work in the childcare systems in many different countries, we do not need to reinvent the wheel here. Denmark, Sweden, Germany... even many eastern European countries have a more viable system that works and is affordable. Hugely state subsidised in all cases of comparable countries, even if you want to look at Canada or Australia. Not from the goodness of their hearts, but because it makes economic sense, to make the maximum constribution per month a couple of hundred pounds per child. You then save tens of thousands of pounds per child in the longer term by increased tax revenues from parents (mainly mothers) not having their careers trashed as not financially viable, the cost of which goes on until old age and insufficient pensions! Decreases equality, better outcomes for children...

But they have announced no policies on how they will fix this. They are just as useless IMO. Or what they will do for children with SEN. Or about schools. Or about the issues with the tax system penalising single parents. Completely useless.