Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disagreement over glitter on toys

113 replies

Thatglitter · 12/02/2023 10:48

I would like to know who IBU between DH and me. We have two little girls, 4 and 2.

For various reasons I thought yesterday that they deserved a treat. I took oldest to the toy shop and let her choose something for her and her sister. She saw a little fairy doll - her eyes lit up, you know the drill. So I bought one each for her and her sister. She was SO happy with it and she still is. Little sister loves hers too.

I did not inspect the material of the dolls' dresses before buying them. I hold my hands up to this. I wanted her to have something she really wanted - she isn't often taken to the toy shop to pick out something. This was my error.

So it turns out the overlayer of the fairies' dresses has annoying glitter that sheds. Both DH and I are tidy by nature but he can take it too far (I feel) and I have expressed concern in the past that I don't want the girls feeling on edge about creating mess or playing at home, in what I perceive to be a normal way. Put another way, I can tolerate more mess and am accepting of the need to tidy and clean up around young children. Housework is quite evenly split between DH and me with me doing more of the day to day and him doing a blitz over the weekend.

So DH has now had a low voice rant to me about the fairies and wants to cut their sparkly dresses off them. This would leave them with a cotton dress underneath but the sparkle is the main thing that makes them fairies, and the things both girls love about them.

I've said a flat out no so it's not happening. I've said I'm happy to have them as downstairs toys and when the novelty wears off them they could probably go on a shelf in each girl's bedroom.

DH is very concerned about air quality if that changes things. We have air purifiers in all bedrooms, he won't have a wood burner etc.

I'm feeling angry. I feel sad he can't turn a blind eye to the glitter when he sees the enjoyment the girls are getting. I do agree glitter is annoying but I feel he takes it to the extreme. He'll be tense now when they're playing with them and I feel like it sucks the joy out for us all. They won't play with them forever and they won't be little forever either.

YABU - get rid of the glitter

YANBU - keep the glitter

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JonahAndTheSnail · 13/02/2023 16:25

YANBU. I'm sure the girls aren't planning on eating the dresses! I expect they'd ingest far more microplastics drinking from a plastic bottle than what would shed accidently from the dolls onto their bed and accidently get swallowed or inhaled. From a mess POV, even if both dolls shed every speck of glitter onto the floor it's not going to amount to more than a teaspoons worth.

Hopefully he manages to get the help he needs to be less anxious.

BruceAndNosh · 13/02/2023 15:36

I'm greatly amused at how many posters are saying "suck it up" as a solution to glitter

SirVixofVixHall · 13/02/2023 11:21

3487642l · 12/02/2023 10:54

It sounds like your husband is either very controlling or has some form of disorder like ocd that is impacting on his life and needs treatment.

I agree with this. The amount of glitter must be tiny ! Nothing like the amount that would inevitably come from making Christmas cards or something.
I try and be careful with glitter as I worry about micro plastics, so for play I bought eco glitter. A fairy doll though.. the glitter and sparkle are what makes the doll so enticing. As a child and still as an adult I love sparkle. I would have been so delighted with a fairy doll as little girl.
Your husband sounds really obsessive in that he can’t allow the joy of seeing a happy small child playing with a new toy, to makeup for a worry about “mess” , which in reality will be a minute amount of glitter .

WhoNeedsSleepNotISaidMyBody · 13/02/2023 11:13

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 12/02/2023 12:21

I would brush it to remove loose glitter then spray it with a non-toxic, clear lacquer spray for fabrics.

Also get a four-inch diameter cork for DH's mouth.

@TwoLeftSocksWithHoles

i do enjoy your posts! That wasn't where I thought you were going to suggest she put the cork!!

it made me laugh when you said you hadn't namechanged on the holey socks thread!!

@Thatglitter if he's that worried about inhaling micro plastics I suggest you put him in a hermetically sealed room!

WimpoleHat · 13/02/2023 11:13

lollipoprainbow · 13/02/2023 07:59

The dolls weren't what I was expecting ! I was visualising a hard doll wearing something very very glittery that my dd once had. They look very tame in comparison and hardly full of glitter.

Agreed, @lollipoprainbow - they look like beautiful, high quality toys. I was imagining some poundshop knockoff Elsa doll with glitter glue sprayed on it which came off with every movement! (And even then, so what - my kids loved those in their day!). A bizarrely extreme reaction from your DH; glad you’ve spoken to him about it.

CrazyLadie · 13/02/2023 10:55

WhoNeedsSleepNotISaidMyBody · 12/02/2023 11:39

@Mumoffairy the solution isn't to ruin the kids toys! These dresses won't be the only messy thing two small girls have!

@Thatglitter You need to have a serious talk to him when he's not wound up. He needs to see how unreadable he's being, how stifling and unfair. He needs to not put it down to his quickly bit of OCD, but realise it's serious & he needs help. Proper help.

(For me) he would need to understand that it's something HE has to fix & quickly, because I would NOT continue raising my children in this environment or living in it myself.

watch for your own behaviour too, my cousin is very +very* house proud (?). When her girls were growing up you'd never have known that 2 girls & a golden retriever lived in the house, looked show home 24/7/365. Both her adult daughters have issues.

My Mum likes a spotless house, don't get me wrong we were allowed to make a mess but everything was put away when we were finished. I like a lived in house where ya can see a family and messy child live there, ya want yer kids to remberer the fun you has with them, they won't remember a messy house

percypig82 · 13/02/2023 08:59

Sorry, but I think the issue is with your DH and OCD (and I don't mean this in a flippant way as I suffer from forms of OCD myself). Don't let him cut the dresses off. If he can't cope with glitter in the house, the issue is his.

CupidCantAimStraight · 13/02/2023 08:58

Glitter is the herpes of the craft world - it can be impossible to get rid of - but he still sounds miserable as fuck.

He's completely right about the wood burners though. 5-10 years from now people will be ripping them out on air quality grounds.

lollipoprainbow · 13/02/2023 07:59

The dolls weren't what I was expecting ! I was visualising a hard doll wearing something very very glittery that my dd once had. They look very tame in comparison and hardly full of glitter.

Soubriquet · 12/02/2023 22:17

Oh god. Let the girls take their dollies to bed for gods sake.

Stop pandering to your husband.

BertieBotts · 12/02/2023 22:07

Really messed up?! It's just glitter ffs Confused

JudgeRudy · 12/02/2023 22:03

I would hate this. I think you've really messed up by not noticing but it's done now and on balance it would do the most harm if the dresses were destroyed.
Why not try a squib of hairspray or even make up 'setter'

pictoosh · 12/02/2023 21:26

I mean fgs. Get a grip the pair of you.

pictoosh · 12/02/2023 21:25

You're still pandering to his shite by not letting the girls take the dollies to bed.

Johnnysgirl · 12/02/2023 20:07

Such a palaver Hmm. There's a finite amount of glitter that can possibly be shed from those dolls. It's hardly like emptying a bucket of the stuff. Wtf?
You sound nearly as bad as he is.

Thatglitter · 12/02/2023 19:57

So I've spoken to him - I asked if he could see that it wasn't a normal response to some glitter. To be honest he couldn't really and started distinguishing it from situations like where they do arts and crafts with glitter etc.

The issue is definitely the control aspect - like with an activity he can control where it goes and clean up afterwards. With these toys the glitter is all over the house.

I told him I'm worried for the future and him projecting this anxiety onto the girls. I can tell he is hurt because he works hard not to let them see when he is struggling with some "tendency" towards cleanliness - but it is what it is and he needed to hear it. I've asked him to make a GP appointment and he's agreed.

I told him that if he cut the glittery material off the dresses that it would be something they'd remember forever, etc. He accepted that and said that's why he came to me with the idea as a suggestion. He's not a dickhead he won't insist (and nor would I agree) to something like that. It was more that the mere suggestion set alarm bells ringing in my head.

I think where we've got to is that he sees the potential ocd is an issue, but probably not in the context of this glitter disagreement specifically. Anyway I'm glad I've spoken to him about it as I wouldn't be doing right by my girls not to.

In respect of the dolls, they will be put to bed downstairs so we don't get glitter all over their beds etc. This is the main issue for DH, the microplastics thing. On a practical level everyone can live with that.

OP posts:
Getthefiregoing · 12/02/2023 17:54

PinkElephantsInLemonade · 12/02/2023 14:11

Just so you are aware op, deliberately damaging a toy is a well known illustration of abuse used in safeguarding training.
Usually the example of burning a teddy is given, but your situation is also a bit of a red flag. If this is our of character your DH needs to get help before it escalates. If it's not out of character I'd be very worried for your kids as that sounds like emotional abuse.

Absolutely this. Toys and even the smallest silly little trinkets are so precious to children. It would be incredibly cruel to do anything to them.

StephanieSuperpowers · 12/02/2023 17:10

It's important to not allow your husband to use something that's good (environmental awareness) to bully and control the children.

purpledalmation · 12/02/2023 17:00

Your DH is taking the eco purity side too seriously. I get the glitter and sequin argument, but they've been bought so that's the end of it.

Goodadvice1980 · 12/02/2023 16:41

Your dh sounds like an insufferable bore, let the dc’s enjoy their toys!

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 12/02/2023 16:38

Tell him to suck it up.

It won’t be long before someone gives them a gift set of 10,000 tiny beads to string that will get dropped on the floor and you’ll still be finding them 10 weeks later….

Dogcafedreamer · 12/02/2023 16:35

WiIson · 12/02/2023 16:28

Dogcafedreamer. Brilliant. I remember.

Oh I remember those, always so sad 😞

WiIson · 12/02/2023 16:28

Dogcafedreamer. Brilliant. I remember.

Robin233 · 12/02/2023 16:14

Ok
Give it a week and most of the glitter will have gone.
My little one had strap on fairy wings from grandma one Christmas
She was 4 I think
She looked great running around with matching fairy wand
Anyway it became quite apparent that said fairy wings shed fairy dust - I mean glitter

It was amazing where you found it. Dh wasn't bother
I'm very house proud but found it amusing
She had so much fun with those wings
It hoovered up in the weekly sweep
Soon they were relegated to bottom of the toy box.
I did say when we've moved the next owners would still be finding it.
So this ti will pass

Dogcafedreamer · 12/02/2023 15:35

Everyone on here is possibly younger than me...

But this would've been a classic Simon Bates Our Tune story.....

I remember I was five years old, I'd got an excellent school report and so has my sister. As a rare treat our DM took us to a toy shop. We were never really allowed free choice in a toy shop, this was a very special treat.

We both chose the loveliest dolls that matched, chosen because we both loved the glitter on their dresses, something not really allowed in our house. We were never allowed glitter in arts and crafts, our dad was concerned about "air quality".

We took these prized dolls home with us, it was clear that dad was not pleased, we could hear his cross voice ranting at mum. We both sat quietly holding our dolls tight.

But dad wouldn't let this drop and despite mum protesting, he insisted that he cut their dresses off and so the glitter was gone and we had two plain dolls with nothing looking nice. Honestly, to us two little girls, the entire joy of those dolls was gone, they were never played with again and neither of us ever forgot those scissors taking off their beautiful sparkly dresses.

This story would then be followed by a very sad song..