Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I read it?

156 replies

TinaTeaspoons · 12/02/2023 10:47

Been worried about sister of late.
She has chronic health issues but are well controlled but seems unhappy and fed up. She is approaching 40, no kids, lives with our mum and stepdad and is single.
Was meant to be seeing a friend for dinner the other night, they cancelled and seems to have sent her into an even worse mood.
She does work as a outreach worker (ironically) but only does part time.
I was in the house alone last night and not proud of this
but I read her diary. She had not hidden it well but I know that's not an excuse.
Basically it had me in tears. She wrote about what a failure she is, what an embarrassment to the family she has become, how she gets used by everyone, and is invisible to us all and about her loneliness and how she has nobody to really chat to and other more disturbing info that I cant write here.
So what do I do now? Admit I read it and ruin our relationship or what?
I have felt on the verge of tears ever since which I know is my fault but I just knew she wouldn't open up to me. Again, I know that isn't an excuse. I haven't even told DH. Just don't know what to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Phatgurlslym · 13/02/2023 12:58

We don’t actually know what the “other disturbing things” are. Might be extreme to OP but not so much to others.

Most of us are more concerned about the violation because it vindicates the sister’s view that her family doesn’t treat her like an equal or with respect. Thank

also the reaction the OP got on here is a demonstration of how people react to your written words and give what they think is honest feedback in response. It might make her think very deeply about how she will approach and treat her sister going forward.

Lavender14 · 12/02/2023 22:46

I wouldn't tell her you read it as she would feel betrayed and embarrassed on top of whatever else she is already feeling and I don't think much good would come from it. I'd try to actively include her and invest in her and encourage her to tell you herself

echt · 12/02/2023 22:43

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 22:33

Absolutely spot on. She has posted that she knew it was wrong and asked for advice as to what to do with the information she has as a result - information that includes an indication that her sister intends to harm herself. In response, the majority of posters have declined to give any advice at all, in favour of putting the boot in because she read the diary, and infighting with anyone who dared to suggest that the sisters’ wellbeing was the most important thing.

And have you noticed something ? Has anyone noticed it ? The OP hasn’t been back since 12.30 this afternoon. And I don’t blame her. One look at some of the awful, judgmental things that have been written from folk who clearly care more about the ‘betrayal’ of reading her diary than what actually happens to her obviously vulnerable sister, should have told her that MN is not the place to post about such things. If the intention was to make the OP feel worse than she already did, then congratulations because that’s clearly what’s happened.

The OP did not ask for advice as to what to do, only about should she tell her sister about having read the diary. So yes, that's what posters focussed on.

NoodleC · 12/02/2023 22:43

Gymnopedie · 12/02/2023 13:33

Tell her you are struggling and you know she is working part time but would she have time to help out a bit at yours. Say i need help to get sorted and you are so good at xyz.

There's this and one further upthread about asking her to baby sit. I get that it's trying to make her feel involved and valued, but if as she writes in her diary she feels like everyone uses her that isn't the best place to start. Fun social things, coffees, shopping, days out are the first things.

Hi i see your point of view, i did not think about her feeling used. Thanks for mentioning it as i would hate to make it worse, i hope the OP ignores my original post. Cheers hun 👍

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 22:33

keeprunning55 · 12/02/2023 21:22

@DuplicateUserName

Yes, and she clearly regrets it. I would call that a mistake. It’s not the main issue is it. She is worried about her sister.
People steal, lie, commit much worse than the op and make awful decisions in life-I expect most of them feel it was a mistake.

Absolutely spot on. She has posted that she knew it was wrong and asked for advice as to what to do with the information she has as a result - information that includes an indication that her sister intends to harm herself. In response, the majority of posters have declined to give any advice at all, in favour of putting the boot in because she read the diary, and infighting with anyone who dared to suggest that the sisters’ wellbeing was the most important thing.

And have you noticed something ? Has anyone noticed it ? The OP hasn’t been back since 12.30 this afternoon. And I don’t blame her. One look at some of the awful, judgmental things that have been written from folk who clearly care more about the ‘betrayal’ of reading her diary than what actually happens to her obviously vulnerable sister, should have told her that MN is not the place to post about such things. If the intention was to make the OP feel worse than she already did, then congratulations because that’s clearly what’s happened.

keeprunning55 · 12/02/2023 21:22

@DuplicateUserName

Yes, and she clearly regrets it. I would call that a mistake. It’s not the main issue is it. She is worried about her sister.
People steal, lie, commit much worse than the op and make awful decisions in life-I expect most of them feel it was a mistake.

DrManhattan · 12/02/2023 21:19

@keeprunning55 no way is that a mistake. Its a horrible thing to do and then compound it by telling further people.

DuplicateUserName · 12/02/2023 20:17

keeprunning55 · 12/02/2023 20:11

There are harsh reactions on here about you reading her diary. Everyone makes mistakes.

Don’t tell her, but do all that you can to support her.

It wasn't a mistake, it was a deliberate act that the OP knew was wrong, but did it anyway.

keeprunning55 · 12/02/2023 20:11

There are harsh reactions on here about you reading her diary. Everyone makes mistakes.

Don’t tell her, but do all that you can to support her.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 19:56

Stravaig · 12/02/2023 19:10

or am I some dinosaur for having a loving and trusting relationship and regarding my partner as a confidante with whom I can trust anything ?

You are confusing trusting your DH with any confidence about yourself, which is entirely your choice; and telling your DH private information about another person, which you obtained without their consent, in a complete betrayal of their trust in you. Which is the OP's scenario.

OP violated her sister's trust by reading her diary; then OP violated her sister again by publishing the gist of what she read on the internet; and now you recommend a third violation, that OP share her sister's private thoughts with her DH.

I remove people with incontinent boundaries from my life. I recommend to OP's sister that she do the same. If OP genuinely cared about her sister this thread would not exist.

If I were the OP and my ‘incontinent boundaries’ meant that I stopped my sister from harming herself, then so be it. Depends on whether you prioritise what is and isn’t ethical over the physical well being of someone you love.

butterfliedtwo · 12/02/2023 19:45

Stravaig · 12/02/2023 19:10

or am I some dinosaur for having a loving and trusting relationship and regarding my partner as a confidante with whom I can trust anything ?

You are confusing trusting your DH with any confidence about yourself, which is entirely your choice; and telling your DH private information about another person, which you obtained without their consent, in a complete betrayal of their trust in you. Which is the OP's scenario.

OP violated her sister's trust by reading her diary; then OP violated her sister again by publishing the gist of what she read on the internet; and now you recommend a third violation, that OP share her sister's private thoughts with her DH.

I remove people with incontinent boundaries from my life. I recommend to OP's sister that she do the same. If OP genuinely cared about her sister this thread would not exist.

All of this. Absolutely. Get the thread removed, so the media doesn't pick it up. Your poor sister.

007DoubleOSeven · 12/02/2023 19:39

"incontinent boundaries" is exactly how to describe some people @Stravaig

Stravaig · 12/02/2023 19:10

or am I some dinosaur for having a loving and trusting relationship and regarding my partner as a confidante with whom I can trust anything ?

You are confusing trusting your DH with any confidence about yourself, which is entirely your choice; and telling your DH private information about another person, which you obtained without their consent, in a complete betrayal of their trust in you. Which is the OP's scenario.

OP violated her sister's trust by reading her diary; then OP violated her sister again by publishing the gist of what she read on the internet; and now you recommend a third violation, that OP share her sister's private thoughts with her DH.

I remove people with incontinent boundaries from my life. I recommend to OP's sister that she do the same. If OP genuinely cared about her sister this thread would not exist.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 19:09

saraclara · 12/02/2023 19:00

You were actively encouraging OP to share this with her DH. It's bad enough that one person, the OP, has read this vey private diary. Yet you think she should share it further with her DH?

We’ll have to agree to disagree as we obviously have different priorities. The OP has read something to the effect that her sister is thinking of harming herself, so that would be my priority above everything else, and in a similar situation I would trust my DH enough to disclose and ask for his advice. As I said, it depends on the relationship with DH, and no, if told something in confidence, I would not disclose to DH. Different situation altogether.

saraclara · 12/02/2023 19:00

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 18:50

How have you got to that from what I said ? If someone asks me to keep something confidential I do - it’s not repeated to anyone, DH included. How is that relevant to this situation - I was talking about the OP sharing the information she had found with her DH in the knowledge that it would go no further and she would have trusted input into what to do with the knowledge she had. I despair of MN sometimes - do none of you trust your partners, or am I some dinosaur for having a loving and trusting relationship and regarding my partner as a confidante with whom I can trust anything ?

You were actively encouraging OP to share this with her DH. It's bad enough that one person, the OP, has read this vey private diary. Yet you think she should share it further with her DH?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 18:50

saraclara · 12/02/2023 18:38

My DH is the one person on earth I can tell anything to without fear of being judged and in the knowledge that it would be completely confidential.

Anyone who told their DH something that I'd kept private would get my absolute fury and I'd have nothing to do with them again @DotAndCarryOne2

It's an appalling thing to do. Absolutely appalling.

How have you got to that from what I said ? If someone asks me to keep something confidential I do - it’s not repeated to anyone, DH included. How is that relevant to this situation - I was talking about the OP sharing the information she had found with her DH in the knowledge that it would go no further and she would have trusted input into what to do with the knowledge she had. I despair of MN sometimes - do none of you trust your partners, or am I some dinosaur for having a loving and trusting relationship and regarding my partner as a confidante with whom I can trust anything ?

saraclara · 12/02/2023 18:38

My DH is the one person on earth I can tell anything to without fear of being judged and in the knowledge that it would be completely confidential.

Anyone who told their DH something that I'd kept private would get my absolute fury and I'd have nothing to do with them again @DotAndCarryOne2

It's an appalling thing to do. Absolutely appalling.

airfryerandelectricblanket · 12/02/2023 17:37

My teenage daughter keeps a diary.

Although we get on well and are very close, it's probably got some not very nice things about me in it from those days I tell her she can't do something etc!

I don't want to read it as I could get upset too!!!!

IDontWantToBeAPie · 12/02/2023 17:33

Never every say you've read it. Just act on what you've learned and try to do more with her, be more loving, little gifts of the 'oh I just saw it and it made me think of you' etc. tell her you're proud of her whenever she does something new/an achievement

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 16:36

ThreeRingCircus · 12/02/2023 16:28

What you did was absolutely awful, and I can see why your sister doesn't talk to you about important stuff or come to you for help if you're the sort of person who can invade someone's privacy like that then even consider telling them you did it. That's all about you and your guilt.

Feeling guilty and having to keep quiet about what you did and never tell another soul is in my opinion, your punishment for breaking her trust like that. You're just going to have to suck it up.

All you can do now is use that knowledge to try and support her as much as you can and be there for her.

So you missed the part about how concerned the OP is for her sisters’ mental health, and the fact that there may be self harm involved ?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 16:34

rubberduckiee · 12/02/2023 16:25

@DotAndCarryOne2 Just re-read and understand now. You were aiming at me for what I said about telling her DH. I think it says more about you than me

This is getting ridiculous and I'm going to stop replying to you. No one is "aiming at" you, no one is bullying you 🙄🙄🙄 I hadn't even seen your comment about your DH or whatever. You quoted me in some kind of rant, I replied you and then tagged you in an immediate follow up to add more context.

No, it wasn’t a rant and I never suggested at any point that anyone was bullying me. Your quote above cut off the most relevant part of what I said, so yes, I think we should leave our exchange there and draw a line under it because we’re clearly at odds and in danger of derailing the thread.

ThreeRingCircus · 12/02/2023 16:28

What you did was absolutely awful, and I can see why your sister doesn't talk to you about important stuff or come to you for help if you're the sort of person who can invade someone's privacy like that then even consider telling them you did it. That's all about you and your guilt.

Feeling guilty and having to keep quiet about what you did and never tell another soul is in my opinion, your punishment for breaking her trust like that. You're just going to have to suck it up.

All you can do now is use that knowledge to try and support her as much as you can and be there for her.

rubberduckiee · 12/02/2023 16:25

@DotAndCarryOne2 Just re-read and understand now. You were aiming at me for what I said about telling her DH. I think it says more about you than me

This is getting ridiculous and I'm going to stop replying to you. No one is "aiming at" you, no one is bullying you 🙄🙄🙄 I hadn't even seen your comment about your DH or whatever. You quoted me in some kind of rant, I replied you and then tagged you in an immediate follow up to add more context.

SerafinasGoose · 12/02/2023 16:24

Apologies. My autocorrect has apparently decided it doesn't know what an adverb is. I meant 'unfailingly', not 'unfailing', on both counts!

rubberduckiee · 12/02/2023 16:22

DotAndCarryOne2 · 12/02/2023 16:06

Treating people as worthy equals – even if on the face of it, they're not – is one of the best things you can do for mental health. Don’t know what you mean by that. At all. One of the best things you can do for mental health is provide an environment where the sufferer can feel supported enough to open up about their issues and not judged in any way - certainly not as not a worthy equal ‘even on the face of it’.

The OP had concerns about her sister and read her diary, which she probably wouldn’t have done had she not been concerned. She didn’t say she ‘faced planted’ into her sisters’ diary ‘accidentally’ - she admitted she’d read it. Why do you assume she would be ‘intrusive and patronising’ given that they are closely related and she is so worried about her - even more so now that there is evidence that may relate to self harm ? I think this is more your subjective interpretation than mine

Well yes, we both clearly have different views (including about how to treat people), which is what threads and forums are for. You first policed my comment and I was merely providing context as to why I provided that suggestion. Again, we clearly have different views as to what kind of basic respect to treat others with, so this is an unproductive conversation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread