Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who would want to be a teacher now?

342 replies

Painauchocolats · 12/02/2023 08:13

I've just read an article (found on the DM) that a 53 year old teacher has taken her own life before she was due to appear in court for accidentally catching a pupil's hair. This was whilst she tried to confiscate the girl's mobile phone.

A male teacher (also in the DM) faces being struck off for shouting 'Who the hell do you think you are?" At some pupils who filmed tik toks during his lesson, and slammed his hand on the desk.

Sometimes teachers lose their temper, especially if this behaviour is incessant. Who can blame them? This is why pupils' behaviour is so poor these days, because there are no consequences, and because of things like this.

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 12/02/2023 12:20

Last week a colleague was made to have a restorative with a teen who has threatened to get their dad in to beat her up and get her sacked. All the teacher did was follow the school policy, and got a barrage of abuse.

Yep, I was on-call in a school one day and was called on the walkie-talkie to remove a student from a lesson for exactly this. Mouthful of abuse to an incredibly lovely teacher who was just calmly following the behaviour policy. The girl then said her dad was coming in that day (to see the Head yet again about her behaviour), so she would get him to beat the teacher up. Teacher and I both reported the incident in full. Nothing was done, because the student had apparently already reached the maximum amount of days of exclusion. The school wanted to permanently exclude her, but it was turned down on appeal.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 12:18

Parents should back up school but we All know that doesn't happen

Re phones in class, how can parents police that.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 12:16

It would be much easier all around if the government simply put a stop to phones in classrooms and tried to make school a phone free space.

Bring it into ofsted to make slt do something about it a d make it slt issue.
. With proper back up.

It's ridiculous to even be having a conversation about it. I've seen students watching programs in lessons because they can

Timeturnerplease · 12/02/2023 12:16

I teach Year 3 in a very ‘nice’ village primary and even we have seen a massive increase in behavioural issues. Going to our local secondary for a meeting now feels a bit like walking through the apocalypse. I do not know how secondary teachers do it.

MiniEggsz · 12/02/2023 12:14

Mariposista · 12/02/2023 12:12

A woman ends up dead and a family is grieving because a disobedient brat could not put her phone away. Just imagine, if she had behaved herself, the lesson would probably have developed normally and the lady would be home with her family.
Parents, parent your children. If they can't cope with owning a phone, don't let them have one.

Well said.

Mariposista · 12/02/2023 12:12

A woman ends up dead and a family is grieving because a disobedient brat could not put her phone away. Just imagine, if she had behaved herself, the lesson would probably have developed normally and the lady would be home with her family.
Parents, parent your children. If they can't cope with owning a phone, don't let them have one.

MiniEggsz · 12/02/2023 12:02

@Grumpybutfunny It may be a generational issue in that generally speaking, there are real issues with young people today.
They have no respect, no boundaries and seemingly don't understand or believe in society, or the benefits of it.
I am part of that generation too, and I would be extremely unhappy about people filming me. I remember MSN chat and all that drama.
We never recorded lectures on phones, but did use them to take pictures of posters etc. Not sure why as we had a system where things could be uploaded online- think it was called Moodle and we could access it at home, we did have a very slow laptop at home, so I opted to use the school library after school, and there were many others there too. They were used as a tool, this has escalated. It is unnecessary to use phones, schools went a long time without them, with better outcomes than today.
It is disrespectful to film people without their consent, and certainly not appropriate in a place of education.

StanFransDisco · 12/02/2023 12:00

@miniaturepixieonacid I can only assume that you actually are on acid as your assertions that the majority of teachers are happy in their jobs is just blatantly wrong. In the last ten years of the 270,000 teachers who qualified, more than 81,000 have left. Taking into account the many that just can't up and leave, for whatever reasons, and the numbers speak for themselves. The teaching profession is on its knees.

Appuskidu · 12/02/2023 11:56

FrippEnos · 12/02/2023 11:51

We have not "sleepwalked" into this,
teachers have been telling you what has been going on for years.

And we have been accused of Whinging and whining.

Absolutely-accused of being moaning whingebags who just don’t know what it’s like in the real world and should just leave (or never have started) teaching if they weren’t happy…

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 12/02/2023 11:54

GuyFawkesDay · 12/02/2023 09:06

Many have swallowed the Paul Dix "restorative" approach whole.

Last week a colleague was made to have a restorative with a teen who has threatened to get their dad in to beat her up and get her sacked. All the teacher did was follow the school policy, and got a barrage of abuse and is now being goaded and tormented by this girl and her friends.

And she's expected to sit in a meeting with her as if she is half to blame for the situation.

I had to do this years ago with a boy who had held a lit lighter very close to my head. We each had to give our side of the story. As far as I was concerned I had already given mine so either they believed me or they didn't. There were witnesses so he could hardly deny it (he tried) but then he tried to defend what he did and she was nodding sympathetically. I couldn't believe it, if I had been wearing hairspray or something my hair would have gone up in flames. Quite honestly I wish I had had the presence of mind to walk out instead of sitting there while he and the HOY had a nice cosy chat. Fortunately for me I left secondary teaching not long afterwards.

FrippEnos · 12/02/2023 11:51

BlackFriday · 12/02/2023 08:16

Well yes. These are extreme cases you quote but we have sleepwalked into a massive and serious recruitment and retention crisis in the profession.
The warnings are out there but people are determined to ignore them.

We have not "sleepwalked" into this,
teachers have been telling you what has been going on for years.

And we have been accused of Whinging and whining.

MrsHamlet · 12/02/2023 11:46

We have a no phones policy.
In the last two weeks, I've been aggressively challenged by a y13 who claimed that he "didn't know" about it, and we've had an irate dad storming in to complain that his kid had been put in isolation for using his phone. Said child had borrowed his mate's phone to text dad after his own had been confiscated.
We've just banned smartwatches after a couple of unpleasant incidents. Apparently this is against their human rights.

Parker231 · 12/02/2023 11:45

Redebs · 12/02/2023 11:33

You are told in staff meetings that there is zero tolerance of phones and if you see one, you must demand that it is handed over, then take it immediately to the office and wait while they file it away under pupil's name. (You don't know the child, so have to rely on them telling you truthfully. )

It's morning break. You are on your way to set up your classroom on the other side of the site. You know you will have to move desks and collect litter before the pupils arrive. You want to put out settling activities to get them in quietly.

You see a child in a corridor using their phone. The child won't just hand it over. So you have to negotiate / persuade / follow them around to try and get it. Other children will be laughing, egging them on, swearing at you and FILMING IT ON THEIR PHONES.

You know other members of staff turn a blind eye, so kids will be shocked at having someone enforce the rules.

If the child refuses, you stand there being jeered by a group of teens. If you get the phone, you have to take it to the office, carrying all your books, laptop etc. The office will be busy.

You arrive late and stressed to a scruffy classroom with a queue of rowdy teens at the door. Everyone else's classes have gone in.

The other teachers are based in the department, so they have their own, tidy classrooms, cupboards of resources and they've not had to go out for break. They have already done the register, because their laptops stay turned on in their room. Yours loads slowly, because it's registering on the network.

You have to remember your seating plan and be prepared to argue it out.

You have to find pencils for all the kids that don't have anything to write with.

You are trying to find a marker to write a Learning Objective on the whiteboard. The kids have emptied the drawers.You have to clean the board first.

Pupils are wandering in late, stinking of smoke. The class cheers when they come in...

One time I challenged a girl using her phone openly at break and was sworn at that she was allowed to have it. Turns out the (one of many) temporary Head had informed the pupils in assembly that morning that phones were now ok.
Head just forgot TO TELL THE STAFF!

That’s appalling - where is the leadership in the school?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/02/2023 11:44

Agree but it's usually poor parenting cycles and or undiagnosed sen cycles

No it isn’t. I’ve taught kids from the same families, one of whom can be off the wall.

CriticalAlert · 12/02/2023 11:44

I didn't/ couldn't even complete a PGCE... that was 20 years ago. Behaviour in the secondary school I was placed at was appalling....then! Kids came in drugged first thing in the morning. None of them were interested in anything I tried to do for them. I felt like a social worker. A horrific experience. I honestly don't know how teachers do it. Kids aren't getting an education now.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 11:44

@Redebs

I know! Which is why I said earlier slt need to enforce it ateast until its just given that it's happening.
//
I also find students are slightly more wary / intrgueed by people they don't know or see less... So more likely to comply.

Fairislefandango · 12/02/2023 11:43

I was part of the first true social media generation and really wouldn't be bothered about someone filming me and uploading it to TikTok etc. I teach adults in a work based setting and let them record it.

Are you serious? You think that adults filming you in a work-based setting is comparable to the kind of videos and images that teenagers (embellish) and post online of teachers (and indeed other students)? Why do you think they film teachers? It's not for educational purposes. I assure you, these members of the social media generation are not so blasé about it when they are on the receiving end and abusive images of them are shared online by their peers.

noblegiraffe · 12/02/2023 11:43

I do a lot of volunteering across different schools.
I'm talking about teens I see right now.

And you need to be really careful not to extrapolate your experience to every teen you see. They are not your children and have not had the same 'journey' as them.

KnittedCardi · 12/02/2023 11:41

It's so sad, and worrying the way our society is going. This "disrespect" theme is endemic. What the hell? Why should an adult, any adult, have to respect a child, particularly when their behaviour is unacceptable. Why do we have to acquiesce to abusive and entitled parents.

Is it poverty, not if you look to somewhere like India, where education is seen as a privilege and a route out of poverty. Not numbers, if you look to China or South Korea where discipline and deference is part of society.

It depresses me, and I am not even a teacher, but my DD is looking to become one.

Whatmarbles · 12/02/2023 11:40

@Namechangeteach it sounds like you are having a rough time of it.
I have a 16yr old with ASD, my dh and I being on the same page whilst managing their behaviour is a must.
I can imagine how damaging it is for you and your son that his father is going against you.
Sounds like a nightmare situation.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 11:40

@noblegiraffe

I do a lot of volunteering across different schools.

I'm talking about teens I see right now.

Has I not gone through a speficic journey with dc 2 then I wouldn't be aware of the pitfalls.
I'm very keen to make them well known and point them out.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 11:37

@notacooldad

Agree but it's usually poor parenting cycles and or undiagnosed sen cycles.

Even getting ehcp is largely parents driven.
The parent's that don't see their own sen can't diagnose their own dc or get them help and unfortunately no one else can or will.

Which is why we need urgent change from early on.

I wouldn't call us middle class but we are certainly fairly well educated. And yet my own dd was floundering because no one knew what was going on.
I was told to wait and things would click. I was not given any other support or help. My this point dd behaviour was suffering because she was unable to read she couldn't keep up in class.
Her self esteem was starting to take a massive hit.
Year 2. The rot was well setting in.

Thank goodness for covid.

I see dc now in their teens who probably had dd experience and it's so late to try and turn that around by then.

Dominoeffecter · 12/02/2023 11:37

Grumpybutfunny · 12/02/2023 10:10

Is this a generational issue I wonder? I was part of the first true social media generation and really wouldn't be bothered about someone filming me and uploading it to TikTok etc. I teach adults in a work based setting and let them record it.

I do find it hard to say to DS hey you can't take your watch, airpods, phone etc to school whilst I run round looking for my charger to take mine to work. Maybe it's time schools just didn't get involved in what happens on social media or phones, have a policy like you can't use them during the lesson but can openly use them at break time. Any consequences of such are on you.

We recorded our lecturers in the late 00's and they were cool with it, so phones could also be used a revision aid. We also made notes on laptops which I'm genuinely surprised hasn't become the norm at secondary schools especially in affluent areas.

It’s parents that expect schools to deal with issues on social media 😵‍💫 and that’s when they happen outside of school! Imagine how much worse it would be if it was on school grounds. It doesn’t matter what policies done parents have signed/agreed to when it comes down to it they are unsupportive and often aggressive

DisneyChops · 12/02/2023 11:36

miniaturepixieonacid · 12/02/2023 11:29

You are very much in the minority. Both in your experience and your opinion

I'm really not. Otherwise, we would have no teachers. Obviously there are issues, as evidenced by the recruitment crisis and strikes. But there are hundreds of thousands of teachers, the majority of whom are choosing to do it.

It's the same with all careers - lots of problems and not for everyone but worth it for many.

Probably because they're stuck, having to consider what they can do without suffering a big drop in salary, forcing themselves to do it day in day out because they have no other option.
Alot stay for the holidays too and pension etc.
I'm one of them and I only do two days a week now, but even then that's only just bearable.

noblegiraffe · 12/02/2023 11:34

Unfortunately because its such crisis within schools I'd really hesitate to to rule out sen.

It feels like because you've seen it with your own kids you're now assuming that it's the solution to every issue.

The pandemic caused a lot of problems with children's behaviour.