Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who would want to be a teacher now?

342 replies

Painauchocolats · 12/02/2023 08:13

I've just read an article (found on the DM) that a 53 year old teacher has taken her own life before she was due to appear in court for accidentally catching a pupil's hair. This was whilst she tried to confiscate the girl's mobile phone.

A male teacher (also in the DM) faces being struck off for shouting 'Who the hell do you think you are?" At some pupils who filmed tik toks during his lesson, and slammed his hand on the desk.

Sometimes teachers lose their temper, especially if this behaviour is incessant. Who can blame them? This is why pupils' behaviour is so poor these days, because there are no consequences, and because of things like this.

OP posts:
princesssugarless · 12/02/2023 09:55

I'm probably going to get flamed here but our major issue is parental support . Some of our parents are wonderful, supporting the school, ensuring their kids are doing the right thing (following the published behaviour policy). Some of the parents won't support school - refuse to allow their kids to hand a phone over / do a detention/ even wear the uniform. Once that happens we have no where to go. Suspensions reflect badly on the school (although we do them) and have no impact on the student unless parents also discipline at home. Some parents don't want to deal with a student once they are out of their door in a morning - it's the schools problem. I have lost count of the times I have been verbally abused by a parent this year, we can do nothing about it as we still have to communicate with parents. Being told you are fucking useless on a daily basis gets to you after a while.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 12/02/2023 09:55

I think in terms of teachers losing control etc, it's not just behaviour. When you are put under pressure in every aspect of your work, you have less patience/resilience to deal with poor behaviour, as well. A lot of it comes from the culture at the top of the school.

It's also the pressure teachers are out under dealing with students in mental health crisis and getting no support or those who have undiagnosed sen and no support or those who have very difficult home lives and no support.

Every other underfunded public service can increase waiting lists, increase thresholds for intervention and put people off, but these students are in school every day so the schools have to find ways to deal with these issues.

Isitsixoclockalready · 12/02/2023 09:55

GuyFawkesDay · 12/02/2023 08:58

And therein lies the problem.

I had a teen refuse to handover phone just this week. Parents were called. Parents defended the child.

That is definitely part of the problem - parents being unwilling to believe that their child could be at fault.

Workyticket · 12/02/2023 09:55

I've been teaching (secondary and FE) for 23 years. Barely anyone I qualified with is still teaching.

New teachers coming through last weeks or months, not years

I still love some parts of the job but reading about teachers working in warehouses for £150 a month less than their teaching salary is more appealing every week.

I'm lucky not to have been attacked but most colleagues have at some point. FE feels like Year 9 this year behaviour wise.

mintdaisy · 12/02/2023 09:54

I couldn't do it any more. To be honest the thought of walking into a classroom makes me feel panicky and I haven't taught for 10 years. I love teenagers and still work with them in a different way but couldn't handle the stress of teaching. Schools should ban phones really because students can use them to control and humiliate teachers in class, this was just starting to happen when I was in schools but must be more prevalent now.

KattyKattyKatz · 12/02/2023 09:54

Hercisback · 12/02/2023 09:41

@cansu You have nailed it!

Yes. Kids are controlling their parents instead of parents controlling their kids . It all starts in the home .

DisneyChops · 12/02/2023 09:53

I work in a small village school and there are different challenges. Some very entitled and rude behaviour for a start. Kids from quite wealthy backgrounds often think they're god's gift and can be very spoilt and entitled. Answering back, thinking they're right, the list goes on.
And I'm talking about primary aged children. Also children who spend far too much time on games at home, often into the night.

Responsibilities in a small village school can also be huge. I'm MFL leader and I can't even speak French, never mind put the curriculum together for the whole school with good progression.
I'm also English and phonics lead and I only work 2 days a week.

So yea, don't be fooled by the 'nice village school' thing.

Silverbook · 12/02/2023 09:51

I had a truly inspirational English teacher who went on to teach at another school where an allegation was made against him. He took his own life and the pupil confessed it was made up. I often wonder how that pupil copes as an adult and what, if any, trauma they carry as a result of their actions.

WiIson · 12/02/2023 09:49

A tragic story op. I don't blame teachers for not wanting to do it anymore. Parents need to start supporting and backing the school, removing devices and being engaged in their child's education and, more importantly, their behaviour. Otherwise the world just gets worse and worse with the new generations absolutely not giving a shit about anything or anyone.

Fairislefandango · 12/02/2023 09:49

Teaching is my vocation too. I love it.

However, it's hugely bad for my own mental (and physical) health and has a huge impact on my family.

So I am leaving. I am sad, because I love the job. And I am bloody good at it. But I just cannot see myself doing another 25+ years without it breaking me.

It's awful that teachers like you are being driven out of the profession by the awful conditions. I'm one of the lucky ones. Financially needed to go back to full time work age 51 after over 15 years of sporadic supply and very pt roles. Didn't think I could face it and was about to quit teaching and try and do something else. Then landed a job in a lovely girls' grammar school. I will never leave except to retire. It's terrible that only schools like mine make teaching bearable. The workload is still massive, but the environment makes it worth it.

Shinyandnew1 · 12/02/2023 09:49

You could say that about any job, though. People are suited to different things and all jobs come with different challenges and rewards.

I would genuinely be interested to compare the retention and recruitment rates of teaching with a cross section of other jobs. Are there countless other ‘Exit the X and leave’ type Facebook support groups, I wonder?

Testina · 12/02/2023 09:48

Dinosaurpoopy · 12/02/2023 08:54

They are already in my school, but what do you do when a student refuses to hand it over? Slt do nothing..

I was talking to my Y10 about phones in class and the punishment. After telling me about handing them over and a detention, she went straight into, “and if you refuse to hand it over which means SLT have to be called, that makes it an instant C5”… the fact that they have a clear and well known policy for escalation shows me just how many children just refuse 😡

StanFransDisco · 12/02/2023 09:48

Christmascracker0 · 12/02/2023 08:55

I was considering retraining as a teacher but this is a worry for me.

If I ended up in a nice small rural school like the one I went to I would be fine, but I couldn’t deal with bigger schools and all their issues.

No. A small rural school= responsibility for all curriculum subjects shared between only a small group of teachers. Never ending playground duty, assembly duty because there aren't enough teachers to share the load. And don't imagine for a minute that rural = no social issues as that is categorically not the case.

purpledalmation · 12/02/2023 09:48

Teachers are not supported by parents and management who don't put good systems in place, for instance around mobile phones in schools.

DisneyChops · 12/02/2023 09:47

miniaturepixieonacid · 12/02/2023 09:21

You could say that about any job, though. People are suited to different things and all jobs come with different challenges and rewards.

I love teaching. I can't imagine wanting to do any other career, ever.

I can think of many other jobs that I would hate and/or not cope with due to my personality and skill set. Lots of people would hate and/or not cope with teaching because of their personality or skill set. There's no need to say that you can't understand why anyone wants to teach just because it's not for you. Thousands of us do it and love it.

You are very much in the minority, both your experience and your opinion.

Amdone123 · 12/02/2023 09:47

Yes, I agree @cansu has nailed it. Also, @KattyKattyKatz , I started teaching about 30 years ago and this was one of the first things I noticed. When I was at school ( primary or secondary) and misbehaved, I would never have told my parents. I would have been embarrassed and ashamed. Now, and indeed, 30 years ago, reprimand a child and their parents defend them. No support, whatsoever.

Whatmarbles · 12/02/2023 09:46

@KattyKattyKatz the parent's don't back school up.
We have a particularly obnoxious yr9 girl. When she is given an SLT detention, which is after school, her parent's keep her off that day.
Because the parent's need to be informed if it is an an after school, there is no chance of keeping her back for an impromptu one.
She is absolutely untouchable, she is rude, disruptive and quite honestly rather unlikeable.
Sadly, she, and others like her, are our future. And when they reproduce, the circle will forever decrease.

MrsMurphyIWish · 12/02/2023 09:45

cansu · 12/02/2023 09:40

The biggest factor is parenting and lack of support. The drive to excuse behaviour and make teachers responsible for bad behaviour is also a problem. Child refuses to work must be the teachers fault that the work is boring. Child tells you to fuck off when you give them an instruction they have anger management problems or they have problems at home so that's OK. Parents will also support this bad behaviour by looking for an excuse for their child when they are given detentions or are excluded. It is also the case often that they themselves have lost control at home. If the child tells their parent to fuck off then what chance does the school have? Can the parent impose sanctions at home? No they can't.

Yes!

I teach a Yr 9 student who regularly puts their head on the desk and “sleeps”. Not just my lesson but others too. Pastoral contacted parents to see about placing them on a behaviour card … we were told our lessons must be boring by the parent. Before said child can be placed on report we now to need to prove how we’re making our lesson engaging enough.

KinderCat · 12/02/2023 09:45

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 08:56

@Dinosaurpoopy

No. They need to properly banned to the extent that no pupil would dare bring it in.

In fact it shoud be paet of slt / ofsted role to count the phones held and pupils.
Slt need to enforce it.

I have worked in two schools where they are banned. Kids still bring them in. Parents argue the safety aspect heading to/from school. But then temptation exists and they are out. In both schools I have worked in kids have taken pictures have been taken of staff and recordings more than once and there have been some exclusions. Did it stop the behavior? Absolutely not. And as stated by another poster you can have the sanctions but the biggest barrier to enforcing it is parents. Only need a few to argue their child will not be sanctioned for it and it all falls apart. And no you can't just tell them to leave in case this is suggested.

Teaching is not what it was a decade or two ago, but many careers are not on balance. Still I am one of the many who want to leave because there are better and easier ways to live than this...

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 12/02/2023 09:44

Christmascracker0 · 12/02/2023 08:55

I was considering retraining as a teacher but this is a worry for me.

If I ended up in a nice small rural school like the one I went to I would be fine, but I couldn’t deal with bigger schools and all their issues.

Luckily you get to choose where you work but I don't think there's a clear split between "small, rural" and "big, inner city" anymore necessarily.

There are small rural schools with massive issues including drugs etc, there are big city schools with lots of resources that are great places to work.

And underfunded rural services for mental health issues etc create further problems for schools.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/02/2023 09:43

NooNakedJacuzziness · 12/02/2023 09:37

I wonder if CCTV in every classroom is the answer - any violent outbursts referred to police

No! It would just be an excuse observe teachers and get rid of the ones whose face doesn’t fit.

I taught secondary for many years in a nice are. The kids were lovely. It’s the only thing l miss. l don’t miss being the answer to everything and the pressure.

The only way to get phones out of the classroom is for Ofsted to mandate it. ZBut l taught subjects that required a lot of research. The school computers were broken, slow and had all the keys missing. It’s easier to use a phone. There are also other school based activities that can use a phone in class. It can be a learning tool.

Glad l got out.

GuyFawkesDay · 12/02/2023 09:43

Yep! Ineffective parenting, particularly with younger kids whilst the parents have more influence and can mould behaviour patterns

By the time they're 14/15 and huge, it's far, far harder to effect any sort of change or control them. The stable door needs bolting before the horse has bolted over the horizon

Hercisback · 12/02/2023 09:41

@cansu You have nailed it!

cansu · 12/02/2023 09:40

The biggest factor is parenting and lack of support. The drive to excuse behaviour and make teachers responsible for bad behaviour is also a problem. Child refuses to work must be the teachers fault that the work is boring. Child tells you to fuck off when you give them an instruction they have anger management problems or they have problems at home so that's OK. Parents will also support this bad behaviour by looking for an excuse for their child when they are given detentions or are excluded. It is also the case often that they themselves have lost control at home. If the child tells their parent to fuck off then what chance does the school have? Can the parent impose sanctions at home? No they can't.

KattyKattyKatz · 12/02/2023 09:40

Whatmarbles · 12/02/2023 09:31

I think people who haven't been in school since they were a pupil themselves would be seriously shocked if they went into some schools today.
I can't think of many jobs where you get told to fuck off, sometimes multiple times a day, and where the clientele actively try to break or deface equipment.
There are some lovely pupils but for every lovely one, there are numerous aggressive and rude ones.
I'm not sure why but I am still shocked at the appalling behaviour, despite being 7 years at the school.
School prior was much more genteel but apparently that is going the same way.

This is so awful pupils destroying equipment when there are kids around the world who are desperate for an education but don't have the resources or are denied schooling. As for swearing at a teacher omg that would have been instant detention and parents informed. The consequences at home would have been dire to say the least . What the heck has gone wrong where kids can swear at a teacher multiple times and get away with it ?