Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who would want to be a teacher now?

342 replies

Painauchocolats · 12/02/2023 08:13

I've just read an article (found on the DM) that a 53 year old teacher has taken her own life before she was due to appear in court for accidentally catching a pupil's hair. This was whilst she tried to confiscate the girl's mobile phone.

A male teacher (also in the DM) faces being struck off for shouting 'Who the hell do you think you are?" At some pupils who filmed tik toks during his lesson, and slammed his hand on the desk.

Sometimes teachers lose their temper, especially if this behaviour is incessant. Who can blame them? This is why pupils' behaviour is so poor these days, because there are no consequences, and because of things like this.

OP posts:
KinderCat · 12/02/2023 10:09

Remmy123 · 12/02/2023 08:16

You can't go round slamming kid's hands on their desk!!!

the other story, well there has to be more to it than that for it to go to court!

And sorry to double post, but really doesn't need to be more. I worked in a school and was off for a while medically. When I returned I found in my absence a staff member covering me had been suspended as a student had accused her of pinning her to the wall. Half a class backed her. It only came to light this girl was a known bully, serial liar and one of the worst behaved girl in an already tough school and had pressures others into being her witness. Through fear and not fully getting what the implications of this accusation would be the others had gone along with it. It only fell apart when two quiet girls felt guilty and admitted that they and the others had been lying and then the others had to own up. The girl got one day in isolation. Although as the cover teacher tried to send her to tell her to leave a lesson due to her behaviour. Luckily the cover teacher was thick skinned but this kind of thing plays on your health and wellbeing and makes you not want to be in the classroom....

Belladonna208 · 12/02/2023 10:09

One of the main reasons I didn't go into (secondary) teaching after I qualified was the behaviour management aspect. The training has come in useful in my current job though as it requires me to train adults, thankfully they want to be there and it's usually in small groups or one to ones, and often via Teams or Zoom.

I don't know why anyone would want to go into classroom teaching these days, even primary is mostly miserable and I hear from friends that lockdowns during COVID have often resulted in children who are dramatically developmentally delayed (and it was bad enough before 2020).

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:08

It's very much a case of pupils and parents focussing on rights, but not responsibilities. The problem being is that their children disrupt and destroy the education of those around them, as well as their own. It really isn't good enough.

Festivfrenzy · 12/02/2023 10:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 10:07

@Fairislefandango

I don't doubt that but I volunteer in places with very high needs students who have behaviour issues and I've seen simply firm instructions work.

The phone is removed at the start and end of the lessons.

They do it.

mrsbrownhat · 12/02/2023 10:05

It all started going downhill rapidly when they got rid of corporal punishment. Kids nowadays know that there will be little or no consequences to their behaviour. If they are the sort to misbehave they will.

I really don't know what the answer is unless parents are forced to sign a 'contract' with the school with things like 'no phones' etc written in.

polhad · 12/02/2023 10:05

I don't think parents understand what is happening in classrooms now. I work in an outstanding primary in a leafy London suburb. Most days we have incidents where members of staff have to restrain a child, it's only a handful of children that are involved. 10 years ago this was unheard of, now staff and other children being hit, kicked, spat at and bit is a daily occurrence. Most of the time we are able to remove children before they are hurting other children, so it's mainly just the staff taking the brunt. I read lots of posts on Mumsnet saying my child's school would expel these pupils but the reality of that is very challenging. We have 2 children waiting for placements in special schools, but there are none - one was deemed too challenging by a special school - yet we are expected to manage in mainstream. We also have parents refusing to accept that specialist settings would be more appropriate and throwing all the behaviour challenges back at us - what did staff to to escalate the situation.
There is also an expectation that we can materialise staff to support all these children 1:1. Very few EHCPs have this level of funding attached and schools are on their knees financially- we don't have the funding to provide the level of support needed.
Add to this the wave of mental health problems we are facing (from parents and children) and the absolute lack of support these families are able to access so schools are left to manage these families.
It is grim now, I love my job, but in 30 years in the classroom things have never been so tough.

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:05

I think teachers need more support and backing to be able to come down harder on poor behaviour and remove phones. And if parents don't back it maybe they should remove their child from the school. Also consequences for threatening and aggressive behaviour from parents.

rockpoolingtogether · 12/02/2023 10:05

I honestly think, sad as it is, we are best going to some sort of oak academy style of learning for some lessons where children sit in booths and watch the lesson on screens and complete their work within in the booth. Security guards are employed with legal permissions to remove disruptive pupils who are sent to some sort of detention centre for repetitive disruption. Sounds awful, but perhaps then those who want to learn would be able to.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 10:05

@DisneyChops

Very hard. Especially when can't get rid of them.

There should be a default school to send them. Too. Or.a special unit.

Parents need to understand education is two way street and its a privalidge. One that can be removed and where they may then have to get their child to a school further away.

I saw a program which had an in house special support group for disruptive dc and they worked with the parenrs as well. It was amazing.

Painauchocolats · 12/02/2023 10:04

I remember we had a girl in year bloody 8 that many teachers were scared of. For whatever reason she was nice to me but she was atrocious in most other lessons. I just ignored her which wasn't the way to deal with it but I just couldn't put up with the hassle of her.
Once she brought a fake weapon of some sort into school. I remember the deputy head actually saying it's such a shame it wasn't a real one as they'd then have grounds to permanently exclude her.

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 12/02/2023 10:03

Schools and teachers that want too can easily take phones then return them.

I assure you that I've taught many students from whom it would be not be 'easy' to take a phone. Students whose parents would definitely not back the school in its right to remove their child's phone.

JudgeJ · 12/02/2023 10:03

PineappleMel · 12/02/2023 08:51

Schools are full of broken kids these days and teachers seem to be expected to pick up the pieces and act as therapist and social worker as well as a teacher.

This, 100%, schools are now considered the first resort in sorting problems that are, in reality, usually caused by ineffectual parents and their deisre not to 'upset, ie say No, their sprogs.
I was once sitting with a group at a table and I slid an excercise book across to a girl who, because she was talking, missed it and it fell on her lap. The next day this had escalated by her parents into I threw a heavy text book at her, luckily their were too many witnesses to the truth but nowadays incidents like that can ruin a career or, as in this case, a life. I hope the brat with the phone is feeling proud of herself and it's known in the school and wider community who she is.

Appuskidu · 12/02/2023 10:02

I would imagine being at or teaching at a small rural school in the 80s, was probably quite nice!

Now, the ones round here are nearly all part of massive MATs and have to follow some seriously bonkers academy guidance which is clearly written for the secondaries in the trust!

Some have classes of 30 year 3/4/5/6 and that poor teacher has to manage the planning alone. Even the bigger village schools that manage to have a year group per year, have nobody to share the planning with-it makes your workload huge.

A friend of mine teaches Y3 in a local rural school-she is also SENCo, deputy, in charge of phonics, history, geography and science, assessment and PP. She does assemblies twice a week, break duty most days, teaches virtually full time and has no TA! She is leaving teaching altogether at Easter…!

BounceyB · 12/02/2023 10:01

GuyFawkesDay · 12/02/2023 09:04

Yep I have been teaching 20 years and it's much worse than when I started

SLT have their hands tied on exclusions etc and often don't want to deal with aggressive/useless parents and some kids have umpteen millions reason why they can't behave. So those kids get away with it, and then the rest follow.

We have awful issues with things ranging from vaping in loos to county lines drugs problems.

It is relentless. And exhausting. And teachers are voting with their feet because one slip and you are this poor, poor woman.

Exactly. I love my job but the question I'm continually asking myself is how would I act if the parents were watching? It's a useful rule of thumb but I also have times when I think I can't be that kind of teacher all the time and I need to be tougher. The other issue is not enough money for good support staff - TAs are right at the bottom of the pile in terms of respect and they're the ones who frequently run the gauntlet of having various items thrown at them. If the job of TA was better paid and support and better training offered, teachers would have a much easier job.

Redebs · 12/02/2023 10:00

I could fill pages and pages about the horrendous stuff teachers have to put up with, but would have to change my name first!

Unless you've been in the situation, you can't imagine how awful things can be.

I was almost unalived by thirteen years in the profession. Nuff said.

Marjoriesdoor · 12/02/2023 10:00

I have just resigned from my teaching job. It’s an awful job nowadays. I cannot wait until Easter when I get to kiss goodbye to my 20 year career!

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 12/02/2023 10:00

Every year we have two members of staff who come to work in the school from abroad. A variety of different countries. They are always experienced in working in schools and youth centres in at least two other countries before they come to us. More and more frequently they are appalled by the general poor behaviour and attitudes of our students. And this is at a ‘good’ school. This year one of these members of staff has said in the last country he worked in children have very few opportunities but they are motivated to do their best but here children have opportunity after opportunity and they do not care and many will prevent others who do care from achieving by being disruptive.

we have created through poor parenting, removal of any responsibility on the students and parents, and a system that has excused poor behaviour for years, a rot of entitlement. They will not work beyond the minimum but the expectations to gain decent grades are there.

it might change when the responsibility for grades goes back to the work the student puts in rather than how entertaining the teacher is. But that takes time.

Floofyduffypuddy · 12/02/2023 10:00

I volunteer and see it first hand.

  1. children should of course have their phones on the way to school and at the end of the school day.
  2. they enter school property, in locas parentis

Parents can't dictate rules into the school.

Schools and teachers that want too can easily take phones then return them. Whether that's at the start and ends of each day or the start and ends of each lesson.

Fairislefandango · 12/02/2023 09:59

I suspect made-up allegations and vexatious complaints are incredibly common. Let's face it - if you are a horrible, appallingly-behaved 14yo, who is constantly in trouble, takes no responsibility for your actions and you hate teachers for telling you off and putting you in detention, why wouldn't you just maliciously tell your parents a teacher mistreated you and persuade them to make a formal complaint, when you know the school will have to investigate and probably at the very least suspend the teacher?

Often the teacher will leave regardless of the outcome of the investigation, because the whole thing is too traumatic and will always be a stain on their reputation. Lots of teachers are 'disappeared' like this. Bonus for the school if they are expensive experienced too.

Painauchocolats · 12/02/2023 09:59

I was threatened by a 15 year old pupil once. He walked over to me and calmly told me, "If I find out you've put another detention on for me there are going to be severe consequences."
I reported it, he spent a day in isolation then back to lessons as usual.

Another year 10 boy was misbehaving all lesson. I was in the middle of typing it up so that on call would come and collect him, and he came over and tried to grab the keyboard from me and physically rip my hands from it. Another teacher said she didn't feel safe with him in the room, but again nothing done.

If someone was filming a tik tock in my lesson I'd probably ask them too who they thought they were.

OP posts:
Cyclistmumgrandma · 12/02/2023 09:59

Christmascracker0 · 12/02/2023 08:55

I was considering retraining as a teacher but this is a worry for me.

If I ended up in a nice small rural school like the one I went to I would be fine, but I couldn’t deal with bigger schools and all their issues.

I taught in a large primary in a largish town... Then I taught in a small rural school in a village outside the town. I was (un)pleasantly surprised to encounter children who had been excluded from the larger school. The rural school had places so had to take them!

DisneyChops · 12/02/2023 09:57

So many parents wash their hands of their kids. Some parents we feel like we can't inform them of bad behaviour as they'll always defend them. I imagine this is because it makes life easy for them so they don't have to deal with the fallout of trying to discipline.

We have one parent who put a formal complaint in that our headteacher was unfairly targeting their child and treating them differently to all the other children.
He wasn't, it was simply that their child is an absolute little shit but now nobody can discipline him as his parents would only create more problems. It wasn't worth the stress but now this kid walks round thinking he owns the place.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 12/02/2023 09:56

Lots of parents support strict behaviour systems - right up until it is applied to their own child!

AngelinaFibres · 12/02/2023 09:55

Christmascracker0 · 12/02/2023 08:55

I was considering retraining as a teacher but this is a worry for me.

If I ended up in a nice small rural school like the one I went to I would be fine, but I couldn’t deal with bigger schools and all their issues.

I finished my career in a small rural school in an idyllic village. The head was a bully and many of the parents were an absolute nightmare. Small is as shit as large

Swipe left for the next trending thread