Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to refuse to go on a business trip to Dubai

313 replies

ElizaDav · 12/02/2023 01:48

I have been asked to provide my expertise on a product development project. Not part of my main responsibilities but an interesting opportunity and cool way to get more exposure in the organisation. Part of it will entail participation in a 4 day meeting with global colleagues on Dubai. Am an out and proud lesbian and definitely not a place I want to go to. Would it look bad if I refuse? Could I suggest they have the meeting in the UK (where we are HQed) or another country? I feel angry that i have been put in a position where i have to choose between career development and travelling to a homophobic and misogynistic country. Our organisation is always going on about diversity inclusion etc yet men making decisions that we should all meet in Dubai just smacks of institutional homophobia and misogyny. Arrghhh...

OP posts:
GoodChat · 12/02/2023 22:20

PeanutButterSmoothie · 12/02/2023 22:19

It's odd how people are so quick to criticise places like Dubai yet terrified to comment on Muslim homophobia in the UK.

In the last survey I read, over 50% of UK Muslim respondents openly stated that homosexuality should be an imprisonable crime. The mind boggles.

But it's not an imprisonable crime in the UK

PeanutButterSmoothie · 12/02/2023 22:19

It's odd how people are so quick to criticise places like Dubai yet terrified to comment on Muslim homophobia in the UK.

In the last survey I read, over 50% of UK Muslim respondents openly stated that homosexuality should be an imprisonable crime. The mind boggles.

amoobaa · 12/02/2023 21:50

Wagt · 12/02/2023 13:50

YABVU. Your sexual preferences shouldn’t prevent you from doing your job.

Plus, Dubai has cool waterparks.

I get that you disagree with Dubai’s policies - so do I. But by your logic no-one should visit Russia, China, most of South America, etc etc. I wouldn’t even be able to go to Scotland 🤣

I’m guessing you’re in your twenties? This kind of “I think the workplace should change to accommodate my feelings” is so Millennial snowflake… All the senior managers are fed up of it. Just do your job or quit and let someone else do it.

@Wagt ”Your sexual preferences shouldn’t prevent you from doing your job”

Um. That’s literally the point being made.

Only you seem to think it’s the person being discriminated against that is causing the problem.

C8H10N4O2 · 12/02/2023 20:40

saraclara · 12/02/2023 08:41

Part of it will entail participation in a 4 day meeting with global colleagues on Dubai.

If their global colleagues, is say that Dubai had been chosen for its openness to offering visas to almost all nationalities.

Could I suggest they have the meeting in the UK (where we are HQed) or another country?

Highly unlikely that this would work, given that some or many of those participants would be refused visas.

I feel angry that i have been put in a position where i have to choose between career development and travelling to a homophobic and misogynistic country.

This is where you recognise your privilege as a white British person. Yes, it's uncomfortable for you to visit a place where theoretically lesbianism is illegal. But this is a one off, you can go and you will be safe, and you can avoid it if you're determined to miss out on this professional opportunity.

Now imagine what it's like for those who are unwelcome here to the point that they are not allowed the freedom you have to travel for work, due to the colour of their skin or the poverty of their country. They don't get a choice. They're simply blocked from coming here.

I agree with both you and @Lentilweaver - saying "let them come here" is a bit "let them eat cake".

We also have to go to meetings/conferences with clients which are sometimes in places which I'd rather not visit. However we have exactly this problem - "liberal" majority white countries can be both expensive and a nightmare to visit if you are from countries which do not claim the liberal high ground. Some of those liberal countries are pretty selective on which rights they will honour as well - Malta springs to mind.

I also remember this exact scenario from an I&D module, I wonder if the OP will be returning with more info.

AnorLondo · 12/02/2023 20:19

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 20:06

you are saying in effect that any gay woman can say they won't go to Dubai or other place to work because they are gay ? How about if you are a straight woman? WTF is going to know if she is gay or not? Anyone can end up paying someone off for being drunk , disorderly, vomiting in a taxi, whatever in a bad situation. No one would know! Principles are altogether a different thing. People are going to get fed up with that - well Liz won't go to China because they eat dogs, she won't go to Thailand because they have animal shows, she won't go to France because they eat horses, she won't go to the USA because they are racist...and on and on... and as is often the case the majority have to bend for the minority.

If you can't understand why someone who is gay would not want to go somewhere that it is illegal to be gay then yoy are severly lacking in empathy and I feel sorry for you.

ancientpants · 12/02/2023 20:11

This thread is awful. It's like telling a person of colour in the 60's to go to meeting in the Deep South of America and just not be openly black. That work and a career is more important than standing up to oppression and that it's great how so much more liberal things are now.

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 20:07

OP hasn't been back on thread 🤔 I usually make it a rule to never post on a drop and dash.

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 20:06

NumberTheory · 12/02/2023 19:20

The whole point is that people do recognise how it works in Dubai and that is why they think OP should feel okay to refuse to go and to point out that having the meeting there is not inclusive of her. Because she doesn’t want to have to pay off people for simply being who she is.

you are saying in effect that any gay woman can say they won't go to Dubai or other place to work because they are gay ? How about if you are a straight woman? WTF is going to know if she is gay or not? Anyone can end up paying someone off for being drunk , disorderly, vomiting in a taxi, whatever in a bad situation. No one would know! Principles are altogether a different thing. People are going to get fed up with that - well Liz won't go to China because they eat dogs, she won't go to Thailand because they have animal shows, she won't go to France because they eat horses, she won't go to the USA because they are racist...and on and on... and as is often the case the majority have to bend for the minority.

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 19:59

AnorLondo · 12/02/2023 19:07

Nothing about as soon as she steps off the plane, that was invented by you in your attempt to defend these barbaric laws.

No it wasn't me - I quoted that as it mentioned being lashed. Read properly.

YoBeaches · 12/02/2023 19:34

If you believe your company would support you, then raise it on the basis that you'd rather not travel to a country with such restrictions on human rights.

I know where I work would totally respect this. Sometimes there are things they just haven't thought of until someone mentions it, then they realise they've been narrowminded.

You don't really lose anything just by raising it though. For discussion to start with rather than point refusal.

NumberTheory · 12/02/2023 19:20

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 15:40

Again so many people who do not understand that your/UK assumption of the law and how things SHOUD be are not recognised worldwide. The Emiratis do turn blind eyes to lots of things but you never know when you encounter a taxi driver , a policeman or official who is looking for a little bit of side money. It's the way it is - as in many countries. Go about your business or holiday , be respectful and don't be obviously drunk in public creating a scene and you will be fine.

The whole point is that people do recognise how it works in Dubai and that is why they think OP should feel okay to refuse to go and to point out that having the meeting there is not inclusive of her. Because she doesn’t want to have to pay off people for simply being who she is.

CupidCantAimStraight · 12/02/2023 19:15

YANBU; they shouldn't be asking someone to go to a country where they could be arrested for existing.

Cross dressing is illegal in Dubai, and I'll bet they have a wide definition of what that is, so if you're more at the butch end of the spectrum it would be especially unsafe.

AnorLondo · 12/02/2023 19:07

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 16:41

Here.

Nothing about as soon as she steps off the plane, that was invented by you in your attempt to defend these barbaric laws.

Ponderingwindow · 12/02/2023 19:07

fancylike, do I have this right? You are claiming that the multiple stories of women being arrested for being raped. All those women were prostitutes and these are actually jobs gone bad?

Fancylike · 12/02/2023 18:37

Even though posters are completely ignoring the first hand experiences of women who currently leave in the UAE, I have to chime in now that sexual assault is being brought up.

I was recently sexually assaulted here in Dubai, by a British tourist, and the hotel I was visiting reported to police against my wishes. The police tracked him down and arrested him and charged him. I was believed despite it being he said, she said with the only evidence the security cameras showing him following me. At no point was I made to feel like a criminal or treated like I wasn’t believed. They took my feelings very seriously and were very kind throughout. I didn’t end up going to court as I didn’t want to see him and they instead had my statement read to the court through a proxy.

The experience was the polar opposite to how I was treated after being raped back home. Even with witnesses the police there were so awful to me that I dropped it.

Those pulling up stories about women being arrested for sexual activity in the UAE should double check the dates - it’s been years since this has been considered a crime. I think the last case was at least 5 years ago, and the couple was deported. The remaining stories are only about the woman being arrested, never about her being charged and convicted. This is because in these cases, like the one linked above, the woman is a sex worker and while there’s a large number of sex workers in Dubai, it’s still illegal. When caught, especially Westerners, they will spend a week or two in holding, then have their visa revoked and get deported. The men in the earlier mentioned case would have had the same outcome but they’ve been quicker and fled before that.

Again, if you don’t actually know how rules are applied then don’t bother commenting. If OP is concerned about being gay here, she can ask someone who lives it. Although the zero cases of lesbians being arrested and charged for being gay probably says enough, you can also compare the number of hate crimes here (zero) to those in the UK…

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 12/02/2023 18:32

A lot of people are missing the significant difference between not going somewhere that has laws you disagree with, and not going somewhere that has a law against you personally.

It's fine until it's not

This.

There are 2 aspects to risk - likelihood and size of consequence.

In this case the probability of a run in with the law is very low. But if it does happen, the potential consequence is large.

And it's not all down to factors under your control - for example if you fall ill and are hospitalised then, if you have a partner or wife, her rights to visit or make decisions won't be recognised.

SoulCaptain · 12/02/2023 18:27

I agree with previous posts asking for your work to undertake a risk assessment.

WinterDeWinter · 12/02/2023 18:25

MrsTerryPratchett · 12/02/2023 02:21

They're asking you to go somewhere that makes you a criminal. Fine to refuse. And say why. But be all 'curious' about the choice. Make them say why it's OK.

This. And it would be great if you could push back not just on the grounds that you will be extremely uncomfortable and potentially in danger personally but that any country with such a terrible human rights record on multiple grounds (race, sex, sexuality, right to protest, no democracy, migrant workers/modern day slavery etc) should never have been considered regardless of who is going.

starlingdarling · 12/02/2023 18:13

It is not that she is likely to be assaulted.
the problem is if a woman is assaulted and seeks medical care or reports the crime to police she can be arrested and face serious charges in the uae.*

I suspect she would be more likely to be assaulted. If you grow up in a country where women are shamed and punished for being raped, you're going to grow up with a very skewed view of women as people.

Crazycrazylady · 12/02/2023 17:23

Honestly op, my company works with some large organisations that I don't think much of, it also trades with some customers in the mise east but I don't get to chose not to deal with them and it was an issue for me, I'd simply leave the company .
I honestly don't think it's your place to protect your morals on to your company's business policy.

saraclara · 12/02/2023 17:16

queerintheworld.com/gay-dubai-uae-travel-guide/

Ponderingwindow · 12/02/2023 17:12

Hadjab · 12/02/2023 08:21

Curious as to why you think OP is more likely to be sexually assaulted going to Dubai, than if she were going anywhere else?

It is not that she is likely to be assaulted.
the problem is if a woman is assaulted and seeks medical care or reports the crime to police she can be arrested and face serious charges in the uae.

i would expect the company to have a medical evacuation service on standby to get female employees out of the country immediately by private plane in the event of an assault. It should not depend on the victim being in good enough shape to make her own way to the airport. if they can’t arrange that, they shouldn’t be holding the meeting there.

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 16:41

but it's bollocks.

MrsDubai · 12/02/2023 16:41

sashh · 12/02/2023 06:06

Homosexuality is illegal in Dubai.

You are advising the OP to do something that could get her jailed and lashed.

That is why it is stupid.

Here.

Marths · 12/02/2023 16:16

RampantIvy · 12/02/2023 16:14

I'm puzzled why posters are saying that the OP will be arrested and lashed for being gay the minute she steps off the plane.

I mean, how will they know what her sexuality is? It doesn't say so in your passport. Are they assuming that the OP looks butch?

Who said that?