Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on with parenting these days?

667 replies

whocaresaboutbeingpopular · 11/02/2023 22:26

Ok, so as my name change suggests I am aware this won’t be popular. My children are almost adults, youngest is 17 this year.

me and OH are away this weekend, we went to a place that to be fair we were aware would be full of kids; but we didn’t think that would matter as we don’t dislike having children around, however, since when did it become a thing to….

put your kids in front of a screen when they are having a meal? Not to mention having full volume of Peppa Fucking Pig?

let your kids shriek at high pitch continuously?

let your 18 month old walk themselves down the stairs despite a massive queue of people behind t? Ffs pick them up!

yes, no doubt I sound a right miserable bastard, but come on - is this how people are raising their kids these day? Bring on the entitled generation.

OP posts:
Spikeyball · 14/02/2023 08:18

"too many parents refuse to do parenting programmes because they think it’s an insult to them - why?"

Parenting programmes are sometimes inappropriate for a child's needs. Many parents of children with Asd have had to sit through programmes giving inappropriate advice often delivered by someone without expertise and delaying the child getting proper support.

Spikeyball · 14/02/2023 08:12

"You can always tell the children that don't sit for family meals at the table at home , as they can't tolerate sitting still."

You are wrong. They are different environments. When eating out there are far more distractions and it is a different sensory environment.

whocaresaboutbeingpopular · 14/02/2023 08:10

Peaplant20 · 14/02/2023 07:56

Also, it’s quite telling that I posted about my 18mo and screen time in restaurants genuinely asking for some advice and not a single person replied, all
the comments since have just been everyone arguing with each other and the OP has replied to many of the comments but not mine.

This thread has over 500 posts - I can’t reply to them all - it would be too much screen time 😃

re your 18 month old - what do you think parents of challenging 18mo did before screens were commonplace? Why don’t you do a parenting programme such as incredible years? And that is not a comment to put you down - too many parents refuse to do parenting programmes because they think it’s an insult to them - why? Nobody automatically knows how to parent their child - it’s about learning as you go along and making use of what is available to give them the best start and outcomes.

And before someone tries to turn this around on me - yes I have done more than one parenting programme; the last being Take 3 when I was struggling with my teen’s behaviour - despite the fact I work with teenagers.

OP posts:
UncannySerenity · 14/02/2023 08:09

Like most of this stuff, it’s not black and white.

There is lots I prefer about modern child upbringing. Not smacking. Actually listening to them and encouraging them to express their feelings. A bigger focus on reporting bullying. Allowing talk about mental health.

What is not so good in my view is the idea of not saying no, and not enforcing boundaries. I remember going out with a bunch of kids and parents after the seven plus exam and the others allowing their kids to fold menus into paper planes and fly them round the restaurant. Annoying staff and other diners. My kids did not join in as they knew it was poor behaviour. The other kids were then allowed to make ‘cocktails’ ie pour ketchup, salt etc into the water jug. These were not toddlers. When kids are annoying others, parents should step in.

I don’t care if other young kids watch screens as long as the volume is off. I don’t think there has been enough research on how iPads etc affect cognitive development in children long term but that’s the parents’ look out. Just keep the sound down and I am not bothered!

I do think consideration to others is needed. Even if it’s hard to do the strict boundaries thing with your children. It pays off in the end.

AGoldenNarwhal · 14/02/2023 08:05

Children nowadays are much better-behaved in many ways than in previous generations. They might annoy you in restaurants, but later on they drink less, smoke less, engage in less risky behaviours, are more socially aware and place more value on friendships, experiences and personal connection. Their parents spend more quality time with them.

They also face different challenges, including screen-time, social media, intense competition for resources and an education system that pushes them too hard, too young. In many ways, we adults should be apologising to children for bequeathing them such a fucked up world, not moaning because we have to wait a couple of minutes for a toddler to walk down some stairs.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/02/2023 07:58

I don’t think someone who can directly quote Socrates needs any help from arguing women on the Internet 🙄

Peaplant20 · 14/02/2023 07:56

Also, it’s quite telling that I posted about my 18mo and screen time in restaurants genuinely asking for some advice and not a single person replied, all
the comments since have just been everyone arguing with each other and the OP has replied to many of the comments but not mine.

Peaplant20 · 14/02/2023 07:49

Brieandcamembert · 14/02/2023 07:04

You can always tell the children that don't sit for family meals at the table at home , as they can't tolerate sitting still. They need to roam, watch screens etc. If we all taught children to sit at the table as an expectation at home they wouldn't misbehave half as much when out.

Not true. My 18mo sits in the high chair for every meal at home without a screen.

Peaplant20 · 14/02/2023 07:47

To backup that every generation thinks this… a quote…

“The children now love luxury; they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants, not the servants of their households“

Its from Socrates… you know, the Ancient Greek philosopher!

MatronicO6 · 14/02/2023 07:37

FieldofTulips · 13/02/2023 23:04

That was actually my thought too! Thank God you are not a teacher! As in many well advanced countries the use of iPads in schools is considered super important starting from primary and kids grow up speaking at least 3 or 4 languages somehow. Better than being forced to colour endless colouring books and being threatened to leave if children make any noise or express any feelings at all at every pub their parents want to stop by at. For some parents it's about the substance and not some lady sitting on the next table. For others it's about your child saying 'yes please and sorry' at the right time.

My kids usually play language games in Chinese for example that they are currently learning whilst we are waiting for food when we are out. However all you would see is

' omg she gave them screens'.

Ipads are great for learning and there is definitely a big difference between using an ipad to watch Netflix and playing a maths game. However, in class there is an expectation that the volume is turned off or low so as not to disturb the other children in the class and respect the environment. If teachers can manage to get a class of 30 kids to do respect others, it's reasonable to presume parents should teach their own kids to be mindful of others.

canonlydoblue · 14/02/2023 07:24

The amount of people trying to justify screens by comparing them to colouring or reading or playing cards - you do know they are completely different don’t you. There are actually physical processes involved that you cannot replicate with a screen.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 14/02/2023 07:16

YANBU OP

Brieandcamembert · 14/02/2023 07:04

You can always tell the children that don't sit for family meals at the table at home , as they can't tolerate sitting still. They need to roam, watch screens etc. If we all taught children to sit at the table as an expectation at home they wouldn't misbehave half as much when out.

Lordofthebutterfloofs · 14/02/2023 06:54

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 13/02/2023 23:17

They’ve never watched TV?

Not whilst eating a meal, no.

Morestrangethings · 14/02/2023 06:52

“Parents no longer discipline their children”

Said every generation ever.

Stewball01 · 14/02/2023 06:42

Parents no longer discipline their children.

Miisty · 14/02/2023 06:34

I looked after 2children(paid nanny) while their mother went in a course and had to stay overnight zither issue was the 4year old had never ever sat at a table to eat a meal Sat in front of the tv Goodness knows what he will do with school dinners and couldn’t use a knife and fork Also had TV in bedroom chose of bedtime story or Tv not both story one Trouble is out with children mobile phones take over and a bad distraction We are contactable 24/7 years. Ago just landline

UncannySerenity · 14/02/2023 06:29

FieldofTulips · 13/02/2023 20:21

And nobody is putting a screen in front of your child in a restaurant 🙄 what other parents choose to do shouldn't concern you or OP at all. I have a friend with a kid who has got adhd and he just doesnt sit still and it helps him sit down and have at least something to eat as well as gives his parents a break to be together as a family. Also often in parenting it's not about what you don't allow or don't do but about what you actually do. And you don't know the amount of things other people do for their kids.

I personally think there are so many old bags in this country who just can't mind their own business and have to look around looking for something or someone to judge.

‘I personally think there are so many old bags in this country’

What happened in your life to make you so sexist and ageist? Dreadful phrase to use, however upset you are. Makes you no better than those who have hit a nerve with you.

UncannySerenity · 14/02/2023 06:12

WedonttalkaboutMaureen · 13/02/2023 23:05

or never refuse to be picked up and insist on climbing the stairs themselves.

This sentence sums up the problem for me. The kid in question was around 18 months. If I needed to pick up my son around that age, and even up until around 3-4, he was picked up and that was that. He didn't get a choice at that age, if we needed to move faster than he was moving! Especially near roads etc.

How on earth can a child barely a toddler "insist" on anything unless you're such a wet, ineffective parent that's scared of a squealing tiny person? It's pathetic to not be able to be in charge of your own child! An 18 month old can yell and squirm sure, but they don't get the final call on what happens fgs - is this where it's going wrong? Adults giving way to toddlers. Madness.

Agreed. Indulging a toddler and inconveniencing everyone else. Selfish behaviour.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 01:01

Morestrangethings · 14/02/2023 00:47

Actually no, not a nightmare child alert. child.

Hourbyhour is absolutely right. There is a tendency for older people to forget the shittier moments of parenting young children. Many do look back through rose coloured glasses. They’d do well to think about it all a bit more honestly.

There is nothing new in people criticising other people’s parenting. It’s that screens have become the new symbol of ‘parental neglect’ - ludicrous.

It’s only ever about putting someone down to make themselves feel superior. Trouble is the feeling doesn’t last long does it? Because it’s all so inauthentic.

This is very true.

My mum is very judgmental and bangs on about how we ‘never had screen time’. I had to remind her that we watched The Little Mermaid so much she had to buy a second VHS tape because we wore the first one out!

Also YY to leaving kids in the car with crisps and pop while they went in for a drink. And many other weird 80’s punishments like fairy liquid on our tongues if we swore. And she has the nerve to tell me I shouldn’t tell DD off so much 🙄

Morestrangethings · 14/02/2023 00:47

oakleaffy · 13/02/2023 20:34

Parent of nightmare child 🚨 alert!!

Actually no, not a nightmare child alert. child.

Hourbyhour is absolutely right. There is a tendency for older people to forget the shittier moments of parenting young children. Many do look back through rose coloured glasses. They’d do well to think about it all a bit more honestly.

There is nothing new in people criticising other people’s parenting. It’s that screens have become the new symbol of ‘parental neglect’ - ludicrous.

It’s only ever about putting someone down to make themselves feel superior. Trouble is the feeling doesn’t last long does it? Because it’s all so inauthentic.

CrazyLadie · 14/02/2023 00:14

maeveiscurious · 11/02/2023 23:37

The "manners" you talk of are not just niceties, they are the reflection of consideration for each other in society.

Sitting at a table with a child on a tablet, is on one level saying to them they aren't interesting to be engaged with.

It also reinforces that the interaction over meals isn't important.

Having a distraction at the table takes away the importance of eating and not mindlessly putting food in your mouth.

Having a chat and interaction with your DC is building a relationship and setting up a social premise for the future.

A tablet is a poor option and will create further problems in the future.

Read about language and behaviour acquisition and the tablet will be put away.
Nothing beats interaction and language.

That'd presumptuous, now he is older my boy takes his switch, he yaps for a bit the goes plays, as a single Mum I don't often get time to spend with other adults. I work from home so I spend time and speak to him everyday about all sorts of things. But because I want to yap and catch up without talking about roboox I'm a shit parent? Hardly!!! In fact have been stopped by strangers to tell me how nice and polite my boy is

CrazyLadie · 14/02/2023 00:10

whocaresaboutbeingpopular · 11/02/2023 23:29

That comment was designed to make me feel shit, and other ones after - the poster is obviously one of “those” parents.

as for screens keep them Occupied - how about interacting with your own children? You know? It used to be called parenting

As a single parent I interact with my child every day, all day. Sometimes when I meet with another adult I just wanna have some adult conversation bot about Dan TDM or bloody roblox!!!! Mine is older now so conversation usually consists of grunting or speaking for ages about stuff I have no idea about 😅😅

SpainwithouttheS · 13/02/2023 23:46

@Cuppasoupmonster Then just don’t look. It’s not your problem to worry about.

WedonttalkaboutMaureen · 13/02/2023 23:40

@Getir we are absolutely not saying "how easy it is". Teaching manners, consideration and how to behave in public is a long long slog of repeated and repeated teaching, warning, modelling, following through on consequences for years to be able to turn out children who know what's expected and are a pleasure to have as company. And hopefully become decent, thoughtful adults.

Easy is the opposite. Easy is letting them run feral and play games at top volume to avoid dealing with any resistance from them to behave. Avoiding parenting.