Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on with parenting these days?

667 replies

whocaresaboutbeingpopular · 11/02/2023 22:26

Ok, so as my name change suggests I am aware this won’t be popular. My children are almost adults, youngest is 17 this year.

me and OH are away this weekend, we went to a place that to be fair we were aware would be full of kids; but we didn’t think that would matter as we don’t dislike having children around, however, since when did it become a thing to….

put your kids in front of a screen when they are having a meal? Not to mention having full volume of Peppa Fucking Pig?

let your kids shriek at high pitch continuously?

let your 18 month old walk themselves down the stairs despite a massive queue of people behind t? Ffs pick them up!

yes, no doubt I sound a right miserable bastard, but come on - is this how people are raising their kids these day? Bring on the entitled generation.

OP posts:
Noicant · 21/02/2023 15:46

We’ve never taken screens out, tbf this means that it wasn’t much fun and all the conversation was directed at engaging DD rather than DH and I talking. But at 3 (just turned) she can sit reasonably well at a restaurant, she says please and thank you to waiters and waitresses if asked how she is she will say “I’m fine thank you, how are you”. She does need a lot of exercise so it’s not that she isn’t fidgety etc. We just keep stating expected behaviour.

Yeah we have definitely had meltdowns etc but it’s a process. But I wouldn’t judge another parent who uses a screen, kids are all different.

londonloves · 21/02/2023 12:28

@MelaniesFlowers I suspect we won't agree on this, and that's fine, you're perfectly entitled to your views.
My point is, though, that these studies are very polarised. Reading = good brain. Screens = fucked brain. And the parenting discussions here are equally polarised. Coloring book = good, respectful, attentive parenting. Screen = lazy, crap parenting.

If you'd sat next to us in a restaurant on Friday late afternoon last week, you'd have seen my 5yo playing a game on my phone for ten minutes with the sound off while we waited for our food. You, and many others in this thread, would no doubt have judged me for my shitty parenting.
You wouldn't have seen us reading together in a cafe at lunchtime and me engaging with him for a full day of sightseeing. You wouldn't have seen him taking part in activities at a museum in an engaged and interested way. You would probably not have noticed him giving me back my phone when the food arrived and chatting with us throughout the rest of the meal. You wouldn't have seen any of that. You'd have judged me on 10-15 minutes of our day.

MelaniesFlowers · 21/02/2023 12:13

@londonloves That “generic news article” links to peer reviewed studies and scientific evidence if you care to follow the sources.

Unless your child has had an MRI, you have absolutely no idea of the impact screen time has had on his brain.

londonloves · 21/02/2023 11:46

@MelaniesFlowers it's not either/or though, as this generic news article seems to suggest. It's possibly to have a child who is read to frequently and also uses screens sometimes. I would know, I have one. There's nothing wrong with his brain.
The problem here is that people take a snapshot of a moment in a restaurant and judge parents' whole ethos on that moment.

Personally I think the shrieking and running around is totally unacceptable and would never allow it (and have also hardly ever seen it). The screens thing, I just think it's another thing some parents like to feel superior about.

MelaniesFlowers · 21/02/2023 11:37

londonloves · 21/02/2023 11:31

@MelaniesFlowers maybe so but that doesn't change the impact it has on people around you? Which is what this thread appears to be about. (Although I would love to see the peer reviewed neurological evidence on this statement 😬😬😬)

The information is out there if people care enough to find it.

edition.cnn.com/2020/01/16/health/child-brain-reading-books-wellness/index.html

londonloves · 21/02/2023 11:31

@MelaniesFlowers maybe so but that doesn't change the impact it has on people around you? Which is what this thread appears to be about. (Although I would love to see the peer reviewed neurological evidence on this statement 😬😬😬)

MelaniesFlowers · 21/02/2023 11:26

londonloves · 21/02/2023 09:46

You can also chat to your kid while they're playing a game on their tablet, or play with them. Sound can be set low or turned off. No different to playing a card game etc. Tablet does not necessarily equal zombified state.

Actually it’s completely different to colouring or playing a game as it uses a different part of your brain processes.

GrapesAreMyJam · 21/02/2023 10:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

londonloves · 21/02/2023 09:46

LightDrizzle · 11/02/2023 23:02

“How is colouring different to a tablet? You’re allowing them to be distracted in both circumstances”

You can talk when colouring and it isn’t a passive uptake of highly repetitive and heightening, addicted animations and sounds. Children often chat to you about their drawings and colourings (mind-numbingly I found) so it’s not an entirely independent activity.

You can also chat to your kid while they're playing a game on their tablet, or play with them. Sound can be set low or turned off. No different to playing a card game etc. Tablet does not necessarily equal zombified state.

Hope551 · 21/02/2023 09:25

I even tell my partner off if he doesn't use headphones on his phone when watching something on a train or at a table. It's just plain rude whatever age. If everyone did it you wouldn't be able to hear a thing.

My Parents were OTT as in children should be seen not heard. So no noise whatsoever, sat up straight, not even allowed to touch anything and don't get me started on how to eat properly and etiquette at a table from the minute I was out a high chair 😂

I'm hoping as my LO grows up I'll be a little lenient but if they start screeching I'll be taking them straight outside 😂 not just for others but I can't stand loud noises or screaming. I'm a bit noise sensitive. Obvs I can't predict her toddler years but I'd hope she would manage basic parenting and scoulding 😅 I'd feel so embarrassed if she was really badly behaved.

Morestrangethings · 21/02/2023 09:22

There are women in every generation that do that performance parenting. At least since the late 70s. I’ve seen men doing it too now occasionally, so that’s new.

But reading to your child in public is not performance parenting. Unless you are doing it with that special voice which is saying ‘look at me, I’m parenting’ We can all identify that.

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/02/2023 09:19

I agree about quick meals out. Cafe lunch, pub dinner, that kind of thing - keep it around an hour, so they can build up their tolerance. We took DD out for lunch (she’s 3) at the weekend for the first time in a while, it wasn’t hard to keep her occupied with games of I Spy and talking to her. No tablet needed, just a bit of effort and engagement.

MelaniesFlowers · 21/02/2023 09:15

Liorae · 20/02/2023 13:09

I'd rather 100 kids on muted tablets than 1 minute of that kind of performance parenting.

None of that is “performance parenting”. It’s just basic parenting that all parents should be doing.

Excited101 · 21/02/2023 09:12

@Liorae you do know that’s parenting right? There’s nothing performance about it, it’s just actual, decent parenting. Maybe stay at home if you don’t want to see someone read to their child and let them hold a menu ffs

BubziOwl · 21/02/2023 09:11

@Tiddler39 I totally agree. It seems on mumsnet, any woman (because it's always a mum who gets slagged off for this, rarely a dad) who dares to interact with her child in public is performance parenting.

I can only imagine these accusations come from incredibly insecure people. Most people aren't even considering what strangers in public think of their parenting, let alone performing for them...

Morestrangethings · 21/02/2023 08:17

It’s awful for other patrons, but I saw the same 30 years ago. So no change there.

MaryBeardsShoes · 21/02/2023 07:50

I saw a woman change her child’s nappy on a restaurant floor the other week.

Tiddler39 · 21/02/2023 07:18

Liorae · 20/02/2023 13:09

I'd rather 100 kids on muted tablets than 1 minute of that kind of performance parenting.

😱

Read it back. If you REALLY think sitting your toddler on your lap and showing them a book or toy to keep them quiet is ‘performance parenting’ then things have really lost their way.

There’s not a lot that shocks me on MN but this really has!

Liorae · 20/02/2023 13:09

Tiddler39 · 17/02/2023 19:31

@Peaplant20

Mum of 3 here. My advice would be:

  • Lower your expectations. Don’t expect your LO to sit still for long - it’s just not fair at that age. Lots of the issues on this thread are because parents want to continue their old life with regard to eating out. You can’t. Try quick meals out or a coffee at a cafe first and build up to lunch or dinner.
  • If she’s in a high chair and getting restless, get her out and sit her on your lap and do something with her, like look at a book. Pre-empt.
  • Consider having a specific toy or book that she ONLY gets when you go out for a meal. Then she’ll look forward to it. My kids liked a set of teddies that you dress in different outfits - it had loads of possibilities.
  • Give her the menu. Seriously! My kids loved being given the menu to ‘look at’, because it was something they’d never seen before. They also felt grown up. Then I would read it to them.
  • Involve them in choosing what to eat.
  • Sit them so they are facing other people in the restaurant so they can people watch.
  • Accept that you will probably have to interrupt your own meal at some point, and possibly leave straight after the meal. Just acknowledge that this won’t be fun for you for a few years but you are teaching her valuable lessons that will pay you back.
  • Don’t give in and give her a screen - however tempted you are. This will be controversial on this thread but I personally think that if you do it once she will ALWAYS ask for it from then on. Make it something you just don’t do and then she won’t ask.
  • Goes without saying, but don’t use your own phone at the table!

I'd rather 100 kids on muted tablets than 1 minute of that kind of performance parenting.

donutqueen · 20/02/2023 12:14

TomorrowAndTomorrowAndTomorrow · 11/02/2023 22:38

I'm mum to a toddler. I'm a good mum - promise. I also let my daughter watch a screen sometimes at the table in a restaurant. Sometimes because she is massively overstimulated, or tired, or ill, and I want to limit the impact she has on other diners if she were to have a meltdown. And rarely, but sometimes I do it because I need a bloody break for ten minutes.

I am otherwise a really good parent. My daughter is loved and bright and inquisitive and generally wonderful. She is also a much kinder person than you sound, so I must be doing something right.

Bringing up a kind child but calling the OP names for having an opinion? Bit strange that.

Peaplant20 · 17/02/2023 22:31

Tiddler39 · 17/02/2023 19:31

@Peaplant20

Mum of 3 here. My advice would be:

  • Lower your expectations. Don’t expect your LO to sit still for long - it’s just not fair at that age. Lots of the issues on this thread are because parents want to continue their old life with regard to eating out. You can’t. Try quick meals out or a coffee at a cafe first and build up to lunch or dinner.
  • If she’s in a high chair and getting restless, get her out and sit her on your lap and do something with her, like look at a book. Pre-empt.
  • Consider having a specific toy or book that she ONLY gets when you go out for a meal. Then she’ll look forward to it. My kids liked a set of teddies that you dress in different outfits - it had loads of possibilities.
  • Give her the menu. Seriously! My kids loved being given the menu to ‘look at’, because it was something they’d never seen before. They also felt grown up. Then I would read it to them.
  • Involve them in choosing what to eat.
  • Sit them so they are facing other people in the restaurant so they can people watch.
  • Accept that you will probably have to interrupt your own meal at some point, and possibly leave straight after the meal. Just acknowledge that this won’t be fun for you for a few years but you are teaching her valuable lessons that will pay you back.
  • Don’t give in and give her a screen - however tempted you are. This will be controversial on this thread but I personally think that if you do it once she will ALWAYS ask for it from then on. Make it something you just don’t do and then she won’t ask.
  • Goes without saying, but don’t use your own phone at the table!

These are really good tips thanks!

Tiddler39 · 17/02/2023 19:40

Dijoduo · 14/02/2023 12:52

So your youngest is 17 but you’re complaining about the parents of an 18mo who were about your age? Ok then.

Any thread with “these days” in the title is an ageism thread, whether intentional or not.

OP might be early 40s and be the same age as parents of an 18mo…

Tiddler39 · 17/02/2023 19:36

nannykatherine · 15/02/2023 22:47

You’ve totally got child led wrong
it is not about adults not interacting with children
it
is about observing
then being able to provide what they need to develop
it’s about letting the child play and solve problems and use open ended resources their own way to solve problems
it is definitely not about ticking boxes
it is moving away from that and from pre planned activities and topics
take a look at froebel
reggio
forest school
the slow approach
I’m glad things are moving this way
And rolling snack is about children taking responsibility for they own needs
at home children can ask for drink snack
when they feel the need

you’re welcome

Not for me thanks. The term ‘rolling snack’ is about the worst thing I’ve heard all week.

So they’re teaching kids to eat, alone, whenever they feel like it instead of at set times all together around a table?

😬

Tiddler39 · 17/02/2023 19:31

Peaplant20 · 14/02/2023 08:56

Thanks both but the link is about screen time in general.. LO has very low screen time so that’s not the issue it’s more how to deal with the restaurant situation which is why I’m also not looking for a parenting course just tips for dealing with this specific scenario I thought some people on here might have some advice! I’ve googled before and tried all the tips like walking around the restaurant and not putting them in the high chair until the food comes, taking toys, books, practicing at home etc. I thought there might be some lived experienced advice from people on here that are so opinionated about it!

@Peaplant20

Mum of 3 here. My advice would be:

  • Lower your expectations. Don’t expect your LO to sit still for long - it’s just not fair at that age. Lots of the issues on this thread are because parents want to continue their old life with regard to eating out. You can’t. Try quick meals out or a coffee at a cafe first and build up to lunch or dinner.
  • If she’s in a high chair and getting restless, get her out and sit her on your lap and do something with her, like look at a book. Pre-empt.
  • Consider having a specific toy or book that she ONLY gets when you go out for a meal. Then she’ll look forward to it. My kids liked a set of teddies that you dress in different outfits - it had loads of possibilities.
  • Give her the menu. Seriously! My kids loved being given the menu to ‘look at’, because it was something they’d never seen before. They also felt grown up. Then I would read it to them.
  • Involve them in choosing what to eat.
  • Sit them so they are facing other people in the restaurant so they can people watch.
  • Accept that you will probably have to interrupt your own meal at some point, and possibly leave straight after the meal. Just acknowledge that this won’t be fun for you for a few years but you are teaching her valuable lessons that will pay you back.
  • Don’t give in and give her a screen - however tempted you are. This will be controversial on this thread but I personally think that if you do it once she will ALWAYS ask for it from then on. Make it something you just don’t do and then she won’t ask.
  • Goes without saying, but don’t use your own phone at the table!
AGoldenNarwhal · 17/02/2023 19:00

Feetupteashot · 17/02/2023 17:50

Screens are so annoying. We don't use then at restaurants but they are noisy and it ruins the atmosphere. Plus my kids spend the whole time straining their necks to try and watch other kids screens. Otherwise they are usually a pleasure to eat out with, we wouldn't do it Otherwise.

😂. So they prefer the delights of screens to your scintillating and entertaining company. Maybe you just need to up your conversational game?

Of all the arguments against children using screens, I must admit to finding the "they're a corrupting influence on our own impeccably-behaved brood" one more than a little funny. Maybe teach them not to be sheep and follow the crowd?

Swipe left for the next trending thread