Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on with parenting these days?

667 replies

whocaresaboutbeingpopular · 11/02/2023 22:26

Ok, so as my name change suggests I am aware this won’t be popular. My children are almost adults, youngest is 17 this year.

me and OH are away this weekend, we went to a place that to be fair we were aware would be full of kids; but we didn’t think that would matter as we don’t dislike having children around, however, since when did it become a thing to….

put your kids in front of a screen when they are having a meal? Not to mention having full volume of Peppa Fucking Pig?

let your kids shriek at high pitch continuously?

let your 18 month old walk themselves down the stairs despite a massive queue of people behind t? Ffs pick them up!

yes, no doubt I sound a right miserable bastard, but come on - is this how people are raising their kids these day? Bring on the entitled generation.

OP posts:
sacremerde · 12/02/2023 07:06

Your toddler just sounds placid @MelaniesFlowers and you sound extremely smug!

I know parents like you in real life and their kiddies are naturally chilled. They're often late walkers (post 12 months) and happy to sit. They're also more likely to be female toddlers for whatever reason.

I relish it when parents like you have a second child with a more naturally active temperament! Of course you can't take all two year olds to restaurants. It entirely depends on temperament.

pilates · 12/02/2023 07:06

I agree with a lot of what you have said but I would not choose to go to a place like you have described.

Longwhiskers · 12/02/2023 06:58

I’ve never allowed screens in cafes and restaurants but I don’t judge those who do as maybe they need a break! I think parents can sometimes be too quick to resort to screens when out and about.

but the walking down the stairs thing I had to chuckle. I was trying to get down the stairs to a tube platform a couple of years ago and found myself in a crowd plodding down held up by a toddler taking it one step at a time. I muttered to my DH, ‘for god’s sake just pick her up.’ The proud dad must have heard me as he yelled back that she was allowed to walk down the stairs herself. Yes fine! But not on a busy station!

Swiftswatch · 12/02/2023 06:53

Hups · 12/02/2023 04:49

I disagree @Morestrangethings I remember exactly what mine were like.
Bad behaviour wasn't tolerated and they knew it right from being old enough to walk and talk.

Absolute nonsense that your just walking and talking toddlers knew not to ‘shriek’ or run around.
Selective memory.

Flowersfield · 12/02/2023 06:50

Oh I don't know maybe the parent that allows their child a tablet at the dinner table just wants a minute to eat (too) in peace. Maybe it's been months since they've been able to go out as a family, maybe that child just isn't themselves at the moment; they may be tired, coming down with something, it may be something you can't physically see etc. The list goes on and on. Look it's very easy for you to judge now as your children are grown up. Im sire there was a point in time when you too were judged on your 'parenting'.

MrsMikeDrop · 12/02/2023 06:30

Workjobfind · 11/02/2023 22:43

And a lot of NT children do too. My wrath wasn't aimed at you specifically but the general MN approach of "well they must be ND" Whenever behavioural issues are up for discussion. It's never actually just piss poor parenting at play according to this site.

Exactly, this

Talapia · 12/02/2023 06:29

Workjobfind · 11/02/2023 22:38

I have a ND child who doesn't shriek or use an iPad when eating out. Stop putting this one on us and our children.

So true

. My ND children are grown up., So no iPad babysitter. We had some difficult times when they were little and had to leave places, if it was too much for them. No way would I have inflicted screeching and non stop screaming iin a restaurant on other people.

We used to find a restaurant that would allow us to take photos pre visit and make a photo book. Then we'd pop in for a few minutes without ordering food, just to see how the kids coped. Over time we'd be able to have a drink them a meal. I'd always take a bag of small fiddle type toys which were only produced for these occasions. Sometimes, one of us would have to take a child out or go home.

It wasn't easy. It also entirely depends on the ND child's ability to cope so for some of my friends with ND children, eating in a restaurant was never obtainable.

I have no issue with the current gentle parenting. However, some parents seem to believe it negates the need to set boundaries and show regard for other people.

Underhisi · 12/02/2023 06:10

My child is 16 and all the things you talk about happened back then too. Peppa Pig on screens has been around a long time.

Alexisrose16 · 12/02/2023 06:09

I let my child have a screen sometimes in restaurants, she’s 2, we talk about what is happening on the screen because I have exhausted all conversation about the things we saw on the walk here, what we are doing today, tomorrow, next week. I also take colouring books, sticker books, jigsaws. I do this because I live in a very rural place. We go to the park, walks, on the bus, train often. We will start going for picnics when the weather is warmer. But other than my toddler I have spoken to nobody all weekend. Letting her have screen time in a restaurant means I can have 10 minutes to eat and just switch off. We go often as it’s a change of scenery for me. Having a Covid child was very isolating and I hate that I am being judged for my parenting when I became a parent where everything was online, I gave birth almost alone until the midwife came to see me, spent two weeks in hospital unable to leave the room. Parenting is the loneliest, most isolating thing to happen to me. So yes she has screen time because this is one of the only times I day I can message friends, arrange the very few play dates we have and just be somewhere that isn’t home. It’s good to know though that I’m not welcome in restaurants despite the fact that my girl is very well behaved, does not climb or run around and is very often told no.

Creamcakesandpastries · 12/02/2023 06:06

MelaniesFlowers · 11/02/2023 22:46

I have a 2 year old. We don’t do screen time when out and about; never have. I do judge parents who just stick their kids in front of a screen to keep them quiet when they go into a restaurant.

I want to bring my toddler up to be well behaved and patient in resultants, not just stick her in front of a screen and then in a few years time wonder why she won’t sit still/behave appropriately. As a result we can take her to any restaurant or cafe.

I would allow her to walk down the stairs because I think it’s important but I would not allow us to hold other people up. So I wouldn’t do it if it was a small staircase where people couldn’t pass.

@MelaniesFlowers Spot on, exactly the same here!

mybunniesandme · 12/02/2023 06:01

I'm a single parent and have 2 year old twins - I choose places to eat out carefully - I go for ones that look child friendly - ie not posh ones and not pubs. I Go slightly earlier than the usual lunch time rush or dinner and ask to be seated in a quieter area away from other diners if possible. I'll only usually order 1 course to reduce the amount of time sat around and Yes I whip out my phone with Disney on if I need to but I pack up and leave if the kids start getting noisy and running around. People will judge people for anything and everything these days but I've also experienced huge amounts of kindness whilst eating out - a mum who went and found me a chair as there wasn't one at my table and I was obviously going between 3 children sorting their food out, the cafe manager who distracted the twins so I could take my eldest to the loo. You just sound miserable and holier than thou OP which is the worst kind of judgy

Sleepless1096 · 12/02/2023 05:40

This is not a new phenomenon 🙄.

Every generation since the Romans has had its complaints about the parenting of the next generation.

RWB9 · 12/02/2023 05:39

Liorae · 12/02/2023 01:01

Two year olds should only be allowed to go to places with a soft play. They should not be allowed in restaurants or cafes intended for adults or children who know how to behave.

In the same vein, only adults accompanying children should be allowed in aquariums in the school holidays?

ChillysWaterBottle · 12/02/2023 05:33

namechange143 · 12/02/2023 00:13

I think threads like this are why anxious people (like me) dread taking my DS out anywhere.

Not the shrieking, or the dropping food, the thought of being judged by everyone else.

My DH always says of course nobody is bothered what we're up to, they're too busy concentrating on themselves.

Clearly not from some of the comments. Can't believe I've actually just read "I judge other parents". It's nothing to be proud of 😂

Please, please don't let these silly threads bother you. They pop up all the time on Mumsnet, whinging about kids in cafes, buses, planes, parks, supermarkets, trains, aquariums apparently 😅. Please go out with your kid, have fun, and consider ruining the day of these people as a nice bonus to a lovely day out. Its funny, you read all these posts with people smugly talking about what good parents they are or were compared to all the others they see for a few minutes or hours, and often all you end up thinking is 'their poor kids, imagine being raised by that person'. I wouldn't give any mind to these posters. In real life I've often been taken aback about people's kindness and helpfulness x

Hups · 12/02/2023 04:49

I disagree @Morestrangethings I remember exactly what mine were like.
Bad behaviour wasn't tolerated and they knew it right from being old enough to walk and talk.

Morestrangethings · 12/02/2023 03:58

the people on here who have forgotten what their kids were like and choose to remember the shining moments when they were all behaving perfectly. It’s called ‘selective memory.’

No one has all control over a toddler. They are learning and exploring and trying to do things independently. That’s one of the things that makes childrearing so exhausting. You are forever watching and anticipating.

Hups · 12/02/2023 03:01

The only things allowed at the table that my kids were eating at was food, drink and cutlery, whether we were dining in or out, regardless of age.
Shrieking and other ridiculous loud noises were stopped before they got started.

Moobae · 12/02/2023 02:58

Gen z kids breeding zombies

itsabigtree · 12/02/2023 02:56

I agree mainly about the tablet thing. I don't actually think badly of people when I see them do it. But I don't agree that it's the same as a colouring book for a few reasons. A tablet is immersive and takes the child away from engaging with the world, whereas colouring allows for conversation with family. But I can 100 percent understand why parents make the decision to use them even if it's not something I'd do myself.

namechange143 · 12/02/2023 02:51

Liorae · 12/02/2023 00:46

Not the shrieking, or the dropping food, the thought of being judged by everyone else.
Believe me, we are judging you for not dealing with the shrieking.

Oh you won't be judging on my shrieking kid as we don't go out for meals to avoid the judgey types (He also doesn't shriek, not in public anyway) Wink

Morestrangethings · 12/02/2023 02:33

No, nothing changed re kids. Kids were always noisy and often wanting to walk down stairs on their own and sometimes you let them because it’s the easiest way to avoid the conflict over dinner etc.

What has changed is your age, and your kids’ ages. You’ve grown past the ability to not let it bother you because your kids aren’t small anymore.

I wouldn’t go on a weekend were I knew there was going to be little kids. As I don’t find it peaceful and it annoys me.

I have grandkids now and they’re lots of fun and I really enjoy my times with them;?but even that hasn’t bought back my tolerance for kids in holiday type places.

And every generation refers to ‘kids these days’ being different. They aren’t different. We just forget and become less able to tolerate as we age.

Toomanybooks22 · 12/02/2023 02:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That's really not on to make ageist comments like that

StClare101 · 12/02/2023 02:14

I’m baffled by giving kids screens in restaurants. We’ve never done it. We don’t own iPads. Our kids are seven and eight and when they were toddlers we went to cafes where the food was served quickly. Now they chat with us, like we all used to at the same age.

Do people think their kids will learn how to chat with adults in a restaurant all on their own ? That it will just suddenly happen at a certain age? No. You are conditioning them to expect to be stimulated and entertained in these settings.

EmmaDilemma5 · 12/02/2023 02:10

Sad miserable person 🤭

LemonSwan · 12/02/2023 01:46

WedonttalkaboutMaureen · 12/02/2023 01:10

Ouch there's a lot of aggression on this thread on both sides, it's a touchy subject.

I do think OP has a point about a small minority of parents when she said this:

  • when are children supposed to learn to tolerate a bit of tedium and boredom?

Most parents of young/primary age children I see are doing a damn good job but there's a few that seem determined to never let their child feel any negative emotion EVER:

Hungry? Fifteen snacks in 2 hours
Bored? Tablet instantly provided before child has even sat down
Tantrum? Anything to attempt to soothe and cajole for ages rather than just take them outside
Say No/stop that/enough - oh no never say that! the horror of squashing their creativity as they kick shit out of other kids

The parent seems determined to always provide a way of avoiding/solving any situation that might make their child feel at all uncomfortable- so how the heck does the child ever learn to deal with adversity, emotions, social norms that might be a little difficult to learn, navigating new situations and so on?
I do wonder how these kids who never hear No or learn how to handle a situation not to their liking will get on when they are older and fending for themselves. I don't think it's a good prep for the real world. I don't mean be horrible to our kids cos the world is horrible. I want us to raise kids who are empathetic and kind, by modelling kindness. But also to know and respect boundaries, and have awareness of others and how their behaviour can impact other people.

I was reading the thread and thinking gosh I am lucky with my 10 month old. Did a 3 hour 3 courses evening meal and coffees in quite a posh independent Italian impeccably last week no tablets or anything.

Luckily he’s weaning so my tactic was to very slowly drip feed him food to poke about and explore. And apparently that’s not ok either 🤣

It’s in this moment I realised everyone’s a bad parent in the eyes of someone somewhere 🤣 and that’s not a snipe at poster I am replying to. Just a realisation. We all just have different things which are important to us and trying to do the best we can in the moment.