Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is going on with parenting these days?

667 replies

whocaresaboutbeingpopular · 11/02/2023 22:26

Ok, so as my name change suggests I am aware this won’t be popular. My children are almost adults, youngest is 17 this year.

me and OH are away this weekend, we went to a place that to be fair we were aware would be full of kids; but we didn’t think that would matter as we don’t dislike having children around, however, since when did it become a thing to….

put your kids in front of a screen when they are having a meal? Not to mention having full volume of Peppa Fucking Pig?

let your kids shriek at high pitch continuously?

let your 18 month old walk themselves down the stairs despite a massive queue of people behind t? Ffs pick them up!

yes, no doubt I sound a right miserable bastard, but come on - is this how people are raising their kids these day? Bring on the entitled generation.

OP posts:
Heronwatcher · 12/02/2023 08:07

Nothing’s gone wrong with parenting, you’re just getting a bit older and can’t seem to tolerate relatively normal child behaviour. Also what you will have seen will be a very short snapshot of the day. Maybe some parents have spent hours earnestly interacting with their kids and just want 10 mins peace before they attempt the journey home and use a screen for that- it’s no worse than a pen and paper (I agree though headphones should be used). Maybe it’s the first time that the 18m old had attempted stairs, and did anyone die for waiting a few mins? Maybe all the shrieking kids had been perfectly behaved all day and just needed 5 mins to let off steam and in fact it was the combination of so many of them which was the issue. I would definitely have tried to quiet them down and calm them down if mine but I will 100% admit that it didn’t always work quickly. Or maybe it was you having a bad day which made it all worse. I’d visit these sorts of places in term time in the future as it’s not going to make you happy to become a tutter and you need to find a way to desensitise yourself to it I think.

Morestrangethings · 12/02/2023 08:05

@Alexisrose16 you have my total sympathy. That sounds all very tough. But it also sounds like you are doing all the right things. Ignore those that have perfectly behaved children who never have scene time in a cafe so mum can get 10 much needed minutes to herself. I don’t judge: lots of people don’t judge. And there are many women who would be absolutely understanding. the judgy types can judge each other.

wherethewaterisdarker · 12/02/2023 08:03

You sound awful and I feel sorry for your own children honestly. We are still a remarkably un-child friendly society with opinions like yours the norm. Children shriek, children walk more slowly - they also have as much right to take up the space as you do! I imagine that’s a radical thought for you.

ChocMarshmallows · 12/02/2023 08:00

I really hate all this screen judging!! My 11 and 9 year old boys have both survived toddler years using a screen at the table! They have both developed into well mannered, well behaved young children. They are polite and able to have conversation in a restaurant despite occasionally being given a screen when they were 4 in pizza express!!

I really think all the posts implying that children given screens when in a restaurant age 3, won't grow into well mannered 11 year olds are ridiculous and incredibly judgemental.

We have some friends and the children are same age as mine (11 and 9). They are lovely children, but so are mine!! The mum is also on the whole really lovely. But these children have never been given a screen. They are not allowed to play computer games, watch YouTube etc... And the smugness and superiority which ooses from the mum about this really pushes my buttons!!!

The superior attitude of the anti screen bunch I just find so odd!!

Iwantabloodypizza · 12/02/2023 08:00

winterpastasalad · 12/02/2023 07:49

@Iwantabloodypizza of course they've always existed. My point is that libraries used to be places where it was expected to be fairly quiet, even for children. Now it's the adults (parent) riling up the dc and actively encouraging them to make noise.

But I have always seen that!

When my ds was a baby I lived in nappy valley. The library was wall to wall, over the top animal sounds from parents while their children just looked bored and chewed the corners.

Loud parents have always existed, libraries are the key stomping ground because they tick all the look at me boxes for them.

Using a library - tick! Interacting with my child - tick! They are clearly cleverer than yours and will go to Cambridge because they are 10 months and can make a froggy sound which you must all know about because I will make them screech it at full volume twenty times - tick! “Look darling, mummy is a froggy! look at mummy hop like a froggy, can you hop like a froggy! Who’s watching me! You must all watch me and see what a fabulously mummy I am!” - while the child doesn’t give a shit and just wants to go home.

Oh god, it’s been grating on me for two decades!!

Hups · 12/02/2023 07:56

Swiftswatch · 12/02/2023 06:53

Absolute nonsense that your just walking and talking toddlers knew not to ‘shriek’ or run around.
Selective memory.

No selective memory here.
They knew from the off that they had to behave or else.

MaryShelley1818 · 12/02/2023 07:54

MelaniesFlowers · 11/02/2023 22:46

I have a 2 year old. We don’t do screen time when out and about; never have. I do judge parents who just stick their kids in front of a screen to keep them quiet when they go into a restaurant.

I want to bring my toddler up to be well behaved and patient in resultants, not just stick her in front of a screen and then in a few years time wonder why she won’t sit still/behave appropriately. As a result we can take her to any restaurant or cafe.

I would allow her to walk down the stairs because I think it’s important but I would not allow us to hold other people up. So I wouldn’t do it if it was a small staircase where people couldn’t pass.

I agree with all of this.
We don't do screens when out and about. I have a 5yr old and 2yr old and they're not perfect but really do have beautiful manners/behaviour at restaurants, we can take them anywhere. We always take something small and quiet we can do with them at restaurants if we're going for a longer meal or with other people so puzzle games, board books, Colouring.

DD went through a thankfully short phase of thinking it was amusing to shreik, but lasted a week or so if that.

I have no problem with a child walking independently on stairs but if holding people up would step to the side so people could pass. I wouldn't stop her walking though and pick her up.

Adrelaxzz · 12/02/2023 07:53

secretllama · 12/02/2023 07:43

My mum hated it and was v judgemental. But if I didn't bring the screens she was judgemental of the children talking and fidgeting etc.. so you can't win.

@ChocMarshmallows exactly this. The OP is simultaneously moaning about kids shrieking and moaning about screens. Maybe the parents of kids with screens are trying to stop them kicking off. Also, as another PP said... why is a screen any different from colouring at a table?

But it's so often kids who are older, I get it with toddlers but a 4 year old plus should be learning how to sit quietly for a bit. I was out last week with friends in a very nice restaurant. The table next to us had 3 kids aged about 7 and older who didn't even put their iPads down to eat. The parents talk a bit to each other but I never saw them once engaging with their children. They were there for 2 hours. It was a bit depressing. I can't think of a situation where I have done then, even when knackered or grieving or mid divorce where I would ignore my kids that long.

winterpastasalad · 12/02/2023 07:49

@Iwantabloodypizza of course they've always existed. My point is that libraries used to be places where it was expected to be fairly quiet, even for children. Now it's the adults (parent) riling up the dc and actively encouraging them to make noise.

ChristmasPizza · 12/02/2023 07:48

My eldest will sit at a table in a restaurant fairly nicely with some colouring.

My youngest (22 months) can sit still for approximately 2 minutes. Every fibre of his being wants to escape his high chair and run around and touch every button, break out of fire escapes, talk to everyone, climb everything. When he's cornered and brought back to the table he screeches and writhes like a wet fish. He gets bored of colouring and books after a couple of minutes.

So it's either that, he disturbs everyone around us and I have a nervous breakdown, or we put some (very quiet) telly on my phone for him while we eat.

I'm sure he'll calm down a bit when he's older, but I don't think his personality has anything to do with my 'bad parenting' - he's just a toddler. Maybe if your toddlers sit perfectly at the table you just got lucky with a chill one Wink

Buildingthefuture · 12/02/2023 07:46

YANBU. DH and I tried a new restaurant last night. It’s a cocktail bar and restaurant and definitely not somewhere that I would take young children. But, there were several children in there and they were running riot!! Literally, running around the (very busy) restaurant, fighting with each other, climbing all over other peoples chairs, up the bar stools, screaming etc. Parents just ignored it. Awful.

Adrelaxzz · 12/02/2023 07:46

Workjobfind · 11/02/2023 22:38

I have a ND child who doesn't shriek or use an iPad when eating out. Stop putting this one on us and our children.

Hear, bloody hear!! We had to spend time engaging with them but my DS with SNs didn't rely on screens when out.

secretllama · 12/02/2023 07:43

My mum hated it and was v judgemental. But if I didn't bring the screens she was judgemental of the children talking and fidgeting etc.. so you can't win.

@ChocMarshmallows exactly this. The OP is simultaneously moaning about kids shrieking and moaning about screens. Maybe the parents of kids with screens are trying to stop them kicking off. Also, as another PP said... why is a screen any different from colouring at a table?

WonderingWanda · 12/02/2023 07:40

I'm with you op it seems that parents these days don't like to say no to their offspring, ever.

CTRALTDEL · 12/02/2023 07:40

I wouldn’t have let my kids do those things, but YABU because I suspect you’ve forgotten what it was like to have small kids, and that your parenting and their behaviour really got on other people’s nerves at times, and was far from perfect

LlynTegid · 12/02/2023 07:40

The parents who do not set boundaries and challenge unacceptable behaviour are those who will suffer the most, especially when their DC get older.

ChocMarshmallows · 12/02/2023 07:38

Well I agree with you on the screaming and the walking down the stairs.

But iPads for under 5s/6s are really useful.

My children are 9 and 11 and haven't used an iPad when out for years, but when little they played on a kindle/tablet/phone at the table largely for the benefit of other people in the restaurant/cafe etc.. so they were quiet and not trying to leave the seat etc.. or disrupt anyone.

My mum hated it and was v judgemental. But if I didn't bring the screens she was judgemental of the children talking and fidgeting etc.. so you can't win.

Screens are a helpful way, when they children are small, for everyone to enjoy the meal. The adults can relax, mum (and it usually is mum) can also relax without having to stress over keeping the children quiet and keeping them entertained etc.., the children can have fun and not get bored, the other customers and staff are happy as no disruptive children.

My children appear to have no lasting damage! They are capable at 11 and 9 of holding good conversation at the table and are well mannered.

I think people just have unnecessary judgement about screens the same way they do with dummies.

tillylula · 12/02/2023 07:36

MelaniesFlowers · 11/02/2023 22:46

I have a 2 year old. We don’t do screen time when out and about; never have. I do judge parents who just stick their kids in front of a screen to keep them quiet when they go into a restaurant.

I want to bring my toddler up to be well behaved and patient in resultants, not just stick her in front of a screen and then in a few years time wonder why she won’t sit still/behave appropriately. As a result we can take her to any restaurant or cafe.

I would allow her to walk down the stairs because I think it’s important but I would not allow us to hold other people up. So I wouldn’t do it if it was a small staircase where people couldn’t pass.

Easy to do when you only have 1

Iwantabloodypizza · 12/02/2023 07:31

winterpastasalad · 12/02/2023 07:19

My youngest is a teen now but I agree parenting has really changed. I don't care much about seeing screens at the table, I'd rather that than them running around or shrieking. Earphones must be used though. I regularly go to IKEA and the (one way) stairs always have a queue because someone is giving their toddler "autonomy" and they are taking ages to go down. Don't get me started on libraries - you used to be able to go in and have a quiet read. The last few times I've been in they seem to be a hive for performative parents. One mum was really trying her best mummy act by very loudly asking her young son to demonstrate what noise each dinosaur makes Hmm

Oh come one, those sort of dipshit “look at me! I’m the best parent ever!” performative parents have always existed. They were certainly around 20 years ago when my ds was a baby, clogging up staircases and being loud in libraries.

I remember them from my own childhood 40 years ago, we had the loud family at the horse riding school who would give a running commentary on how well their children were riding and my mum would do impressions all the way home. That’s not a new thing. i’m

Sleepyquest · 12/02/2023 07:29

MelaniesFlowers · 11/02/2023 22:46

I have a 2 year old. We don’t do screen time when out and about; never have. I do judge parents who just stick their kids in front of a screen to keep them quiet when they go into a restaurant.

I want to bring my toddler up to be well behaved and patient in resultants, not just stick her in front of a screen and then in a few years time wonder why she won’t sit still/behave appropriately. As a result we can take her to any restaurant or cafe.

I would allow her to walk down the stairs because I think it’s important but I would not allow us to hold other people up. So I wouldn’t do it if it was a small staircase where people couldn’t pass.

I'm the same as you. Have never done screen time out in public!

Iwantabloodypizza · 12/02/2023 07:27

My oldest is 21 and my youngest is 2, and one in the middle.

I’ve been parenting a long time.

I don’t see it’s changed all that much.

Yes, we have fantastic tech now. I think tablets are bloody wonderful. Children can learn so much from them.

I used to let my eldest play snake on my nokia on car journeys 🤣

He used to get bored eating out sometimes because it can get boring for children.

They aren’t destined for a life of solitude and no social skills because they used an ipad at the Harvester.

Fwiw, I don’t let my children use tablets at restaurants or anywhere else - they stay at home, mainly because I don’t want them lost or broken, and I do think it’s rude when people have them at high volume. But do I give a shit of other parents let their kids use them? Nope. I don’t care what other people do.

I think a lot of it is looking a back at rose tinted specs, which I don’t do seeing as I’ve been in the thick of it for so long.

winterpastasalad · 12/02/2023 07:19

My youngest is a teen now but I agree parenting has really changed. I don't care much about seeing screens at the table, I'd rather that than them running around or shrieking. Earphones must be used though. I regularly go to IKEA and the (one way) stairs always have a queue because someone is giving their toddler "autonomy" and they are taking ages to go down. Don't get me started on libraries - you used to be able to go in and have a quiet read. The last few times I've been in they seem to be a hive for performative parents. One mum was really trying her best mummy act by very loudly asking her young son to demonstrate what noise each dinosaur makes Hmm

Morestrangethings · 12/02/2023 07:18

Sleepless1096 · 12/02/2023 05:40

This is not a new phenomenon 🙄.

Every generation since the Romans has had its complaints about the parenting of the next generation.

Exactly.

CalpolDependant · 12/02/2023 07:15

I’m with you OP, but I’ve been lucky with my kids thus far, in that they will sit quietly at the dinner table for circa 2 courses, provided one of those courses contains chocolate.

I do let them go on their tablets in the car on the way home though, and they would quite literally do anything to earn those 15 minutes. It’s all stick with me, baby. I’m a briber.

I don’t know what I’d do if I had kids that couldn’t hack the table, maybe I’d let them have tablets too.

My SIL has let hers all have her phone at the table since before they could actually eat. (4 months) I smugly and quietly judge her for it, which isn’t nice of me, but I do keep all of my thoughts to myself IRL

FilthyforFirth · 12/02/2023 07:06

I agree with everything you've said and I have a 5 and 2 year old.

Shreiking when out and about is a no no and I always tell mine to be quieter and mindful of others, it's not hard, just takes some parenting.

I am very anti screens, so mine dont get them at all. I do find it sad when kids arw shoved in front of them, especially from such a young age.

The 18mo thing is also ridiculous, practicing to walk should not inconveniece everyone else. But a lot of parents are very entitled and think the world revovles around them.

YANBU

Swipe left for the next trending thread