Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why the hell do some parents do this?

444 replies

Atethehalloweenchocs · 11/02/2023 19:39

Went out for a nice celebration lunch. It was a step up from your regular restaurant, the kind of place where chef sounds out an amuse bouche, there is one menu for the day, the waiters put on white gloves to bring your plates and cutlery etc etc. But pretentious, but had heard good things and it was amazing food. And expensive, but a celebration so we splashed out. Near us was a group which a young couple with their two children. One was a babe in arms who cried - fair enough, babies cry and after a while of not being able to quiet him or her, dad went out and walked around outside. Much appreciated that he did that. However, the other child, a girl of about 5 or 6, was allowed to sing, at the top of her voice for over an hour. The same line over and over, which I finally worked out was 'I don't care' from Let It Go. For a fucking hour. I get it is hard to manage kids in public sometimes but you could see people looking from all over the restaurant. If we had been in the local pub I would not have thought twice. But in a place which is way out of most peoples usual daily reach, am I unreasonable to think those parents should have said something to this child and told her to stop?

OP posts:
PinkSyCo · 15/02/2023 07:39

KatherineJaneway · 15/02/2023 07:29

Oh look everyone, one of the parents of these 9 year olds has just turned up!

Such a lazy and predictable retort, but I don’t take offence because I would not be ashamed if I were one of the parents. 🤷🏻‍♀️

gogohmm · 15/02/2023 07:39

Can i point out you need to talk to and entertain your children so they don't annoy other diners even at pizza express. It's perfectly possible but takes work, you can't just talk to your friends! Don't take your kids out unless you are willing to interact with them, my sil (much younger than me) brings a bag of quiet items to restaurants now, it's not just me!

PinkSyCo · 15/02/2023 07:36

rookiemere · 15/02/2023 07:22

@PinkSyCo I agree - I thought the train story wasn't relevant to OPs situation. I mean unless you're in the quiet carriage, or possibly first class, you expect DCs to make some noise on a long trip - particularly one that's been delayed.

Not really comparable to OPs situation, where all the diners have paid a large amount of money to enjoy a sophisticated meal, and the unwritten assumption is there will be an atmosphere to match.

Exactly. I wouldn’t dream of taking a noisy child to a posh restaurant, but I wouldn’t dream of not letting my child chat/sing on a delayed train journey either.

gogohmm · 15/02/2023 07:33

I don't understand why today's parents don't bring paper and pens, but that age we would have been playing hangman or boxes, they also would have coloured, done puzzles etc. No smartphone's then so you had to entertain them and went prepared. My children did go to many nice restaurants too, and they didn't disturb other guests singing

KatherineJaneway · 15/02/2023 07:29

PinkSyCo · 15/02/2023 07:18

Just proves what a nation of moaning, intolerant stress heads we’ve become then.

Oh look everyone, one of the parents of these 9 year olds has just turned up!

rookiemere · 15/02/2023 07:22

@PinkSyCo I agree - I thought the train story wasn't relevant to OPs situation. I mean unless you're in the quiet carriage, or possibly first class, you expect DCs to make some noise on a long trip - particularly one that's been delayed.

Not really comparable to OPs situation, where all the diners have paid a large amount of money to enjoy a sophisticated meal, and the unwritten assumption is there will be an atmosphere to match.

PinkSyCo · 15/02/2023 07:18

KatherineJaneway · 15/02/2023 07:00

So two 9 year olds got on with making innocent entertainment for themselves, without the aid of screens or snacks, while held up in a tunnel and adults have a problem with this?

For 40 solid minutes? Yes, I'd have a problem with that.

Just proves what a nation of moaning, intolerant stress heads we’ve become then.

KatherineJaneway · 15/02/2023 07:00

So two 9 year olds got on with making innocent entertainment for themselves, without the aid of screens or snacks, while held up in a tunnel and adults have a problem with this?

For 40 solid minutes? Yes, I'd have a problem with that.

TerfIngOnTheBeach · 15/02/2023 06:27

This is why places like Brewers Fayre were invented, and why you don’t see couples with grown up children in there.

YANBU.

PinkSyCo · 15/02/2023 06:23

PegSliderskew · 11/02/2023 19:52

I was on the train recently- it was packed and across from me were a dad, his daughter and her friend. They were a bit excited and giggly, but only about 9 and obviously only just out of afterschool club so probably overtired as well. Quite sweet really.

Then the train stopped in a tunnel. For 40 minutes. And for the entire time the girls were allowed to practise a long clapping rhyme neither of them could actually finish. The entire time, over and over and over again. I went from thinking 'he'll tell them to quieten down in a minute', through 'how the hell can he just pretend he hasn't noticed' to being fascinated about how long he could keep ignoring them. I think the rest of the carriage were in a similar position- we started off feeling that it would be mean to say anything to a pair of tired little girls and then it tipped over to the point where it would be embarrassing to say something after so long.

Anyway, if anyone wants to practice a clapping rhyme about a lady with a big, fat bum who can wiggle, she can waggle, she can even do the splits, hit me up. I'm an expert now. And if you get it wrong, you're not my friend.

So two 9 year olds got on with making innocent entertainment for themselves, without the aid of screens or snacks, while held up in a tunnel and adults have a problem with this?

Ellyesse · 14/02/2023 22:55

Spikeyball, Were you asking me about where I worked or what kind of work I did?
If so, the things you mention mean nothing to me. Just to be polite I shall tell you some of my background. I have worked in the Institute of Psychiatry, attached to the Maudsley Hospital where I did research and learned to recognise signs of psychiatric disorders. This makes following some conversations on social media quite interesting.
I worked in other places after doing a post graduate course at the Institute of Neurology and I taught in three universities.

Regarding this Forum I think Atethehalloweenchocs explained a situation that’s very relevant and useful to discuss. She made it very clear what she wanted to address -should parents ask their children not to be noisy in public places such as the restaurant she described.

I think it’s abundantly reasonable to expect parents to ask their children to keep their noise level down when in the situation described in this discussion.

Many thanks Atethehalloweenchocs, it’s a good topic. I have noticed since I first became a mum that parents vary from those who let their brats smack bricks into your telly and hit your baby to those who apologise if their baby burps. I guess the world is like that and we probably need to be courageous and stick up for our rights in the face of the lousy parents and maybe give confidence to the shy ones. But I know if one tries to, for example, ask if someone could keep the noise down, it can still be upsetting just having to do this!
I hope you get a reason to celebrate again soon and your next meal at the lovely restaurant will be leisurely, relaxed, delicious, and peaceful.

Spikeyball · 14/02/2023 20:35

"were you working for SonRise or some sort of ABA behaviour modification program? 😱."

Sounds like it. All about appearing ' normal' to others and no thought for what the behaviour is communicating

Ellyess · 14/02/2023 20:05

Atethehalloweenchocs · 13/02/2023 16:22

Yes, @Countdown2023 - parents are responsible - not teachers, not waiters and not me. There are too many people who are lazy or entitled, feel that as long as they are not bothered by something it should be ok including their little darlings disturbing others.
@Itisbetter - it was a small dining room, there was no where to be moved to. The waiters were visibly uncomfortable by the whole thing. As for mentioning it, do you think the parents really didn't know that was not ok? They just didnt give a crap about anyone else.

OP said she was 5 or 6.

OP said the Parents did nothing.

OP said all in the dining room were adversely affected.

OP made it clear this is about the parents making no effort to do anything to create a comfortable environment for the other Diners. They did not even talk to the child about it, let alone try and divert her attention.

It is not about special needs or rare disability.

It's about negligent parents of a 5 year old, who, even if she does not have the ability to behave in a social situation such as this, does need to be taken out. But I doubt very much that she could not have been very pleasantly made to stop, if handled the right way. I taught for 20 years, my favourite age group Infants, then I studied Psychology, did research on Autism and worked in hospitals as a Neuro Psychologist. I met loads of different children and parents and they all were reasonable and cared about the comfort of others. The 'my nephew has echolalia' argument does not mean this child age 5-6 can sing loudly like that in that setting non stop for an hour and the parents not try to stop her. It's bananas to try and create excuses for the parents.

Bleachmycloths · 14/02/2023 19:47

Atethehalloweenchocs · 14/02/2023 17:03

For crying out loud - to all those who have made this about disability - kids like repetition - same stories over and over, same songs over and over. That is normal. She may have been ASD but she may equally well have not, and just trying to amuse herself. And her parents needed to help her balance that with disrupting others and they clearly did not give a shit. When did it get the norm that you can do disruptive or annoying behaviour until asked not to? Where is the personal fucking responsibility?

It is very clear there are many people who feel whatever their children do is ok. And that is fundamentally not ok. Not asking for perfect silence, children being seen not heard, not moving around - nothing like that. Just expect that if you have procreated yourself you will understand that part of your job as a parent is giving children the skills they need to function in the world and not expect it to revolve around them - and manners is part of this.

I am on your side. There’s some real bullshit on here from people who missed the point then tried to make it a disability thread. They underestimated you. You would have seen if the child had problems. You were there, the bullshitters weren’t.

Ellyess · 14/02/2023 19:46

Atethehalloweenchocs · 14/02/2023 17:03

For crying out loud - to all those who have made this about disability - kids like repetition - same stories over and over, same songs over and over. That is normal. She may have been ASD but she may equally well have not, and just trying to amuse herself. And her parents needed to help her balance that with disrupting others and they clearly did not give a shit. When did it get the norm that you can do disruptive or annoying behaviour until asked not to? Where is the personal fucking responsibility?

It is very clear there are many people who feel whatever their children do is ok. And that is fundamentally not ok. Not asking for perfect silence, children being seen not heard, not moving around - nothing like that. Just expect that if you have procreated yourself you will understand that part of your job as a parent is giving children the skills they need to function in the world and not expect it to revolve around them - and manners is part of this.

Yessssssssss!

So true

As a foot note, I only responded about Special Needs for the sake of people writing with concern about Special Needs. From experience with parents of children with special needs, but I remember they all wanted their children to learn behaviour that made them calm and not annoying to others in social settings. I know some parents can be very sensitive.

I hope I made it clear that it makes no difference whether a child has special needs or not. As parents it is our responsibility to teach our children to behave in away that shows consideration for others and be aware when they are being noisy, irritating etc. For Heaven's sake, I have small rescued dogs 2 of which are nervous and more inclined to bark. But I never leave them barking in the garden for any longer than a few minutes (while I finish going to the loo).

This forum is about parents who don't show that consideration and don't teach it to their children.

And OP, Definitely, YANBU!

Itisbetter · 14/02/2023 19:21

@Mumsanetta its unfortunate but realistically if you read someone being overtly racist and for example suggesting that a particular race should stay out of posh restaurants you’d challenge it, because it’s the right thing to do. If they continue to do so you continue to challenge those ideas. It’s the same when someone does it to disabled people, and more so if you love someone who is disabled.
@Atethehalloweenchocs I’d have asked them if she could be quieter or asked the waiter. I’m sorry your posh celebration wasn’t how you wanted it to be, I hope the food was lovely and you got some joy.

Mumsanetta · 14/02/2023 18:51

Agreed that they are two separate discussions but don’t think it’s fair that the discussion on disability has derailed the OP’s original thread!

Itisbetter · 14/02/2023 17:32

@Atethehalloweenchocs I think the discussion of inclusion of disabled people is separate to the incident with the noisy little girl. Most people were just responding to the idea that disabled people shouldn’t be in restaurants if they can’t hide their disability. In the case of your little girl it’s far more likely she’s upset by the new baby imo than has any SN

Atethehalloweenchocs · 14/02/2023 17:03

For crying out loud - to all those who have made this about disability - kids like repetition - same stories over and over, same songs over and over. That is normal. She may have been ASD but she may equally well have not, and just trying to amuse herself. And her parents needed to help her balance that with disrupting others and they clearly did not give a shit. When did it get the norm that you can do disruptive or annoying behaviour until asked not to? Where is the personal fucking responsibility?

It is very clear there are many people who feel whatever their children do is ok. And that is fundamentally not ok. Not asking for perfect silence, children being seen not heard, not moving around - nothing like that. Just expect that if you have procreated yourself you will understand that part of your job as a parent is giving children the skills they need to function in the world and not expect it to revolve around them - and manners is part of this.

OP posts:
Itisbetter · 14/02/2023 16:04

FYI all the families I had the pleasure to meet followed our program or that of their local team if they lived too far away and all of them made wonderful progress. The children all had difficult behaviour problems at the start, and all of them progressed so well that they were able to happily follow the social norms of different situations such as eating out, going to Church, to the theatre, and so on. were you working for SonRise or some sort of ABA behaviour modification program? 😱. Is “progress”passing for normal? 100% success rate at stuffing autistic children into nt moulds, yikes.

UWhatNow · 14/02/2023 15:46

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 09:42

Are you god our saviour? If you ‘told’ me to move or leave I’d laugh and tell you to fuck off

Wow how depressing... We stand no chance then as a society if people like you don’t give a shiny shit about disturbing others and are happy to tell them to fuck off. What kind of utopian world are you promoting there with those values?

Jeez you really need to check yourself.

Ellyess · 14/02/2023 15:00

Itisbetter
You said:
'I really hope you didn’t have much contact with the parents of disabled children when you were working. If you did I wonder how they felt after hearing how to stay in the shadows and not bother the older more able people. I hope they went home and saw your message for what it is. Revolting.'

You are a liar and abusive.
That is not what I said. I have never said anything so stupid and you are deliberately lying to arouse hatred. This is extremely abusive and I shall not tolerate your attacks any more.
FYI all the families I had the pleasure to meet followed our program or that of their local team if they lived too far away and all of them made wonderful progress. The children all had difficult behaviour problems at the start, and all of them progressed so well that they were able to happily follow the social norms of different situations such as eating out, going to Church, to the theatre, and so on.

You need to keep to the point of this forum:

The child in this case we are told is 5-6 years old and does not appear SEN.

I said that any young child who could not be stopped from making a constant noise so loud it disturbed the whole restaurant should be taken outside to stop the child from disturbing other people, and to distract the child, just as the father who took the crying baby outside. Obviously the parents should ask the child to quiet down first.

That is perfectly reasonable and is supported by the voting on this forum where 92% feel 'those parents should have said something to this child and told her to stop?'

Noise pollution is a real disturbance and people expect to enjoy a meal without an irritating noise going on throughout it when they come to this type of restaurant. If a child of 5-6 years old cannot keep quiet enough not to disturb people in all the restaurant, [OP said people all over the room were looking at her] I think she should not be there. Maybe she is too young to be in such a restaurant. If a disabled adult does not understand the required noise levels then special arrangements need to be made for them to enjoy eating there or other customers paying the high prices will be driven away. The constant repetition of one line of a song in a loud volume constitutes noise pollution nuisance level noise. Such things have been used as torture throughout time.

Now, Itisbetter, Keep to the facts. Stop making up lies and stop writing offensive imaginings about me. Stop you trolling abuse.

MatronicO6 · 14/02/2023 13:10

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:42

I have never said it’s ok to watch loud iPads without headphones so not sure why you’re asking me?

I didn't mention loud ipads in my comment.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:42

MatronicO6 · 14/02/2023 10:20

What about the ND children and adults who are distressed by loud disruptive noises? Auditory sensitivity is common in people with ASDD. Do we not have to consider their needs and accommodate them?

I have never said it’s ok to watch loud iPads without headphones so not sure why you’re asking me?

MatronicO6 · 14/02/2023 10:47

Sirzy · 14/02/2023 10:35

And this clash of needs is where things get complicated.

ds can’t cope with extra noises so we have to plan as best as possible to avoid things where problem noises will be. For him he can’t cope with singing at all (to the point I can’t listen to anything but 5 live in the car incase I sing along without realising!) so someone nearby singing the same line over and over would mean we had to leave before he ended up in meltdown.

balancing needs isn’t a black and white situation because needs vary so much.

I completely agree with you. I was trying to make the point that it is not clear and it is a grey area. There are so many different needs that we cannot meet everyone's at all times.

But I do think it is fair for parents of neuro typical children to be aware of the spaces thet are in and reach them to be respectful of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread