Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified by these ‘baby boxes’?

328 replies

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 11/02/2023 09:55

This just came up on my newsfeed and I’m absolutely horrified by the whole concept of women abandoning their newborns in the US:

www.newschannel10.com/2023/02/10/newborn-surrendered-baby-box-installed-less-than-3-months-ago/?fbclid=IwAR1qz7BbrIeF390b6YXl4mAscw82cTvt-Bzwnp_LMaZMMCjBcpltEZGHav0#ldzrvrvoa7ecauugx04

Im NOT having a go at these women, and this is supposedly to prevent newborns being abandoned in unsafe places.

But surely the answer isn’t “Hey brand new mum with raging hormones, probably depression, who is tired, stressed and not thinking straight - put your baby here for a nice new family” - it should be about supporting mums with PND, improving practical support, healthcare and rights of new mothers and reproductive rights. Not just “Oh well you don’t feel OK today so probably best you don’t be a mum, here’s a little box to pop your baby in”.

My spidey senses were tingling so when I did a bit of further research, the woman who started these is, of course, fiercely anti abortion. So that’s what it’s all about. it’s about not allowing women their reproductive rights but making them go through a birth they don’t want, have the trauma of having a baby they don’t want but it’s OK, and the heartache of giving them away - no harm done ey 😡

OP posts:
RoseGoldEagle · 11/02/2023 12:49

If these boxes have led to an increase in the numbers of babies being abandoned then you might have a point. The numbers seem low though, so it sounds like these are babies that would have been abandoned anyway, so this is just making that horribly sad situation that would have happened anyway a bit safer for the baby.

Coyoacan · 11/02/2023 12:46

I'm with you OP and I found your post perfectly clear.

Abandoned babies are a sign of a society where there is a stigma attached to being a single mother, so women have to hide their pregnancies and then give the baby up for adoption in secret.

The US has next to no support for poor mothers and now they cannot even get an abortion, but those baby boxes indicate that even having the baby is being stigmatised and, as usual, people are more interested in getting a baby for free than making it easier for those children to stay with their mothers.

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/02/2023 12:38

They’ve been around for centuries. Nothing new.

I can see they have purpose when all else fails. There are other options so most mothers won’t chose this. One of the things I think is tough on birth mothers in UK adoption law is that your identity is know to your child who can search for you if they want to. I expect most people are fine with this, but there should be an option to opt out. Amongst other things this provides that.

Knoblauch · 11/02/2023 12:32

My grandmother was abandoned as a baby in the 1920's. She was left on a door step in the cold during a winter storm. She's very lucky she survived, was taken in by this family and went on to live a long life with a big family of her own. Many many abandoned babies aren't that lucky though. Many end up being abandoned in dangerous situations, become unwell or die. Why on earth you'd think this concept is a bad idea is absolutely baffling. Baby boxes have been around for a very long time, especially in many European countries, where is your outrage at that?

Didactylos · 11/02/2023 12:29

I think this sort of system to allow abandonment of a baby with anonymity for the mother started in the 12th Century - look up “foundling wheels”. I can imagine in a world with limited food security, no contraception, no consequences for the perpetrators of rape and or violence, and where many women had no resources (and if they were lucky family assistance) it was a reasonable solution that gave an unwanted or unsupported child a chance of survival.
And yes OP, I agree, its literally a medieval solution and surely we can do better for mothers in this day and age.

Rebellious23 · 11/02/2023 12:28

And I think they should be available in the U.K. they don't replace access to safe legal abortion but should be an add on to it

Rebellious23 · 11/02/2023 12:27

MintJulia · 11/02/2023 11:11

OP, I think you need to walk a mile in someone else's shoes.

Think of the girls from backgrounds where having a child outside of marriage is absolutely unacceptable. Who have hidden their pregnancies. Of the very young who leave in fear of family members. Who don't have the access to healthcare or resources that you do.
Of the absolutely desperate who would otherwise be forced to abandon babies.

You've clearly never experienced that fear and desperation, but it's not that rare even in the UK in 2023.

That ^^
I use 2 forms of contraception. If I got pregnant and it was too late to have an abortion, I absolutely would not be keeping a baby. So I can see why people use the boxes

(Before anyone starts, I would love a child, but can't afford one so physically no way of keeping one and I imagine other people are in the same situation)
Not everyone knows they are pregnant early enough

ElizabethBest · 11/02/2023 12:20

This is what you’re focusing on? Not the poor state of mental health services, unaffordability of health care, lack of maternity benefits, lack of sex education and lack of access to abortion? Yes OP, it’s the boxes that are the issue. Hmm

ShippingNews · 11/02/2023 12:18

In what way is this linked to abortion laws, when about 1 baby per WEEK is abandoned in the UK ? I'd be happy to see Safe Haven boxes available here, to save those babies from a cold and neglected death .

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 11/02/2023 12:17

Baby boxes or baby hatches are used in several countries including Switzerland and others in and around the EU.

They have alarms that notify staff immediately so the baby can be collected within minutes, they're safe, warm and as important, they are often part of a wider program that allows the parent anterior of time to collect the baby afterwards and work with social services to retain parental rights.

One of my friends was abandoned in a phone box 50 odd years ago, we read about babies being left in parks.

These programmes give a safe place to leave the baby and an opportunity to seek support.

Eyerollcentral · 11/02/2023 12:16

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 11/02/2023 09:57

And imagine a woman who DIDN’T want an abortion but is just struggling and has a moment of madness who will come to regret doing that - it’s just not the answer, in any situation, for women or for babies

‘My spidey senses’ - please never use this embarrassing phrase again. Baby boxes make sure people who can’t look after their children can ensure the baby is looked after with no question asked. Who they hell do you think you are to tell anyone who wants to use them that they are wrong. You sound incredibly naive.

Maddison12 · 11/02/2023 12:12

Ask yourselves why we don’t have them in the UK

Well I am asking myself why we don't have them in the UK. The amount if times there's been horrific news stories about a baby being found dead in a carrier bag, or an abandoned baby found frozen to death, maybe we should.

Thelnebriati · 11/02/2023 12:11

I understand your horror. The boxes exist, support and healthcare for women does not.
In a better world, women would have more support, and not feel they need to abandon an unwanted baby behind a wheelie bin.

110APiccadilly · 11/02/2023 12:10

Can't you have better support, maternity leave, etc, and also baby boxes?

And we don't have them in the UK, but there have been babies abandoned here, occasionally you hear of it on the news, so maybe we should have them. Thankfully it's rare, but then so, by all accounts, is the use of these boxes.

LunaMoon21 · 11/02/2023 12:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as spam.

BastardChild · 11/02/2023 12:06

CascaChan · 11/02/2023 10:58

I think you are reading political motives into this when it’s just a woman trying to help babies.

Staggeringly naïve. Read around the issue.

HiccupHorrendousHaddock · 11/02/2023 12:04

Far better there are safe and dry places for the baby and information for the mother should she want to be reunitied with her baby.

Babies are abandoned all over the world for many different reasons. This is a compassionate response to that complicated situation.

747jumbo · 11/02/2023 12:04

I think OP expected everyone to join with her in virtuous outrage and is surprised that others have known an thought about this too.

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 11/02/2023 12:04

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 11/02/2023 10:09

Better, more practical support for struggling women. Better maternity laws in the US so women don’t have to go back to work after just a few weeks. Free healthcare. So many answers before an anti-choice loon gives women an option they may regret.

I don’t think you understand a very complex situation enough to be giving these boxes so much rage. They do give women choices and they also give babies a chance to be placed somewhere safe.

BastardChild · 11/02/2023 12:01

It's horrible. All part of the republican religious right, attack on the rights of women and maintaining "the domestic supply of infants" for adoption as a US Supreme Court Judge put it.

If care and appropriate social support was available for the mothers it would not be necessary.

Abhorrent. Adoption is trauma.

Tessabelle74 · 11/02/2023 12:01

You're aware abortion is illegal in the US right? These boxes are for women who have had zero choice but to give birth to a child that for whatever reason they can't raise. It saves lives from illegal abortions and stops babies being dumped in rubbish bins etc

BlondeBombshelf · 11/02/2023 11:59

What would you rather? Would you rather that a scared new mum, maybe a 13 year old girl, dumps her baby to die behind a wheelie bin? Because that happens? I’ve seen documentaries on this and the alarm sounds within 2 minutes to alert the people inside (so the mum has a short chance to get away) It’s so much better than the alternative and I think it’s a great idea. Women have killed their babies because they’re so worried about people finding out about them. Would you prefer that?!!

msmatcha · 11/02/2023 11:57

I've never heard of these before, think they are a brilliant idea.

MintJulia · 11/02/2023 11:54

OnlyFannys · 11/02/2023 11:31

Ask yourself why they dont have these boxes in the UK

I do ask myself that question every time I hear about a baby who has been abandoned in the UK and died.

About 500 babies a year are abandoned in the UK. Nine a week!

Child abandonment is illegal in the UK, but in practice, action is seldom taken against the mother, if she is found, concern being more for her health and well being.

I would prefer it to be legal, with a safe facility in every town.

Crinkle77 · 11/02/2023 11:54

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 11/02/2023 10:18

Well I am horrified that these boxes are an option and abortions are not

It was clear to me OP.