Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel generous enough to do this…

242 replies

Distractedatdawn · 11/02/2023 07:41

NC as outing.

Been married 15 years. Originally PIL bought both me and DH thoughtful gifts at Xmas and often money to share.

DH and I have been though a rough patch. I suspect, but don’t know, he’s told them his version of events. I suspect he won’t have told them about some of his less desirable actions. We are in a better place now but still need to work at things.

I am the main earner. I earn 3 times what DH earns. DH has been able to pursue his self employed ideas and do what he enjoys. Often unsuccessfully in terms of finances.

PIL are welL off and a couple of years ago gave all their children a large lump sum that has helped us to pay off our mortgage. Hugely grateful. We (I) thanked them by buying vouchers to stay and have food at a fancy hotel I remembered they like.

Here is my AIBU:
Since DH and I have been struggling I’ve noticed a downgrade in how they treat me. They are still nice to me but don’t give as much in terms gestures of caring.

Christmas- we got joint presents of food - not a hamper - just gift bags with food in. Some nice chocs but basically a food shop - TBH I suspect they are re-gifting some stuff they don’t want from their pantry but I can’t be sure. They don’t look like very carefully selected items. I don’t mind. I’m not that fussed on gifts. DH got given a special card of his own with money in it. It felt pointed.

This isn’t the only example of me getting different treatment from their DC and from before. It’s a shift.

They have a significant birthday coming up. DH wants us to buy them a trip away - weekend somewhere.

I am not feeling that generous…AIBU?

OP posts:
DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 09:35

RichardHeed · 11/02/2023 09:26

He seems to enjoy being part of her financial life while he’s spunking OPs money up the wall with all of his failed “business ventures”. Perhaps OP could weigh up the years and years of financial sponging from him and the mortgage money and see what’s what..maybe they could have paid the mortgage off on their own if this hobbiest businessman had knuckled down and put some effort into providing for his family?

This. Absolutely. Yay, someone gets it !!!

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 09:32

Crumpetdisappointment · 11/02/2023 09:27

perhaps they are feeling the pinch, as with plenty of others.
dont be mean

FFS read the thread !!!

Schnooze · 11/02/2023 09:31

KangarooKenny · 11/02/2023 07:47

I can’t see a problem with them giving their kids more than the kids partners. And I think they were very generous to help pay off your mortgage. If it was me I’d have ring fenced that money, perhaps now they see they have made a mistake.

There is no problem if that was the norm. But it wasn’t the norm and it’s the implied reason for why the change, that is upsetting the op. I’d be upset too.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 09:30

DeliberatelyObtuse · 11/02/2023 09:19

I think you need to rise above it, be the better person, act graciously in face of blah blah blah and just organise/arrange it as you normally would.

It's great they paid off your mortgage but something like that can never be a gift entirely without strings, even unspoken ones.

You've seen from this thread that people aren't generally with you on this (I am) so I think you probably have to accept it and move past it.

From what I can see, and I’ve read the whole thread, the people who aren’t ‘with’ the OP haven’t actually grasped the point and are focusing far too much on the PIL’s financial contribution, when it’s been explained several times that it’s not the material things, but the shift in attitude.

Maray1967 · 11/02/2023 09:29

EsmeSusanOgg · 11/02/2023 08:37

This seems wise

Agreed. We pool money for the joint bills - but family presents etc come out of our own separate accounts. But if he doesn’t normally actually organise the gift then simply leave it up to him. If no gift, it’s his problem. I’ve shifted to that.

Nowdontmakeamess · 11/02/2023 09:28

Tell your DH you’ve noticed a considerable change in how his parents treat you, and from now on all gifts for his family are his responsibility to pay for and organise.

Its completely ridiculous that a grown man expects his wife to do this under any circumstances.

Also work out exactly what your financial contribution to the household has been since you married compared with DH’s (including money from PIL). I suspect it will be more equal or even show you’ve paid more than you realise if you earn so much more than him. Perhaps that will help you feel less obliged to them.

Testina · 11/02/2023 09:28

“If I do nothing, nothing will get done in terms of their birthday gift. I would feel awful then though”

@Distractedatdawn your answer is right there in your post!

Say, “yes dear - good present idea, go ahead.”

Even with the lessening of gifts to you, I think that as they paid off your mortgage 😳 it’s churlish to not get them a good gift now.

But part of what your husband is supposedly working on is sharing more of the load. And you not nagging. So fine - he can sort out the present. Then you don’t have to feel resentful that you’re doing it when they’ve downgraded you. Just pay for it - but, mortgage 🤷🏻‍♀️

I actually wouldn’t be too harsh in your mind on them. They think you’re threatening to leave him. They don’t know that he has physically assaulted you and is a fucking arsehole to his kids. Not sure why he is a valid “work in progress” tbh.

If they hadn’t paid off your mortgage I’d say no expensive gift on your dime, but they did.

I wouldn’t mention the downgrade in gifting - as you say here, people wrongly latch on to calling you materialistic. You could tell them what a nasty piece of shit he is to their grandchildren though 🤷🏻‍♀️ and how he hurt you.

Honestly I’d cut him loose, and sure you’ll lose a chunk of your pension to the cocklodger but hurrah that you’ll gain some of his parents’ money in the house.

Don’t expect them to like you.

But whatever you do - let him do what he’s supposed to be doing now as a “work in progress ” and sort out the present himself.

Don’t be such a mug!

Distractedatdawn · 11/02/2023 09:28

Loads of great and sound advice there and some really lovely and empathic responses. Thank you 🙏 Some harsh but fair posts which have given me pause to think 🙏 and some pretty mean ones who haven’t read my posts fully, but I appreciate you taking the time nonetheless.

I like the idea of talking directly to them and asking if I’ve done something to upset them. This is the grown up and sensible option. But, when DH raised something with them a while ago all hell broke loose. They are ‘brush it under the carpet’ types. They have lots of unresolved childhood trauma that they are suppressing with an ‘everything is fine’ smile. They are lovely lovely people but rarely emotionally congruent. If I spoke to them directly it would trigger them into defensiveness and put further strain on our marriage. I don’t think, in this case, it’s the best thing to do for DC sake apart from anything else.

I could raise it with DH but we have bigger fish to fry. I need to have an uncomfortable conversation with him about our ongoing issues so I think I need to put this to one side.

Given all that, I think from all the wonderful advice so far, my approach will be to do what I would have done. They are lovely people, they have one side of the story only and are responding to that in an understandable way. It’s not fair that I’ve been branded the ‘bad one’ (if that’s what’s happened) and their shift in behaviour towards me hurts, but I will just end up feeling shit if I don’t behave true to myself.

Thank you all.

Oh and I’m not ready to LTB but will if things don’t keep on the path they are on now, don’t worry. I know where my lines are but I also understand humans aren’t black and white. Good and bad. Some behaviours are unacceptable though. There has been considerable change and I’m clear now on what has gone on, why and what needs to stay in place for me and DC.

Thank you to all who took time to post. Helpful as always to come to the MN wise people. 🙏

OP posts:
Crumpetdisappointment · 11/02/2023 09:27

perhaps they are feeling the pinch, as with plenty of others.
dont be mean

RichardHeed · 11/02/2023 09:26

LemonTT · 11/02/2023 09:17

If you really want to withdraw from their generosity circle, give them back the mortgage lump sum. Or ring fence it for your husband so it is not part of your financial life.

He seems to enjoy being part of her financial life while he’s spunking OPs money up the wall with all of his failed “business ventures”. Perhaps OP could weigh up the years and years of financial sponging from him and the mortgage money and see what’s what..maybe they could have paid the mortgage off on their own if this hobbiest businessman had knuckled down and put some effort into providing for his family?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 09:26

SmileyClare · 11/02/2023 09:19

If you want to salvage your relationship with dh (and his parents) then talk him about it.

And be up front with PILs that you’re sorting through some marital issues, you’re upset that they seem to have taken dh’s side, you appreciate their support for you both in the past and don’t want your good relationship with them to sour.

Just be honest and adult about it instead of all the loaded gift giving. Making a point with gifts (or lack of) is not the way forward. It’s passive aggressive nonsense.

Have you learnt nothing in therapy? 😬

Are you posting on the right thread?

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 09:25

I also agree with those saying stop putting everything in joint finances. You’re husband sounds like a feckless lazy loser. Who is used it being carried by you.

out in an agreed amount in the joint pot to pay essentials. And put the rest away in your own account.

SmileyClare · 11/02/2023 09:19

If you want to salvage your relationship with dh (and his parents) then talk him about it.

And be up front with PILs that you’re sorting through some marital issues, you’re upset that they seem to have taken dh’s side, you appreciate their support for you both in the past and don’t want your good relationship with them to sour.

Just be honest and adult about it instead of all the loaded gift giving. Making a point with gifts (or lack of) is not the way forward. It’s passive aggressive nonsense.

Have you learnt nothing in therapy? 😬

DeliberatelyObtuse · 11/02/2023 09:19

I think you need to rise above it, be the better person, act graciously in face of blah blah blah and just organise/arrange it as you normally would.

It's great they paid off your mortgage but something like that can never be a gift entirely without strings, even unspoken ones.

You've seen from this thread that people aren't generally with you on this (I am) so I think you probably have to accept it and move past it.

Cnidarian · 11/02/2023 09:19

If I do nothing, nothing will get done in terms of their birthday gift.

So do nothing. Presents for his family is definitely a place he can start stepping up. As an aside paying for a weekend away as a gift is very generous, do people actually do this?

TheNine · 11/02/2023 09:18

I couldn’t be with a man I earn 3 x more than, TBH - nor would I want to be with a man who earns 3 x more than me. Unequal earnings will always create a certain amount of resentment and a power imbalance, whether you acknowledge it or not.

LemonTT · 11/02/2023 09:17

If you really want to withdraw from their generosity circle, give them back the mortgage lump sum. Or ring fence it for your husband so it is not part of your financial life.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 09:15

LookingOldTheseDays · 11/02/2023 08:35

This sums it up to me. Your ILs have done nothing wrong.

You have some separate issues with your DH and marriage, which need working on (although I'm not sure I'd forgive a man who shoved me), but that is separate to your ILs. They haven't treated you poorly, he has.

He’s clearly been slagging off the OP to his parents and she’s picking up on a clear attitude change from them as a result. He’s compounded his behaviour in the marriage by telling (one sided) tales to mummy and daddy - who have clearly believed him unequivocally and changed their behaviour towards her without even bothering to do some critical thinking. And you don’t think that’s treating her poorly ? And in the OPs position I would stop pooling money because her DH is clearly irresponsible in his expectations. PIL’s contributions to the mortgage are not a reason to let this continue - would be interesting to see how that contribution compares to that of the OP baling out DH’s multiple failed business attempts in light of so many attaching so much importance to that.

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 09:14

Let him get on with it and pay for the trip for his parents himself.

You don’t have it lump it being treated as a downgraded person.

also stop buying or remembering for their birthdays/Christmas etc.

as for forever being beholden to them for lying a lump sum to their children that enabled your husband to help pay off the joint mortgage, presumably you’ve been paying the bulk of the mortgage off for years as well as paying the bulk of everything. It was the IL’s choice to give that money it doesn’t mean you’re beholden to them. You’ve been paying for a lavish lifestyle for tiger son for years by the sound of it and doing all the domestic drudgery.
you don’t owe your IL’s anything.

if you’re H who’s had a history of dv against you. Y the sound of things on top of all his shit uselessness. Wants to treat his parents, tell him to right ahead out of his own fun money.

stop caring about their feelings, and stop accepting their cheap shit begrudging gifts.

I would heather receive nothing than be insulted with the leftovers from their pantry or different biscuits to their own kids. They’d no doubt be deeply hurt if oyu behaved like that towards them. Why should you take it?

Aishah231 · 11/02/2023 09:14

I wouldn't be feeling generous in your situation either OP. I'd tell him he can buy it out of his spending money. Presumably you both have equal spending money each month? If not I'd start this. It's very easy to be generous when someone else is paying

Sisisimone · 11/02/2023 09:13

Instead of focusing on the gift don't you think you should be finding out exactly what your husband has said to them to cause this shift? He must have said something very significant about you for them to change their behaviour towards you so much

purser25 · 11/02/2023 09:11

Wonder if the PIL are getting older and confused have noticed this with people and it’s not deliberate.

yomellamoHelly · 11/02/2023 09:10

Would you spend the same amount of money for the same kind of trip for yourself (or better)? If not, then your answer has to be a no.

Riverlee · 11/02/2023 09:09

In many ways, your earnings compared to him his a red herring.

The fact of the matter is that, whilst previously your in-laws treated you and dh as equals, there’s now been a distinctive shift in how they view you. It’s not like you’re a new kid on the block, you’ve been married for fifteen years.

Maybe it’s something innocent - they have less money so am prioritising their son. However, they could just buy smaller presents for you both.

I can understand why you feel puzzled and hurt by that.

WimpoleHat · 11/02/2023 09:09

Could you say something like “Oh, I think your parents are trying to tone down the present buying. Look at Christmas. We don’t want to embarrass them, so maybe a meal out would be better than a weekend…..” Or whatever you’re prepared to go for.