Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel generous enough to do this…

242 replies

Distractedatdawn · 11/02/2023 07:41

NC as outing.

Been married 15 years. Originally PIL bought both me and DH thoughtful gifts at Xmas and often money to share.

DH and I have been though a rough patch. I suspect, but don’t know, he’s told them his version of events. I suspect he won’t have told them about some of his less desirable actions. We are in a better place now but still need to work at things.

I am the main earner. I earn 3 times what DH earns. DH has been able to pursue his self employed ideas and do what he enjoys. Often unsuccessfully in terms of finances.

PIL are welL off and a couple of years ago gave all their children a large lump sum that has helped us to pay off our mortgage. Hugely grateful. We (I) thanked them by buying vouchers to stay and have food at a fancy hotel I remembered they like.

Here is my AIBU:
Since DH and I have been struggling I’ve noticed a downgrade in how they treat me. They are still nice to me but don’t give as much in terms gestures of caring.

Christmas- we got joint presents of food - not a hamper - just gift bags with food in. Some nice chocs but basically a food shop - TBH I suspect they are re-gifting some stuff they don’t want from their pantry but I can’t be sure. They don’t look like very carefully selected items. I don’t mind. I’m not that fussed on gifts. DH got given a special card of his own with money in it. It felt pointed.

This isn’t the only example of me getting different treatment from their DC and from before. It’s a shift.

They have a significant birthday coming up. DH wants us to buy them a trip away - weekend somewhere.

I am not feeling that generous…AIBU?

OP posts:
DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:14

BeavisMcTavish · 11/02/2023 10:56

Honestly, these types of thread make me sick. I’m the main earner, my wife also earns very well, we both buy what we want for ourselves, kids and both parents (with consultation on big values).

my parents have financial contributed towards our lives more - does that mean either of us punish the other or respective PIL?

I’d suggest anyone who feels the need to even ask this sort of question have much bigger fundamental relationship issue.

Another failure of understanding.

Sleepless1096 · 11/02/2023 11:13

CatherinedeBourgh · 11/02/2023 08:35

I wouldn't stop him getting it, but I wouldn't lift a finger towards it.

It's not the money you resent (I hope, given that in money terms you are well up on the relationship with them), but the effort and the caring.

So downgrade your effort and caring (to zero) but let your dh use the joint money to buy them the present.

If you always carry the mental load and take care of the bulk of the practicalities, I predict a less effort intensive gift might happen. If your dh steps up and organises everything beautifully, he has shown that he is well capable of organising all your holidays from now on.

This. Agree a budget and let him sort it out.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:11

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 11/02/2023 11:01

I can understand op.
If it's been the norm for it to be a certain way and the all of a sudden DH gets money and you jointly get food in bags I'd say there is definitely a point they are trying to make.

I'd not be contributing to the trip away but it also sounds like you can't afford it as a household? Why is your husband trying to give a costly gift after you've been struggling?

If he has savings just let him pay for it himself.

I dont think the OP meant they were struggling in a financial sense - she meant their relationship.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:08

BraveGoldie · 11/02/2023 10:53

Having read your updates about shoving and 'not quite bad enough for social services' and his self indulgent lack of financial and labour contribution, I think the PILs are pretty irrelevant.

I can understand it being hurtful, but they sound like good people who have imperfect information, understandable concern for their son and are muddling through.

As you said, you have different and bigger fish to fry. To fix all the stuff he's been crap at would take a huge turnaround, including taking ownership and responsibility for the problem, and understanding he has a role in thinking about your needs and taking care of YOU in some ways, rather than being a man child, with you carrying all burdens. If he has given a distorted view of what's going on to his parents, then it shows that he really has not achieved this shift in attitude.

If he had really changed, then it would be mea culpa, acknowledging how useless he had been, and singing your praises for putting up with so much.... and if somehow his parents got the wrong end of the stick, he would be noticing that, and jumping to put it right for your sake. But instead, he's quite happy carrying on with them the way they are..... he's managing his reputation, at your cost.... that is not the action of a changed man.

This.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:07

BeavisMcTavish · 11/02/2023 10:50

I 10000% do not think this no. I think they’re a family unit and they share everything. (As I would if it’s the other way round).

thats entirely my point. Everyone jumping in how shit the man is, when the OP is just being petty as fuck over what is maybe a couple of hundred quid.

There’s nothing to suggest this family unit can’t afford it regardless of anything else the man vultures are reading into.

if the OP wants to leave her bloke for being a lazy arsehole let’s have a separate thread but that’s not what this one is about.

But you’ve entirely missed the point of what the thread is about. The reason the family unit can afford it is because the OP does most of the contributing.
You think it’s acceptable for this man to be lazy, abusive, take the OP for granted in bailing him out so many times, go bleating to his parents about how bad his lot is - to the point that they treat her differently - and still expect her to stump up for a nice birthday present ? And no. No man vultures. Just recognising the lack of input financially and the massive piss take in expecting the OP to continually step up after he’s failed her on so many levels.

Shodan · 11/02/2023 11:06

So, you have a DH who shoves you, is 'triggered' by entirely normal requests to do his fair share of housework/child rearing, is a questionable parent to the dc, has piddled about with (mostly) failed 'businesses', has had his hand out (figuratively) for money from you for most of your marriage to support him, and has also had a gift of money from those parents that he's used in lieu of his own financial contributions to your home, family and married life.

The words Spoilt Brat come to mind. And he's clearly run whinging to his parents that you're a big old meanie who tries to make him DO THINGS (like act like a decent adult). I wonder how he was brought up, to foster such an entitled attitude?

I'm not surprised you're feeling hurt by their obvious downgrading of you.

Their financial gift to their son was generous, of course. And it was entirely reasonable of him to use it in lieu of his own financial contributions to your mortgage. But it wasn't a gift to you, per se, so there's no need to feel this overwhelming gratitude that some PPs seem to think you should. Especially as you will have funded the larger part of all gifts to them up until now, I assume.

If your DH wants to give them an extraordinary gift, he can figure out a way to pay for it. You can contribute a small portion, should you wish to, but you absolutely should not do anything further to facilitate it.

And imo- you should call time on this marriage. It doesn't sound healthy at all.

diddl · 11/02/2023 11:04

Tbh I think I'd say & do nothing.

If he mentions it be non committal & leave him to it.

The mortgage money has obviously helped Op more if she was the one paying the mortgage, but maybe the Pils don't know that.

Seems that Op is still doing most/all of the "heavy lifting".

He's shoved you in the past Op-he's not a good man, husband or father imo.

ivykaty44 · 11/02/2023 11:03

They have a significant birthday coming up. DH wants us to buy them a trip away - weekend somewhere.

then dh can fund it

Isheabastard · 11/02/2023 11:02

I had similar happen to me ref my Dh and his mum. He’s told his mother a version of our marriage that obviously put him in a good light so by logic it put me in a bad light.

I also noticed a downgrading. There’s nothing you can do and you just have to suck it up. However obviously over time it makes you draw back as well.

We are now divorcing, so it’s one less thing I need to care about now.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 11/02/2023 11:01

I can understand op.
If it's been the norm for it to be a certain way and the all of a sudden DH gets money and you jointly get food in bags I'd say there is definitely a point they are trying to make.

I'd not be contributing to the trip away but it also sounds like you can't afford it as a household? Why is your husband trying to give a costly gift after you've been struggling?

If he has savings just let him pay for it himself.

fortheloveofflowers · 11/02/2023 10:58

To be honest I'd got rid off him years ago. He sounds flakey with failed business ventures and a lazy shit leaving you to do all the mental load and domestic chores.

I'm sure you've contributed a lot more towards the house over all the years than the money he has got from his parents, it was only right that he pay his fair share for once by the sounds of it.

5128gap · 11/02/2023 10:58

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 10:42

😆😆😆😆used it to own a larger share of the house?

a larger share based on what? He hasn’t paid anything towards a house he already owns 50% of.

and you’re assuming the outstanding mortgage amount which the OP was paying on her own for fifteen years, is a significant amount in proportion to the value of the house.

by the time my firends mortgage was at fifteen years she'd paid it off almost. So the outstanding percentage in comparison to the value of the house was tiny.

Thats not the legal position regarding marital home ownership though, is it? Otherwise SAHP parents who don't contribute financially to mortgage repayments would be in a poor position, wouldn't they?
Unless it's drawn up otherwise, a jointly owned marital house is presumed to be owned 50/50, with both parties having an equal share of the equity. If they have a joint mortgage then they are jointly and severally liable for the full loan. At the point when his parents gave the money to clear the loan, they could have requested that the deeds were drawn up differently so their son owned a greater percentage of the house.
Yes, I'm assuming it was a significant amount as otherwise I doubt the OP would see it as relevant.

BeavisMcTavish · 11/02/2023 10:56

Honestly, these types of thread make me sick. I’m the main earner, my wife also earns very well, we both buy what we want for ourselves, kids and both parents (with consultation on big values).

my parents have financial contributed towards our lives more - does that mean either of us punish the other or respective PIL?

I’d suggest anyone who feels the need to even ask this sort of question have much bigger fundamental relationship issue.

Crumpetdisappointment · 11/02/2023 10:55

but they are his parents
there are two sides to every story
he has a story of his self employment

by all means be slightly less generous in your present to them which comes out of your joint account.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 11/02/2023 10:54

I'd also be interested to know the standard of Xmas presents normally given by the PIl so that I could judge see how much of a shift this was.

BraveGoldie · 11/02/2023 10:53

Having read your updates about shoving and 'not quite bad enough for social services' and his self indulgent lack of financial and labour contribution, I think the PILs are pretty irrelevant.

I can understand it being hurtful, but they sound like good people who have imperfect information, understandable concern for their son and are muddling through.

As you said, you have different and bigger fish to fry. To fix all the stuff he's been crap at would take a huge turnaround, including taking ownership and responsibility for the problem, and understanding he has a role in thinking about your needs and taking care of YOU in some ways, rather than being a man child, with you carrying all burdens. If he has given a distorted view of what's going on to his parents, then it shows that he really has not achieved this shift in attitude.

If he had really changed, then it would be mea culpa, acknowledging how useless he had been, and singing your praises for putting up with so much.... and if somehow his parents got the wrong end of the stick, he would be noticing that, and jumping to put it right for your sake. But instead, he's quite happy carrying on with them the way they are..... he's managing his reputation, at your cost.... that is not the action of a changed man.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 11/02/2023 10:53

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 10:42

😆😆😆😆used it to own a larger share of the house?

a larger share based on what? He hasn’t paid anything towards a house he already owns 50% of.

and you’re assuming the outstanding mortgage amount which the OP was paying on her own for fifteen years, is a significant amount in proportion to the value of the house.

by the time my firends mortgage was at fifteen years she'd paid it off almost. So the outstanding percentage in comparison to the value of the house was tiny.

"He hasn’t paid anything towards a house he already owns 50% of."

Imagine if the man was the higher earner, and the wife had put a lump sum gift towards the mortgage, could you imagine anyone responding like this about the wife?

OP, if you feel that something has changed in your relationship with PILs, and it's been a good relationship before, why not ask them about it?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 10:51

beamout · 11/02/2023 10:34

I mean. Paying off the mortgage is a huge thing. And it was your husband that enabled that. Did he try to keep some of it for himself, to protect himself in case you decided to say it isn't joint money anymore? Or did he just agree it goes to the mortgage for the benefit of the marriage - because your money is joint money?

Seriously, get over yourself and stop trying to make your hurt feelings over something his parents are doing a reason for exploding the financial basis to your marriage that has benefited both of you in the past

You’ve obviously read a different thread to the rest of us !! And how huge the paying off of the mortgage is, depends on how much is left after 15 years. Because if you’d read properly you’d see that DH has taken OP for granted in expecting her to finance his failed business ventures as well as shouldering most of the financial responsibility. It may not be DHs fault that OP earns more than him, but that doesn’t entitle him to take the piss.

BeavisMcTavish · 11/02/2023 10:50

deeperthanallroses · 11/02/2023 10:26

What the actual fuck? The op has mostly financed them for their whole life together. She paid the mortgage while they had it! The absolute total least he could bloody well do is agree when his parents gave them some money that it went on the mortgage. It isn’t parenting or washing dishes or earning a salary or anything else that goes into a family, but it’s something. And you think maybe he should have kept that too? Genuinely?

I 10000% do not think this no. I think they’re a family unit and they share everything. (As I would if it’s the other way round).

thats entirely my point. Everyone jumping in how shit the man is, when the OP is just being petty as fuck over what is maybe a couple of hundred quid.

There’s nothing to suggest this family unit can’t afford it regardless of anything else the man vultures are reading into.

if the OP wants to leave her bloke for being a lazy arsehole let’s have a separate thread but that’s not what this one is about.

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 10:48

My IL’s treat me and my older dc (not their bio grandchildren) very generously when giving us gifts.

I love them dearly and have no expectations of them, and reciprocate with thoughtful gifts within our budget.

however if they suddenly changed towards us and started giving me food they didn’t want from their pantry, giving me biscuits and their son chocolate biscuits. I’d politely refuse the gifts and stop gifting back.

it hurts to receive gifts that are clearly begrudgingly given. It’s embarrassing and makes me feel horrible.

this is so incredibly unkind. Weaponised gift giving. So people not unlike a lot on here are tripping over themselves claiming OP is grabby and of course the biological child of the family gets better gifts etc. it’s mean and nasty and calculated to hurt the recipients feelings and make them feel less and an outsider.

5128gap · 11/02/2023 10:48

I think the parents are being used as scapegoats for problems with your H.
From their perspective, they have been more than generous to you throughout. Enabling you to be mortgage free is huge.
Your marriage hits problems and their son confides in them. You have no idea of the picture he has painted, but suspect its not good. So, either he has told truths about you that have made them see you in a poor light, or he has lied and exaggerated, which would be a huge issue with him.
Whichever, they are now probably rather concerned about how their son is treated and even primed for a separation. In light of that, I can see why they might not want to give more cash as gifts to a woman who clearly doesn't need the money (four times your Hs wage and mortgage free, you must be comfortable?)
They are nice to you and are providing token gifts, so I don't really see they are the villains here.
If I were you, I'd be far more focused on your H. I'd want to know what he'd been saying about you; and as its clearly an issue, how you can arrange your finances so you don't feel so resentful. His parents are not the problem.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 10:44

dogmandu · 11/02/2023 10:21

absolutely this!

PIL didnt ‘pay off’ the mortgage. They have given all their children a lump sum and it was given to DH who made the decision to put it towards the mortgage. If you’ve read the OPs subsequent posts it’s clear she has been the major contributor while DH has taken the financial security she provides for granted, expecting to be indulged and bailed out when he plays about and fails in business. He’s been abusive too. Perhaps he had a momentary glimpse into his selfishness and that’s why he put the money into the house. What’s happening now doesn’t feel fair because it isn’t. He’s slagged her off to his parents but she’s still expected to step up and ‘do what’s right’ !! And if PIL decide to treat the OP differently based on what their DS has told them without finding out her side of things, then it’s no longer between the OP and her husband - they have made it their business. And I’d be willing to bet that he hasn’t mentioned his physical abuse of the OP or his children because I can’t see any parent condoning that or blaming the other partner.

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 10:42

5128gap · 11/02/2023 10:03

I don't think you can have it both ways. When you accepted the handout and used it for joint benefit (he could have used it to own a larger share of the house. They could have made that the terms of the gift) you set a precedent where financially you are viewed as one in your relationship with them. This means gifts to them come from your marital income.
Its not their fault he earns much less than you, and if that's a problem for you that needs sorting with him.
If I were you I'd be more concerned with trying to get to the bottom of why they're treating you differently rather than contribute to the growing rift by making a passive aggressive gesture of your own.

😆😆😆😆used it to own a larger share of the house?

a larger share based on what? He hasn’t paid anything towards a house he already owns 50% of.

and you’re assuming the outstanding mortgage amount which the OP was paying on her own for fifteen years, is a significant amount in proportion to the value of the house.

by the time my firends mortgage was at fifteen years she'd paid it off almost. So the outstanding percentage in comparison to the value of the house was tiny.

Geepee71 · 11/02/2023 10:36

Slightly off-topic, but you can get a Groupon type hotel overnight stay for relatively reasonable amounts.

But ultimately I'd expect DH to sort it for his parents.

beamout · 11/02/2023 10:34

I mean. Paying off the mortgage is a huge thing. And it was your husband that enabled that. Did he try to keep some of it for himself, to protect himself in case you decided to say it isn't joint money anymore? Or did he just agree it goes to the mortgage for the benefit of the marriage - because your money is joint money?

Seriously, get over yourself and stop trying to make your hurt feelings over something his parents are doing a reason for exploding the financial basis to your marriage that has benefited both of you in the past