Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel generous enough to do this…

242 replies

Distractedatdawn · 11/02/2023 07:41

NC as outing.

Been married 15 years. Originally PIL bought both me and DH thoughtful gifts at Xmas and often money to share.

DH and I have been though a rough patch. I suspect, but don’t know, he’s told them his version of events. I suspect he won’t have told them about some of his less desirable actions. We are in a better place now but still need to work at things.

I am the main earner. I earn 3 times what DH earns. DH has been able to pursue his self employed ideas and do what he enjoys. Often unsuccessfully in terms of finances.

PIL are welL off and a couple of years ago gave all their children a large lump sum that has helped us to pay off our mortgage. Hugely grateful. We (I) thanked them by buying vouchers to stay and have food at a fancy hotel I remembered they like.

Here is my AIBU:
Since DH and I have been struggling I’ve noticed a downgrade in how they treat me. They are still nice to me but don’t give as much in terms gestures of caring.

Christmas- we got joint presents of food - not a hamper - just gift bags with food in. Some nice chocs but basically a food shop - TBH I suspect they are re-gifting some stuff they don’t want from their pantry but I can’t be sure. They don’t look like very carefully selected items. I don’t mind. I’m not that fussed on gifts. DH got given a special card of his own with money in it. It felt pointed.

This isn’t the only example of me getting different treatment from their DC and from before. It’s a shift.

They have a significant birthday coming up. DH wants us to buy them a trip away - weekend somewhere.

I am not feeling that generous…AIBU?

OP posts:
DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:48

DarkDarkNight · 11/02/2023 11:31

Do you know or can you find out whether the kind of gifts given to their other children’s partners have stayed the same or been downgraded? Are you the only one out of everyone who is suddenly getting a different type/value of gift? Have you asked him what he has said about you to his parents? I think it could be possible your husband has been telling tales, and they are likely to side with him.

You say they are wealthy but is this still the case after they have paid off mortgages for their children? Maybe they are feeling the pinch? My parents buy less generous gifts now they are retired, but they always told us this would be the case.

I would discuss with your husband an amount you are comfortable with for the gift, and he can match it or put more in if he would like. You are financially in a very fortunate position thanks to his parents, their gift has freed up a lot of money, so he has also contributed financially even though you out-earn him.

You are financially in a very fortunate position thanks to his parents, their gift has freed up a lot of money, so he has also contributed financially even though you out-earn him

You’re making a lot of assumptions here. We don’t know how much the lump sum was, or how much was left on the mortgage. And do you not think that they are in a fortunate position just as much thanks to the OP’s hard work in keeping the roof over their heads for the last 15 years by paying the mortgage without much input from DH ?

shewhomustbeEbayed · 11/02/2023 11:48

I’d tell your husband you don’t feel disposed to spend that sort of money on his parents while you have this tension between you and them due to him telling them his version of events. Then maybe he might try to improve the relationship between them and you ?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:42

5128gap · 11/02/2023 10:58

Thats not the legal position regarding marital home ownership though, is it? Otherwise SAHP parents who don't contribute financially to mortgage repayments would be in a poor position, wouldn't they?
Unless it's drawn up otherwise, a jointly owned marital house is presumed to be owned 50/50, with both parties having an equal share of the equity. If they have a joint mortgage then they are jointly and severally liable for the full loan. At the point when his parents gave the money to clear the loan, they could have requested that the deeds were drawn up differently so their son owned a greater percentage of the house.
Yes, I'm assuming it was a significant amount as otherwise I doubt the OP would see it as relevant.

At the point when his parents gave the money to clear the loan, they could have requested that the deeds were drawn up differently so their son owned a greater percentage of the house.

And I’m sure the OP would have been more than happy for DH to claim a bigger percentage of the home she’s kept over their heads for 15 years with minimal contribution from him. Who wouldn’t ?

user375242 · 11/02/2023 11:40

Just wanted to say that my in laws give me an equal amount of cash and gifts for birthdays and Christmas as DH. If they suddenly stopped of course I would be wondering what I have done to upset them too. I'd never have expected it in the beginning but to suddenly stop absolutely does have meaning imo. Not sure why people are saying if course you shouldn't get the same.

Did you actually read the card your DH got? Just because in my case we used to get separate cards with cash in, but sometimes we get a fancier card that is addressed to both of us inside. I wouldn't put it past your DH to not make that clear it was for both of you.

billy1966 · 11/02/2023 11:38

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 11:26

This absolutely THIS.

he is NOT a home maker or stay at home parent who cooks, cleans, does the housework, mental load, home admin and childcare and the million other things a stay at home mum traditionally does.

Comparing this man to a SAHP is insulting to SAHP’s!

Absolutely but you know how so many MN's bend themselves out of shape to excuse the most odious of men.

He's an aggressive lazy man that is only a step down from SS needing to be involved to protect his children.. ffs🙄.

He's lived off his wife whilst she carries the financial and caring, mental load and household responsibilities.

He's the type of aggressive scum that shoves his wife too....

........but none of that will deter the defenders of him on MN.🙄🙄

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:38

BeavisMcTavish · 11/02/2023 11:21

Nah. Don’t misunderstand a thing - just fundamentally disagree.

you say lazy, abusive and OP bailing out.that ISNT WHAT SHE SAID. He has multiple failed businesses - he isn’t successful we can agree but your take is that he watches Jeremy Kyle all day.

Change around the gender roles and the replies would be ‘you’re a team, don’t be such a wanker to her parents, she’s trying’

its a joke.

OP said over multiple posts that he has had several attempts at turning something he enjoys into self employment, has failed, and she has had to shoulder the financial responsibility for that until he retrained and is now doing better. She also said he hasn’t pulled his weight at home, has been abusive to her and the children, and the to top it off has gone whining to his parents about their marital problems. He may be ‘trying’ in your estimation, but if he’s told half a story to his parents and is now standing back while they treat her differently as a result, then he’s not trying very hard is he ? And I’ll lay a pound to a penny he hasn’t told them about the physical abuse because very few parents would condone that in their son, or lay the blame at their daughter in laws’ door. Might not be Jeremy Kyle, but it’s not far off.

Porkyporkchop · 11/02/2023 11:34

AlwaysGinPlease · 11/02/2023 07:44

Let him pay for it. See how that works out for him.

This. Totally this. They are his parents, he can pay for them as he is now the chosen one ☝️

SerafinasGoose · 11/02/2023 11:33

namechange9374 · 11/02/2023 08:15

Agree with this.

Not sure what's wrong with so many people this morning on Mumsnet every thread I go on the OP is getting a right kicking.

Indeed. I'd not feel inclined to tell any fellow Mumsnet member they seem like a 'horrible person' in any event. We are strangers on the internet. I don't know them, and they don't know me.

Ad hominem attacks devalue both the threads and the person posting them. They say more about that person than they do the OP. It's not big, powerful and clever to hand someone's arse to them rather than merely say you think their actions and wrong and give a reason.

Tedious, and a waste of column space.

JudgeJ · 11/02/2023 11:33

CoffeeBeansGalore · 11/02/2023 07:45

Surely if DH wants to treat them then let him crack on. If he can't afford it without you paying then tough.

Had it been a low earning woman and a high earning man then it would, in MN terms, been 'family money'.

DarkDarkNight · 11/02/2023 11:31

Do you know or can you find out whether the kind of gifts given to their other children’s partners have stayed the same or been downgraded? Are you the only one out of everyone who is suddenly getting a different type/value of gift? Have you asked him what he has said about you to his parents? I think it could be possible your husband has been telling tales, and they are likely to side with him.

You say they are wealthy but is this still the case after they have paid off mortgages for their children? Maybe they are feeling the pinch? My parents buy less generous gifts now they are retired, but they always told us this would be the case.

I would discuss with your husband an amount you are comfortable with for the gift, and he can match it or put more in if he would like. You are financially in a very fortunate position thanks to his parents, their gift has freed up a lot of money, so he has also contributed financially even though you out-earn him.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:27

SerafinasGoose · 11/02/2023 11:22

Absolute cobblers.

I'd fully expect in-laws to prefer their own child to a daughter- or son-in-law. But a pointed change in their attitudes showing marked disapproval for the in-law is intended to be pointed, and the OP is not being unreasonable or 'materialistic' in noticing that intended slight, and being hurt by it.

I would not spare the finances for this trip in your position, OP. Equally, I would not put myself under obligation to them by accepting any further monetary gifts.

If your DP has turned them against you by running to him with your private issues, then I'd view this as a betrayal and see no harm in letting him feel the consequences of his actions. Perhaps he'll keep his trap shut and sort out any problems between the two of you in future.

YANBU.

Yep. And in addition to him feeling the consequences of his actions, I don’t see why PIL shouldn’t feel the same for theirs in accepting without question that their Whiney little DS has told them the whole story, and treating the OP accordingly.

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 11:26

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:20

But he’s not a stay at home parent. He’s a failed businessman who relies on the OP to finance him. That’s not the same thing. But I take your point.

This absolutely THIS.

he is NOT a home maker or stay at home parent who cooks, cleans, does the housework, mental load, home admin and childcare and the million other things a stay at home mum traditionally does.

Comparing this man to a SAHP is insulting to SAHP’s!

BeavisMcTavish · 11/02/2023 11:25

I’ll caveat that I certainly haven’t invested my life in this thread, so if it has been drip fed with extra info and I’m missing something not in post 1 then fair do’s

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:22

user1492757084 · 11/02/2023 11:15

Don't take things so personally. Your parents-in-law are getting older; they will be faultering more and they have been so generous. Soon they may not be able to give gifts at all. Just go on treating them as you always have.

They would have to have been shocked and very worried with their son talking about the rough patch. The last thing they would have wanted is for you to leave the family. It possibly prompted them to support him more so that he can overcome the difficulties and be a good husband.
Only give the expensive gift if you can afford it, otherwise give a gift that you can afford. It causes stress to be broke and you don't need any more stress.

FFS !!!

SerafinasGoose · 11/02/2023 11:22

MelaniesFlowers · 11/02/2023 07:45

This.

Absolute cobblers.

I'd fully expect in-laws to prefer their own child to a daughter- or son-in-law. But a pointed change in their attitudes showing marked disapproval for the in-law is intended to be pointed, and the OP is not being unreasonable or 'materialistic' in noticing that intended slight, and being hurt by it.

I would not spare the finances for this trip in your position, OP. Equally, I would not put myself under obligation to them by accepting any further monetary gifts.

If your DP has turned them against you by running to him with your private issues, then I'd view this as a betrayal and see no harm in letting him feel the consequences of his actions. Perhaps he'll keep his trap shut and sort out any problems between the two of you in future.

YANBU.

5128gap · 11/02/2023 11:21

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 11:16

when a bloke who’s been a financial liability throughout the marriage makes any financial contribution it looks significant. Because he’s a financial liability usually.

its interesting how you’re suddenly twisting this to well a marital asset doesn’t work that way, but a gift which has been invested in the marital asset suddenly is significant and the gift giver who has no legal ownership of the marital home should be acknowledged as significant or give them their money back. It was the OP’s H who received the money and put it in the house he lives in without making either financial or personal contributions.

but op who has spent her married life carrying the dead weight of her husband should grovel and kowtow to her IL’s and H for making one financial contribution which I’m not convinced is significant in comparison to the fifteen years of money OP has spent on her family and financially bailing out her H and his repeated business failures.

and on divorce the SAHP/lesser earning spouse gets awarded assets based on need and the view of having sacrificed their earning potential to support and enable the higher earner to go out and developed their career.

OP’s H has not done this.

he’s a useless, abusive, violent waste of space who happily spends OP’s money.

I think you must be confusing me with someone else as I've never mentioned returning the money. Nor by stating the legal position regarding home ownership am I 'twisting' anything.
I have at no point defended the H, and agree completely with your opinion of him.
But, the thread is about OPs relationship with his parents, isn't it, which you seem to be struggling to separate from the failings of their son.

BeavisMcTavish · 11/02/2023 11:21

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:14

Another failure of understanding.

Nah. Don’t misunderstand a thing - just fundamentally disagree.

you say lazy, abusive and OP bailing out.that ISNT WHAT SHE SAID. He has multiple failed businesses - he isn’t successful we can agree but your take is that he watches Jeremy Kyle all day.

Change around the gender roles and the replies would be ‘you’re a team, don’t be such a wanker to her parents, she’s trying’

its a joke.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:20

ApiratesaysYarrr · 11/02/2023 11:18

But that would also be true of a marriage where the man was the high earner and wife had been SAHM for years. That's marriage for you.

But he’s not a stay at home parent. He’s a failed businessman who relies on the OP to finance him. That’s not the same thing. But I take your point.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:19

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 11:16

when a bloke who’s been a financial liability throughout the marriage makes any financial contribution it looks significant. Because he’s a financial liability usually.

its interesting how you’re suddenly twisting this to well a marital asset doesn’t work that way, but a gift which has been invested in the marital asset suddenly is significant and the gift giver who has no legal ownership of the marital home should be acknowledged as significant or give them their money back. It was the OP’s H who received the money and put it in the house he lives in without making either financial or personal contributions.

but op who has spent her married life carrying the dead weight of her husband should grovel and kowtow to her IL’s and H for making one financial contribution which I’m not convinced is significant in comparison to the fifteen years of money OP has spent on her family and financially bailing out her H and his repeated business failures.

and on divorce the SAHP/lesser earning spouse gets awarded assets based on need and the view of having sacrificed their earning potential to support and enable the higher earner to go out and developed their career.

OP’s H has not done this.

he’s a useless, abusive, violent waste of space who happily spends OP’s money.

👏👏👏

ApiratesaysYarrr · 11/02/2023 11:18

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:16

I took that to mean that prior to him making the lump sum contribution, he already owned 50% of it despite not making much by way of contribution.

But that would also be true of a marriage where the man was the high earner and wife had been SAHM for years. That's marriage for you.

mn29 · 11/02/2023 11:18

deeperthanallroses · 11/02/2023 07:53

The op has clearly been happy enough with the concept of joint money to finance multiple failed business attempts from her husband and to accept that he will never finance the family. That to me is pretty impressive! Even saints occasionally feel a little bitter and it’s perfectly understandable in this case.

i wouldn’t have spare finances for this gift op. ‘I’ve noticed since we’ve been talking through a few issues that for example there’s a special Christmas present for you not me and they treat me differently generally. It would only be taking a leaf from their book to say I don’t feel like finding the extra money for this present, you are welcome to. You haven’t objected to their change in attitude, which presumably stems directly from what you’ve told them, so you can’t object to my reacting to that.

All of this

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 11:16

ApiratesaysYarrr · 11/02/2023 10:53

"He hasn’t paid anything towards a house he already owns 50% of."

Imagine if the man was the higher earner, and the wife had put a lump sum gift towards the mortgage, could you imagine anyone responding like this about the wife?

OP, if you feel that something has changed in your relationship with PILs, and it's been a good relationship before, why not ask them about it?

I took that to mean that prior to him making the lump sum contribution, he already owned 50% of it despite not making much by way of contribution.

Crumpleton · 11/02/2023 11:16

AlwaysGinPlease · 11/02/2023 07:44

Let him pay for it. See how that works out for him.

Absolutely this....

frazzledasarock · 11/02/2023 11:16

5128gap · 11/02/2023 10:58

Thats not the legal position regarding marital home ownership though, is it? Otherwise SAHP parents who don't contribute financially to mortgage repayments would be in a poor position, wouldn't they?
Unless it's drawn up otherwise, a jointly owned marital house is presumed to be owned 50/50, with both parties having an equal share of the equity. If they have a joint mortgage then they are jointly and severally liable for the full loan. At the point when his parents gave the money to clear the loan, they could have requested that the deeds were drawn up differently so their son owned a greater percentage of the house.
Yes, I'm assuming it was a significant amount as otherwise I doubt the OP would see it as relevant.

when a bloke who’s been a financial liability throughout the marriage makes any financial contribution it looks significant. Because he’s a financial liability usually.

its interesting how you’re suddenly twisting this to well a marital asset doesn’t work that way, but a gift which has been invested in the marital asset suddenly is significant and the gift giver who has no legal ownership of the marital home should be acknowledged as significant or give them their money back. It was the OP’s H who received the money and put it in the house he lives in without making either financial or personal contributions.

but op who has spent her married life carrying the dead weight of her husband should grovel and kowtow to her IL’s and H for making one financial contribution which I’m not convinced is significant in comparison to the fifteen years of money OP has spent on her family and financially bailing out her H and his repeated business failures.

and on divorce the SAHP/lesser earning spouse gets awarded assets based on need and the view of having sacrificed their earning potential to support and enable the higher earner to go out and developed their career.

OP’s H has not done this.

he’s a useless, abusive, violent waste of space who happily spends OP’s money.

user1492757084 · 11/02/2023 11:15

Don't take things so personally. Your parents-in-law are getting older; they will be faultering more and they have been so generous. Soon they may not be able to give gifts at all. Just go on treating them as you always have.

They would have to have been shocked and very worried with their son talking about the rough patch. The last thing they would have wanted is for you to leave the family. It possibly prompted them to support him more so that he can overcome the difficulties and be a good husband.
Only give the expensive gift if you can afford it, otherwise give a gift that you can afford. It causes stress to be broke and you don't need any more stress.