Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to use the bus like everyone else?

454 replies

toddlertamer20 · 10/02/2023 22:47

Hi,
I'm a single mum of 3, live in london and am now reliant on a wheelchair. I use buses to get around as I don't drive. I'm just getting so sick and tired of people being so incredibly selfish on buses. Wheelchairs have the priority, as obviously we cannot fold, however, as I have found out in the last few years, if there are prams on board and they refuse to fold...there is not much the driver can do as they can't be physically removed.
Most of the time, if a bus comes along with 2 prams, I will wait for the next bus. But sometimes I have to be somewhere and considering that is the only spot I am able to use on the bus, I feel like I should be allowed to use it. Everytime I insist that I need to get on it either a)end up with an argument eith the driver as he won't ask people to move or fold their prams....then a call to TFL who apologise and promise the educate the driver again.
b) I get let on but then the people with the pram won't move and argue with me, one of these times the driver was oblivious that I was mid gangway still and pulled off causing me to be thrown into a pole and break my arm. Or c) They just pull off and don't even attempt to let me on or put the ramp down.
Today again I ended up in a big argument. I needed to get a bus to get my youngest from school. The bus didn't come for ages. It eventually came but 3 buggies were on board, one without a child in it. The driver tried to tell me the next bus would be along in 20 minutes to which I said I couldn't. So he played the announcement asking the people to move their buggies. Then suddenly another passenger comes to the door and informs me that I need to wait as the people with the prams were there first. So I told him that actually by law I have priority, and I need to be on this bus. He then proceeds to tell me how I just need to wait and can't just get on and kick people off. At this point I was late already to get my child from school, so I did insist I got on. In the end I was allowed on bus got a mouthful off both the parents with the prams. I just don't know if it's me. I can understand it's frustrating if you're on a bus and suddenly you have to move or fold your pram up, but I cannot fold my wheelchair. It feels like everyone thinks I am in the wrong when I'm trying my best to just be a normal mother! Please tell me there aren't just selfish people put there...or is this honestly just me?
(by the way I do try to leave super early to make sure I have plenty of time to get there but then I am also waiting outside in the cold and I have problems with my joints so not a good combination)

OP posts:
Lwrenagain · 11/02/2023 12:20

I used to be a carer for a lad in a massive electric wheelchair, it was really difficult to get on and off transport, busses especially. I always wondered why society doesn't appreciate being mobile its something we all have forever and why we don't just invest in seatless busses specifically for wheelchair users.
It makes so much more sense to give disabled people more independence and freedom.
It's fucking disgusting to expect disabled people to wait extra hours for a bus and the pram space is small anyway.
We need to make society move inclusive for wheelchairs in general, the amount of times I've walked my clients on the road because some thoughtless gobshite has parked on the pavement etc, we need to do better really. Its not much to ask we give those with a mobility disadvantage a fair and accessible society to live in.

beAsensible1 · 11/02/2023 12:18

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 11:11

I can see your point and I sympathise, but at the same time I think some toddlers are safer and it's less stress and anxiety for the parent if the child/baby is secure in their pram/pushchair where they're not going to be constantly trying to wriggle off their parents laps and try stand up and run down the bus. I have two kids with ASD and I know for a fact that it would have been so stressful and cause me anxiety if I had taken them on the bus with no pushchair. I very rarely use the bus but on the times I did I kept them in their buggies. The end of the day it's first come first served, unless they state that it's not in some areas. You're not the only person with needs, not everyone else's needs are obvious and visible. Not every child can sit still and quiet on the bus on their parents knee. I think if people have older toddlers that are capable of this then they should fold their prams, but I don't think it's up to people to judge other people's personal circumstances and say "That child doesn't need to sit in the pram!" I do think that the bus companies should make more wheelchair/ pushchair/standing space though because 2 places isn't enough.

then if thats the case when the space is needed keep them in the pram and get off the bus so you can wait for the next one.

Xol · 11/02/2023 12:18

Bus drivers are not empowered to do anything about it. You’d probably find that if a driver intervened and there was a complaint to the LA, the company would be fined. That’s why they don’t let people on the bus if they are late too. As a bus driver, why would you want to risk your job to address some dispute between passengers over their entitlements?

They have power to direct the person using the space wrongly to leave the bus, and to refuse to leave until they do. In the final analysis, they can call the transport or ordinary police to get the person in question off. if they don't intervene, the bus company could be on the wrong end of a substantial discrimination claim.

DaisyCornflowerBlue · 11/02/2023 12:15

YANBU. People are dickheads.

I have bus routes near me that go to three major hospitals, yet when a person with extra mobility needs requires the space, people kick off. I despair.

Wakeywake · 11/02/2023 12:15

I was with a friend in a wheelchair trying to get on the bus. I could see a lady with a pram noticing us and starting to fold her pushchair, only for the driver to say we can't get on as there is a pushchair there already. I can't blame the mum, but the bus driver gave me the rage. Complaint filed as soon as we got back.

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 12:12

@Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious I defend a child in a disability buggy or someone with an actual disability using the spot, yes. I don't think anyone should sit there if they don't need to!

ElliF · 11/02/2023 12:11

Gossipxox · 10/02/2023 23:06

This is shocking and the drivers should be doing more about it, I often get on the bus with my pram, and on one occasion I got off the bus for a wheelchair user not because I was asked but because it is the right thing to do. But the drivers where I am in the north east are pretty good at informing people with prams that there is a chance the buggy may need to be folded if a wheelchair comes on. It’s a disgrace your getting the backlash from mothers with their prams it’s rude on their behalf

Bus drivers are not empowered to do anything about it. You’d probably find that if a driver intervened and there was a complaint to the LA, the company would be fined. That’s why they don’t let people on the bus if they are late too. As a bus driver, why would you want to risk your job to address some dispute between passengers over their entitlements?

In regard to parents with push chairs, more often than not the entitlement mentality comes from a place if lower intelligence and the struggle those types of people have dealing with complex society and working out how to be polite and compassionate to others. There is no room to think for some people because the variables are too fast moving, requiring spontaneous thought and the ability to process empathy at the same time, in an instant, and in households lower down on the spectrum, these sorts of thoughts for others is just absent. They are where they are for a reason.

So, if I were in OP’s position, I’d be try to forgive those parents (and their apologists) and pity their children who are going to grow up and emulate their mothers behaviours and attitudes to the world. And they’ll struggle and be limited because of it. OP’s kids on the other hand will see a mother who fought and didn’t give up, and will likely learn to tackle adversity and not give up. And they’ll be happier and better for it.

Johnnysgirl · 11/02/2023 12:11

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 12:08

Prepared to get flamed for this but this is why I believe that wheelchair spaces on a bus should be kept free at all times, and buggies only allowed on if folded at the outset.

Perhaps then parents would campaign for their own spaces, rather than taking what disabled activist groups campaigned for for decades.

I'm inclined to agree, having heard the barely coherent "arguements" put forward by the likes of @Scooby5kids

Merryoldgoat · 11/02/2023 12:10

@CherLloydbyCherLloyd

Are you serious? I’ve just given it away on Freecycle! Oh well. Someone got a good deal.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 11/02/2023 12:09

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 12:08

Prepared to get flamed for this but this is why I believe that wheelchair spaces on a bus should be kept free at all times, and buggies only allowed on if folded at the outset.

Perhaps then parents would campaign for their own spaces, rather than taking what disabled activist groups campaigned for for decades.

Not flamed by me, I agree.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 11/02/2023 12:08

Prepared to get flamed for this but this is why I believe that wheelchair spaces on a bus should be kept free at all times, and buggies only allowed on if folded at the outset.

Perhaps then parents would campaign for their own spaces, rather than taking what disabled activist groups campaigned for for decades.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 11/02/2023 12:06

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 11:43

@Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious I guess we're just going to have to agree to disagree then, because I definitely disagree and if that make me selfish and entitled or whatever then I can take that. I don't go on public transport now anyway because I've got a car which is safer and less stressful for my family's circumstances, but I will defend any other parent that feels they need to use the space if they feel they have a justifiable need.

You'd defend someone using a space over another person who actually is entitled to use it? Yep I'd say you are selfish. The spaces are for wheelchair users to have priority, anyone arguing against that is selfish.

Parker231 · 11/02/2023 12:06

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 12:03

@Parker231 okay well I suppose we just have to sit and wait for that to happen. Don't hold your breath!

Why break the law in the first place when you know it’s wrong not to give a priority to a wheelchair user in a wheelchair space?

Their need to the space is greater than yours. They don’t get a choice as to how they get about.

Xol · 11/02/2023 12:06

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 12:03

@Parker231 okay well I suppose we just have to sit and wait for that to happen. Don't hold your breath!

As the case law demonstrates, bus companies that fail to insist on wheelchair spaces being vacated for wheelchair users can and do find themselves on the wrong end of disability discrimination claims. Bus drivers have become much better about enforcing the law since the 2017 decision.

Renoir56 · 11/02/2023 12:04

It's a wheelchair space. Not a space for people with other disabilities. Not a space for prams. I don't know why people don't seem to get this. It's tough enough for people in wheelchairs, don't make it harder.

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 12:03

@Parker231 okay well I suppose we just have to sit and wait for that to happen. Don't hold your breath!

Johnnysgirl · 11/02/2023 12:03

The bus driver is not going to start debating who is more disabled because that would be risky territory
You keep arguing nonsensically because you still don't actually understand how it works.
There is no ambiguity in this, just read the bloody sign.

Kanaloa · 11/02/2023 12:02

As in, I was just using my own experience.

Kanaloa · 11/02/2023 12:02

NeverHadANickname · 11/02/2023 10:41

That entirely depends on where you are. I live in the US and would have to travel probably an hour in any direction to find a place that has busses or even trains. Taxis aren't even a thing where I am really although I think there might be 1 Uber driver in the area now.

YANBU OP, people should be more considerate. Maybe a phone call to the bus company and ask for more signs put up?

Well yes obviously. I didn’t say ‘all over America is like this.’ I was simply pointing out that other places have much better facilities. Same as how if you went up and lived on a tiny Scottish island you’d probably struggle for a bus!

Parker231 · 11/02/2023 12:01

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 11:58

@xol I suppose if the bus driver got up and said "you're going to have to move" then the other person would have to move. But that rarely ever happens and it's left for the passengers to decide if their need is justified. So the supposed "law" that people keep quoting is useless anyway. The bus driver is not going to start debating who is more disabled because that would be risky territory. I think perhaps the only fair situation in all this is to have to apply for some kind of pass system and that would certainly eradicate most of the problem.

It’s not a supposed law - it’s legislation which went as a high as the Supreme Court.

In January 2017 the Supreme Court clarified the law as it affects access to the wheelchair space for wheelchair users, ruling that drivers must do more than simply request other passengers vacate the space when it is required by a wheelchair user.

Xol · 11/02/2023 12:01

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 11:58

@xol I suppose if the bus driver got up and said "you're going to have to move" then the other person would have to move. But that rarely ever happens and it's left for the passengers to decide if their need is justified. So the supposed "law" that people keep quoting is useless anyway. The bus driver is not going to start debating who is more disabled because that would be risky territory. I think perhaps the only fair situation in all this is to have to apply for some kind of pass system and that would certainly eradicate most of the problem.

The bus driver doesn't have to get into any debate. It's absolutely straightforward. The wheelchair space is for the wheelchair user. The driver can tell the buggy owner to fold or get off the bus, and can refuse to drive off till they do.

DarkDarkNight · 11/02/2023 11:58

The end of the day it's first come first served, unless they state that it's not in some areas.

It absolutely isn’t first come first served. It is a wheelchair space which can be used by others if it is not needed by a wheelchair user. Next time you’re on the bus try to read the sign.

Scooby5kids · 11/02/2023 11:58

@xol I suppose if the bus driver got up and said "you're going to have to move" then the other person would have to move. But that rarely ever happens and it's left for the passengers to decide if their need is justified. So the supposed "law" that people keep quoting is useless anyway. The bus driver is not going to start debating who is more disabled because that would be risky territory. I think perhaps the only fair situation in all this is to have to apply for some kind of pass system and that would certainly eradicate most of the problem.

BlackberrySky · 11/02/2023 11:57

This entitlement from parents of babies and toddlers seems to be getting worse. I live on a busy, very frequent London bus route (bus every 4 mins). The other day there were already three unfolded pushchairs on the bus and this woman got on with another one, refused to fold and proceeded to block both access to the upstairs and the exit doors. I literally had to climb over her toddler and buggy to get out. I don't how the less agile managed it. She seemed bewildered when I told her she should have waited for the next bus 4 mins behind (there are arrivals boards with this info on).

ChungusBoi · 11/02/2023 11:55

There are several possible solutions to this:

Mandatory training for all public transport drivers about the rights of wheelchair users, that includes role playing what to do to for example, if someone with a buggy is refusing to vacate the space for a wheelchair user.

Proper support for drivers and wheelchair users from British Transport Police, enforcing the law and issuing on the spot fines.

A public information campaign.

Maybe some form of badge scheme for buggies that are effectively wheelchairs for disabled children, so that these parents are recognised as having rights to use the wheelchair space as a wheelchair user.

If you like these ideas, maybe write to the transport company and your MP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread