Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Struggling with colleague

131 replies

Krayvon2 · 10/02/2023 21:58

A colleague I manage has ADHD. I've always been more than happy to accommodate and I've asked them several times what adaptations need to be made to brief in tasks etc

They've never been forthcoming with specific recommendations and it's always been vague so I've done my best and given them double the amount of time with tasks, ensured briefs are crystal clear with deadlines and regularly checked in and offered to help.

For a recent task I gave them double the amount of time I would give myself, sent them a brief and made sure they weren't given too many other tasks that week so they could concentrate on this one. I've always made clear that if they have difficulties for whatever reason, they need to let me know.

They left the task to the last minute and didn't do half of it so I had to step in and do a lot myself at the eleventh hour in order to avoid missing a client deadline. They didn't communicate difficulties at any point until I checked in. I'm at a loss as to what they were actually doing in the week I gave them to do the task.

When I pulled them up on it and asked what had happened, they mention the limitations of their condition straight away and explain how they have trouble with things like prioritising and focusing. Yet they didn't reach out once to explain this or ask me to brief in a different way to make it easier for them.

Have I been unreasonable here? I'm not pretending I have the answers but I have tried all I can think of to accommodate yet its not working and they're not really giving me much guidance on what they need yet it's always the reason why they can't do the work I set.

Meanwhile I'm taking on lots of extra work so as not to overload them yet they struggle with completing one single task. No idea what to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jitteryquick · 13/02/2023 17:53

@hopsalong the FFS comes from the frustration of someone trying to impose their own views of what is a disability on others.

Definition of disability (from Wikipedia);

"Disability is the experience of any condition that makes it more difficult for a person to do certain activities or have equitable access within a given society. Disabilities may be cognitive, developmental, intellectual, mental, physical"

ADHD like all of the ND / SpLds are on a spectrum, to mild to very severe. You say your ADHD is severe but you are functioning well despite that and without medication. I am not. Of course you are entitled to not see your ADHD as a disability if it's not making it harder for you to do certain activities, or function in everyday life. If it is, then you could rightfully say you have a disability, but also you could choose not to. You can define yourself however you choose.

I'm frustrated at the way you minimised the impact of poor executive function in your previous post, placing the blame for not being better and the responsibility to just get better at stuff on the individual.

"Well I've got severe ADHD and I'm doing fine so why aren't you?" Is not helpful at all.

hopsalong · 13/02/2023 17:12

I am probably older than some of you, and I was diagnosed 35 years ago. So I've had ADHD for long enough (have also in this time seen many different psychiatrists, both in the US, Germany and here, and tried most of the available medications.) So I'm not exactly ADHD naive. Not sure where the FFS comes from.

For most of the time that I have had ADHD it has not been regarded as a disability. And I have never considered it one, partly because I've been able to get a PhD and have a successful career. I have poor executive function, of course. I have difficulty meeting deadlines. But like many people with ADHD I bristle at the idea that I'm disabled. (I am considered by the way to have severe ADHD; if I didn't, I wouldn't have been prescribed the medications for large parts of my adult life by the NHS.) The idea that ADHD is a disability seems to have arisen in the last five years (so too for dyslexia).

Some posters in this thread might consider themselves disabled, but this is far from universal. It is also the case that I have performed poorly at jobs for reasons that have nothing to do with my ADHD. To get back to the original poster, it sounds to me as if the ADHD colleagues was not making the best effort to communicate or manage their symptoms. It's not a cover-all explanation for poor performance at work.

jitteryquick · 13/02/2023 16:55

hopsalong · 13/02/2023 01:55

@InattentiveADHD

I can think of a lot of things that are disabling in the way that ADHD isn't. My father had his leg amputated in his mid-30s after a workplace accident. He couldn't drive, he couldn't take me to school (or easily come to concerts, parents' evenings etc because of the stairs), we almost never went on holiday. He was also seriously depressed. Poor executive function is irritating and compromising. But not a disability, unless you want to stretch the word so far that it makes it meaningless for anyone who really has a disability. Besides, ADHD has a range of very successful medication options. If I take Ritalin or vyvanse my executive function is pretty good. (I currently choose not to because I don't like the side effects. Again, if someone had given my father back the use of his whole body, a dry mouth, slightly fast heart rate etc would have been trivial to him.)

Just because ADHD isn't as disabling as having an amputation that doesn't mean it isn't a disability. Poor executive function can have a huge impact on someone's life. The stats re unemployment and depression/ anxiety for those with ADHD are really sad and quite shocking.
I am diagnosed. So far meds haven't helped. I cannot function at work in the way my colleagues function. No matter how hard I try. For years I had no idea why I just didn't seem to "get" life like everyone else I knew did. Why were really simple straightforward things paralysing. I'm not stupid, I have a masters degree. But I regularly made mistakes filling in simple forms. And diary management is pretty much impossible. Why?
If people trivialise it and argue that it's not a disability, then the person with ADHD will have no choice to to try and fit in and function like everyone else can. At what cost? I regularly work way over my hours, things take me far longer than they take my colleagues and I know I'm not as productive as they are. But I also know o al working way way harder than them just to stand still.
So no, I not had my leg amputated, I'm not blind, I haven't had a stroke and lost the use of one side of my body. And if you look ar me I look fine. But I'm not. I have a disability. It's just one that's invisible and misunderstood and displays itself through symptoms that you usually relate to someone who is lazy and disorganised and a big weird.
FFS.

InattentiveADHD · 13/02/2023 12:55

hopsalong · 13/02/2023 01:55

@InattentiveADHD

I can think of a lot of things that are disabling in the way that ADHD isn't. My father had his leg amputated in his mid-30s after a workplace accident. He couldn't drive, he couldn't take me to school (or easily come to concerts, parents' evenings etc because of the stairs), we almost never went on holiday. He was also seriously depressed. Poor executive function is irritating and compromising. But not a disability, unless you want to stretch the word so far that it makes it meaningless for anyone who really has a disability. Besides, ADHD has a range of very successful medication options. If I take Ritalin or vyvanse my executive function is pretty good. (I currently choose not to because I don't like the side effects. Again, if someone had given my father back the use of his whole body, a dry mouth, slightly fast heart rate etc would have been trivial to him.)

Lots of conditions are disabling in different ways. Doesn't mean that ADHD isn't also disability. Some conditions are more disabling than others of course. It's not a race to the bottom, and it doesn't mean that because it's more disabling to have one condition, conditions that are less disabling don't count!

The availability of medication also doesn't mean a condition isn't disabling.

If ADHD wasn't a disability, I don't think it would be considered a disorder at all. Everyone forgets their keys sometimes, or struggles to get themselves organised or is late occasionally. To be diagnosed with ADHD you have to have symptoms that occur frequently and negatively impact functioning in at least two areas of your life eg social and work. This in effect automatically meets the definition of a disability. If the condition isn't disabling you, you probably don't have ADHD, you won't meet the diagnostic criteria.

hopsalong · 13/02/2023 01:55

@InattentiveADHD

I can think of a lot of things that are disabling in the way that ADHD isn't. My father had his leg amputated in his mid-30s after a workplace accident. He couldn't drive, he couldn't take me to school (or easily come to concerts, parents' evenings etc because of the stairs), we almost never went on holiday. He was also seriously depressed. Poor executive function is irritating and compromising. But not a disability, unless you want to stretch the word so far that it makes it meaningless for anyone who really has a disability. Besides, ADHD has a range of very successful medication options. If I take Ritalin or vyvanse my executive function is pretty good. (I currently choose not to because I don't like the side effects. Again, if someone had given my father back the use of his whole body, a dry mouth, slightly fast heart rate etc would have been trivial to him.)

Spiderboy · 12/02/2023 00:14

Give them half the time, not double the time. Tasks worth a long deadline fail prioritisation.

It comes down to a few things.

Look into how to manage those with ADHD. It may help in other areas.

Their adhd may be badly managed - talk openly. They may need to be more productive

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 11/02/2023 23:51

"Driven to Distraction" is a really good book to have a read of. It has a number of case studies and lots of strategies to help manage it.

HamBone · 11/02/2023 23:48

@BadNomad i hope they work out some suitable accommodations, the current situation sounds untenable for both the colleague and the OP.

BadNomad · 11/02/2023 23:27

HamBone · 11/02/2023 23:07

@BadNomad i appreciate that the ADHD may have caused his inability to complete the task, it’s the lack of concern that I don’t understand, tbh.
He wasn’t worried about it and let the OP complete the task for him. I suppose I don’t get it, but I can see why it’s hard to work with.

How do you know he wasn't worried or concerned? The fact that he was able to start it and complete half shows that he felt stressed and under pressure as the deadline became immediate which is what enabled him to start. If he hadn't been worried/concerned he wouldn't have done any of it.

I can appreciate that it's hard for people who don't experience ADHD to understand it. But it is unfair to apply a NT interpretation to ND behaviour. For a "normal" person, his actions would give the impression of apathy, lack of respect, not caring etc. But in a ND person that couldn't be further from the truth.

HamBone · 11/02/2023 23:07

@BadNomad i appreciate that the ADHD may have caused his inability to complete the task, it’s the lack of concern that I don’t understand, tbh.
He wasn’t worried about it and let the OP complete the task for him. I suppose I don’t get it, but I can see why it’s hard to work with.

GCWorkNightmare · 11/02/2023 22:31

Showmethefood · 11/02/2023 20:51

Oh and also that I should continue masking as it was working fine before. When I told her masking gave me a headache when I got home and ruined my evening - she said “well now you’re not and it’s ruining work isn’t it!@ 🤷‍♀️ I kid you not.

Grievance. Now.

BadNomad · 11/02/2023 22:18

HamBone · 11/02/2023 22:04

They left the task to the last minute and didn't do half of it so I had to step in and do a lot myself at the eleventh hour in order to avoid missing a client deadline.

@BadNomad Surely the colleague must realize that they’re not doing their job if they only complete half a task though? It sounds as if they weren’t particularly bothered about it either-that’s not really cooperative behavior.

Most people are concerned if they miss a client deadline, possibly even worried about keeping their job. This person doesn’t seem to be taking any responsibility at all.

They only did half of it because they ran out of time to finish it due to starting it at the last minute because of ADHD. That has nothing to do with cooperation. They cooperated by trying out the idea of extra time. It didn't work. What might have worked better was an earlier deadline, so when they only got half finished they could have been granted a short "extension" to finish the rest. Then, because they were filled with stress and adrenaline, they might have been able to complete the task. That is how ADHD works. Stress or pleasure are the things that drive action.

HamBone · 11/02/2023 22:04

They left the task to the last minute and didn't do half of it so I had to step in and do a lot myself at the eleventh hour in order to avoid missing a client deadline.

@BadNomad Surely the colleague must realize that they’re not doing their job if they only complete half a task though? It sounds as if they weren’t particularly bothered about it either-that’s not really cooperative behavior.

Most people are concerned if they miss a client deadline, possibly even worried about keeping their job. This person doesn’t seem to be taking any responsibility at all.

Dontknownow86 · 11/02/2023 21:16

@CloudyOwl why are you so determined to be right about something you only know about on a surface level?? I have adhd and I am also tell telling you I could not work in that scenario. I definitely do not have any asd traits.

Showmethefood · 11/02/2023 20:51

Oh and also that I should continue masking as it was working fine before. When I told her masking gave me a headache when I got home and ruined my evening - she said “well now you’re not and it’s ruining work isn’t it!@ 🤷‍♀️ I kid you not.

Showmethefood · 11/02/2023 20:46

I wish you were my boss OP. When I told my boss i had it - she told me:

  1. That everyone has it nowadays and it has become like a fashion label.
  2. That I should be careful taking meds as it will be like “taking speed”.
  3. That the team won’t tell me when I’ve done things well as it will make my self esteem Lower - if I hear nothing I’m going fine apparently.
  4. Basically that I should just pull my socks up as it’s not fair on the team that I’m struggling at the moment.

All this was after I went to the doctor, had an assessment and was going for meds. Told the boss I wanted to get better and function the best I could. She now makes comments infront of me and others in my team of how she hates adults seeking these mental health diagnosis’s when she reads things in the paper etc. Safe to say I’m livid.

jitteryquick · 11/02/2023 17:40

BlueHeelers · 11/02/2023 17:32

I don’t think that’s necessarily a managers job - surely that’s what trained Occupational Health practitioners do?

@Krayvon2 has already tried to assist her colleague to help him figure out how he can do his job. He’s not cooperated and now the OP is being scolded for making things harder for him. You can’t have it both ways!

And in none of her posts has the OP mentioned Occ Health. That's what I've "scolded" her for. A referral to them should have been one of the first things she did when the employee disclosed their ADHD.

BadNomad · 11/02/2023 17:38

BlueHeelers · 11/02/2023 17:32

I don’t think that’s necessarily a managers job - surely that’s what trained Occupational Health practitioners do?

@Krayvon2 has already tried to assist her colleague to help him figure out how he can do his job. He’s not cooperated and now the OP is being scolded for making things harder for him. You can’t have it both ways!

How has he not co-operated? All I see is them trying things which haven't worked. That isn't his failure. What is a manager's job if not to manage individuals? If you as a manager can only handle one type of person, then you are not a very good manager. But you can become a better manger if you want.

jitteryquick · 11/02/2023 17:38

@CloudyOwl apologies I got your username mixed up with the other poster who is leaving her job because she's struggling to manage a supervisee with ADHD Blush

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/02/2023 17:36

MichelleScarn · 11/02/2023 17:19

But inform me that I need to tell somebody exactly what I need when I'm sat there thinking 'I CAN'T DO THIS'? You're just dumping another distraction, a huge task, upon my head.

How can a manager 'manage' then?
On this thread op and others are being lambasted for not helping in the right way/not doing enough research/not finding out what will help the colleague in their individual manner, but to actually ask what's needed is a distraction as well?

How about looking at it as though you're speaking to somebody on the floor with a clearly broken ankle 'You aren't standing up. We all stand up here'. They responded through the pain 'I've broken my ankle'?

The current replies are 'Well, that's all very well, but what do you want us to do about that? You have to stand up, we all stand up here, there's a random person on the 3rd floor who said he broke his ankle, but was fine and just walked it off by trying really hard. Come on, tell us what your plan is to be standing up like the rest of us'.

...I've broken my ankle?

'Not good enough. Now you're behind on your standing up, so you need to stand up AND provide me with a fully researched and costed report upon exactly how broken ankles are treated and the biological, chemical and physical processes by which they become not so broken so that you can stand up just like everybody else without a broken ankle. By tomorrow morning, because you've got a lot of standing up to catch up now.'

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 11/02/2023 17:34

BlueHeelers · 11/02/2023 17:32

I don’t think that’s necessarily a managers job - surely that’s what trained Occupational Health practitioners do?

@Krayvon2 has already tried to assist her colleague to help him figure out how he can do his job. He’s not cooperated and now the OP is being scolded for making things harder for him. You can’t have it both ways!

Occ health can only advise.

Managers still have to decide what adjustments can be made.

BlueHeelers · 11/02/2023 17:32

I don’t think that’s necessarily a managers job - surely that’s what trained Occupational Health practitioners do?

@Krayvon2 has already tried to assist her colleague to help him figure out how he can do his job. He’s not cooperated and now the OP is being scolded for making things harder for him. You can’t have it both ways!

BadNomad · 11/02/2023 17:29

Because people are assuming people with ADHD know what will help but are choosing to keep it to themselves. It's not like that. We don't always know. It is a major problem and you want us to figure out how to solve it. Some people will have ideas and strategies that work for them, others will only have ideas and strategies that worked once, in a specific circumstance, which wont work now. It's like any other disability. You don't say to someone in a wheelchair "tell me what to do so you can walk up that flight of stairs." You work together to find a way to get that person where they need to be. If something doesn't work, try something else. Dont just throw your hands up and say "I've tried. You've not."

MichelleScarn · 11/02/2023 17:19

But inform me that I need to tell somebody exactly what I need when I'm sat there thinking 'I CAN'T DO THIS'? You're just dumping another distraction, a huge task, upon my head.

How can a manager 'manage' then?
On this thread op and others are being lambasted for not helping in the right way/not doing enough research/not finding out what will help the colleague in their individual manner, but to actually ask what's needed is a distraction as well?

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 11/02/2023 17:13

2bazookas · 11/02/2023 17:07

If she's in a work situation and well aware of problems prioritising/focusing, how hard is it just to write down the check list of tasks you gave her and number them by priority. She could ask you to confirm.

Once she has a written list of tasks in order of priority....

Lists don’t work for me. There could be one thing on it and I’d do 50 other things until 5 mins before that thing is due before doing it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread