Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend's new boyfriend - a red flag?

85 replies

Pigtailsandall · 10/02/2023 21:42

Something so odd happened today that I thought it deserved its own AIBU.

I have a lovely friend of many years. I live in London, she lives up north, so we see each other a few times a year. She's been dating this man for about a year now - it's been a slow start because they were both travelling/working a lot in the start, but the relationship seems to have gained momentum recently.

They are visiting London and staying for a long weekend ,and today was the first time I met him. I took a half a day off work to meet them, and we went straight for lunch. He seemed nice, chatty and quite funny, and he insisted on paying for the whole lunch as I was "an old friend" of his now too. I agreed, slightly reluctantly.

We went for a walk in a nice neighbourhood, and eventually stopped for a coffee at a patisserie. When we walked in he announced I could get anything I liked and he would "treat us". I said, firmly, that I would pay for myself this time but thanks. As we left, I realised he had paid while I was in the loo between ordering and our coffees coming. I though he was trying a bit hard, but then something truly bizarre happened. I was appraising the cakes as we were getting our coats and leaving and he insisted (loudly, people were turning to look) that I take home a few cakes. He said he would buy a few for them too, for breakfast the next day. He kept saying that a particular cake looked really nice, "don't worry, I'll get it for you" and I kept saying no, thank you, I was ok. But he was getting quite loud, it was a small space and eventually I said, Fine, more to get him to shut up so we could leave. I pointed at a small chocolate cake, and he went to the till, got 3 small cake boxes, paid and handed me one.

We then went for a stroll on the high street, looking at shops. My friend wanted to buy a present for her niece, so we went into an absurdly expensive children's clothing store (He paid, of course) and when he saw me picking up and looking at something (I don't even remember what, I was really just waiting for my friend to choose) he was by my side like a flash asking if I wanted it for my DC. I almost dropped the garment. It felt like an uncomfortable afternoon, and I missed not being able to chat to my friend freely - I felt like she was quieter than normal. I made a very specific effort to not touch anything else at subsequent shops.

But now, I'm home after a glass of wine with them (he paid, of course - I was totally worn out and just let him) and I've opened the cake box. Inside is the cake HE noted looked good - not the chocolate cake I chose. I texted a very nonchalant message to my friend, basically asking if maybe our boxes got mixed up, and she texted me back saying "No, XXXX thought that one looked really good and thought you should have it". I know it's only a cake, but what kind of a freak changes someone's order behind their back? Or am I overreacting? I feel like this is a total red flag, right?

OP posts:
BenCoopersSupportWren · 11/02/2023 08:45

To those saying he's clearly controlling etc based on this story alone. That is pure projection and quite a sad way to see things. I can certainly see why someone would get twat vibes though, while I wouldn't judge yet - he sounds hard work!

Nope, it’s based on experience, both my own and that of good friends. If he was really trying simply to “make a good impression” he’d have bought the OP two chocolate cakes, or the cake she wanted plus the cake he wanted to treat her to. But he ignored her clearly stated choice and forced his own preference on her instead.

I understand that to people who haven’t been on the receiving end of or witnessed loved ones enduring controlling, narcissistic behaviour it might seem like a small and insignificant thing. But it speaks volumes about this man’s character and attitude to women.

TibetanTerrah · 11/02/2023 08:15

The whole way thru I could just about put it down to nerves/wanting to impress and give him the benefit of the doubt, until he ordered you a different cake.

He really steamrolled over that whole day out didn't he Confused

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/02/2023 08:15

Seems odd and claustrophobic. I’d be keeping an eye on your friend. Maybe compliment him to her with ‘gosh, incredibly generous, is he always like that?’ Ask for examples of what he’s done etc.

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 11/02/2023 08:12

What cake did he choose to replace the chocolate cake you chose?

Not relevant I know but I am intrigued.

But anyway, I would be cross and he sounds controlling. An ex of mine was a bit like this, all grand gestures and had to pay for everything and showing off. It gets really old really quickly.

I hope your friend doesn't get arsey if you raise it with her...

Jimboscott0115 · 11/02/2023 07:44

I wouldn't say red flag but definitely sounds full on and very OTT right now. The type of cake he got us pretty small fry and I think he was probably a bit over excited and trying to make an impression.

The way by I'd see it is he didn't mistreat your friend in any way, in fact he was probably trying too hard to treat you both really well. There's nothing alarming about this behaviour you've described, other than if this is who he is - he sounds a bit too much and too full on to get along with.

To those saying he's clearly controlling etc based on this story alone. That is pure projection and quite a sad way to see things. I can certainly see why someone would get twat vibes though, while I wouldn't judge yet - he sounds hard work!

winningeasy · 11/02/2023 07:31

Sounds like a bloody annoying weirdo

rainbowstardrops · 11/02/2023 07:28

I'd wonder if he was just trying to make a good impression but swapping your cake choice would piss me off!
Are you going to mention it to him and ask him why when you see him?
I'd also be ready to support your friend when she needs it.

Mainlinethehappy · 11/02/2023 06:25

If this behaviour meant that I could stop work and enjoy hobbies all day, where do I sign up to get one of him?
But I'd keep an escape fund...

BellaJuno · 11/02/2023 06:22

HarlanPepper · 11/02/2023 05:27

I don't understand how anyone can read the OP and not think this guy's behaviour is, at the least, odd!

I know it's mainly about cake, and cake is nice and everything, we all like cake. But this is someone who won't take 'no' for an answer. I can almost understand about lunch - friendly arguments about paying for a meal can become a bit of a power play sometimes, but having 'won', it's like he had to keep winning all day. Weirdo. Red flags everywhere.

Yep, this for me. The lunch thing sounds pretty normal on its own, first time meeting and he wanted to impress etc but the rest would give me pause for thought. Is he just socially unaware and clumsily trying to prove to you how capable he is of looking after your friend, or he is a massive control freak who thinks he knows better than everyone and won’t take no for an answer?

I’d be having a chat with my friend when he’s not around, gently pointing out you felt a bit railroaded/had your wishes over-ridden and see how she reacts. Was he acting out of character or does he act that way with her in general?

The cake is a massive red herring (so to speak 😂) that the more flippant posters are getting distracted by, your instincts are telling you something isn’t right.

RebeccaCloud9 · 11/02/2023 06:21

If he'd got you both cakes it would have been more about being generous and awkwardly trying to make a good impression on his gf's friend. Replacing your order makes it more about control and narcissism.

Sally2791 · 11/02/2023 06:16

I think it’s creepy. Did you speak about it with your friend?

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 11/02/2023 06:15

He might be a complete psychopath but he may also clumsily be trying to be generous. Are they staying with you?
We often visit a friend in London and although I don't buy clothes for her children I would buy all the food, treats and treats for her children that I also usually take out for the day. As part of a couple DH would be paying too.

custardbear · 11/02/2023 06:09

It's odd and controlling. I also don't like people incessantly insisting on paying either

ElizaGumpyLeg · 11/02/2023 06:01

bloodymary100 · 10/02/2023 21:55

Red flag for me but I have friends who aspire to meet a man like that...

@bloodymary100

Lol this. This guy sounds like a total dickhead to me but there’s a lot of women who are with guys like this who either seem to find it normal or even appreciate it!

BenCoopersSupportWren · 11/02/2023 05:54

The fact it’s about cake is irrelevant. The key point here, which turns “a bit pushy about paying / ostentatiously generous / trying to make a good impression but coming off a little weird” into “big red flag” is his inability to respect a woman’s choices, including her choice to say “no” to something. He’s someone who has to have his own way and who will override a perfectly valid choice to impose what he thinks the woman should do.

Deliberately changing someone else’s order to your own preference is a controlling power play. This is not a Nice Guy.

MiddleParking · 11/02/2023 05:50

The cake thing is weird and annoying as fuck but the huge red flag for me was:

My friend wanted to buy a present for her niece, so we went into an absurdly expensive children's clothing store (He paid, of course) and when he saw me picking up and looking at something (I don't even remember what, I was really just waiting for my friend to choose) he was by my side like a flash asking if I wanted it for my DC.

Unbelievably creepy.

CementTrucker · 11/02/2023 05:46

Anyway, I see red flags everywhere. The sickly sweet obsequiousness to you as the friend (had a friend whose dp liked to accompany us and treat us as ‘his’ ladies when out - utter creep), the having to ‘win’ as someone else pointed out, the OTT gifting/treating, making a scene in the cake shop. One or two of those you could attribute to nervousness, but the cake swap means I wouldn’t give this bloke the benefit of the doubt. There is simply no way that can be interpreted positively.

CementTrucker · 11/02/2023 05:40

givingupchocolatemonday · 11/02/2023 04:09

You sound quite obsessed to be honest

You go out for the day, it turns out to be uncomfortable, confusing and not at all what you expected, you think it over when you get home and ask others what they think. Pretty standard.

HarlanPepper · 11/02/2023 05:27

I don't understand how anyone can read the OP and not think this guy's behaviour is, at the least, odd!

I know it's mainly about cake, and cake is nice and everything, we all like cake. But this is someone who won't take 'no' for an answer. I can almost understand about lunch - friendly arguments about paying for a meal can become a bit of a power play sometimes, but having 'won', it's like he had to keep winning all day. Weirdo. Red flags everywhere.

Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 11/02/2023 05:18

Massive red flag!

DoristheDuchess · 11/02/2023 05:08

Some red flags here.

My take on the situation was that he was almost trying to infantise you. You don't know what you what, I know what you want. I wonder if he would have behaved the same if you were a male friend?

Because that's the acid test here for me. If you change your sex to male, then the whole day would have been different. People will say, ' of course it would be different, a bloke wouldn't be like that to another bloke'. But think about that for a second, why would it be be different and why should we as women accept that it would just be different?

People can shrug this off as being nice or chivalrous, or as trying too hard to make a good first impression. But this guy doesn't hear the word no, and certainly not from a woman. That's a problem if he thinks that's a good first impression.

Whilst on the surface this would seem awesome, would you really want to be in a relationship with someone who sees your opinion as less than theirs?

OP is not in a relationship with him, so she gets the luxury of avoiding him. But the price could be the friendship.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 11/02/2023 05:00

Perhaps the shopkeeper just mixed up the cakes?

Iwantabloodypizza · 11/02/2023 04:48

I’m skint, I would’ve rinsed him 😳

givingupchocolatemonday · 11/02/2023 04:09

You sound quite obsessed to be honest

ScattyHattie · 11/02/2023 04:03

Paying for the meals I'd just think overly keen to impress on first meeting but then the shop behaviour is like he wants to prove has wealth and is a good catch.

So he liked how the cake looked but had not been there before to know it actually tasted good? Most people are wary when told to choose by others as they know tastes are very individual so to overule your preference does show a total lack of respect. If he'd given you both cakes then it would be irritating but less of a dick move.

I've always thought it weird in films where the guy orders a meal for the lady and it's portrayed as romantic. I'd worry for friend too as she's clearly enjoying being spoilt and didn't see an issue with the cakes, so may not notice there is controlling undertone till gradually all her choices may default to him. Is she type of person that prefers to hand over decision making responsibility then go with the flow?