Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend's new boyfriend - a red flag?

85 replies

Pigtailsandall · 10/02/2023 21:42

Something so odd happened today that I thought it deserved its own AIBU.

I have a lovely friend of many years. I live in London, she lives up north, so we see each other a few times a year. She's been dating this man for about a year now - it's been a slow start because they were both travelling/working a lot in the start, but the relationship seems to have gained momentum recently.

They are visiting London and staying for a long weekend ,and today was the first time I met him. I took a half a day off work to meet them, and we went straight for lunch. He seemed nice, chatty and quite funny, and he insisted on paying for the whole lunch as I was "an old friend" of his now too. I agreed, slightly reluctantly.

We went for a walk in a nice neighbourhood, and eventually stopped for a coffee at a patisserie. When we walked in he announced I could get anything I liked and he would "treat us". I said, firmly, that I would pay for myself this time but thanks. As we left, I realised he had paid while I was in the loo between ordering and our coffees coming. I though he was trying a bit hard, but then something truly bizarre happened. I was appraising the cakes as we were getting our coats and leaving and he insisted (loudly, people were turning to look) that I take home a few cakes. He said he would buy a few for them too, for breakfast the next day. He kept saying that a particular cake looked really nice, "don't worry, I'll get it for you" and I kept saying no, thank you, I was ok. But he was getting quite loud, it was a small space and eventually I said, Fine, more to get him to shut up so we could leave. I pointed at a small chocolate cake, and he went to the till, got 3 small cake boxes, paid and handed me one.

We then went for a stroll on the high street, looking at shops. My friend wanted to buy a present for her niece, so we went into an absurdly expensive children's clothing store (He paid, of course) and when he saw me picking up and looking at something (I don't even remember what, I was really just waiting for my friend to choose) he was by my side like a flash asking if I wanted it for my DC. I almost dropped the garment. It felt like an uncomfortable afternoon, and I missed not being able to chat to my friend freely - I felt like she was quieter than normal. I made a very specific effort to not touch anything else at subsequent shops.

But now, I'm home after a glass of wine with them (he paid, of course - I was totally worn out and just let him) and I've opened the cake box. Inside is the cake HE noted looked good - not the chocolate cake I chose. I texted a very nonchalant message to my friend, basically asking if maybe our boxes got mixed up, and she texted me back saying "No, XXXX thought that one looked really good and thought you should have it". I know it's only a cake, but what kind of a freak changes someone's order behind their back? Or am I overreacting? I feel like this is a total red flag, right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
enoughofthiscrap · 17/02/2023 12:12

Any update? Did you speak to your friend?

rainbowstardrops · 11/02/2023 13:50

So he was overbearing yesterday and now he has decided to change the plans for today. I hope your friend ditches him soon.

ChaToilLeam · 11/02/2023 13:11

The combination of excessive generosity, ignoring your “no thank you” and changing your cake point to him being controlling. I hope your friend will see this soon and extricate herself.

NeedNwJeans · 11/02/2023 13:02

It's a bit weird, but some people are more generous than others and I would expect someone you meet for the first time , he's trying to impress you if know that you & your friend are close. The cake thing- are you sure the cake shop didn't get them mixed up? Otherwise that's the weird one.

Also, if your friends travels with his BF for a weekend away, you'd expect to see them as a couple, not seeing your friend alone?

Triffid1 · 11/02/2023 12:48

Like.others the insisting on paying was annoying and a bit infantalising perhaps and I would have found it annoying. But would probably give him benefit of the doubt- first meeting, nerves etc.

But changing your cake after insisting you buy one is a huge red flag. This is the kind of man who will complain you weren't grateful.enough after he spent all this money....

WimpoleHat · 11/02/2023 12:30

I chose a chocolate cake, kind of sachertorte looking thing, he swapped it for an elaborate carrot cake.

Oh - that is really weird. I could just about (just about) see it if you’d chosen the smallest, cheapest chocolate thing and he thought you’d have liked something more elaborate along the same lines (even then, it’s odd not to get both). But maybe you don’t like carrot cake! Lots of people don’t! Or you could be allergic to nuts, or orange or something. Very odd indeed to swap your cake.

FlipFlopBattle · 11/02/2023 12:22

Good that your friend can see his controlling behaviour to an extent, but she may still justify it somehow at this early stage.

If she's starting to have doubts but not sure, good tests would be: announcing that she's thinking of getting her hair cut really short / dyed a different colour; mentioning that she's going to have dinner with a male friend she's known for years; asking if he still in contact with any exes.

If he puts pressure on her not to do either of the first two, and gets ranty about all exes being the ones responsible for their relationship going wrong, you've pretty much got your answer: a control freak whose previous partners have probably legged it as far away as possible.

DowntonCrabby · 11/02/2023 11:53

Just seeing the update, yes hopefully it won’t last.

DowntonCrabby · 11/02/2023 11:52

It’s the not accepting “no, thank you” for an answer the first time that’s the massive screaming red flag. Yuck

AliceOlive · 11/02/2023 11:52

Oh that’s good. Suspect it won’t last.

Pigtailsandall · 11/02/2023 11:47

Thank you for your replies, it sounds like I'm not alone in thinking this is weird behaviour. To answer a few questions:

I chose a chocolate cake, kind of sachertorte looking thing, he swapped it for an elaborate carrot cake. Cake is no more because DC saw it and shared it with DH this morning. Not that the type of cake makes difference

They don't live together, no. It's still relatively new because they didn't see each other much in the first 6 months.

My friend is quite introverted and hates conflict, so often you don't know what she's thinking until she's done it. We've been friends for 20 years so I feel like we can be honest (although diplomatic). We've gone through shit relationships and always been honest.

They are not staying with us, no.

I looked back at some of the messages and I get the impression he is also a bit of a compulsive shopper/spender. I texted my friend this morning and she is annoyed because they had made plans and he now wants to go to the Imperial War Museum because the weather is no good. Weather is fine, btw, grey but not raining. I said to her that it sounds like he's pretty set on what he wants and she said yes, he can be quite bulldozing at times. So she sees it. Good.

I hope I can get one on one time with her soon. Sadly we are going away this afternoon for half term so yesterday was my only chance to see them/her.

OP posts:
whatwouldAnnaDelveydo · 11/02/2023 11:04

Big red flag. Hope your friend likes not making decisions about her own life. It sounds like he doesn't care about what anyone wants, except him.

Schnooze · 11/02/2023 11:04

FebName · 11/02/2023 03:28

I almost get the trying to be over generous to impress his girlfriend's friend.

BUT! Changing your cake order. Because he knows best!!

That's off the scale nuts! Who does that? Controlling narcs, that's who. Fucking weirdo.

Poor friend. Is she living with him yet? Would you be able to text him without him reading?

A PP had a good idea, saying lovely day but wasn't strange he decided to change your cake order? Test the waters.

This

Newusernameaug · 11/02/2023 11:03

Massive red flag!

MuffinTahp · 11/02/2023 10:59

I'd text him and tell him you ate the cake but it wasn't st the one you chose, you're highly allergic to the one he swapped it for and now you're in an ambulance, so thanks alot 😂😂

monsteramunch · 11/02/2023 10:54

Aldisfinest · 11/02/2023 10:09

I wouldn't write him off completely yet. Seems like he was just desperate to impress you.

Taking no for an answer would have been a lot more impressive!

jellybe · 11/02/2023 10:10

The insisting on paying for lunch and coffees would annoy me but I'd put that down to nerves, and a miss placed idea of chivalry.

However, the switching of the order and insisting you have a cake in the first place and not accepting that you didn't want one would set my red flag o-meter spinning. Especially how insistent he was when you declined, the breaking down of boundaries over small things soon leads to crossing boundaries in big things.

At this point though all you can do is be there for your friend and keep lines of communication open and hope she sees what a twat he is soon.

Aldisfinest · 11/02/2023 10:09

I wouldn't write him off completely yet. Seems like he was just desperate to impress you.

FebName · 11/02/2023 10:08

HarlanPepper · 11/02/2023 05:27

I don't understand how anyone can read the OP and not think this guy's behaviour is, at the least, odd!

I know it's mainly about cake, and cake is nice and everything, we all like cake. But this is someone who won't take 'no' for an answer. I can almost understand about lunch - friendly arguments about paying for a meal can become a bit of a power play sometimes, but having 'won', it's like he had to keep winning all day. Weirdo. Red flags everywhere.

Exactly @HarlanPepper and that's why we get this sad threads later on when the man beats the fuck out of them "out the blue".

How anyone can read the OP and think that is normal behaviour! Shows how fucked up some woman are.

xsquared · 11/02/2023 09:38

I think I'm with you OP. Paying for lunch as a one off on your first meeting seems like he is trying to make a good first impression. Normal.

Paying when you've already said no to coffee and patisserie and insisting on paying for a different cake to the one you thought looked nice, is overbearing. He should have respected your decisions and that's twice he's not taken no for an answer.

I am not saying he is a potential abuser or narcissist, but in my experience it starts with little things like this, and if you say no to other things further down the line, then you're the one who is made out to be the bad guy.

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 11/02/2023 09:17

my niece had a boyfriend like this and although generous meant that we had no choice and it got very frustrating.

MistyFrequencies · 11/02/2023 09:12

FlappyValley · 10/02/2023 22:21

More red flags there than a jubilee street party, OP. He sounds like a controlling narcissist. Perhaps those saying it’s fine have never learnt the hard way that you should never, ever trust a man who refuses to hear the word NO.

Assuming you’d prefer not to just tell your friend that you think he’s a giant creep, I’d gently ask her if she’s comfortable with his extreme “generosity” and say you found his insistence a bit overwhelming (or something along those lines). That way she’s less likely to ignore any nascent doubts she may already have about him.

This. Sounds exactly like my sisters ex. She ended up fleeing with nothing but the clothes on her back. Stay in touch with your friend, she may well need you.

WimpoleHat · 11/02/2023 09:05

I’ve come across the “won’t let a woman pay” types before and they usually mean well rather than being sexist pigs; it’s like an extreme “ladies first” upbringing. The “I’ll pay for lunch as you’re an old friend of mine now” was quite charming in its own way and he was probably trying to impress you. But the cake thing? Yes, that was very odd. Very odd indeed. But time will tell, I suppose…..

TootsAtOwls · 11/02/2023 09:02

He sounds utterly bonkers!

I'm guessing the cake he chose for you was bigger than the one you pointed to? He'd probably say "oh she was just being polite so I got her the big cake she must have wanted really".

As pp have said, lots of red flags .

DoristheDuchess · 11/02/2023 09:00

Thing is, with controlling people they don't suddenly become controlling. There are always little tell tale signs that give away their need to control. Most people are blind to them, brush them off or lean towards always giving people the benefit of the doubt. They don't really open their eyes and see what's happening. They gaslight themselves or others unintentionally because 'No he/she isn't really a bad person, they meant well'.

It's an astute person who trusts their own intuition and acts on it.