Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To have kicked my friend and her daughter out at 8pm

232 replies

Terriblefriend07 · 10/02/2023 21:17

I will try not to drip feed, so might be a
long post. I have name changed. My friend and her 4 year old daughter was due to stay this weekend.
my DC is has complex health condition which leaves them in hospital when ever they spike a fever or unwell. We try to live life normally the best we can. We have always had rules that If you are sick you do not enter our house.
my friend is 100 percent aware of the situation.

they arrived this evening with in a few seconds friend announces she has a wee bit of a cough ( I could deal this ) but it was very clear when I heard her that I was a very active new cough and she did not look well. Full of a virus / hacky cough / snot everywhere and bright cheeks. Was miserable and screaming. She then vomited in my hallway and I checked temp which was 39 ! I am an awful friend but I told them they had to leave. The only options were to travel back 3 hours or to go to a local hotel I have them the choice and I would pay for the hotel. I’m angry, she’s angry , we have had a bit of a big fall out and I feel like a terrible friend.

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 11/02/2023 07:22

I don’t think I could have done that, it’s so harsh on the ill child- and sending them out to find a hotel at 8pm when they don’t even have a car!

She’d probably only just got really ill there and then. Sickness can come on instantly with DC.

I think you were way OTT. You should’ve just sent both kids to bed.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 11/02/2023 07:21

WhatNoRaisins · 11/02/2023 07:03

I don't know if having long distance overnight guests are a good idea in your situation. Train tickets cost a small fortune and can't be refunded for illness. I can also believe with small children that this sort of thing can come on very suddenly during a long train journey.

There's too much potential for bad feelings if someone commits to a long journey and then has to cancel. Better they stay somewhere else so it's not all wasted.

That’s not a decision for the OP to take, that’s for the guest. Presumably the child’s mother is adult. She’s aware of the OPs situation. It’s down to her to understand that the situation could change.

I mean, when booking things like that she’d have to accept that if her child caught something like chicken pox or noro she wouldn’t be able to travel regardless of the OPs situation.

The onus shouldn’t always be on the OP. Her friend has a brain too to think of possible issues.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 11/02/2023 07:18

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/02/2023 06:07

They certainly should take a long hard look at themselves. It's unreasonable saying OP should do this or that differently when they're neither the child's doctors nor the child's parents and they really know bugger all about the situation.

There's a vulnerable child in my DC class, who can attend school masked but can't go out into the playground. Their parents have determined along with their doctors what is ok and what isn't and anyone who doesn't know the details of the child's medical needs shouldn't be judging the parents. Like many things in life it's finding a balance, isolation can be really mentally damaging to the child as well as their carers. As OP obviously loves her DC and is protective of their health why would anyone assume she's not doing everything necessary, as determined in consultation with the child's doctors, to keep her DC safe.

It’s very common, especially on here.

You can’t win. You’re either ridiculously OTT and expecting too much of people. Or slack lazy and endangering your child.

The assumptions they know best are baffling.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 07:15

Sometimeswinning · 11/02/2023 00:12

I don't think you are terrible but I'm suprised you would allow guests to stay in your home. You made the right call but maybe this experience will stop you letting guests come over to stay? In your position I'd assume a blanket rule would be no one stays overnight. You should have said no from the start.

But you know nothing about the child’s condition and nothing about what may have been discussed as permissible with the doctors. The OP didn't post for uninformed opinions on overnight guests, but to confirm she was right to turn away a selfish friend who knew the rule about sickness and turned up anyway. Length of stay is irrelevant if you’re not sick. Seems reasonable to me.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 07:13

AthenaPopodopolous · 10/02/2023 23:16

Well I think you should be ashamed to kick a four year old poorly child and your friend out after they’d travelled for hours to see you. Absolute disgrace really and I don’t think the friendship will recover.

@AthenaPopodopolous I think you are the absolute disgrace who ran your mouth without even reading the OP's posts; her child has serious complex needs, is on IV medication, immunocompromised and has oncology-like protocols to stay away from people. FFS, stop making an idiot of yourself, and LEARN TO READ before running your mouth!

WhatNoRaisins · 11/02/2023 07:03

I don't know if having long distance overnight guests are a good idea in your situation. Train tickets cost a small fortune and can't be refunded for illness. I can also believe with small children that this sort of thing can come on very suddenly during a long train journey.

There's too much potential for bad feelings if someone commits to a long journey and then has to cancel. Better they stay somewhere else so it's not all wasted.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 11/02/2023 07:02

AthenaPopodopolous · 10/02/2023 23:16

Well I think you should be ashamed to kick a four year old poorly child and your friend out after they’d travelled for hours to see you. Absolute disgrace really and I don’t think the friendship will recover.

Try reading the OP properly. The friend knew she should not visit when sick because the OPs child is vulnerable. Would you let an obviously sick child near your own when even a mild illness could land them in hospital ? The friend should have turned around and gone home as soon as she realised her child was sick.

Bunnycat101 · 11/02/2023 06:46

if I was visiting you, I’d take temp before travelling and before entering your home and be well aware that sudden illness might mean a hasty exit. You did the right thing protecting your child. Unfortunately with small children there is always a chance they come down with something quickly and unexpectedly.

The fact that her reaction was to calpol up the child shows she didn’t get it at all. Masking the fever was going to do nothing to stop her being infectious.

For the future though you may need to think about timing of having people to stay. Feb half term feels risky just because there is so much circulating. The chances were always going to be relatively high of the child coming down with something over the weekend unfortunately. I would have never invited myself over during winter in the circs.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/02/2023 06:07

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 11/02/2023 00:33

People having a pop at the op for having visitors need to have a word with themselves.

Its hard enough finding the balance between shielding a child from illness and allowing them to have a life without people implying there is an iota of blame on the OP for someone ignoring clear boundaries and basic manners.

As much as we may wish to those of us with very, very vulnerable children cannot isolate for their whole lives.

They certainly should take a long hard look at themselves. It's unreasonable saying OP should do this or that differently when they're neither the child's doctors nor the child's parents and they really know bugger all about the situation.

There's a vulnerable child in my DC class, who can attend school masked but can't go out into the playground. Their parents have determined along with their doctors what is ok and what isn't and anyone who doesn't know the details of the child's medical needs shouldn't be judging the parents. Like many things in life it's finding a balance, isolation can be really mentally damaging to the child as well as their carers. As OP obviously loves her DC and is protective of their health why would anyone assume she's not doing everything necessary, as determined in consultation with the child's doctors, to keep her DC safe.

HelenOfCroy · 11/02/2023 05:59

You are 100% right and the friend is wrong. Lots of people are like your friend, they don't think beyond their own needs and wants. In your shoes, I'd not welcome overnight guests, if they visit, they have to have accommodation elsewhere sorted. We had visitors for the day a few weeks ago, their dc had a stinking cold, my youngest dc caught the exact same virus from them and missed a week's school including some end of term tests as a result. 😞

DaveyJonesLocker · 11/02/2023 05:50

YANBU
for two days her kid has been a bit off, she should have let you know then.

She's tried to downplay her kids illness so you'd let them stay knowing your child is vulnerable.

She has done something really vile tbh, she deliberately chose to try to force you into something you've told her not to do to because she wants a weekend away.

NewtoHolland · 11/02/2023 05:16

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/02/2023 04:08

Perhaps she didn’t cancel the trip as the train ticket is non refundable so she wanted to use them and / or her dd was excited about going away. The real test will be if she contacts you in a few days to apologise, thank you for the money and see if your dd is ok.

But OPs daughter can't be in close contact with an infectious child, oncology protocol means like no immune system. OPs child could get very very seriously I'll very easily from being close to this child...mum knew she was unwell and not drinking for days. The real test has already happened she not only brought risk to Ops door, she then tried to stay there and continue to put her daughter at high risk of serious illness.
She is not any kind of friend.

Randomly up post someone said it could be travel sickness. Travel sickness would not give a child a significant fever of 39 degrees.

kateandme · 11/02/2023 05:13

knowing your child suffers like they do i would never have dare to enter the gate never mind the house with a poorly child!

kateandme · 11/02/2023 05:11

what would you regret more op.making the right decision to protect your child. or not and the possible consequences if they caught it?
you feel bad because your a nice person who doesnt want to see a friend go home or have to make the journey back.
and it wouldnt matter even if they had made the trip just to see you. she knows the deal.so do you. this was a no option situation.
but its ok to care a bout how the situation went.
but then you have to park it.not take it on or inside as something bad on you or becasue of you. it happened and you id the right thing.
what would she have done?
seriously any parent?
she has no right to put a hissy fit on you here. be sad your trip to see weacother couldnt happen.but no blame

LAMPS1 · 11/02/2023 05:08

You shouldn’t be feeling bad about this at all OP.

Your friend invited herself to yours.
She knew the serious consequences of bringing sickness to your house
She knew her dC was sick before entering your house
She minimised her dC symptoms with no regard for your own Dc whatsoever.
She showed little understanding of your predicament in your home to which she had invited herself and little knowledge of how a virus is spread and was reluctant to take responsibility, so you were forced to.
Upsetting as it was, you did the right thing and handled it all brilliantly.
I hope she phones you to apologise.
Also really hope your dd didn’t catch the virus.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 11/02/2023 04:53

Your friend should never have put you in that position. I wouldn't turn up with a sick child in normal circumstances, no way I'd bring an infectious illness around someone who would end up in hospital if they caught it. She's the unreasonable one, yes saying sick 4 year old has to leave wouldn't sit well, but you only needed to do that because your 'friend' did the wrong thing. I'm guessing she's either entitled and thoughtless or doesn't really believe your DD is that sick. You did the only thing you could in the circumstances and you went above and beyond offering to pay for a hotel when your friend was the one in the wrong.

LunaMoon21 · 11/02/2023 04:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as spam.

SeasonFinale · 11/02/2023 04:36

MichelleScarn · 10/02/2023 21:19

Is it possible the sickness was related to travelling for 3 hrs and the stress of that? Did you have any discussion like this?

🙄

StoppinBy · 11/02/2023 04:33

She's the one in the wrong, even if her daughter had just developed the cough alone she should have either checked before coming or not came at all.

zimbabe · 11/02/2023 04:26

Absolutely not unreasonable. And even if it came on quickly and she took a turn for the worse on the train, a true friend would have called and said we are here but DC is unwell, I'm not sure I can bring her to the house, and left it to you to say come anyway so I can assess (or just say ahhhh shame and you yravelled all the way here) while protesting that they will get a hotel or go home so as not to endanger your DC. But she chose to be dishonest and underplay it.

Experienced parents putting their friends' and families'feelings over us so as to not make THEM uncomfortable. You aren't the one whose wrong in this scenario. She is.

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/02/2023 04:08

Perhaps she didn’t cancel the trip as the train ticket is non refundable so she wanted to use them and / or her dd was excited about going away. The real test will be if she contacts you in a few days to apologise, thank you for the money and see if your dd is ok.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 04:00

YANBU She sounds so incredibly selfish, she KNEW they shouldn't have been there. The fact you paid for her hotel and meds is extremely generous. If she can't see that, she's not a true friend. If I were you I would be livid at them turning up like that. Absolutely livid.

kittensinthekitchen · 11/02/2023 01:48

Why did you send her money for calpol?

NumberTheory · 11/02/2023 01:12

YWNBU at all.

On the one hand, if the symptoms came on while they were traveling then I can kind of see how someone not immersed in a situation could fudge things a bit hoping it’s not actually a virus while they got their head around the fact that, yes, their child was ill and, yes, they do need to leave even though it’s going to be a nightmare with a sick child at that time of night.

Hopefully that’s all your friend’s anger is about and once she’s had time to process it she’ll realise you didn’t have a choice. If not, you’ll know she’s incredibly selfish, with no regard for you and your DD, and you’re probably better off without her in your life.

But at least a little bit of me would be wondering if your friend already knew and brought her DD anyway hoping to get away with it. The wanting to mask symptoms with calpol as though that would stop there being a virus at all, suggests either incredible ignorance, or a blatant lack of concern for what’s really happening and what might happen to your DD as long as she can pretend the formalities were followed.

Starstruck2020 · 11/02/2023 00:54

Your friend should not have brought her daughter in your home. She should have come in (if she had a car) or phoned you from a coffee shop near by if taxi/train and had a conversation with you.

It is very unfortunate but given how sick your DS gets, knowing there was a slight cough before they left she probably should either never have come or been prepared to stay somewhere else if she was worse after the trip to get to you. It is selfish of her to put you in that position. Who does these things???

Swipe left for the next trending thread