Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'gender affirming care" is barbaric and should be banned?

211 replies

Appalonia · 10/02/2023 21:12

This article is from the US but these procedures have been carried out in the UK. Teenagers who are confused and vulnerable do not have the mental capacity to consent to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or life altering surgery.

Please read this devastating article from a whistleblower who has been working in a gender clinic in the US.

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

OP posts:
Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:42

Gender dysphoria kids commit suicide when they don't feel accepted by people around them. Banning gender affirming care is not a solution to people being trans.

Why is there so much hatred towards trans people? This is the problem.

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 11:42

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:32

@WinterTrees

As stated in my previous post, very few trans kids are actually accessing medical care in the uk. The waiting lists are years long.

Do you think these families should have support at all, such as counselling, until the young people are 18?

They are though. There might not be many doing it on the NHS but as I pointed out, there are many other avenues and growing amounts of funding to facilitate it. Unfortunately the funding is only for ‘affirmative care’ which consists of affirming the self diagnosis of the child and starting them on puberty blockers or cross sex hormones. It does not fund and proper exploratory therapy to uncover the root causes of the distress which frequently out to be issues such as bullying or sexual abuse and completely not requiring any transition as a solution. This is dangerous for children and young people.

I absolutely agree that there should be far better mental health provision for all distressed young people and people open exploratory therapy to help the individual understand their issues.

I hope that you will join the campaign to ask the government not to make this exploratory therapy illegal by calling it ‘gender identity’ Conversion Therapy.

Helleofabore · 11/02/2023 11:38

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:28

There is no evidence to support the idea that children with gender dysphoria are any more likely to commit suicide than any other young person with mental health problems. In fact, the noteable suicides or sudden deaths have happened to the children taking cross sex hormones.

This is incorrect. Even a quick Google will tell you otherwise

Google is the wrong place. There are a few large surveys done in the USA that were done with people being offered a chance for reward to participate, ie. not a great start for methodology. There was no way of checking answers. And many of the people answering suffered from family issues that were not being addressed or probed.

The clinics themselves have stated that the suicide statistics are falsely represented.

And the clinicians who work there report, across the world, that suicide rates are not reduced by transitioning treatments alone. And that those patients who have not had extensive, and that means for years, mental health treatment to diagnose and treat underlying issues first have very poor outcomes. In fact, too many patients who transition, having believed this would ‘cure’ gender dysphoria found that they felt just as dysphoric and even worsen then had significant medical issues for life.

I cannot believe any person who had any depth of understanding about these treatments would say just ‘google it’ .

ComeTheSpringLobelia · 11/02/2023 11:38

VestaTilley · 10/02/2023 21:26

YANBU. In 25 years time there’ll be the mother of all public scandals because thousands of gay, lesbian and autistic teens were sterilised and castrated.

And politicians will look all shocked and pretend they don’t know why. This is why. Feminists warned them, and they didn’t listen. I’m looking at you, Labour Party.

100% agree.

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:37

@RichardBarrister don't be so patronising. I don't have time right now to dig up evidence for a randomer on the Internet, but that doesn't mean the evidence isn't there.

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 11:34

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:28

There is no evidence to support the idea that children with gender dysphoria are any more likely to commit suicide than any other young person with mental health problems. In fact, the noteable suicides or sudden deaths have happened to the children taking cross sex hormones.

This is incorrect. Even a quick Google will tell you otherwise

The Tavistock clinic has stated this, it is the best information we have - google is not a reliable source.

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:32

@WinterTrees

As stated in my previous post, very few trans kids are actually accessing medical care in the uk. The waiting lists are years long.

Do you think these families should have support at all, such as counselling, until the young people are 18?

TheKeatingFive · 11/02/2023 11:32

I have no idea why anyone is comparing this to abortion.

Abortion practices are long standing, well researched and risk assessed. We haven't got a clue what long term implications 'gender reassignment' surgery brings with it.

Equally, abortion doesn't impact on life long fertility. As the article points out, how can any minor meaningfully consent to loss of fertility/impairment of sexual function for the rest of their lives? It's nothing short of criminal to let them do this.

WinterTrees · 11/02/2023 11:28

And what is this obsession with Trans people in general? Let people make decisions themselves about their own bodies. It's no one else's business.

I think this comment takes on a different perspective entirely if you substitute 'people' with the specific group we're talking about here. Children.

There's a good reason why the law says you can't get a tattoo under the age of 18. What seems like a fundamental part of your identity at 16 (that massive crush on Harry Styles, your K-pop fandom, the name of your first boy/girlfriend) will likely turn out to be something you leave behind as you discover the world and yourself.

We don't do children any favours at all if we don't put boundaries around what, as adults, we know may be something they will see differently as they mature. No matter how passionately they insist they won't and they'll love Harry Styles FOREVER and you're a big old meanie dinosaur who doesn't understand. If we turn a blind eye to the potential harms of unlicensed drugs, hormones and surgery on growing bodies and immature minds with a shrug and 'it's up to them, it's not my business', we are all complicit in the damage done to generation.

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:28

There is no evidence to support the idea that children with gender dysphoria are any more likely to commit suicide than any other young person with mental health problems. In fact, the noteable suicides or sudden deaths have happened to the children taking cross sex hormones.

This is incorrect. Even a quick Google will tell you otherwise

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 11:23

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:12

@EdgeOfACoin and also a lot at stake if I don't support him. Such as suicide.

As I’m sure you are aware, many organisations such as Mermaids and other trans charities have been caught coaching/advising children to threaten suicide if they are not allowed to socially or medically transition.

There is no evidence to support the idea that children with gender dysphoria are any more likely to commit suicide than any other young person with mental health problems. In fact, the noteable suicides or sudden deaths have happened to the children taking cross sex hormones.

I hope that helps you to rest more easy - obviously your priority is the safety of your child and I hope they can get access to proper open minded therapeutic support to explore any wider issues they may have that are driving their identity difficulties.

BlackForestCake · 11/02/2023 11:22

"We have NO long-term research on the impact on puberty blockers and hormone treatments on the body and brain. It doesn't exist."

Exactly. The likely effects of an abortion on the patient, good and bad, are well understood. We know much less about long term effects of medical "transition", and what we do know isn't good at all.

And yet people are saying its ok for teenagers to make these decisions, when we otherwise don't let them get a tattoo.

BlackForestCake · 11/02/2023 11:18

"If there was more support, counselling and discussion before gender affirming medical treatment and procedures, young people could be supported to make an informed choice which is right for them as an individual."

Uh yes, but that is now called "conversion therapy" and people are campaigning for it to be banned.

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 11:15

I believe that the reason some people detransition is the lack of support for young people, not too much of it. If there was more support, counselling and discussion before gender affirming medical treatment and procedures, young people could be supported to make an informed choice which is right for them as an individual.

Exactly. Children and vulnerable young adults are being allowed to rush into making these decisions and self diagnosis is blindly accepted without adequate support or questioning.

In fact, the recent proposed law on change on Conversion Therapy would outlaw any exploration of whether social or medical transition is right for the patient or whether an alternative, non trans solution would be more appropriate.

Doctors and psychologists (and parents) will have to unquestioningly accept the self diagnosis of a young person in a mental health crisis who may have been groomed by trans activists, online or in schools, to think they are trans.

They are very likely to turn out to be gay or autistic and not trans at all (people with autism tend to latch onto simple solutions for feelings of ‘difference’ and are disproportionately likely to be referred to a gender clinic - this needs urgent investigation) but because there is inadequate exploration before they jump into medical intervention from places like Gendergp and other private or NHS clinics, there is huge risk of getting it wrong.

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:12

@EdgeOfACoin and also a lot at stake if I don't support him. Such as suicide.

EdgeOfACoin · 11/02/2023 11:07

I would say I'm more qualified to say than many, as the parent of a trans 18 year old.

So there's an awful lot at stake if it turns out some years down the line that gender affirmation for your child was not the correct path.

Burgoo · 11/02/2023 11:05

@Meaningofthesea "The writer is not a doctor, psychologist.psychiatrist or reasearcher and did not have direct experience with patients. She advocates stopping gender affirming care for trans youth - something that would result in real harm to this population."

Nonsense. The "harm" is the distress these young people experience as a result of their psychological state. Would you tell an anorexic person that if they think they are fat then they are? That if they want to stop eating because of that belief that then is okay?

What we need is evidence based psychological treatments for trans children so that they can accept and tolerate the fact that they feel disconnected and in the wrong gender.

We need to stop this nonsense that non-affirmation leads to suicide. That isn't true. The psychological condition makes trans people more likely to experience misery that leads to suicide. Is society non-acceptance a factor? Sure. But that doesn't mean they haven't got a psychological problem.

As I said I am actually pro trans rights. And at the same time I can't patronisingly agree with - what is essentially - a body dysmorphic illness.

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 11:05

newnamefortodays · 11/02/2023 10:47

I think so actually, yes. People have cosmetic surgery that’s completely unnecessary and carries risk, and are allowed to do so.

Wow! Thankfully medical ethics does not agree with you. The Hippocratic oath says ‘first do no harm’

A doctor who was performing unnecessary leg amputations on patients with a mental illness (j would say that by definition, wanting to remove healthy body parts is a form of mental illness) was made to stop.

Sadly these days the Hippocratic oath is not applicable to people who have mental health issues around identity and self image and people are being harmed. There is a world of difference between making minor alterations to a nose or breast implants and entirely removing breasts or a penis or uterus and ovaries.

It is well known that doctors make women who want a hysterectomy wait until after they are 30/35 because they might change their mind about wanting more children. Adopt a trans identity and you can do it at 18. That doesn’t make any sense.

Burgoo · 11/02/2023 11:01

Firstly I want to be transparent - I am pro trans rights, as a rule.

That said, I think we are doing HUGE damage to these young people which in decades time will be looked at with horror. There are a few key issues here:

  1. We have NO long-term research on the impact on puberty blockers and hormone treatments on the body and brain. It doesn't exist.

  2. Unlike homosexuality (which was a mental disorder but declassified), I believe transgenderism is a psychological problem that needs investment and treatment. Being gay was often distressing because society demonised gay people for decades. Trans folk feel an inherent discomfort in their own bodies - similar to those with anorexia or body dysmorphia. Would we affirm to an anorexic child that they are fat and need to lose weight? Of course not. What is the difference?

  3. Social contagion which has ALOT of evidence. I don't buy that there has been a (something like) 5000% increase in referrals to gender services in the past decade, simply because more trans people can come out. But when you start talking about being able to "choose" your gender in schools, to impressionable young people, you sow the seeds of doubt.

  4. I was an effeminate boy, into dolls etc. I turned out to be gay (then bisexual, don't ask!) Had I had this option I may well have thought I was a girl and I wouldn't need responsible adults affirming that to me.

  5. The pattern of people with autism, anorexia and personality disorder being disproportionately trans is completely ignored. This is astounding. All three have a disordered sense of self (or an inability to form relationships/feeling disconnected from society). Yet nobody is willing to raise this as an issue.

If you are an adult you can make all the decisions you want. Fine. For children though, lets watchfully wait and not jump into affirmation.

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 10:56

Sorry about the large gap in the post..

C8H10N4O2 · 11/02/2023 10:55

Many years ago I had Mermaids in as part of a series on diversity (for which I was sponsor at the time). They did a good presentation about how to provide accepting care (as opposed to affirming care) and the importance of accepting and leaving all doors open. Their position then was that most children experiencing feelings of gender dysphoria would likely settle into gay or bisexual orientation or simply be gender non conforming but settled into their own sex. This was before Susie Green took over.

A few years later considering having them back the position had completely changed - it was all affirmative and promoting early medication, breaching all safeguarding rules by excluding parents from the discussion etc. The whole focus was shifted. Anyone even wanting to do research on methodologies and longitudinal studies was a heretic under #nodebate. We didn't have them back.

The problem is when ideology trumps evidence and compassion the main victims are the very people the ideology claims to help.

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 10:55

I would say I'm more qualified to say than many, as the parent of a trans 18 year old.

There is one NHS clinic in the uk which treats children and young people. This is currently closing and restructuring. There are thousands on the waiting list, most of whom never get to the top before they are 18. CAMHS has a gender pathway, for which my son waited from the age of 14, and never got seen, and has now been discharged from CAMHS as he turned 18.

The services to support gender questioning and trans young people are grossly inadequate, which has resulted in the rise in private practice such as gender gp.

I believe that the reason some people detransition is the lack of support for young people, not too much of it. If there was more support, counselling and discussion before gender affirming medical treatment and procedures, young people could be supported to make an informed choice which is right for them as an individual.

abcdeg · 11/02/2023 10:53

she repeats this odd assertion that autistic people don't know themselves well enough to be truly lgbt

LGB is not the same as T.

Meaningofthesea · 11/02/2023 10:51

Out of the thousand or so patients she has seen, she only references a half dozen specific anecdotes of poor experiences for transgender youth patients (you'll note that, despite these, the trans patients continue to identify as trans). She leaves out the stories of what must be the rest of the thousand patients who saw their mental and physical health improve dramatically.

The writer is not a doctor, psychologist.psychiatrist or reasearcher and did not have direct experience with patients. She advocates stopping gender affirming care for trans youth - something that would result in real harm to this population.

the author of the piece feels the origin of people's dysphoria just about anything else except being trans, even including obesity ( if you took a random sample of American teens, I'm fairly sure at least some would fall into this category)

she repeats this odd assertion that autistic people don't know themselves well enough to be truly lgbt

Bicalutamide is used to treat “metastatic prostate cancer.” Bicalutamide is also used to treat hair loss and excessive facial hair in women. The outrage!

The author cites one detransitioner (out of thousands the clinic saw).

So you've made your little mumsnet thread, all the self -identified 'vipers' will come and affirm your view, some people will reply to me aghast that surely one detransitioner is one too many, and hardly anyone will consider the fact that gender-affirming care saves lives. (And yes, I do think it's right that age-limits in UK are more stringent than in the us)

newnamefortodays · 11/02/2023 10:47

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 10:45

Should people ever have bodily autonomy that allows them to amputate healthy body parts and take non medically necessary drugs that are known to cause serious harm to health?

I think so actually, yes. People have cosmetic surgery that’s completely unnecessary and carries risk, and are allowed to do so.