Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'gender affirming care" is barbaric and should be banned?

211 replies

Appalonia · 10/02/2023 21:12

This article is from the US but these procedures have been carried out in the UK. Teenagers who are confused and vulnerable do not have the mental capacity to consent to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or life altering surgery.

Please read this devastating article from a whistleblower who has been working in a gender clinic in the US.

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 11/02/2023 15:54

I am posting this because this was a study that was much lauded at publication as proof that surgery improved mental health. There really is so much misinformation out there. Please note readers, the conclusion was retracted and corrected to say there was no proof of improvement.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31581798/

Reduction in Mental Health Treatment Utilization Among Transgender Individuals After Gender-Affirming Surgeries: A Total Population Study


Branstrom & Pachankis (Aug 2020)


And Pachankis is a professor from Yale, caught out drawing conclusions where the evidence was so weak they had to retract.

I don’t believe that there has been any study released to change this outcome.

i am very happy to see any new studies though.

FOJN · 11/02/2023 14:45

Gender dysphoria kids commit suicide when they don't feel accepted by people around them.

This is an analysis of the available evidence on suicide and self harm risk in gender questioning children.

www.transgendertrend.com/the-suicide-myth/

This link outlines who Transgender Trend are and what they aim to achieve. I'm seeing a group of concerned adults asking for a robust evidence base for gender affirming medical intervention. No hate here.

www.transgendertrend.com/transgender-trend-constitution/

Here are more links to resources and support for parents trying to navigate their way through supporting a gender distressed child. Again there is no hate, just desperately worried parents trying to do their best for their children.

4thwavenow.com/

www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/about_us/

CampervanKween · 11/02/2023 13:37

It's a social contagion at the moment. I see signs that the younger cohort might not be as interested which is hopeful. Imagine thinking that you have to sterilise your healthy body, take life long health damaging wrong sex hormones 🤔

The only people to benefit are the plastic surgeons and the drug companies.

These people are also making themselves incredibly niche in terms of future life partners. Just making their future lives more difficult in every way for no reason.

Tessabelle74 · 11/02/2023 13:32

@Meaningofthesea 13 year olds ANYWHERE shouldn't be making those decisions, I must have missed where I specified a country in my comment?

abcdeg · 11/02/2023 13:23

Yep, also abortion counselling isn't supposed to affirm either way, is it? It's meant to be objective not push you to terminate or have a baby

If abortion clinics/counsellors did that, then it would be criticised equally.

Unexpected pregnancy isn't something you can do nothing about, you have to make a choice. But nobody has to transition. Whereas a baby will be born if you don't make up your mind.

Naunet · 11/02/2023 13:13

newnamefortodays · 11/02/2023 10:24

Ignoring the fact this is about trans people, at what age does someone have bodily autonomy? Do teenage girls have the mental capacity to choose to have an abortion (or not) if they later go on to regret their choice? FWIW I don’t think anyone under the age of 18 should be having these surgeries, but they’re both optional procedures, so I don’t know how one is justified and the other isn’t?

You can’t see the difference?! Really?

Let me help, having a baby is a far, far bigger deal than having an abortion, the choice is not, continue living life as you were, or have an abortion. Child birth also presents its own risks and potential life long changes, so abortion is the less radical option if anything.

Not only that, but an abortion doesn’t put you on a dangerous medical pathway that you could be on for the rest of your life. It does not take away your choice to have children in the future, it does not leave you without any sexual function, it doesn’t leave you with irreversible changes to your body.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 11/02/2023 13:05

Dysphoria is a mental illness.
Affirmation, drugs and surgery will not cure it.

It is often an unhealthy coping mechanism for childhood trauma or poor mental health.

The majority of teens will grow out of it when their body and brain matures. Affirming the impossible is not the healthy option and does not get to, or treat the causes of their mental distress.

The only difference between anorexia and 'gender' dysphoria is a multi billion dollar a year gravy train that encourages, celebrates and takes advantage of vulnerable people.

What EXACTLY is 'gender'?

There is no magic inner gender essence.
No one is born in the wrong body.
No one can change sex.

Allowing children to permanently damage their perfectly healthy body because of poor mental health or because they don't fit into the rigid sex role stereotypes, which are being imposed by gender ideology fanatics, is child abuse.

I have no idea why anyone is comparing this to abortion

Forced teaming.

Like adding the T and Q the the LGB and pretending they are the same.

Or men telling women that wanting single sex facilities is the same as apartheid.

Or pretending mentally vulnerable teenage girls who suddenly hate their body have anything in common with cross dressing grown men or AGP'S. Most of whom keep their fully functioning sex organs whilst encouraging teenagers to become sexless and sterile adults.

All because of a feelings based new religion.

If we were told that scientology must be taught in schools as fact, and any non believers must be shunned, punished and sacked, their would be uproar.
Yet pushing a homophobic, misogynistic, nonsense, subjective feelings based religion with ever changing rules and increasingly absurd demands is somehow accepted? Why?

Because it's about men's sex rights and money. The removal of female boundaries, protections and child safeguarding.

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 12:44

Meaningofthesea · 11/02/2023 12:17

Good job, then, that in the UK no 'life altering' decisions are being made by 13, or 14, or 15 year olds

I understand where you are coming from, this is such a bad situation that many people understandably experience disbelief and don’t want to admit that it is happening.

We trust our medical profession to provide appropriate care that will not cause unnecessary harm but in too many cases that trust is misplaced.

This is happening.

Thanks to the major efforts of the trans activists in suppressing research there is very little data and proper numbers available but we do know that it is too many and rising.

In the GMC hearing when Dr Webberley, owner of Gendergp was struck off, evidence was presented where they were prescribing puberty blockers and cross sexual hormones to children as young as 9. This was with minimal assessment, little monitoring and utterly inadequate record keeping. They have thousands of patients on their books - not all minors but they do target marketing at children and young people.

They have been found to prescribe cross sex hormones to minors (15) without the knowledge of their parents. They have deliberately structured the business to evade UK regulation and rules on prescribing and are now looking to expand their market by recruiting Susie Green from trans charity Mermaids (currently under investigation for major safeguarding failures).

As I said in my previous post, Gendergp are expanding a fund to pay for more children and young people to pay for puberty blockers and cross sex hormones.

There are many private clinics throughout the UK who are very busy with trans medication and surgery. Crowd funding is a common route and there seem to be a lot of middle class families and friends who are happy to donate.

midgemadgemodge · 11/02/2023 12:23

Please read through the typos / autocorrect madness there - double negative is not intended for example

midgemadgemodge · 11/02/2023 12:22

So no 14 or 15 year old has ever been put in puberty blockers ?

No 14 or 15 year old has never been socially transitioned ?

Both "treatments" that seem to reinforce the need to fully transition rather than help them cope

Hardly surprising really - you can't change sex so any milder "treatment " will be unsatisfactory, but will reinforce the idea that meaningful change is possible

Toomanywaterwipes · 11/02/2023 12:22

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 10:28

Just to clear things up, it's next to impossible to get support let alone any form of treatment for trans kids in the UK.

And what is this obsession with Trans people in general? Let people make decisions themselves about their own bodies. It's no one else's business.

I strongly disagree.

It's the parents business too if the person involved is underage.

Meaningofthesea · 11/02/2023 12:17

Tessabelle74 · 11/02/2023 12:12

Most 13 year olds don't know any they want for lunch at school tomorrow so allowing them to make life altering decisions seems crazy to me!

Good job, then, that in the UK no 'life altering' decisions are being made by 13, or 14, or 15 year olds

Tessabelle74 · 11/02/2023 12:12

Most 13 year olds don't know any they want for lunch at school tomorrow so allowing them to make life altering decisions seems crazy to me!

Helleofabore · 11/02/2023 12:05

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:42

Gender dysphoria kids commit suicide when they don't feel accepted by people around them. Banning gender affirming care is not a solution to people being trans.

Why is there so much hatred towards trans people? This is the problem.

“Gender dysphoria kids commit suicide when they don't feel accepted by people around them.”

There is absolutely no evidence that this is more prevalent than any other group of ‘kids’ with poor mental health. Please stop spreading fear and misinformation. The situation is much more complex than this sentence indicates.

”Banning gender affirming care is not a solution to people being trans.”

Who is ‘banning’ gender affirming care? Clinicians and governments are preventing experimental treatments from being given to children and teenagers who cannot understand the full implications of the treatment.

There are other treatment plans that are available that are not hormonal or surgical. In fact, the authors of the Dutch Protocol have publicly stated that even their treatment or extensive mental health care first is not suitable for the current cohort of teenaged female patients. And it is also clear that their treatment plan has been cherry picked even for male patients- and the extensive mental health treatment is either skipped in most part or wholly.

”Why is there so much hatred towards trans people?”

There are many people who regularly post on this topic have loved ones who are have declared trans identities. You are now resorting to ridiculous hyperbole to try to frame people who are widely read about this topic (and for personal reasons) as haters.

This is a very familiar tactic to emotionally manipulate people when there is no evidence that can be presented.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 12:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

abcdeg · 11/02/2023 11:58

Anybody who is suicidal should be seeking unbiased mental health services immediately not making life-altering, changes to their body

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 11:56

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:28

There is no evidence to support the idea that children with gender dysphoria are any more likely to commit suicide than any other young person with mental health problems. In fact, the noteable suicides or sudden deaths have happened to the children taking cross sex hormones.

This is incorrect. Even a quick Google will tell you otherwise

You are the one who is incorrect. You should educate yourself before gullibly believing all the lies and manipulations you've been told. www.transgendertrend.com/the-suicide-myth/

Abhannmor · 11/02/2023 11:52

Ridelikethewindypops · 11/02/2023 09:49

m.independent.ie/irish-news/health/irish-gender-affirmation-surgeon-based-in-florida-is-reported-over-false-promotion-in-tiktoks-42051361.html

This is a doctor I came across having seen her name mentioned on threads here.
Worryingly blasé attitude to the harm she is doing.

My least favourite fellow Irish person - and there's some stiff competition. Sidhbh lures vulnerable youngsters with her chatty upbeat videos. Or Scythe as some call her.

Then there is Johanna Olsen Kennedy who has done more 'gender reassignments' than even Scythe. She moans about patients having psychological assessments before she can get to them.

'After all if I was putting someone on insulin I wouldn't have to send him for therapy first ' she said. I hope they are saving some of that lovely lolly for the lawsuits.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 11/02/2023 11:51

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:12

@EdgeOfACoin and also a lot at stake if I don't support him. Such as suicide.

The lie that trans people are more likely to suicide if not supported has been debunked time and time and time again. It simply is not true. In deed and in fact, trans people are more likely to suicide POST surgery. When reality hits that surgery solved nothing for them and didn't make them feel better.

Regardless, the 'I'll suicide if you don't confirm my mental illness' is suicide ideation and is considered emotional manipulation which no psychologist recommends you fall for. Interestingly, it's used mostly by male to female trans people, and it's typical Male Pattern manipulation. "If you dare leave me, I'll kill myself" is the same thing. It's simply a symptom of Male Pattern violence and coercion and should never be validated. Also you wouldn't say to an anorexic girl who is skin and bones with hip bones protruding through the skin "yes dear, you are fat" in case they commit suicide. So why is an emotionally manipulative male posing as a female any different?

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 11:51

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:37

@RichardBarrister don't be so patronising. I don't have time right now to dig up evidence for a randomer on the Internet, but that doesn't mean the evidence isn't there.

How am I being patronising? I have told you what the research carried out by the Tavistock.

As you pointed out, it is the UK’s only gender clinic for children. Their research in many aspects of this has been woeful for some reason but they were very clear that there was no excess risk of suicide in their patients compared with other children with mental health problems.

I thought that would be good news?

It is important to be aware that there are many activist doctors and research organisations, especially in the US who have a financial or ideological interest in perpetuating the lie about suicide stats. It is utterly abhorrent that they are using this as a lever to force worried parents to agree to giving drugs to their kids that will sterilise and ruin their health.

Btw the trans medication market has expanded from being worth $millions in the 90s to $billions now. There is a proliferation of gender clinics across the developed world and they make a lot of money.

RinklyRomaine · 11/02/2023 11:51

Framing concern for children, especially girls in a porn soaked society; those with comorbidities such as AN and autistic traits as hate for trans people is disingenuous at best and extremely manipulative at worst. The suicide stats have absolutely been debunked, and there are now studies showing that actually, rates are higher amongst those who have gone through 'treatment', because changing one's body to fit a mental issue is NOT the answer for many, many young people. All you have to do is look at issues with people like Jazz Jennings who was clearly transitioned by horrible, homophobic parents. A simple affirmation is just not good enough.

These children absolutely need to be treated, but with gentle care and understanding, not drugs and surgeries.

TheKeatingFive · 11/02/2023 11:46

Gender dysphoria kids commit suicide when they don't feel accepted by people around them.

That's a big bold statement. Where's your extensive research to back that up?

Banning gender affirming care is not a solution to people being trans.

Gender affirming care is highly experimental and poorly understood. Don't you think children struggling with their gender deserve some basic risk assessment and understanding of long term consequences?

Why is there so much hatred towards trans people?

Honestly, I'm beginning to think it's the TRA side that hate gender questioning children. You're using them as unconsenting Guinea pigs

ComeTheSpringLobelia · 11/02/2023 11:44

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:42

Gender dysphoria kids commit suicide when they don't feel accepted by people around them. Banning gender affirming care is not a solution to people being trans.

Why is there so much hatred towards trans people? This is the problem.

No hatred on this thread that I can see. Just serious genuine concern about the wellbeing and safeguarding of children.

WinterTrees · 11/02/2023 11:43

Shardonneigghhh · 11/02/2023 11:32

@WinterTrees

As stated in my previous post, very few trans kids are actually accessing medical care in the uk. The waiting lists are years long.

Do you think these families should have support at all, such as counselling, until the young people are 18?

OF COURSE. Absolutely. We need a massive investment in counselling for young people with all kinds of mental health issues. (Having trodden the woeful, distressing and ultimately useless CAMHS path with my teen I am very well aware of how inadequate this currently is.)

But, we need this support to be explorative, not merely affirmative. Trans rights activists, many politicians and charities such as Mermaids are trying to tag such care as 'conversion therapy' and ensure that it's banned.

TheKeatingFive · 11/02/2023 11:42

Even if the suicide claims are true (they aren't) since when have we ever thought that the answer to feeling suicidal is pushing people into highly experimental surgery, the outcomes of which we barely understand?

That's just crackpot

Swipe left for the next trending thread