Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'gender affirming care" is barbaric and should be banned?

211 replies

Appalonia · 10/02/2023 21:12

This article is from the US but these procedures have been carried out in the UK. Teenagers who are confused and vulnerable do not have the mental capacity to consent to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or life altering surgery.

Please read this devastating article from a whistleblower who has been working in a gender clinic in the US.

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:22

I think it becomes quite clear that some people who are heavily invested in pushing for affirming only treatments use the tactic of using polarised cognitive distortions and misrepresentations in discussion to support their argument. Without the emotional manipulation, the science and the evidence doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:21

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:18

So you think we should section anyone who wants to have gender-affirming medical interventions?

I didn't say that. You did. But I think people do need to be supported to take care of themselves and be supported to make sure the decisions they make, that will impact the rest of their lives, are the right ones. There's no going back from extreme body modification.

Surprised anyone would think otherwise really. There's probably some weird fucked up reason for that.

I didn’t say that- you said being trans and seeking interventions was comparable to anorexia. It isn’t. we section people for anorexia (to prevent them dying), but realise it would be completely wrong to do that to a trans person seeking gender affirming treatment. They aren’t remotely the same, and you apparently understand that too.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:19

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:15

yes, I’ve read it many times.

So you disagree with Dr Hilary Cass? Do you believe that social transitioning a child or a teen is a ‘neutral’ act?

If you disagree with her, why?

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:18

Already answered that one. Read and digest it.

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:18

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:13

It's not about persuading people to be 'normal'. It's about getting them to understand and accept their physical reality, to be who they want, and dress how they want, but not damage their healthy bodies in pursuit of this.

Why should they have to “accept physical reality” when there are treatments available to help. Or do you say that to anyone asking for medical help/ treatment/ interventions ? Sorry, no help for you, how about some “therapy” to help you accept your physical reality.

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:18

So you think we should section anyone who wants to have gender-affirming medical interventions?

I didn't say that. You did. But I think people do need to be supported to take care of themselves and be supported to make sure the decisions they make, that will impact the rest of their lives, are the right ones. There's no going back from extreme body modification.

Surprised anyone would think otherwise really. There's probably some weird fucked up reason for that.

BravoWhisky · 12/02/2023 10:18

Lead story in the Times today

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/e04f4958-aa26-11ed-8a03-b2faadede0c5?shareToken=81bddfc85342137edc81797069ccd8cb

This is a scandal and those clinicians and politicians responsible should be in jail.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:17

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:11

By “open exploratory therapy” , you mean conversion therapy to try persuade them to be normal because people like you don’t like it otherwise.

That you posted this shows that really have a deep prejudice about what others are saying. You keep framing words to be the worst, bad faith interpretation.

The authors of the ‘Dutch Protocol’ were very specific that extensive exploratory therapy was done before transition. Are you saying those clinicians were wrong?

Redebs · 12/02/2023 10:16

VestaTilley · 10/02/2023 21:26

YANBU. In 25 years time there’ll be the mother of all public scandals because thousands of gay, lesbian and autistic teens were sterilised and castrated.

And politicians will look all shocked and pretend they don’t know why. This is why. Feminists warned them, and they didn’t listen. I’m looking at you, Labour Party.

Absolutely so

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:15

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:13

Did you read the Cass report posted for you to read on another thread?

I am very happy to post the link again.

yes, I’ve read it many times.

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:13

It's not about persuading people to be 'normal'. It's about getting them to understand and accept their physical reality, to be who they want, and dress how they want, but not damage their healthy bodies in pursuit of this.

Ohheckethump · 12/02/2023 10:13

By “open exploratory therapy” , you mean conversion therapy to try persuade them to be normal because people like you don’t like it otherwise.

How is talking about their feelings of gender dysphoria, their history & being honest about transition conversion therapy?

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:13

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:06

Both "treatments" that seem to reinforce the need to fully transition rather than help them cope

you have no idea what you are talking about.
and social transition isn’t a “treatment” it’s just allowing kids to dress and be called what they want. Or do you think anyone born with a vagina should be forced to wear pink dresses until the age of 18 ?

Did you read the Cass report posted for you to read on another thread?

I am very happy to post the link again.

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:12

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:10

Medical transition can and does cause serious harm to people's bodies. I think anorexia is very comparable. Emotionally and physically.

So you think we should section anyone who wants to have gender-affirming medical interventions?

Cool.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:12

C4tintherug · 12/02/2023 10:03

My daughter (now recovered) suffered from anorexia. We had to FORCE her to eat 6 x a day. She would regularly threaten suicide because of this. She took overdoses, she self harmed, she threatened to jump out the window, she ran away. We had to manhandle her into the car to appointments and she would scream at the public that we were child abusers. She would tell people that there was no difference between us forcing her to eat and her being raped.
All because we would not affirm her delusion that she didn’t need to eat.

Thankfully we are the other side of the worst of this, but imagine if we had just affirmed her anorexia? All because she threatened suicide?

Flowers

The suicide issue is not that these children and teens are not feeling that way, but are they more prone than others with mental health distress? Clinicians have said this is not the case. And as you rightly say, what other conditions are affirming only when to do so causes great harm to healthy bodies and creates life long medical patients?

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:11

RichardBarrister · 11/02/2023 11:42

They are though. There might not be many doing it on the NHS but as I pointed out, there are many other avenues and growing amounts of funding to facilitate it. Unfortunately the funding is only for ‘affirmative care’ which consists of affirming the self diagnosis of the child and starting them on puberty blockers or cross sex hormones. It does not fund and proper exploratory therapy to uncover the root causes of the distress which frequently out to be issues such as bullying or sexual abuse and completely not requiring any transition as a solution. This is dangerous for children and young people.

I absolutely agree that there should be far better mental health provision for all distressed young people and people open exploratory therapy to help the individual understand their issues.

I hope that you will join the campaign to ask the government not to make this exploratory therapy illegal by calling it ‘gender identity’ Conversion Therapy.

By “open exploratory therapy” , you mean conversion therapy to try persuade them to be normal because people like you don’t like it otherwise.

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:10

Medical transition can and does cause serious harm to people's bodies. I think anorexia is very comparable. Emotionally and physically.

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:08

C4tintherug · 12/02/2023 10:03

My daughter (now recovered) suffered from anorexia. We had to FORCE her to eat 6 x a day. She would regularly threaten suicide because of this. She took overdoses, she self harmed, she threatened to jump out the window, she ran away. We had to manhandle her into the car to appointments and she would scream at the public that we were child abusers. She would tell people that there was no difference between us forcing her to eat and her being raped.
All because we would not affirm her delusion that she didn’t need to eat.

Thankfully we are the other side of the worst of this, but imagine if we had just affirmed her anorexia? All because she threatened suicide?

Being transgender is not comparable to being anorexic . Being trans doesn’t kill you or make you sick. Trans people can live happy, healthy and fulfilling lives .

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:06

midgemadgemodge · 11/02/2023 12:22

So no 14 or 15 year old has ever been put in puberty blockers ?

No 14 or 15 year old has never been socially transitioned ?

Both "treatments" that seem to reinforce the need to fully transition rather than help them cope

Hardly surprising really - you can't change sex so any milder "treatment " will be unsatisfactory, but will reinforce the idea that meaningful change is possible

Both "treatments" that seem to reinforce the need to fully transition rather than help them cope

you have no idea what you are talking about.
and social transition isn’t a “treatment” it’s just allowing kids to dress and be called what they want. Or do you think anyone born with a vagina should be forced to wear pink dresses until the age of 18 ?

BlackeyedSusan · 12/02/2023 10:05

VestaTilley · 10/02/2023 21:26

YANBU. In 25 years time there’ll be the mother of all public scandals because thousands of gay, lesbian and autistic teens were sterilised and castrated.

And politicians will look all shocked and pretend they don’t know why. This is why. Feminists warned them, and they didn’t listen. I’m looking at you, Labour Party.

This.

I am particularly angry at the targeting of autistic girls. Having been one and having a daughter who is one.

C4tintherug · 12/02/2023 10:03

My daughter (now recovered) suffered from anorexia. We had to FORCE her to eat 6 x a day. She would regularly threaten suicide because of this. She took overdoses, she self harmed, she threatened to jump out the window, she ran away. We had to manhandle her into the car to appointments and she would scream at the public that we were child abusers. She would tell people that there was no difference between us forcing her to eat and her being raped.
All because we would not affirm her delusion that she didn’t need to eat.

Thankfully we are the other side of the worst of this, but imagine if we had just affirmed her anorexia? All because she threatened suicide?

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 09:32

And here we have a book from an investigative journalist employed by the BBC about the many issues with the Tavistock and GIDS.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/f38ca170-a236-11ed-9d5c-69bd3c5b98b3?shareToken=08c87b70474a5200b2d70b4b1cd67574

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 09:30

Sorry for the format fails there.

This is the first link

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5580378/

Effects of Medical Interventions on Gender Dysphoria and Body Image: A Follow-Up Study

and this is the second link

www.mdpi.com/2227-9032/10/1/121/htm

Care of Transgender Patients: A General Practice Quality Improvement Approach

And the points I wanted to highlight for this paper were :

-the number of patients with underlying mental health issues. And how they are being completely let down by affirming only treatment.


-The number of visits before receiving hormones was 2.7 appointments.

-67 patients average age 27.8 years -range was 12- 54
-42 females, 22 males, four NB (3 f / 1 m)
-Female mean age is 18 years, male 23 years.
-Out of the 67, only 9 (13%) had NO mental health diagnosis. 10 (15%) had diagnosed ASD, 4 with ADHD (6%), 3 (4%) with OCD, 1 with Bipolar, 7 (10%) with a Personality Disorder. 13 (19%) had documented childhood abuse, neglect or violence.


-the rate of detransition amongst those who had received at least hormones was 9.8%.

This is in line with the European study which showed a long term detransition rate of medicalised transitioners of males 8.8% and females 8.3%.

My point being, when data is scrutinised in studies and reviews that are not specifically designed to discover detransition rates, the numbers before the massive increase in young female patients were already showing signs of being between 8- 10% .

The massive increase in detransitioners raising their hands and wanting to be counted and have their voices heard is an indication that the narrative of ‘there is so few’ is false and is being clung to to prop up groups pushing through affirming only treatment plans.

If the true figure can be considered 8-10% detransition after medicalised treatment, are any posters who are fully in support of affirming only treatments happy with a collateral rate of 10% of people who detransition?

Are people who use the suicide argument fully comfortable that 8-10% of patients have to live with the decision they made that will likely cause them significant health issues. Life shortening one’s.

I don’t believe one person on this thread would not support extensive mental health support and screening. It is the hormones and the surgeries that are the significant issues.

In saying that, even social transitioning a child or teen is not a neutral act and one Dr Hilary Cass warns should not be treated as not potentially causing harm.

Helleofabore · 11/02/2023 16:26

Here are some interesting studies which looked at transgender patient’s health which also highlight detransition rates .

//www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5580378/

135 natal males (119 living in the female role, 12 in the male role, 4 did not report their current gender role) and 66 natal females (60 living in the male role, 5 in the female role, 1 did not report a current gender role)

So... 8.88% of males and 8.33% of the females (this does not include those who did not answer the question which if the answer was to detransition would make these figures higher). And in Figure 3. 22.2% of those who socially transitioned, detransitioned

This study does not even include the current cohort of young female transitioners.

And this paper is interesting too.

www.mdpi.com/2227-9032/10/1/121/htm

A few things stand out.


  •   the number of patients with underlying mental health issues. And how they are being completely let down by affirming only treatment.
    



-The number of visits before receiving hormones was 2.7 appointments.


-67 patients average age 27.8 years -range was 12- 54
-42 females, 22 males, four NB (3 f / 1 m)
-Female mean age is 18 years, male 23 years.
-Out of the 67, only 9 (13%) had NO mental health diagnosis. 10 (15%) had diagnosed ASD, 4 with ADHD (6%), 3 (4%) with OCD, 1 with Bipolar, 7 (10%) with a Personality Disorder. 13 (19%) had documented childhood abuse, neglect or violence.


  •   the rate of detransition amongst those who had received at least hormones was 9.8%. This is in line with the European study which showed a long term detransition rate of medicalised transitioners of males 8.8% and females 8.3%.

    

From this study


Nine patients had stopped hormone therapy; one related to practice policy because they had not attended any GIC follow-up (the patient has restarted since the audit). Thus, eight patients had stopped hormones voluntarily (20% stopping rate; six trans men, two trans women).

Those posters minimising the detransition rates are looking at biased reports from lobby groups that seem overly invested in also minimising detransition rates.

When discussing rates of regret, that is a whole other issue. Because the reality is only just being realised.

It took up to two decades for the number of women to have accumulated enough to have been acknowledged who suffered significant life limiting and shortening effects from lupron use. The effects are still not widely publicised. The long term impacts will not show for years, but the signs are already there in the detransitioner recounting their stories.

Appalonia · 11/02/2023 16:07

And yet another story of a life devastated by this:
thefederalist.com/2023/02/10/detransitioners-are-being-abandoned-by-medical-professionals-who-devastated-their-bodies-and-minds/

OP posts: