Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'gender affirming care" is barbaric and should be banned?

211 replies

Appalonia · 10/02/2023 21:12

This article is from the US but these procedures have been carried out in the UK. Teenagers who are confused and vulnerable do not have the mental capacity to consent to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or life altering surgery.

Please read this devastating article from a whistleblower who has been working in a gender clinic in the US.

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 12:08

This post is long but it is worth reading.

It is a paper about how parents and children’s predetermined expectations are impacting the quality of care given by clinicians.

It supports this negative framing of exploratory therapy as ‘conversion therapy’, when it is this negative framing that is causing significant detriment to young patients.

Australian children and adolescents with gender dysphoria: Clinical presentations and challenges experienced by a multidisciplinary team and gender service

Published April 22, 2021
Kasia Kozlowska, Georgia McClure et al

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/26344041211010777

Our study found that the children and families who came to the clinic had clear, preformed expectations: most often, children and families wanted a diagnosis of gender dysphoria to be provided or confirmed, together with referral to endocrinology services to pursue medical treatment of gender dysphoria. Parents (vs. children) also largely came with the same expectations, though they were more likely to be interested in incorporating holistic (biopsychosocial) elements, including treatment of mental health comorbidities, family support/therapy, and long-term psychotherapy for the child. It was our impression that these expectations had been shaped by the dominant sociopolitical discourse—the gender affirmative model. It will be interesting to track the expectations of children and families in the years to come as sociopolitical discourses become more varied and diverse and as the voices are heard of both those who have done well and those who not done well via the medical pathway.

Our study also found that despite the high rates of family conflict, relationship breakdowns, parental mental illness, and maltreatment (see Table 3)—and our own clinical perspective that both individual and family work were indicated for the majority of families—few families rated themselves as being in a clinically severe range on self-report (SCORE-15). Coupled with the dominant sociopolitical discourse—the gender affirmative model that prioritizes the medical treatment pathway—it is not surprising that the large majority of children and families were not motivated to engage in or to remain engaged in ongoing therapy. These data bring three important phenomena into focus.

First, when children and families were given the space and structure to tell the child’s developmental story—nested in the story of the family—they were able to identify and provide a detailed narrative of the key issues that had contributed to the child’s presentation and distress. Without this space and structure, the issues remain undeclared and unaddressed.

Second, some families—but also some clinicians—function within a non-holistic (non-biopsychosocial) framework where the child’s developmental experiences are disconnected from their clinical presentation. This non-holistic framework is likely to promote a healthcare delivery model that dehumanizes the child (by not examining the child’s and family’s lived experience) and that promotes medical solutions (correcting the identity/body mismatch) for a problem that is much more complex.

Third, as noted earlier, our experience suggests that, insofar as the gender affirmative model is taken as equivalent to medical intervention, clinicians (including ourselves) who work in gender services are coming under increasing pressure to put aside their own holistic (biopsychosocial) model of care, and to compromise their own ethical standards, by engaging in a tick-the-box treatment process. Such an approach does not adequately address a broad range of psychological, family, and social issues and puts patients at risk of adverse future outcomes and clinicians at risk of future legal action.

Relevant bits:

It was our impression that these expectations had been shaped by the dominant sociopolitical discourse—the gender affirmative model.

Coupled with the dominant sociopolitical discourse—the gender affirmative model that prioritizes the medical treatment pathway—it is not surprising that the large majority of children and families were not motivated to engage in or to remain engaged in ongoing therapy.

and the final three paragraphs.

So I ask again, who benefits from the negative misrepresentation of exploratory therapy as ‘conversion therapy’?

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 11:48

Here is something I found from Dr Steensma and team. It is quite old now, but I think it is still relevant. There are some interesting aspects to this paper. One being how much reliance has been put on stereotypes in defining gender in it.

But it is also really important because it shows desistance rates at that time in the Nederlands.

This is a pdf link. I hope it works.

www.researchgate.net/profile/Peggy-Cohen-Kettenis/publication/49738851_Desisting_and_persisting_gender_dysphoria_after_childhood_A_qualitative_follow-up_study/links/09e4150655d20a7ec1000000/Desisting-and-persisting-gender-dysphoria-after-childhood-A-qualitative-follow-up-study.pdf?origin=publication_detail

Desisting and persisting gender dysphoria after childhood: A qualitative follow-up study

Thomas Steensma et al 2011

It is this I thought relevant here:

”As for the clinical management in children before the age of 10, we suggest a cautious attitude towards the moment of transitioning. Given our findings that some girls, who were almost (but not even entirely) living as boys in their childhood years, experienced great trouble when they wanted to return to the female gender role, we believe that parents and caregivers should fully realize the unpre- dictability of their child’s psychosexual outcome. They may help the child to handle their gender variance in a supportive way, but without taking social steps long before puberty, which are hard to reverse. This attitude may guide them through uncertain years without the risk of creating the difficulties that would occur if a transitioned child wants to revert to living in his/her original gender role.”

To be clear, this sentence is the point I want to make.

”They may help the child to handle their gender variance in a supportive way, but without taking social steps long before puberty, which are hard to reverse. This attitude may guide them through uncertain years without the risk of creating the difficulties that would occur if a transitioned child wants to revert to living in his/her original gender role.”

So even in 2011, the Dutch experts recognised issues with ‘social transitioning’.

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/02/2023 11:10

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:52

You don’t need to explain to me that girls have vaginas but I don’t recognise anything in what you say about “making” girls engage in certain activities.

It’s 2023, not 1900. Girls and women can do everything that boys and men can - apart from the activities that their SEX enables only members of their SEX to do. For example, only women can give birth because only women have a womb to grow a baby and a vagina to bring the baby into the world.

Do you understand that?

Well I have a 3 year old and I certainly do recognise the idea that girls are steered towards certain activities. Girls are encouraged to play with dolls, and not cars, they are expected to enjoy sitting and colouring rather than playing outside. They are expected to have long hair styled daily which is often painful. They wear impractical dresses and impractical shoes. Their clothes have slogans like "be kind" "pretty" "happy" etc.
This stuff is absolutely everywhere from birth. It's enforced through schools and nurseries. It's actually very difficult to buck the trend, if you want to be part of modern society

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/02/2023 10:57

newnamefortodays · 11/02/2023 10:45

I agree that attempts to change your sex/gender, whatever you want to call it, are permanent and probably significantly more damaging. But individuals who regret having abortions are psychologically damaged, and can never bring back that pregnancy. I don’t want to come across as a pro-lifer here because I’m far from it, and I do think they are different things, but I’m struggling to understand why I think they’re different.

They are different because having a baby at a young age is a life changing act with the potential to ruin someone's life . There's no good outcome for a pregnant 14 year old.
Waiting 3 or 4 years to have your breasts removed once you are over 18 rather than having it done right now is not going to have anything like the same potential for harm. In fact most children will probably not want it doing by them.

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/02/2023 10:55

Why should they have to “accept physical reality” when there are treatments available to help.

Because no treatments will change someone’s sex - they might change the way their body looks or functions but underneath it all they will still be biologically male or female, which is the reality they need to accept. Gender reassignment surgery won’t change the way illness manifests in their body (often with symptomatic differences in both sexes), won’t remove the physical advantage of male puberty, won’t enable a biological man to experience menstruation or pregnancy.

People can identify any way they chose but underlying that is a reality of biological sex.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:54

I would like to see that evidence that supports your claims about affirming only care Tandora, I know there are several of us on this thread would will carefully read your links to understand the direction of your thoughts.

I would also love to see the evidence of why you feel you can so badly misrepresent posters who use the term exploratory therapy to mean conversion therapy. Why would you wish to portray other poster’s views in such an polarised and absolutist manner?

We know that explorative therapy is supposed to be a main feature of treatment in the UK.

So who benefits from that being so negatively misrepresented?

Certainly not the trans people we love.

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:52

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:44

I don’t think you really need me to explain this to you- but I’ll bite as in a queue for coffee and apparently have nothing better to do with my time. So when someone is born with a vagina we call them a “girl” , usually give them a “girls” name and “she” pronouns, and often dress them a certain way, do their hair a certain way, make them use certain facilities, engage in certain activities etc. Children who “socially transition” may ask for a range of changes to these arrangements- typically pronoun, name, clothing, uniform at school, and “girl/boy” labels.

You don’t need to explain to me that girls have vaginas but I don’t recognise anything in what you say about “making” girls engage in certain activities.

It’s 2023, not 1900. Girls and women can do everything that boys and men can - apart from the activities that their SEX enables only members of their SEX to do. For example, only women can give birth because only women have a womb to grow a baby and a vagina to bring the baby into the world.

Do you understand that?

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:46

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:40

I think @Tandora is having a laugh 😂

They don’t seem to be able to discuss the issue rationally or engage with it without resorting to emotional manipulation, in the past with the kicker of us being told we are ignorant.

I am looking forward to Tandora producing evidence to support their claims where that evidence in relevant and stands up to scrutiny. So far on other threads that has not been forthcoming.

midgemadgemodge · 12/02/2023 10:46

We do more than that

We train girls to be nice and kind and boys to be leaders and fearless

We do all sorts of rubbish based on sex

But it's the rubbish that needs changing not the child !

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:44

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:35

“Natal gender role” - what are you talking about? What is this? Please can you explain?

I don’t think you really need me to explain this to you- but I’ll bite as in a queue for coffee and apparently have nothing better to do with my time. So when someone is born with a vagina we call them a “girl” , usually give them a “girls” name and “she” pronouns, and often dress them a certain way, do their hair a certain way, make them use certain facilities, engage in certain activities etc. Children who “socially transition” may ask for a range of changes to these arrangements- typically pronoun, name, clothing, uniform at school, and “girl/boy” labels.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:42

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:36

How about we entirely reformulate the NHS. No medical services of any kind except mental health support, particularly “open exploratory therapy” to help everyone better “accept their physical realities”. 😆

Considering it has not been proven that hormones and surgery improve the mental health issues of transitioners, I am not quite sure what you investment is here trying to tell people that those ‘treatments’ are the best option for all who are receiving them.

In the group that now forms the majority of youth transitioners, female teens, hormones and surgery are experimental. The effects of them have not been tracked except anecdotally.

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:40

I think @Tandora is having a laugh 😂

midgemadgemodge · 12/02/2023 10:40

No one should need surgery or hormones to live as themselves

They are not born disabled in their body , thier bodies are not failing in any way

What's wrong is that they think you need to look a certain way to live as yourself

Women know that society doesn't always grant us that right , but altering ourselves to try and stop bad people doing and thinking wrong things is bizarre self - victim blaming

Don't give gender the power over you - be free to be yourself

Your whole true authentic unharmed natural self

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:39

Because fortunately the NHS doesn’t exist to cater to everyone’s passing whim and doesn’t operate on the basis of handing out every “intervention” that potential patients may demand.

Ohheckethump · 12/02/2023 10:39

particularly “open exploratory therapy” to help everyone better “accept their physical realities”. 😆

Yes we should. Why would that be a bad thing?

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:38

Natal gender role 🤦‍♀️

The switching of language.

People can live as they want. 'Perform' their lives in whatever way they choose. No one cares. They'll always remain the same sex though. Thats a biological fact.

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:36

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:18

Why should they have to “accept physical reality” when there are treatments available to help. Or do you say that to anyone asking for medical help/ treatment/ interventions ? Sorry, no help for you, how about some “therapy” to help you accept your physical reality.

How about we entirely reformulate the NHS. No medical services of any kind except mental health support, particularly “open exploratory therapy” to help everyone better “accept their physical realities”. 😆

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:35

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:23

Yes, I disagree with her. Denying people medical care, and forcing them to live in their natal gender role is no more or less neutral than the alternative.

“Natal gender role” - what are you talking about? What is this? Please can you explain?

FrancescaContini · 12/02/2023 10:33

Thank you for the link, OP.

It’s child abuse. What @RichardBarrister has just posted re the double mastectomy carried out on a teenage girl - horrifying. Child abuse.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:32

And it is remarkable that you don’t seem to be able to consider that there are clinicians such as Dr Anderson and Dr Bowers, Dr Steensma and now Dr Cass all have flagged issues with affirming only treatment, yet you continue to deny the issues faced by young female patients seeking to transition.

What do you think those four clinicians have to achieve raising flags? Two of them are transitioned males themselves and Dr Steensma has their reputation built on the Dutch Protocol and Dr Cass is a specialist in children’s health who is responsible for ensuring children and teens get the best health care.

Why do you seek to constantly discredit their comments that you don’t agree with?

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:28

what are you here for then?

Sensible and rational conversation with people who have critical thinking skills.

I'm not getting that experience from you.

Hope this helps.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:26

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:23

Yes, I disagree with her. Denying people medical care, and forcing them to live in their natal gender role is no more or less neutral than the alternative.

She is saying, as I did quite clearly on the other thread, that there is a significant issue at the moment with the number of young female children and teens who are seeking to transition.

That you continue to ignore that and you continue to ignore the significantly negative health impacts on that cohort is very clear.

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:24

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:22

They are similar. As I've already said. I'm not here to debate the indefensible with you.

They aren’t remotely similar .
what are you here for then?

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:23

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 10:19

So you disagree with Dr Hilary Cass? Do you believe that social transitioning a child or a teen is a ‘neutral’ act?

If you disagree with her, why?

Yes, I disagree with her. Denying people medical care, and forcing them to live in their natal gender role is no more or less neutral than the alternative.

WiIson · 12/02/2023 10:22

They are similar. As I've already said. I'm not here to debate the indefensible with you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread