Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'gender affirming care" is barbaric and should be banned?

211 replies

Appalonia · 10/02/2023 21:12

This article is from the US but these procedures have been carried out in the UK. Teenagers who are confused and vulnerable do not have the mental capacity to consent to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or life altering surgery.

Please read this devastating article from a whistleblower who has been working in a gender clinic in the US.

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

OP posts:
FrancescaContini · 13/02/2023 08:10

Fantastic posts, @Helleofabore and @RedToothBrush .

@SnackSizeRaisin to return to the point you raised in answer to my previous post: are you in the UK? I don’t recognise what you say about girls being “expected to” have long hair or “encouraged to” sit down quietly and do colouring in. This isn’t what I see around me for my own children or their peers, and it’s certainly not been our experience of any nursery or school setting I’ve come across; if this is what you’re experiencing then it’s very important to raise this with the setting and complain. Other parents as well as Ofsted would take an extremely dim view of regressive gender stereotypes being reinforced in this way.

I see football and rugby teams for girls and ballet classes open to both sexes. I see girls in comfortable leggings (there’s no obligation to buy sparkly “pretty girl” clothes, you know; there are plenty of cheap, bright, practical clothes available) and trainers that allow them to run and climb and ride horses. I see boys and girls absorbed in Lego and reading stories and learning cooking as well as other crucial life skills. I see 17 year old girls passing their driving tests and boys aspiring to be artists and having families one day.

Nobody bats an eyelid at anything listed above and nobody with their marbles intact should imply that any of this must mean that the children engaged in these activities - such as boys wanting to go to ballet or girls climbing trees - have “been born in the wrong body”.

I genuinely don’t recognise your world, @SnackSizeRaisin . Perhaps you are a time traveller from 1900.

Kucinghitam · 13/02/2023 05:18

Great posts, @RedToothBrush !

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 13/02/2023 02:37

@Tandora No one is born in the wrong body. It's not possible. What you are doing is pushing gender stereotypes, in order to say they're born in the wrong body. It is much a mental illness as anorexia is, so you are wrong and deeply ill-informed. Both trans and anorexia believe their body is wrong and want to change it. They are EXACTLY the same thing. It is mental illness, a delusion, when we should be encouraging body positivity and to be happy in the body you've got, because it's the only one you'll have. What you are doing is encouraging delusions and fostering mental illness, telling these people they're right and should change their body. You are brainwashed and your attitude is dangerous.

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2023 22:15

Also treating people with respect and caring for their health - applies to trans identifying children.

They deserve us to ask these difficult questions. It's not hating them to do so. It's caring enough about them to ensure harm isn't done because parents and activists have rigged the system and caused safeguarding and ethical standards to be steam rollered

It's interesting who we see the framing of hate coming from. Often the very people claiming they are the most concerned about the welfare of these children. It doesn't add up to be true.

If they were properly invested in the best care available, they would be actively seeking better data and better oversight. Not going round shouting 'transphobia' as their argument against scrutiny of this area of health care.

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2023 22:11

I would say I'm more qualified to say than many, as the parent of a trans 18 year old.

This statement is one of the most disturbing on the thread. It certainly does not carry the weight of authority it sets out to impose on the discussion.

Whistleblowers have gone on record as saying SOME parents have given them enormous concerns. Not necessarily the poster that put this comment, but the point remains. Whistleblowers are saying they are seeing examples where they believe the child is being sexually abused, where the parents are using it to trans away the gay, where they believe the parents are engaging in munchausens, where they believe the child is mentally suffering from other issues, where the child is expressing the view that their parent want it more than them.

And then to cap it off, unqualified pressure groups and parents are bullying staff or bypassing safeguarding/ ethics to ensure their child is medicalised despite significant concerns.

The idea that it's 'no one elses' business fails when you are talking about minor setting themselves up for life long medicalisation and risky surgery / hormones. Society has a responsibility to safeguard child from harm.

On another day, this comment might be let slide. But not today. Not with the concerns Barnes'book raises. Not when Susie Green acts in a very disturbing manner and seems to be evading accountability. She was that parent too. Who stacked her reputation on being an expert because she was a parent, despite having absolutely no medical knowledge at all. And she and Mermaids have been huge drivers of the emerging scandal which has left even kids who remain happy transitioned with massive regrets about the medicalisation.

Given the same poster thinks the Tavi should stay open despite all the evidence to the contrary about how cavalier it was in dismissing the disturbing comordibities that were emerging and the power of money preventing accountability, I think it very much discredits their opinion as carrying authority.

Indeed I would go so far as to say, the poster, and any other saying similar should be under a magnifying glass as it seems that children identifing as trans should be treated as a big red flag in its own right for other things precisely because of the level of comorbid concerns. The parents of trans identifying children should be under immense scrutiny and treated with a degree of caution in terms of whether they really have their child's best interests at heart.

Given this poster is also parroting discredited bollocks about suicidal intent it's even more worrying. They aren't properly informed despite protesting that they have expertise.

Gender affirming treatment is not neutral and there's every reason to believe it's causing enormous harm because it's being carried out by schools before a child even sees a doctor in some cases and often without parental consent. And we DO have evidence of the physical harms' blockers, hormones and surgery is causing and conversely no real evidence that they actually are improving the life or mental health of children. Because there's no proper studies going on.

I'm afraid any adult advocating hormones or surgery for minors gives me massive cause for concern and I certainly don't think the parents of a trans identifying kid should be treated as any kind of authority whatsoever because of the danger of a potential conflict of interest between them and their child's well being. Such is the ideology and omerta style culture around the subject.

The people who have run these clinics for decades should be brought to court and prosecuted for unwarranted experimentation of children which has caused harm.

Ludo19 · 12/02/2023 21:57

That article is a really tough read OP. Heartbreaking.

Mommawasafarmgirl · 12/02/2023 21:48

Then you have completely misunderstood what I have said @midgemadgemodge.
I believe there are differences between men and women. I do not believe in gender stereotyping - I am GC.
These are not mutually exclusive positions.

midgemadgemodge · 12/02/2023 21:34

I am arguing because if the nonsense you spout

Nonsense that people use to try and justify physically harming children

Mommawasafarmgirl · 12/02/2023 21:28

I didnt make a mistake typing thanks @midgemadgemodge.

I agree everyone should be free to be themselves. Neither do I agree with stereotyping people.

I've already said this. I don't know why you are arguing with me.

midgemadgemodge · 12/02/2023 21:11

Think you made a mistake in typing

At a population level there is no evidence that the differences we see are innate

Hec - years ago it was boys who wore pink frills and women who were computer programmers - the very fact these things change in time ( and cultures ) proves that most is society

And even if there are innate differences- that SHOULD NOT matter at all

Everyone should be free to be themselves

No one should be changed to fit a narrow stereotype

Mommawasafarmgirl · 12/02/2023 20:56

midgemadgemodge · 12/02/2023 15:13

Teachers may say they see differences in girls and boys

Because they expect to

Because the children have already been exposed to training

Decades ago there was a study where small nursery children were cross dressed and then nursery staff ( unaware of the clothes switches) assessed the behaviour of the children

The children in blue were boisterous and liked playing with cars
The children in pink were kind and liked playing gently with dolls

The teachers see what they expect to see and reinforce it

It's hard to fight but you don't fight it by saying it's innate and there is something wrong with people who don't fit

I didn't say there was anything wrong with people who don't fit! I didn't even say there were people who don't fit! I think a wide range of behaviour is normal. I don't agree with stereotyping.

I said that at a population level there are innate behavioural differences between very young boys and girls. This allows for a very wide range of behaviour at an individual level. There are also differences due to socialisation of course.

I haven't heard of the study you mention, but do know that these innate differences in behaviour between male and female infants have been observed in other primates too - and socialisation has been controlled for in these experiments in a way that's not possible for humans.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 17:46

Ahhh... sinner I am trying to remain hopeful on this one.

SinnerBoy · 12/02/2023 16:23

Helleofabore · Today 10:46

I am looking forward to Tandora producing evidence to support their claims where that evidence in relevant and stands up to scrutiny. So far on other threads that has not been forthcoming.

I think she's read a few propaganda articles online and fallen for it, hook, line and sinker and isn't bright, or honest enough to stand back and reassess things. I get that impression by the extreme twisting of poster's words.

Qazwsxefv · 12/02/2023 15:47

it seems the argument some people have is that instead of properly training our early years providers to not propagate sex stereotypes we should instead sterilise and multilate the bodies of young people who don’t fit the stereotypes?

if a young boy wants to wear a pink dress, play with a doll and call himself a princess when they do dress up why on Earth do we need to decide he must really be a girl and so start him on a pathway that will lead to his castration? Why can’t we just let him get on with playing?

as a society we’re going backwards. In 1900 a boy playing with dolls would probably be beaten by his parents, now we castrate him

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 15:19

"And for any poster who is going to post a 'well they are all just haters' type post, why the fuck would any of these clinicians want to lie or contort the truth?"

Just for the record, I also expect to see more of the 'but these anecdotes are just a small number'. Dismissing the very fact that these are just the clinicians who are prepared to put their name to their claims. And that this is a sample from a book just released.

Plus if any poster wants to go down that track of rhetoric, please also then answer:

How many children and teenagers are those posters willing to offer up as 'collateral' considering desistance and detransition rates are still undocumented thanks to the groups who said 'no debate' and shut down any efforts to query those numbers properly??

How many are considered acceptable 'collateral' damage?

That is the very question that logically has to go with 'it is just a small number'.

midgemadgemodge · 12/02/2023 15:13

Teachers may say they see differences in girls and boys

Because they expect to

Because the children have already been exposed to training

Decades ago there was a study where small nursery children were cross dressed and then nursery staff ( unaware of the clothes switches) assessed the behaviour of the children

The children in blue were boisterous and liked playing with cars
The children in pink were kind and liked playing gently with dolls

The teachers see what they expect to see and reinforce it

It's hard to fight but you don't fight it by saying it's innate and there is something wrong with people who don't fit

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 15:13

Even in 2000, the child psychiatrist who set up GIDS in 1989 reported the following about the patient profile.

"Most of Gids’s patients were boys with an average age of 11. More than 25 per cent of them had spent time in care, 38 per cent came from families with mental health problems and 42 per cent had lost at least one parent, either through separation or death. Most had histories of other problems such as anxiety and physical abuse; almost a quarter had a history of self-harm."

From "How the Tavistock gender clinic ran out of control' by Hadley Freeman, The Sunday Times, Saturday 11th February

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/f38ca170-a236-11ed-9d5c-69bd3c5b98b3?shareToken=08c87b70474a5200b2d70b4b1cd67574

I am just going to pull this out so people can see this more clearly:

Boys - average age 11

25% + had spent time in care

38% from families with mental health problems

42% had lost one parent through separation or death

up to 25% had history of self harm

most had histories of anxiety and physical abuse.

Even in 2000, a profile was forming that indicated how vulnerable these patients were. I have read figures that show this has not really changed much except that it is now the majority of female patients.

The interim Cass Report states:

"This increase in referrals has been accompanied by a change in the case-mix from predominantly birth-registered males presenting with gender incongruence from an early age, to predominantly birth-registered females presenting with later onset of reported gender incongruence in early teen years. In addition, approximately one third of children and young people referred to GIDS have autism or other types of neurodiversity. There is also an over-representation percentage wise (compared to the national percentage) of looked after children."

It has been estimated that over half the female patients referred to the Tavistock are lesbian or bisexual too. A vastly over represented category compared to the general population. How has this not be thoroughly investigated?

How do people dismiss the issues that are being raised?

These children and teens have been let down in the standard of care delivered by the NHS. But this is being repeated in other countries too as it can be seen from the article linked up by OP.

Kucinghitam · 12/02/2023 14:59

Who benefits from silencing those raising alarms?

And then followed immediately by exactly who benefits from framing those discussing it and raising alarms as being people who hate trans people? Indeed, who benefits from perpetuating a lie that to be concerned about poor care levels is to hate trans people?

I suppose it benefits Folx who self-identify as being Righteously on The Right Side Of History and who believe that anything they do or say, however (real-world) harmful or dishonest, will ultimately prove Righteous as it is in service of bringing about TRSOH. Circular, but that's the central feature of the ideology!

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 14:18

Here is some points from The Sunday Times article:

Tavistock scandal ‘on a par with East German doping of athletes’ By Glen Keogh, Sat 11th February.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/e04f4958-aa26-11ed-8a03-b2faadede0c5?shareToken=81bddfc85342137edc81797069ccd8cb

These are anecdotes from clinicians at the Tavistock.

"But Dr Anna Hutchinson, a senior clinical psychologist at Gids, said the service was soon “accepting everyone”. She said puberty blockers were supposed to be prescribed to children to give them “time to think” about whether they wanted to transition fully, but she realised that almost all went on to take cross-sex hormones, such as testosterone and oestrogen, which have irreversible consequences."

"Hutchinson told Barnes this was a “holy f*” moment. “It totally exploded the idea that when we were offering the puberty blockers, we were actually offering time to think,” she said."

“Because what are the chances of 100 per cent of people, offered time to think, thinking the same thing? If the service was getting this wrong, it was getting it wrong with some of the most vulnerable children and young people.”

and

"She now believes that “some of those kids would not have identified as trans had they not been put on the medical pathway”.

and

“But what is a bad outcome is creating a cohort of people who are medically dependent who’d never needed to be. And not only medically dependent, but perhaps — we don’t yet know — medically damaged.”

and then there is this family therapist

"Anastassis Spiliadis, a family therapist, told Barnes of the impact of outside groups, and parents, on decisions to refer often vulnerable children for puberty blockers."

"He said in his four years at the service, on two occasions he decided that children from complex family set-ups and backgrounds should not be placed on blockers. However, the families complained and “both ended up on the blocker”."

"Parents who complained were referred to “clinicians who we all knew it was much easier to get on hormones through them, rather than other clinicians”, he said."

and

"In one case, he said, the child told him, “my mum wants this for me”, or “my mum wants the blocker more than I do”. He said there was sexual abuse and domestic violence in the family and he and a colleague agreed that they would not be putting the young person forward for puberty blockers. However, this decision was allegedly overruled by Carmichael."

"On other occasions a change in clinician would be requested by Green, the Mermaids chief, Spiliadis said."

and this clinician

"Matt Bristow, a former Gids clinician, added: “Despite the obvious complexity of all these cases — sexual abuse, trauma, potential FII — the answer was always the same. That the young people eventually get put on the blocker unless they themselves say they don’t want it.”"

And for any poster who is going to post a 'well they are all just haters' type post, why the fuck would any of these clinicians want to lie or contort the truth?

Clinicians around the world are raising alarms about the level of care given to children and teenagers. And there are still posters determined to shame and to contort, misrepresent and to dismiss due to their own prejudices about the people who want to discuss it and want to get the information out there.

It all falls apart when one question is repeated.

Who benefits from silencing those raising alarms?

And then followed immediately by exactly who benefits from framing those discussing it and raising alarms as being people who hate trans people? Indeed, who benefits from perpetuating a lie that to be concerned about poor care levels is to hate trans people?

It most certainly doesn't benefit vulnerable trans people to be told the lie that people hate them.

Mommawasafarmgirl · 12/02/2023 13:26

SnackSizeRaisin · 12/02/2023 11:10

Well I have a 3 year old and I certainly do recognise the idea that girls are steered towards certain activities. Girls are encouraged to play with dolls, and not cars, they are expected to enjoy sitting and colouring rather than playing outside. They are expected to have long hair styled daily which is often painful. They wear impractical dresses and impractical shoes. Their clothes have slogans like "be kind" "pretty" "happy" etc.
This stuff is absolutely everywhere from birth. It's enforced through schools and nurseries. It's actually very difficult to buck the trend, if you want to be part of modern society

But teachers of preschool children will tell you that there are considerable differences in the behaviour girls vs boys, at least when considered as groups rather than individuals.
Take away the clothing or hairstyle differences and they see that boys tend to be more boisterous, they're usually the ones pushing in the queue, they're less likely to sit still. There are differences in nature as well as nurture, at least at a population level.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 13:08

RichardBarrister · 12/02/2023 12:28

you have no idea what you are talking about.

and social transition isn’t a “treatment” it’s just allowing kids to dress and be called what they want. Or do you think anyone born with a vagina should be forced to wear pink dresses until the age of 18 ?

From your posts I think I might understand it better than you. I have read widely on both sides of the issue and spring time thinking about the logic and facts involved.

I’m afraid you misunderstand ‘social transition’. It is not about clothing and hairstyles - I mean, most of us have spent our lives pushing back against the sex based stereotypes you mention.

It is about affirming the idea in an impressionable child’s head that they may actually be the opposite sex and that people around them either agree or can be compelled to agree.

Once a child has been allowed to embark on this path with the announcements of their new identity, a change of name on the school register and an edict to ‘respect their new pronouns’ (with punishment for those who fail), it would be hard to announce that it was all a mistake. I have seen a girl do this - changed name on register, big announcements to all in the school- aged 12/13.

She is now the grand old age of 14 and mightily embarrassed by the whole thing. Unfortunately the school have not been so fast to change her name back (I guess she’s not as special any more) so she is reminded of her brief phase of teenage angst twice every day.

Some schools hold special assemblies for these children, with special exemptions from normal rules and an in house ‘police force’ (the LGBTQ allies) guarding them from any act of disrespect.

Some parents hold special ‘gender reveal’ parties for their shiny new ‘son’ of ‘daughter’ - ostracising relatives who do not jump on board unquestioningly with the celebrations. These are the parents who may have been very disappointed with the sex of the baby when it was born (we all know some of those) but have now got an opportunity to ‘fix’ that and have the child they really wanted.

As reported by concerned GIDS clinicians, some parents were clear that they would rather have a trans child then a gay one.

Children need and trust parents and other responsible adults to make decisions in their best interest. If all these people are agreeing with a child’s self diagnosis of their own mental health problems or cause of distress, the child will trust that. The trouble is, transition is not the answer for the majority, they just need time to grow and good mental health support.

Anyone who can’t see this needs to read and think a bit more.

Yes Richard, your example about that young girl is spot on. I know two students where the school changed the records of those students without the parents even knowing. One of those students was under the care of a therapist who recommended that this did NOT happen. The school still did it, because they never once consulted the parents and did not know about the therapist.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 13:03

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:36

How about we entirely reformulate the NHS. No medical services of any kind except mental health support, particularly “open exploratory therapy” to help everyone better “accept their physical realities”. 😆

And this is yet another absurd polarised and catastrophised contribution.

And fucking ignores the fact that for people who have similar beliefs, that parts of their body is not 'theirs' for example actually DO need this extensive mental health support. Or so too do people who are faced with navigating life because of injury or disease or a medical condition at birth where surgery and medication are not recommended because there is no evidence even after x years of improving the mental health issues. Plus let's not forget the number of people for whom there is no further surgical or drug treatment that will help.

There are groups of people who most definitely should be receiving extensive mental health support to be able to accept their physical realities and cannot access it.

To post this is no fucking joke.

It is yet another emotionally manipulative misrepresentation that force teams other people's conditions with those of trans people.

And let's remember this entire fucking thread is about children and teenagers.

Really, this post of shows the issue with absolutist arguments. Once you (general you) have oversimplified the issues to the very point that you think that this post is funny, or even relevant, you (general you) really are showing those reading along the lack of wider understanding and/or balance regarding the medical treatment of children and teenagers.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 12:49

"I don’t think you really need me to explain this to you- but I’ll bite as in a queue for coffee and apparently have nothing better to do with my time. So when someone is born with a vagina we call them a “girl” , usually give them a “girls” name and “she” pronouns, and often dress them a certain way, do their hair a certain way, make them use certain facilities, engage in certain activities etc. Children who “socially transition” may ask for a range of changes to these arrangements- typically pronoun, name, clothing, uniform at school, and “girl/boy” labels."

Firstly, parents who do 'dress them [girls] a certain way, do their hair a certain way, make them use certain facilities, engage in certain activities', have significant issues. Unless you are describing making girls use the spaces designated for their safety, and 'engaging in certain activities' involves learning about their bodies in girl's only sessions.

If parents are enforcing gender stereotypes on their children, that is a topic that deserves a whole thread. I would expect that very few, if any parent on this thread would be doing this.

It is ridiculous to see these stereotypes being presented as some kind of reasoned discussion points over and over. Like the point about 'anyone born with a vagina should be forced to wear pink dresses until the age of 18 ?'

But getting back to socially transitioning.

"Children who “socially transition” may ask for a range of changes to these arrangements- typically pronoun, name, clothing, uniform at school, and “girl/boy” labels."

And changing name to a name that is traditionally used for the opposite sex, insisting on pronouns that are not specific for their sex (not gender) and adopting girl/boy labels outside the family are exactly the issues that clinicians have recognised can cause a child distress when they realise they want to desist from that identity. It is a barrier to desistance.

The numbers for desistance is very high in 2011 in the Nederlands it was between 50-60% in that study posted up thread of patients registered at the clinic. The estimates for children and adolescent desisting from a trans identity over the past couple of years are as high as 80%.

In ignoring clinicians sounding the alarm, "you have no idea what you are talking about" really just seems like more projection.

RichardBarrister · 12/02/2023 12:28

you have no idea what you are talking about.

and social transition isn’t a “treatment” it’s just allowing kids to dress and be called what they want. Or do you think anyone born with a vagina should be forced to wear pink dresses until the age of 18 ?

From your posts I think I might understand it better than you. I have read widely on both sides of the issue and spring time thinking about the logic and facts involved.

I’m afraid you misunderstand ‘social transition’. It is not about clothing and hairstyles - I mean, most of us have spent our lives pushing back against the sex based stereotypes you mention.

It is about affirming the idea in an impressionable child’s head that they may actually be the opposite sex and that people around them either agree or can be compelled to agree.

Once a child has been allowed to embark on this path with the announcements of their new identity, a change of name on the school register and an edict to ‘respect their new pronouns’ (with punishment for those who fail), it would be hard to announce that it was all a mistake. I have seen a girl do this - changed name on register, big announcements to all in the school- aged 12/13.

She is now the grand old age of 14 and mightily embarrassed by the whole thing. Unfortunately the school have not been so fast to change her name back (I guess she’s not as special any more) so she is reminded of her brief phase of teenage angst twice every day.

Some schools hold special assemblies for these children, with special exemptions from normal rules and an in house ‘police force’ (the LGBTQ allies) guarding them from any act of disrespect.

Some parents hold special ‘gender reveal’ parties for their shiny new ‘son’ of ‘daughter’ - ostracising relatives who do not jump on board unquestioningly with the celebrations. These are the parents who may have been very disappointed with the sex of the baby when it was born (we all know some of those) but have now got an opportunity to ‘fix’ that and have the child they really wanted.

As reported by concerned GIDS clinicians, some parents were clear that they would rather have a trans child then a gay one.

Children need and trust parents and other responsible adults to make decisions in their best interest. If all these people are agreeing with a child’s self diagnosis of their own mental health problems or cause of distress, the child will trust that. The trouble is, transition is not the answer for the majority, they just need time to grow and good mental health support.

Anyone who can’t see this needs to read and think a bit more.

Helleofabore · 12/02/2023 12:16

The issue relating to the best care for children and adolescents who have gender dysphoria is being discussed world wide.

This is not just a UK issue. There are so many aspects of this issue now though. Including the wait times and the lack of adequate and balanced mental health support that is not ideologically led.

The perpetuation of the suicide risk is so very harmful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread