Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'gender affirming care" is barbaric and should be banned?

211 replies

Appalonia · 10/02/2023 21:12

This article is from the US but these procedures have been carried out in the UK. Teenagers who are confused and vulnerable do not have the mental capacity to consent to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or life altering surgery.

Please read this devastating article from a whistleblower who has been working in a gender clinic in the US.

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 13:04

Every review of this new book by Hannah Barnes pulls out a very different aspect of the scandal. I am not sure how the Tavistock executives thought they would get away with this.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/91450fd0-a3c5-11ed-8e45-d36dad29d912?shareToken=1b4e1a994662ddf89c244363c01812ad

In 2016, James Bellringer, an eminent consultant urologist, visited the Tavistock child gender identity development service (GIDS) to issue a warning. A specialist in creating “neo-vaginas” in adult trans women, he had noted that natal boys were being given puberty-blocking drugs so young that their penises hadn’t yet fully developed. With insufficient skin for surgery, he was having to construct vaginas with stretches of bowel tissue, a more hazardous, expensive operation, prone to infection and an “unwanted smell”.

Senior GIDS clinicians, including its director, Polly Carmichael, listened to Bellringer and afterwards one psychotherapist proposed writing a leaflet to forewarn parents of boys contemplating blockers. She drafted this, then emailed it to Carmichael for approval. No reply ever came.

then

according to the many whistleblowers Barnes talks to, feared this leaflet would reach Mermaids, a trans charity that is gung-ho for medical intervention in children, which would then accuse her of fear-mongering and transphobia.

So, again clinicians and surgeons raising alarms and nothing, nothing was done.

Or, as we have seen here on this thread, anyone trying to raise the alarm is portrayed as 'Why is there so much hatred towards trans people? This is the problem.' or 'you have no idea what you are talking about.'

Those comments are in the same fuckwittery league as 'it is just a small number'. I notice that not one poster has answered the 'how many children and teens are acceptable collateral' question.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 12:34

I personally love the condescending asides that come with the posts. The 'I am taking my time out to answer your ignorance' posts across different threads show that tactic you suggest rather well, I thought.

SinnerBoy · 14/02/2023 12:16

However, it is a great live demonstration of the tactics used of emotional manipulation, dishonest posting and twisted takes used to try to discredit others.

Yes, the "Shut up and agree with me, or you're a racist and you smell!" tactic, which teenagers tend to have abandoned.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 12:14

SinnerBoy · 12/02/2023 16:23

Helleofabore · Today 10:46

I am looking forward to Tandora producing evidence to support their claims where that evidence in relevant and stands up to scrutiny. So far on other threads that has not been forthcoming.

I think she's read a few propaganda articles online and fallen for it, hook, line and sinker and isn't bright, or honest enough to stand back and reassess things. I get that impression by the extreme twisting of poster's words.

I think Sinner I was too optimistic. As last time, there seems there is nothing to offer by way of evidenced and reasoned contribution.

But hey, at least this time we were not subjected to direct personal attacks and being called 'ignorant' with all the weird mocking dramatics as what happened on another thread. By that I mean, repeatedly posting 'you are all ignorant' over and over and then having nothing to contribute by hastily searched on google studies that were not really even relevant, leaves readers understanding what projection is.

However, it is a great live demonstration of the tactics used of emotional manipulation, dishonest posting and twisted takes used to try to discredit others. Or maybe it is just to feel better about themselves, I have not worked it out. Maybe others will have better insight into the motivation of that style of engagement.

TicketBoo23 · 14/02/2023 12:09

housemaus · 13/02/2023 20:53

Find it very, very weird you're crying over the potential sexual experiences of a young person who evidently does not want to have those experiences.

Teenagers & young people change their minds a lot.

It's called growing up.

Brain does not stop developing til 21 and I'd say all of us could say we learned a lot in life and perhaps changed a lot through our terms, twenties, thirties and beyond.

When I hear teenagers speaking on public transport they very much strike me as older kids .... Their ideas & concepts their preoccupations, how they express themselves .... They are not adult humans

And they should not be making life changing decisions. They should be safe guarded.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 11:46

TheKeatingFive · 14/02/2023 08:59

The risks for female transition seem so much higher than for male transitioners.

Im not sure about that, those fake vaginas seem to be total medical liabilities. But perhaps a much smaller number get to that stage.

That is kind of true.

Except when you then look at the complication rates and the number of operations needed to create a fake penis. That is not including the issues around having most of a forearm muscle removed from all around the bone to create that fake penis.

So, yes the fake vaginas with the reports of ingrown hairs or if from dissected intestine, the smell that never diminishes are not as successful as they are lauded to be . But the symmetry on this, the fake penis surgeries are even more brutal and have even lower success rates.

And yet, it is only recently that some trans people have even spoken out about how disappointed they are, how they expected so much because of only being able to read the good results.

It is like trying to find the negative side effects of wearing a binder. WE KNOW that there are major issues in too many instances. But search engines simply cannot seem to local them as the first x pages are all about agencies telling teenagers how beneficial they are and playing down the negative side effects. I remember reading a surgeon stating, 'if you have regrets later.... just get implants'. Like that will solve the issues of scar tissue and lasting damage, loss of nipple sensation and the breezy 'you don't have to breastfeed, so what are you worried about' attitude of some people posting on line.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 10:33

And if people start looking into Money, they should also look into Foucault. After all, Foucault is often discussed as being the ‘father’ of gender ideology. He was one of those responsible for lowering the age of consent to 14 in France leading to child sex abuse that is only now being discussed by the victims because their abusers are powerful figures in France.

Foucault was all about destabilising societal norms, language and laws.

And is now understood to have been a paedophile.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/french-philosopher-michel-foucault-abused-boys-in-tunisia-6t5sj7jvw

Plug this link into archive sites.

It is actually well written about so it will be easy enough to find. There are also articles written about his role in lowering the legal age of consent to 14 in France in the name of sexually liberating children, apparently for those children’s benefit.

Empowermenomore · 14/02/2023 10:11

Totally agree with @Helleofabore

unfortunately very young children with very ill health will confront their health choices with a view to save their lives. They do so with reliable, robust and unbiased research data and counselled by parents and specialists.

The Dysphoria discussed by PO seems to require interventions on healthy bodies with various and diverse mental conditions. Autism being detected on approx 30% of the girls referred. And one model (affirmation) for all patients, advocated by IT managers (former CEO of Mermaids and associate to the Gender GP Webberley’s fiasco) or the gendered intelligence ginger bread non binary man.

with regards to my concern about children not growing into fully functional adults, maybe look into the father of this ideology and medical path Dr Money. You could find a thing or two. Also read around the WPATH and Dr Harry Benjamin.

children need the same standard of care whether they have a life threatening condition or mental distress. It cannot be disregarded as they know best, and proceed to give them a double mastectomy just because they want one.

grow up, read and learn and don’t wish away the health of children just because they are going through a bad patch!

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 09:43

In fact, here is an indication on how the Scottish equivalent of the Tavistock operate.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/dffaa4b0-abbc-11ed-9cb3-80326348937b?shareToken=4411983868d8a77b64f7d7ea08e2d520

According to the Scottish Pathway for Trans Healthcare (Spath), updated last September, “best practice” has “moved away from psychiatric assessments that focus on evaluating how ‘gender dysphoric’ a person is”. Instead, treatment should consider a patient’s “readiness for initiating particular aspects of gender-affirming healthcare”. The conclusion is thereby established before the evidence supporting it.

Counselling should not be considered “a prerequisite for any gender-affirming healthcare”. There is no need to explore the depth or conviction or provenance of a person’s gender discordance. On the contrary, their declared sense of themselves should simply be affirmed. By such means, even those who do not obviously need medical intervention should nevertheless receive it.

and this part seems pertinent to post as well…

“We must take these issues seriously,” Nicola Sturgeon said last year, “but we owe it to everybody also to treat these issues incredibly sensitively”. This is code. “Sensitively” here really means “these issues should not be discussed in public”. See nothing, say nothing, think nothing.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 09:07

Either way, if you are fully comfortable to accept such high health risks for others, or for your own children, please start posting links to the studies and the papers that convinced you.

If you haven’t got that evidence, why are you on this thread trying to shame others for their concerns.

I think those reading this thread will have noticed that we are at page 8 and there is not one link posted to support the claims or to support the ready dismissal of the significant health impacts.

Despite now several posters either actively dismissing those effects through minimising behaviour, or mocking others concerns or straight out false accusations of hatred.

And those posters doing that dismissing, mocking and accusing seem to have absolutely fuck all to contribute other than that, certainly no evidence to convince otherwise. It all seems to stem from a deep abiding prejudice held by those about posters who disagree with them. So it is really just the same old recycling of shame tactics and projection.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 09:01

”Find it very, very weird you're crying over the potential sexual experiences of a young person who evidently does not want to have those experiences”

It is those who have dismissed the health impacts, who dismiss the lack of sexual function, fertility and the lack of improved long term mental health who are the ones who need to evaluate their own actions.

If they have read written opinion based on research with flimsy conclusions, or by a group who take biased surveys and amplify the findings or haven’t checked the facts properly because they were published by the ‘wrong person’ (usually someone who a community has declared transphobic for raising an alarm), or published in the ‘wrong media’, the onus I am afraid is on that person dismissing these major impacts to accept their actions.

Many of us who are concerned have done the research for personal reasons. We get called obsessed with other people’s sex lives, and other people’s business. no. fuck that. I will not be shamed because some other poster wants to frame my concern in that way.

That is a classic extreme activist tactic and is hiding the truth. Usually that the person trying to shame others either has a very low bar for being convinced by evidence or has none (because they never actually link it up).

Or has fully outsourced their own critical thinking to either self-described ‘influencers’ or lobby groups who are heavily invested and only ever change direction when forced (like when they were sending out tool kits to school telling young children they could be born in the wrong bodies or if they like activities associated with the opposite sex, they may be the opposite sex).

Or it could be all three.

TheKeatingFive · 14/02/2023 08:59

The risks for female transition seem so much higher than for male transitioners.

Im not sure about that, those fake vaginas seem to be total medical liabilities. But perhaps a much smaller number get to that stage.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 08:56

The dismissal of the drugs like Lupron is very harmful. There are women out there who have reported significant life limiting issues from being prescribed it for precocious puberty. I have a friend who used it for another of its prescribed uses in the 90s.

10-15 years after she had a fall which nearly left her unable to walk, 15-20 years later she was diagnosed with severe pancreatitis and diabetes. 25 years later she has such significant osteoporosis she breaks bones doing normal activities, her pancreas is nearly ceased functioning, her teeth are falling out, she has other organ damage.

Reading the accounts of other women, the symptoms she has are the same ones as those who have taken Lupron. The information is out there, women are raising their voices but are ignored.

Just like the known effects of taking testosterone as a woman is known because of those who took it for sports performance (including those who had no idea what they were taking).

And there is now research into the risk of very early dementia in female patients who have had to had their ovaries removed in late 20s or earlier. And the research is into those losing ovary function due to other health conditions, not even beginning to touch on atrophy from testosterone.

The detransitioners too often report significant health issues with their bladders, and other organs.

All these major life limiting and shortening health issues are not discussed widely in public. I suspect there are a few reasons from power of pharmaceutical companies to ignore the issues and not do the research into long term effects, to the reports of a community who doesn’t tolerate those suffering adverse effects speaking out.

Either way, the number of posters I have seen over the years who simply hand wave it all away with ‘it is treatment for trans people, you just don’t understand’. Fuck that! The risks for female transition seem so much higher than for male transitioners. Yet the majority of those young people transitioning at the moment are young females. And people raising alarms are framed to simply ‘hate trans people’.

nolongersurprised · 14/02/2023 03:59

The obvious problem as well with the comparison to other drugs, like chemotherapy, is that they are used to treat a physical medical condition.

Whereas hormonal manipulation in gender affirming care takes a healthy body and reduces/stops its healthy sexual and reproductive function.

Clymene · 14/02/2023 03:43

In addition to the physical impacts of PBs followed by long term wrong sex hormones, no one knows the impact on mental development. We know children change in all sorts of ways mentally during puberty and many of those changes are driven by hormones. What happens if you simply don't have them? No one knows.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 14/02/2023 03:33

discobrain · 14/02/2023 03:25

YABU

No she isn't, she is reasonable, compassionate and sensitive.

discobrain · 14/02/2023 03:25

YABU

NotBadConsidering · 14/02/2023 03:09

Male, treated with puberty blockers at Tanner stage 2, then oestrogen, spironolactone. Now 21, has a micro penis, never had an orgasm. Would quite like to have fertility and sexual function, comes off wrong-sex hormones, hopes his testes will start producing testosterone.

Will he regain any lost sexual function? Probably not, but who knows? There’s no research.

I don’t think this is the correct issue. What is the issue is it’s perfectly predictable that there will be a zero chance of regaining any sexual function, and the gender clinic doctors either don’t tell them, or lie to these children and claim “everything will be fine.”

I’ve seen this happen: a gender doctor deny the reality that a child will have any sexual function or fertility. They’re lying to themselves as much as the patient.

So as much as there are unknowns that cannot be consented to, there are known that can be predicted that children are not and cannot be adequately consented to, often on purpose.

nolongersurprised · 14/02/2023 02:56

housemaus · 13/02/2023 20:51

Do you also believe only over-25s should be able to vote, join the army, buy houses, etc? What about other medical decisions - can under 25 year old adults consent to, e.g. drugs like Roaccutane, or chemotherapy drugs, or disease modifying therapies for MS, all of which can have very severe side effects?

Chemotherapy and roaccutane come with recognised side effects. They are studied and documented.

It’s not just that wrong-sex hormones and blockers are serious, it’s that no one actually knows what the fuck will happen long term How is that consent?

Let’s take a few examples:

Male, treated with puberty blockers at Tanner stage 2, then oestrogen, spironolactone. Now 21, has a micro penis, never had an orgasm. Would quite like to have fertility and sexual function, comes off wrong-sex hormones, hopes his testes will start producing testosterone.

Will he regain any lost sexual function? Probably not, but who knows? There’s no research.

female, aged 20, gone through a female puberty,no blockers, wants testosterone. Not sure whether she may want to get pregnant “later on”. Has heard of “seahorse” dads who become pregnant.

She wants to know how long she’ll have to come off testosterone for that to happen. What do you tell her? No one knows. She wants to know her risk of vaginal atrophy, uterine atrophy. What do you tell her? She has a family history of heart disease, she wants to know if testosterone will increase her individual risk? Will her life expectancy be reduced by exogenous testosterone?

What do you tell her? No one knows.

Mommawasafarmgirl · 14/02/2023 01:55

Many of these people are too young and inexperienced and troubled to make properly informed decisions @housemaus. That’s what makes it so heartbreaking. Those of us who have lived longer know that many will regret their actions and wonder why someone didn't help them when they needed help.

housemaus · 13/02/2023 20:53

Empowermenomore · 13/02/2023 19:30

Tears to my eyes! Really moving to read this as I also have first hand experience of what GIDS was about.

My friend DD, now a trans man is autistic and full of it to the point of setting a crowdfunding to have the top surgery, which is euphemism for double mastectomy, rather than wait on NHS.

Most of these girls haven’t had sexual experiences yet. They do not understand what they are giving up.

😭

Find it very, very weird you're crying over the potential sexual experiences of a young person who evidently does not want to have those experiences.

housemaus · 13/02/2023 20:51

jeaux90 · 11/02/2023 09:47

YANBU OP. It's a decision for adults to make and when I say adults I mean over 25. And even then some of the de transitioning stories are from adults who did this in their 30s etc

I'd go further and say no adult should transition without a shed load of counselling that explores all aspects.

I try and maintain a mental separation between this insidious ideology and those who suffer from awful dysphoria.

Do you also believe only over-25s should be able to vote, join the army, buy houses, etc? What about other medical decisions - can under 25 year old adults consent to, e.g. drugs like Roaccutane, or chemotherapy drugs, or disease modifying therapies for MS, all of which can have very severe side effects?

FrancescaContini · 13/02/2023 20:23

@Mommawasafarmgirl You only focus on clothing and appearance rather than the larger issue of the different activities being offered to boys and girls which @SnackSizeRaisin implied is common.

I certainly agree that making clothing for girls that seems to be “skimpier” or shorter etc than the equivalents for boys is simply outrageous BUT as parents we can choose not to buy such clothing for our daughters and instead allow them to wear clothes that enable them to move freely and feel warm/cool and comfortable.

Equally, teenagers can choose not to adopt the narrow, fake Love Island “look”. I don’t see much of this at all in the young people around me so perhaps it depends on where you are in the UK.

So I still disagree with @SnackSizeRaisin ’s point about there being fixed expectations of the different sexes. It’s perfectly possible to raise your children free of regressive, narrow stereotypes. Many of us brought up in the 70s and 80s were raised in this way without any talk of “being born in the wrong body”.

Empowermenomore · 13/02/2023 19:30

Tears to my eyes! Really moving to read this as I also have first hand experience of what GIDS was about.

My friend DD, now a trans man is autistic and full of it to the point of setting a crowdfunding to have the top surgery, which is euphemism for double mastectomy, rather than wait on NHS.

Most of these girls haven’t had sexual experiences yet. They do not understand what they are giving up.

😭

Mommawasafarmgirl · 13/02/2023 09:41

I do see @SnackSizeRaisin's point, @FrancescaContini. Yes, there have been a lot of changes since the 1900s, but we're not there yet.

Re clothing - there are often threads on MN complaining that girls' clothing is that bit skimpier than boys' clothing. Girls' shorts, for example, are generally shorter and/or tighter than boys' shorts - and this is true even for young children.

A bit difference I see these days is the effort that teen girls go to for a night out on town. The tiny dresses, the make-up, the heels. Absolutely fine if it were all optional of course, but I fear it's not, not really. And it must be a lot of pressure for at least some of the girls who are just becoming accustomed to their changing bodies. I'm an oldie and when I was a teen in the 80s it was absolutely fine to attend a disco in your jeans and plaid shirt. I don't know, the expectations and focus on apperance these days - in particular on girls and young women - doesn't seem like much progress to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread