Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'gender affirming care" is barbaric and should be banned?

211 replies

Appalonia · 10/02/2023 21:12

This article is from the US but these procedures have been carried out in the UK. Teenagers who are confused and vulnerable do not have the mental capacity to consent to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones or life altering surgery.

Please read this devastating article from a whistleblower who has been working in a gender clinic in the US.

www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Helleofabore · 25/02/2023 08:11

What has continued to stick with me overnight was this description:

”This author is a male who describes themselves as an Activist, content creator, legislative researcher, as well as a 'mom' and a Dungeon Master in Dungeons and Dragons.”

What ‘legislative researcher’ would publish something that is so full of poorly substantiated claims, misrepresentation, and what can only be perceived as lies? If that article was supposed to be a portfolio of their work, I would be surprised if they were ever asked to do it on behalf of anything group. I would also be surprised if any person doing a background check would use anything this person presented as credible.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 18:55

WiIson · 24/02/2023 18:49

😆 you're doing a good job of giving up. Hats off to you for perseverance though. It is appreciated.

I don’t think any poster has ever complained about my lack of tenacity… ever. So if I am giving up, it is an insurmountable task… 😂

Thanks for the gin boiled!

Happylittlechicken · 24/02/2023 18:52

@Helleofabore gin and cheese straw? You deserve both.

WiIson · 24/02/2023 18:49

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 17:43

No. I have given up.

😆 you're doing a good job of giving up. Hats off to you for perseverance though. It is appreciated.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 17:49

Just this last lie:

"97.5% of trans youth are stable in their gender identities even 5 years after social transition according to the journal Pediatrics."

Er no. This seems to miss the evidence that has been found in multiple studies and clinical notes now that show huge rates of desistance. And seems to be incongruent with the numbers that are starting to appear about detransitioners.

I will be happy to post (I think I already have on this thread anyway) studies/papers that show detransition rates of 8+% .

Please @Keeley1472 Can you please do fact checking on anything that you post in the future so that these very harmful types of articles are not promoted.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 17:43

WiIson · 24/02/2023 17:38

True. It's energy sapping isn't it. But it needs to be done.

No. I have given up.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 17:42

Erin Reed says:

"Here Jamie repeats anti-trans talking points here blaming gender dysphoria on all other things than being trans. Bizarrely, she includes obesity here. While many transgender people have concurrent disorders, there is no established research showing being “trans” is caused by anything else."

I have already posted about co-morbidities on this thread. Erin Reed seems to have missed the many gender clinic statistics and clinicians all talking about co-morbidities.

However, Erin Reed seems to actually believe that the paragraphs that Jamie wrote "blaming gender dysphoria on all other things than being trans". No. Jamie wrote about co-morbidities.

Erin Reed just built a straw man and burned it to the ground. But entirely misrepresented what Jamie said, and what Jamie said is now well documented. Read the Cass report, read many other clinicians and experts looking at the data. In fact, Jamie Reed linked the Cass Report to the very paragraph that Erin Reed quoted... but removed the link!

Here is another straw man:

"The idea that autistic individuals cannot be LGBT+ unfairly targets autistic people who have pushed back hard against the idea that their diagnosis means they cannot experience genuine gender identities or seuxal (sic) orientations. "

"Lastly, concurrent mental health problems are often solved by transitioning."

No. There is no reputable, peer reviewed and recognised evidence to support this. In fact, this is actually very harmful misinformation.

Evidence shows that transitioning does NOT 'solve' mental health problems, particularly 'concurrent' ones. Read the post at Today 12:47 and watch this video.

Why would any poster post this kind of misinformation? It is truly harmful to trans people to have this very dishonest take promoted.

"There are several things to point out here. First of all, she admits that those who came through her clinic doors saw therapists. Secondly, though she says they only had to see the therapist once or twice, she does not state if that was the case for all or even most of her patients. It is indeed possible that most of her patients had continued to see therapists throughout their clinical journeys and beyond - this is certainly the case for most families of trans youth I have spoken to."

So here Erin Reed discounts Jamie's experience as 'anecdotal' with Erin's own 'anecdotal' experience. Jamie did not actually quantify how many patients she referred as only being seen once or twice either. Erin Reed used cognitive distortion there.

Erin Reed also uses false suicide statistics in this 'debunking' article.

I am not going to bother to go through this any further. I have reached not even a quarter of the way through and the errors, the misinformation and the blatant falsities and bad faith twists are too numerous.

I do look forward to @Keeley1472 though coming back. maybe they read ahead and can point out the facts and and the evidence further along that were correct and accurate.

WiIson · 24/02/2023 17:38

True. It's energy sapping isn't it. But it needs to be done.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 17:27

Sadly Wilson, the only way we can counter analysis such as the one Keeley posted, is to show very clearly the absolute bollocks that the authors write.

WiIson · 24/02/2023 17:22

I read the article Keeley posted. Things I took away from this:

The author is not good at maths or stats.

They based their shonky premise on poor maths and stats.

I wish people would stop posting this junk as some sort of evidence, forcing me to go through and read it.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 17:17

This was posted and the poster obviously found this to be highly compelling and absolutely convincing. I think it is worth evaluating for any reader who also finds it thus.

This author is a male who describes themselves as an Activist, content creator, legislative research, as well as a 'mom' and a Dungeon Master in Dungeons and Dragons.

They have a pinned tweet that says:

Erin inthemorning Aug 7, 2021

"Hey y’all. Are you looking for HRT but don’t know where to start? Worried about therapist letters and gatekeepers? I made this two years ago and have maintained it since. EVERY informed consent HRT spot in the country. No therapist required."

So, let us be clear. This person is a male calling themselves 'mom' and is publicly promoting hormones without any diagnosis. And this person feels that they have enough expertise to call out the experience of Jamie Reed. And does this with supposedly a straight face when they wrote:

"She is not a doctor, a psychologist, a psychiatrist, and does not have direct medical diagnostic experience with patients. She is a case worker, someone who navigates insurance claims and takes intake calls. Throughout her story, she places her own interpretations of events above those of medically educated providers, therapists, and the families and patients that work with them."

OK. So a 'case worker' who saw some horrendous issues and has finally reached the point she wishes to write about them is to be dismissed because Erin Reed who doesn't seem to be "a doctor, a psychologist, a psychiatrist, and does not have direct medical diagnostic experience with patients" doesn't like what Jamie Reed wrote.

And Erin Reed goes on to ignore the interpretations of events above those of medically educated providers, therapists, and the families and patients that work with them. that don't seem to support most of what Erin Reed says. Yet, Keely wants readers to believe Erin Reed over Jamie Reed. (And that is really confusing having the same last name)

In fact, Keely, this person you have posted about seems to have completely ignored the fact that Jamie Reed is married to a female transitioner! Erin Reed conveniently ignores that, Jamie mentioned it in paragraph 2, to attempt to portray Jamie as

"Her statements and omissions reveal a clear ideological bias, and the organizations and representation she has chosen to work with contradict her claim that she “supports transgender people.”"

Do you find that credible?

By the way, I don't care about 'the timing' of Jamie Reed's article. Because at the moment there is so much happening that I suspect that according to Erin Reed there would always be something happening that they felt would call Jamie Reed's article into suspicious.

Plus, the logic doesn't stack up. What the fuck does it matter when it came out? Is it true? Did Jamie make it up? That is the ONLY things relevant here.

Erin Reed also tries to position Jamie Reed as 'right wing' because Erin wishes people to believe that only 'right wing' people could possibly have this view. Jamie also states she is even more to the 'left' than Bernie Sanders who is a Democrat. ie. she is a left wing lesbian. Another convenient thing Erin has forgotten.

Social contagion and ROGD

Erin Reed questions the % of trans people that Jamie saw compared to the expected St Louis population of trans people to attempt to discount Jamie's anecdotes. Why is this relevant? It is not.

Jamie's article is about the clinic she worked in and what she saw happening there.

This is another squirrel moment and a ridiculous one.

Erin attempts to say that there is solid evidence that 'social contagion' and "ROGD" is not happening. There are HUGE glaring faults here.

"As for sex differences of coming out, this too has been disputed by research. Trans masculine individuals (who this writer references as “girls” and often misgenders throughout her document) are not “more likely” to identify as trans"

And yet, this very thing has been documented and published in the clinic figures for numerous countries around the world.

segm.org has a chart on their home page from the UK GIDS reports that shows this very clearly.

There IS one thing that works in Erin's favour here, there is currently NO peer reviewed paper that names the phenomenon of what is happening.

Dr Cass is very aware of the phenomenon. I have been through this on this very thread.

cass.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Cass-Review_Letter-to-NHSE_Jan23.pdf

P.32 of the interim report states:

"In the last few years, there has been a significant change in the numbers and case-mix of children and young people being referred to GIDS. From a baseline of approximately 50 referrals per annum in 2009, there was a steep increase from 2014-15, and at the time of the CQC inspection of the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust in October 2020 there were 2,500 children and young people being referred per annum, 4,600 children and young people on the waiting list, and a waiting time of over two years to first appointment. This has severely impacted on the capacity of the existing service to manage referrals in the safe and responsive way that they aspire to and has led to considerable distress for those on the waiting list. "

"This increase in referrals has been accompanied by a change in the case-mix from predominantly birth-registered males presenting with gender incongruence from an early age, to predominantly birth-registered females presenting with later onset of reported gender incongruence in early teen years. In addition, approximately one third of children and young people referred to GIDS have autism or other types of neurodiversity. There is also an over-representation percentage wise (compared to the national percentage) of looked after children."

P. 33 has the same chart that SEGM has on their home page and these are the stats from that table and chart.

These statistics are from the Cass Report but they are findable elsewhere and they follow the trend in other countries as well.

In 2009, 15 Adolescent female patients were referred to GIDS and 2 Children. That is 17.

In 2016, 1071 Adolescent female patients and 138 Children. That is 1209.

This represents a 7012% increase.

In 2009, 24 Adolescent male patients were referred to GIDS and 10 Children.
That is 34.

In 2016, 426 Adolescent male patients and 131 Children. That is 557.

This represents a 1538% increase.

I posted this on page 10 of this thread. If anyone wishes to support Erin Reed's view on how Jamie was wrong, I am happy to hear it with some supporting evidence.

I will crack on with a few more points that Erin Reed brings up. But frankly, there seems to be ever so much misinformation here.

In fact, my post at Today 12:47 seems even more relevant for @Keeley1472 to read I think.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 16:15

Keeley1472 · 24/02/2023 13:35

I know this article you linked is convincing on fist read. But it’s not written in good faith.

please read this analysis too for a bit more of the broader context of how this piece of writing came to be in your feed.

erininthemorn.substack.com/p/missouri-anti-trans-whistleblower

Before I go through this @Keeley1472 , would you like to tell us what you found convincing about this? What points convinced you?

And fill us in on the background of the person who wrote it, please. Why is this person a reliable person to 'debunk' the article in your mind?

Keeley1472 · 24/02/2023 13:35

I know this article you linked is convincing on fist read. But it’s not written in good faith.

please read this analysis too for a bit more of the broader context of how this piece of writing came to be in your feed.

erininthemorn.substack.com/p/missouri-anti-trans-whistleblower

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 13:18

One more thing I was reminded of that Matilda Gosling from the Sex Matters webinar reminded me of regarding 'detransitioner' rates.

academic.oup.com/jcem/article-abstract/107/9/e3937/6572526?redirectedFrom=fulltext&login=false

”Continuation of Gender-affirming Hormones Among Transgender Adolescents and Adults”

Christina M Roberts,
David A Klein, Terry A Adirim,
Natasha A Schvey, Elizabeth Hisle-Gorman

22 April 2022

Results
The study sample included 627 transmasculine and 325 transfeminine individuals with an average age of 19.2 ± 5.3 years. The 4-year gender-affirming hormone continuation rate was 70.2% (95% CI, 63.9-76.5). Transfeminine individuals had a higher continuation rate than transmasculine individuals 81.0% (72.0%-90.0%) vs 64.4% (56.0%-72.8%). People who started hormones as minors had higher continuation rate than people who started as adults 74.4% (66.0%-82.8%) vs 64.4% (56.0%-72.8%). Continuation was not associated with household income or family member type. In Cox regression, both transmasculine gender identity (hazard ratio, 2.40; 95% CI, 1.50-3.86) and starting hormones as an adult (hazard ratio, 1.69; 95% CI, 1.14-2.52) were independently associated with increased discontinuation rates.

The important part here:

"The 4-year gender-affirming hormone continuation rate was 70.2% (95% CI, 63.9-76.5)."

If after 4 years ONLY 70.2% have continued hormones, that shows a 30% hormone cessation rate. How many of those have 'detransitioned'? Well, potentially a very large portion of them. The rate for females ceasing hormone therapy was 35% after 4 years. If a female has not had a complete hysterectomy, why would they stop hormones and restart menstruation if they were still transitioned?

Can the mounting evidence be ANY clearer? There are issues that are starting to show the cracks.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 13:12

Tandora · 12/02/2023 10:11

By “open exploratory therapy” , you mean conversion therapy to try persuade them to be normal because people like you don’t like it otherwise.

Just adding these comments from the BMJ article to this very clearly poorly informed take from Tandora. Poorly informed because all that Tandora has done for a couple of threads now is show just how ideologically based their understanding of medical treatment for females and in particular for adolescent female transitioners is.

under the heading of The rush to affirm

Sarah Palmer, a paediatrician in private practice in Indiana, is one of five coauthors of a 2022 resolution submitted to the AAP’s leadership conference asking that it revisit the policy after “a rigorous systematic review of available evidence regarding the safety, efficacy, and risks of childhood social transition, puberty blockers, cross sex hormones and surgery.” In practice, Palmer told The BMJ, clinicians define “gender affirming” care so broadly that “it’s been taken by many people to mean go ahead and do anything that affirms. One of the main things I’ve seen it used for is masculinising chest surgery, also known as mastectomy in teenage patients.” The AAP has told The BMJ that all policy statements are reviewed after five years and so a “revision is under way,” based on its experts’ own “robust evidence review.”

Palmer says, “I’ve seen a quick evolution, from kids with a very rare case of gender dysphoria who were treated with a long course of counselling and exploration before hormones were started,” to treatment progressing “very quickly—even at the first visit to gender clinic—and there’s no psychologist involved anymore.”

Laura Edwards-Leeper, a clinical psychologist who worked with the endocrinologist Norman Spack in Boston and coauthored the WPATH guidelines for adolescents, has observed a similar trend. “More providers do not value the mental health component,” she says, so in some clinics families come in and their child is “pretty much fast tracked to medical intervention.” In a study of teens at Seattle Children’s Hospital’s gender clinic, two thirds were taking hormones within 12 months of the initial visit.38

These are clinicians ALL stating that not enough exploratory therapy, if any, is being given, while expressing concern at this.

ONLY a person deeply believing in ideology would continue to frame exploratory therapy with conversion therapy.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 13:00

Sex Matters had a webinar this week with Dr Michael Biggs and Matilda Gosling.

Sex Matters child gender medicine webinar 23rd February 2023

This is a pretty good wrap up of where this 'evidence' is currently and some of the back ground. Including the fact that the first patient of the Dutch Protocol, a female transitioner was reported to have told the Dutch clinicians that they were still gender dysphoric after TWO DECADES and clinicians still reported this as some sort of success.

Plus Matilda pointed out this pertinent bit of information which I have snatched off the Break it down from me post.

There is a slide in this presentation at 25.20 that I think is crucial to understand. That Wiepjes

Time to follow-up 4.6 yrs
Time to regret - 10.8 yrs

van der Loos et al (2023) & Wiepjes et al (2018)

That time to regret was noted in this study

academic.oup.com/jsm/article/15/4/582/6980345?login=false

"The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets". April 2018

Chantal M. Wiepjes et al.

"in our population the average time to regret was 130 months, so it might be too early to examine regret rates in people who started with HT in the past 10 years."

So, for all those people, including posters on this thread, who are constantly minimising the 'detransitioner' numbers, what the fuck do they think is going to start happening in a matter of years? What the fuck do they think the scenario is going to look like by the end of this decade considering the numbers now speaking out?

It really is time for some of these people to either stop falling back on the very childish 'you are all ignorant' and actually read what is being posted and stop childishly dismissing anything that they don't like the author of without coming up with their own dissection of what that author is saying.

Helleofabore · 24/02/2023 12:47

Hi @Appalonia, I hope you don't mind but this week has seen another flurry of content that anyone with any interest in 'gender affirming care' should be reading or watching.

This week seems to be about the appalling weakness of evidence that has formed the basis of these treatment plans. You never know, posters like Tandora might actually start taking notice of what many of us are saying if they really do care about the standard of medical treatment recommendations. Rather than saying they do yet never once acknowledging the issues with it. That is a very sure sign of ideological thinking, yet those posters will also never either see that or acknowledge that.

www.bmj.com/content/380/bmj.p382

Gender dysphoria in young people is rising—and so is professional disagreement

Jennifer Block, investigations reporter 23 February 2023

These are just a few of the relevant paragraphs:

Guyatt, who co-developed GRADE, found “serious problems” with the Endocrine Society guidelines, noting that the systematic reviews didn’t look at the effect of the interventions on gender dysphoria itself, arguably “the most important outcome.” He also noted that the Endocrine Society had at times paired strong recommendations—phrased as “we recommend”—with weak evidence. In the adolescent section, the weaker phrasing “we suggest” is used for pubertal hormone suppression when children “first exhibit physical changes of puberty”; however, the stronger phrasing is used to “recommend” GnRHa treatment.

“GRADE discourages strong recommendations with low or very low quality evidence except under very specific circumstances,” Guyatt told The BMJ. Those exceptions are “very few and far between,” and when used in guidance, their rationale should be made explicit, Guyatt said. In an emailed response, the Endocrine Society referenced the GRADE system’s five exceptions, but did not specify which it was applying.

Helfand examined the recently updated WPATH Standards of Care and noted that it “incorporated elements of an evidence based guideline.” For one, WPATH commissioned a team at Johns Hopkins University in Maryland to conduct systematic reviews.3435 However, WPATH’s recommendations lack a grading system to indicate the quality of the evidence—one of several deficiencies. Both Guyatt and Helfand noted that a trustworthy guideline would be transparent about all commissioned systematic reviews: how many were done and what the results were. But Helfand remarked that neither was made clear in the WPATH guidelines and also noted several instances in which the strength of evidence presented to justify a recommendation was “at odds with what their own systematic reviewers found.”

For example, one of the commissioned systematic reviews found that the strength of evidence for the conclusions that hormonal treatment “may improve” quality of life, depression, and anxiety among transgender people was “low,” and it emphasised the need for more research, “especially among adolescents.”35 The reviewers also concluded that “it was impossible to draw conclusions about the effects of hormone therapy” on death by suicide.

Despite this, WPATH recommends that young people have access to treatments after comprehensive assessment, stating that the “emerging evidence base indicates a general improvement in the lives of transgender adolescents.”12 And more globally, WPATH asserts, “There is strong evidence demonstrating the benefits in quality of life and well-being of gender-affirming treatments, including endocrine and surgical procedures,” procedures that “are based on decades of clinical experience and research; therefore, they are not considered experimental, cosmetic, or for the mere convenience of a patient. They are safe and effective at reducing gender incongruence and gender dysphoria.”12

and

Sweden conducted systematic reviews in 2015 and 2022 and found the evidence on hormonal treatment in adolescents “insufficient and inconclusive.”24 Its new guidelines note the importance of factoring the possibility that young people will detransition, in which case “gender confirming treatment thus may lead to a deteriorating of health and quality of life (i.e., harm).”

Cochrane, an international organisation that has built its reputation on delivering independent evidence reviews, has yet to publish a systematic review of gender treatments in minors. But The BMJ has learnt that in 2020 Cochrane accepted a proposal to review puberty blockers and that it worked with a team of researchers through 2021 in developing a protocol, but it ultimately rejected it after peer review. A spokesperson for Cochrane told The BMJ that its editors have to consider whether a review “would add value to the existing evidence base,” highlighting the work of the UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, which looked at puberty blockers and hormones for adolescents in 2021. “That review found the evidence to be inconclusive, and there have been no significant primary studies published since.”

In 2022 the state of Florida’s Agency for Health Care Administration commissioned an overview of systematic reviews looking at outcomes “important to patients” with gender dysphoria, including mental health, quality of life, and complications. Two health research methodologists at McMaster University carried out the work, analysing 61 systematic reviews and concluding that “there is great uncertainty about the effects of puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries in young people.” The body of evidence, they said, was “not sufficient” to support treatment decisions.

Appalonia · 19/02/2023 23:21

That documentary is fantastic. It sets out the facts very clearly, has insightful comments from therapists and from many detransitioners who talk about how quickly they were transitioned and the devastating effects it had on them. It deserves to be widely shared and I really wish the BBC or C4 would have the guts to show it, as it would blow this whole deceitful mess wide open. Sadly I doubt this will happen, so PLEASE share it within your own circle of influence. We will not stop talking about this until these abhorrent practices in children are banned.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 19/02/2023 23:00

there is quite a lot coming out at the moment. Here is a documentary about US gender care, the back ground, just a sample of the detransitioners speaking up (these were detransitioners I hadn’t seen before, some were trans social media influencers at the vanguard of social media influencing).

This documentary has clinician voices as well.

It is a very clear documentary that raises many questions while answering many as well. This should be something that everyone commenting on threads should watch.

affirmationgenerationmovie.com/

Affirming Generation. It is high quality and free to view.

Helleofabore · 18/02/2023 15:47

Just adding this from this weekend. It is not just the UK. Australia is raising the alarms as well.

Doctor scrutiny on gender clinic reveals legal and safety fears
The Australian , Natasha Robinson, 17th February 2023

archive.ph/DMT87

"Senior physicians at the NSW Children’s Hospital Westmead’s gender clinic have studied the physical and mental health of 79 patients in a rare academic study of the outcomes of children who presented with gender distress and gender dysphoria. The findings cast doubt on the scientific basis of the gender-affirming approach followed by the nation’s other children’s hospitals."

"In an open access academic paper, CHW psychiatrists, endocrinologists and other physicians, and a senior medical ethics expert, called for a “much more nuanced and complex approach” as analysis revealed 88 per cent of children presenting at Westmead’s gender clinic had at least one co-morbid mental health condition, with more than 50 per cent diagnosed with behavioural disorders or autism. One in five children who consulted the clinic with gender-related distress later had these feelings resolved, and almost one in 10 with a formal diagnosis of gender dysphoria, some who had taken puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, later discontinued transitioning."

And

"The CHW doctors have raised concerns that “many unknowns remain” regarding the long-term effects of puberty blockers, which are described by the Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne as “reversible in their effects”. International evidence is in fact casting greater doubt on whether the effects of these medications are reversible. Endocrine reviews of the CHW patient cohort documented side-effects in 23 of the 49 young people prescribed puberty blockers, including low bone density, hot flushes, weight gain and anxiety. The CHW doctors raised concerns about long-term effects on patients’ sexual function in adulthood."

"Within the 9 per cent cohort of patients with a diagnosis of gender dysphoria who had desisted – that is, discontinued the transgender pathway 4-9 years after consulting the gender clinic – three had undergone puberty suppression beginning at the average age of 12. Three had taken cross-sex hormones, one from as young as 15, but not prescribed by CHW. The effects of cross-sex hormones, including infertility, are irreversible."

The article above refers to

Distress: A Prospective Follow-Up Study

by Joseph Elkadi, Catherine Chudleigh, Ann M. Maguire, Geoffrey R. Ambler, Stephen Scher and Kasia Kozlowska

www.mdpi.com/2227-9067/10/2/314

Across the world the alarms are being raised. And still we have posters who will try to frame people raising the alarm on MN as being hateful in an attempt to silence or dismiss what is being said.

I truly wonder just at what point those posters will admit there are issues that need to be addressed with the affirming only treatment paths that have been pushed by groups so heavily invested they will not listen to the clinicians they expect to do these treatments.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 17:00

Vebrithien

I saw this the other day. She said on 31st January

"The Review will continue to share information as it becomes available, and I anticipate submitting a final report to NHSE by the end of the year."

cass.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Cass-Review_Letter-to-NHSE_Jan23.pdf

There may be some more findings released in summer if I am reading this letter correctly.

Vebrithien · 14/02/2023 16:37

Does any know when we can expect the full Cass report?

SinnerBoy · 14/02/2023 15:10

Yes, indeed.

RedToothBrush · 14/02/2023 14:24

SinnerBoy · 14/02/2023 12:16

However, it is a great live demonstration of the tactics used of emotional manipulation, dishonest posting and twisted takes used to try to discredit others.

Yes, the "Shut up and agree with me, or you're a racist and you smell!" tactic, which teenagers tend to have abandoned.

The adults amplifying the teenage level arguments and the publishers tolerating the teenage level arguments in the work place and the people in medicine who are bowing to the teenage level argument...

...are kinda scary tbh.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2023 13:09

I suspect next the comments will be along the line of 'this is a book written by a transphobic investigative journalist who hates trans people and so do all the therapists, surgeons and other clinicians contributing. And it is just a few clinicians, not many - all the rest must agree because they don't say anything'.

That is the level of discourse we seem to be at. Anything perceived to be negative, let's just portray it is 'hate', as 'ignorance' and hope everyone else reading will dismiss it. Because, there can be 'no debate'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread