Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being mistaken for the PA

515 replies

BingBoings · 10/02/2023 21:11

Twice this week I have been in email chains, where I have been asked to supply dates for a meeting.

The reason for this has in both cases, I assume, is that I am the only female name in the thread.

Both situations have seen large numbers of clients and colleagues copied in on emails where… I am asked if I can help give times when my male colleagues are free. I am usually senior to them.

Am I the only person this happens to? I find it half hilarious, and half embarrassing… A few months ago I was asked in a meeting if I could do coffees when I walked in…

i have no issue with managing my own diary nor is there any issue with being a PA… it’s more that I don’t see men having this issue…!

OP posts:
RealBecca · 11/02/2023 13:33

Women, Queen or otherwise, don't owe you NICE, Mark.

MavisFlump · 11/02/2023 13:31

Mark19735 · 10/02/2023 23:13

Hate to say it, but it's only status-obsessed people with a high need for social approval that even give a shit about this sort of thing.

Most people with genuine gravitas and authority couldn't care less. They'll make the brews, and they'll take the brews that others make for them. without a second thought about what it means or how looks. It's inconsequential trivia.

Obsessing about symbols of power and prestige is one of the clearest signals that reveals you don't really merit it.

I completely agree. I was CEO of a large countywide charity, the male CEO’s of three neighbouring counties were so self-obsessed with their status they treated any females in the room with utter disdain.
It would have been amusing if it wasn’t so depressing.
They’re still as obnoxious from what I hear, 10 years after I left.

lieselotte · 11/02/2023 13:30

Mark19735 · 10/02/2023 23:13

Hate to say it, but it's only status-obsessed people with a high need for social approval that even give a shit about this sort of thing.

Most people with genuine gravitas and authority couldn't care less. They'll make the brews, and they'll take the brews that others make for them. without a second thought about what it means or how looks. It's inconsequential trivia.

Obsessing about symbols of power and prestige is one of the clearest signals that reveals you don't really merit it.

Not true. As I said above - women tend to do the non-promotable tasks and it has an adverse affect on their careers.

They volunteer to do them

They are expected to do them

And are thought badly of when they don't do them.

theEndwhen · 11/02/2023 13:28

AuntSallie · 11/02/2023 13:14

That’s awful and is both racism and sexism, how dare your headteacher publicly humiliate you like that. Feeling rage on your behalf. No wonder you were gobsmacked.

Wow, I saw the sexism but not the racism - maybe I've ben subjected to it for so long I am immune nowadays - my country is very racist too with its own people (lots of ethnicities mixed together)

What shocked me a lot also was other women not siding with me, laughing, minimising or being plain blind to what happened

So many crazy stories about that HT and school, the best thing I did was to leave

ThreeblackCats · 11/02/2023 13:23

“Can you make coffee/book next meeting/give oral?”

yes I can, because I’m a woman and can do more than just my job! Can you?

cooldarkroom · 11/02/2023 13:23

I had a really horrid rep. come into the work place I own, all letchy & cock sure of himself, I was the only person in the shop over lunchtime. He asked if I wanted to go & get a bite, or more if willing....nod nod wink wink.... & fill him in on the owner, & any tips to get a sale...
I said no to lunch & he'd have to make aptmt.... with me.

Walkaround · 11/02/2023 13:20

Naunet · 11/02/2023 12:50

So what, women should just embrace these things and not challenge men because if we do, somehow that’s shitting on other women? Come off it, that’s not how job roles work, and it’s not slavery to expect the PA to do their own job rather than having it delegated to the nearest person with a vagina.

No, women should not do as they are told if randomly asked to make coffee or take the minutes. Women as a group should stop looking down on these tasks and playing the same game as men of casting around for whoever is deemed the least important person to do them. As a group, women should question poor leadership and management skills more, rather than aping the inadequate behaviours. What idiot is responsible for not organising the meeting properly in the first place? Why the need to scrabble around at the last minute to find someone to take the minutes or make the coffee? Why was this not already thought of? Is it important or isn’t it? Is it important that it is done well? Why does nobody want to do it if it is actually an important function? If it isn’t, then why should anyone provide it? Can you do without it? Would what has been agreed be done properly if nobody recorded the meeting properly, or could misunderstandings arise? Would people remember what was said?

What is wrong with the leadership and management if they can’t organise a meeting properly? What are they being paid for if they can’t get that right?

lieselotte · 11/02/2023 13:20

There's actually a book on this that I read recently - not on sexism per se but on the fact that women tend to do the office wife work and less valuable work which is less promotable.

Everyone needs to do their share of the smaller tasks that make the office work, but it's usually women who do many more of them - and then don't get promoted. I can't remember the name of it now - something like The No Club. Well worth a read, though focused on the US.

lieselotte · 11/02/2023 13:18

RustyNails · 10/02/2023 21:35

You say you are senior to them do you think maybe they will work around your availability for the meeting? I'm a career EA when organising meetings I base it on the availability of the most senior attendees everyone else needs to make themselves available. I do this for both men and women.

When I arrange meetings I find a slot that appears to suit everyone. I don't expect everyone else to shuffle meetings around to suit the most senior person. There is nothing more annoying than having meetings moved around - I always think why can't they just tell the other person they are busy. Now I know!

I wonder if these sexist men ever do this to younger but senior women when there's an older woman in the room. If they did it in front of me, I would definitely say something!

TheMamaYo · 11/02/2023 13:15

@Mark19735 Take a taxi to 2023 Dear. I’ll pay.

AuntSallie · 11/02/2023 13:14

PositiveIntelligence · 11/02/2023 10:40

I’m a foreiner from a tropical country where the women are usually seen by tourists as sex objects.

In my last job as a TA at a primary school, we moved to a new building - there was a male inspector (not ofsted) coming and the female headteacher said in a brief meeting in front of everybody:

“maybe PositiveIntelligence can give him a tour of the building and distract him with her exotic looks and accent to make sure he doesn’t pay attention to what is not working properly”

This is a woman who prides herself in being progressive and feminist

All of the staff in the meeting were females and they though it was hilarious, no one challenged it.

I was shocked but managed to say:

“I will have to check my contract firts to see if this fits with my job role, I don’t remember signing up for this”

I wish I had come back with something a lot better but in the heat of the moment, that was the best I could do.
Some people told me I was too harsh and should have taken as a compliment 🙀

Now I work in a completely different profession which is mainly male dominated but luckly enough the majority of the SLT are females and I’ve not come accross any mysogeny yet.

That’s awful and is both racism and sexism, how dare your headteacher publicly humiliate you like that. Feeling rage on your behalf. No wonder you were gobsmacked.

Twatalert · 11/02/2023 13:12

Tribollite · 11/02/2023 11:47

I know a few PAs that prefer working for men. The reason being that some senior women are so keen to differentiate themselves from PAs /junior staff and be hard-as-nails that they can be unpleasant to work for.

I have come across some horrendous senior women. They are often bitter about how they were treated in the past and how much harder they have had to work to become so senior, in addition to some own ingrained sexism. Men tend to be just sexist. I have never seen the same bitterness.

Frightingly, I have spotted that bitterness in myself. Because I did have to push harder to get promoted etc. and still feel I have to be on the lookout so I don't get treated unfairly again.

G5000 · 11/02/2023 13:10

Yes Mark, I'm sure all non-white men telling similar stories are also just status-obsessed, because aren't all doctors routinely mistaken for nurses/janitors? Odd though that I haven't seen any white male doctors telling similar stories, but I'm sure the reason is that they are True Kings and not anything systemic.

Jaxhog · 11/02/2023 13:06

This used to happen to me all the time when I was younger. My best experience was when I delivered some papers to my boss in construction. One of the other men asked me to make some tea and my boss stood up and said chillingly 'Jaxhog is my best site engineer, she has better thing to do than make drinks for you'. Another boss 'keeper'.

Now that I'm older, I've apparently become 'scary' so don't get asked anymore.

Cosyblankets · 11/02/2023 13:02

TheodoreMortlock · 11/02/2023 11:21

I did a weekend training event where external trainers came in to our office. Those of us on the course were two women and about 12 men. The boss had organised sandwiches to be collected - we should have had a junior admin dealing with it but he called in sick. On the Saturday morning when the training providers (both men) came in, they asked me and the other woman to sort out coffee. We raised an eyebrow and two of the men jumped up to help. At lunchtime, they stopped the two of us ten minutes early so that we could go and collect the sandwiches. And then just to put the cherry on the cake, at the end of the day when we were all given individual feedback, the men got told what they could do to improve their performance and we got "TheodoreMortlock and "Katie," could you make sure there are pastries for the welcome session tomorrow morning, we'd like pastries with our coffee."

We made a complaint but nothing ever came of it.

So you did get the coffee? And you did get the sandwiches? When you could have just told them where they were.

Fenella123 · 11/02/2023 12:59

Twatalert · 11/02/2023 01:21

Sounds like you are doing OK!

Honest question: throughout your career did you never really observe that you are being treated differently because you are a woman?

I thought these things didn't happen to me until well into my 30s. Turns out it was all so ingrained in me that even I didn't notice. Looking back there were tons of incidents, starting with my first boss calling me a 'good girl' for agreeing to something. No man would ever be called a good boy in a workplace. I was just blind, had no awareness and considered all this normal.

Now I get these things on a different level. Mainly by my male colleagues who think they know my job better than i do. But yes they are dicks too. The more successful my part of the business is the worse they behave.

Back in the 90s, early on in my career, my then-manager said, "Could you (do something I forget what), there's a good girl"

And then he turned white
It was very funny
Even then I had a reputation for being somewhat feral (mellowed a bit with age and more money!).

In his defence he was the father of two young daughters. Since they had come along, his workplace manner had noticeably been more persuasive and collaborative, influenced by his home life - if you try and get little girls to do something by shouting at them they just cry louder, and, if you're really lucky, wet themselves.
It has just spilled over perhaps a bit too much 😎

I'm not sure my monstrous demeanor was of net benefit to me, as it wasn't perhaps the ideal image for promotion either, but OTOH I was never asked to make the coffee. Not only did I look obviously less well turned out than people on the admin side, but they probably worried I would put salt in it 😈

TheaBrandt · 11/02/2023 12:56

Imagine if assumptions were made on job role due to someone’s race? Is that ok mark? Because that’s essentially the same thing.

Twatalert · 11/02/2023 12:54

Cosyblankets · 11/02/2023 08:55

I agree.
And as for some posters saying they were talked over or interrupted or whatever, I would not allow this to happen. I would point it out every single time. They do it because you allow them to get away with it.

I'm pointing it out every single time. 'Name, name (have to say it at least twice), I'm speaking. ' or 'I haven't finished yet'. It seems I work with especially sexist and arrogant pigs. I could see other men in the org doing it, but I think they would stop after a couple of times.

PinkArt · 11/02/2023 12:52

You're such a clever poppet, @Mark19735. One couple not recognising the Queen is exactly the same as hundreds of lived experiences of everyday sexism. Well done you for explaining it to our little lady heads. Girlies, we can get back to the tea making now.

Naunet · 11/02/2023 12:50

Walkaround · 11/02/2023 12:19

It is not only men who are looking down on these tasks. Women are looking down on these tasks. That is why it is deemed to be offensive. When it comes to organising meetings, someone needs to take control, it’s pathetic to play pass the hot potato games with it. The leader of any project should take ownership of this, or specifically and clearly delegate to someone else. It is not beneath anyone to co-ordinate things properly.

As for making everyone coffee at a meeting - again, poor leadership and organisation if people do not have clear expectations and do not feel properly catered for. Enough of this weird slave mentality, where everyone looks for the lowest status person in the room to wait on them.

So what, women should just embrace these things and not challenge men because if we do, somehow that’s shitting on other women? Come off it, that’s not how job roles work, and it’s not slavery to expect the PA to do their own job rather than having it delegated to the nearest person with a vagina.

SamanthaCaine · 11/02/2023 12:49

However, thats not most people in organisations is it? The vast majority of people are fighting for position, promotions, bonuses, for positive feedback from superiors/peers. That goes for male or female, black or white, young or old.

I don't recognise this in my industry, thankfully. But if most people are fighting for their careers then it seems like a good technique that others (men and women) are using to make the competition look inferior. Must work too, if some are actually going off to make tea.

SueG60 · 11/02/2023 12:39

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 11:40

Morning. Wow this thread has been busy.

Lots of interesting perspectives on this thread so far, but none that really change the fundamentals. Little-minded people seem obsessed with job titles, email signatures, and who makes who a coffee. They are easily outraged by every anecdotal instance where assumptions have been incorrectly made, and see everything as a systemic problem. The real rainmakers know that a person's value isn't defined by such trivialities. They are relaxed about it when it happens to them because they know their worth, and it doesn't change based on a job title or who makes the coffee.

Best illustration of this? The story about the Queen and her protection officer meeting American tourists out in Balmoral. They asked her if she'd ever met the Queen and she replied no, but Dick (her protection officer that day) saw her all the time. They then asked her to take a photograph of them with him. Do you think she spent that evening on MN furiously posting about misogyny? Of course not ... because she was an actual Queen! She found it hilarious, and that's exactly what that story is - a funny anecdote about mistaken identity. Real Queens don't care. Nor do Kings. Little people seethe and fume - but really it's a sign of their frustration about their own precarious insignificance - and everyone else in room knows it.

This misses the point though, you're correct in that really senior people often won't care/feel assured in their position.

However, thats not most people in organisations is it? The vast majority of people are fighting for position, promotions, bonuses, for positive feedback from superiors/peers. That goes for male or female, black or white, young or old.

It doesn't help if people subconsciously expect certain characteristics to automatically equal greater competence/seniority, it gives an unfair advantage to those exhibiting those characteristics and is a hurdle that has to be overcome if you don't.

ElsieMc · 11/02/2023 12:36

Oh yes been there. Had a management position and was asked to take the Minutes of a meeting because mine were so much better than the salaried admin lady we had. I was even asked to change something in the minutes which was accurate so I said no because I would not be taking them again and look elsewhere.

Also had to attend meetings with Police as an agency involved where the Chief Inspector used to try and make eye contact with me all the time and give me actions! I mean I was never part of the Police force. Just the only female at the meeting.

NotQuiteHere · 11/02/2023 12:32

VeronicaFranklin · 10/02/2023 21:39

I was once asked in a meeting if I could 'pop out to the shop' to get one of the male managers some Sudafed as he had a cold and was struggling and 'if it isn't too much trouble to grab everyone a Starbucks on the way back would be really helpful'

So I did as asked without question.

When I came back 20 mins later, the meeting hadn't started, everyone sat around looking awkward because as a senior manager, I was chairing it... and consequently everyone was kept an hour later. They assumption was I was a junior note taker, being the only female in the room.

How silly.
You have just wasted everyone's time. Very "efficient" time management demonstrated by a chair of a meeting. I bet the meeting was a complete success in the end.

Chooksnroses · 11/02/2023 12:32

Mark19735 · 11/02/2023 11:40

Morning. Wow this thread has been busy.

Lots of interesting perspectives on this thread so far, but none that really change the fundamentals. Little-minded people seem obsessed with job titles, email signatures, and who makes who a coffee. They are easily outraged by every anecdotal instance where assumptions have been incorrectly made, and see everything as a systemic problem. The real rainmakers know that a person's value isn't defined by such trivialities. They are relaxed about it when it happens to them because they know their worth, and it doesn't change based on a job title or who makes the coffee.

Best illustration of this? The story about the Queen and her protection officer meeting American tourists out in Balmoral. They asked her if she'd ever met the Queen and she replied no, but Dick (her protection officer that day) saw her all the time. They then asked her to take a photograph of them with him. Do you think she spent that evening on MN furiously posting about misogyny? Of course not ... because she was an actual Queen! She found it hilarious, and that's exactly what that story is - a funny anecdote about mistaken identity. Real Queens don't care. Nor do Kings. Little people seethe and fume - but really it's a sign of their frustration about their own precarious insignificance - and everyone else in room knows it.

Mark, I Think it's maybe time for you to stop bothering your pretty little head about things that you can't possibly understand. Run along now darling.